• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
I'm tentatively inclined to agree with the subjugation idea. My only qualm is that I'm a builder and would prefer to see you using that prestige to build up your holdings more. But subjugating the realm would give you a better, more secure, foundation on which to build your prestige and do so.
 
Pretty certain you can’t start 2 wars at once...
 
You can start as many as you want so long as you have no levies raised and no War Declaration Committee in my experience.
I wonder if raising a tribal army via prestige counts as a raised levy for declaration purposes or (as I would hope) it’s event based and therefore exempt. I’m thinking (after my previous mercenary raising miscalculation) that it’s organisation would need some time to get up to speed, and whether it would be possible to raise it in advance of a DoW. Either way, looks like I’d have to make simultaneous declarations before raising my demeaned levies.
 
Just popping in to say that I've been slowly but steadily making my way through this AAR. It looks like you've come a long way so far, and you've had a great deal of invaluable assistance from the other readers. I'm looking forward to getting caught up, and hopefully I can pass on some of what I've learned as well when the situation calls for it.
 
Just popping in to say that I've been slowly but steadily making my way through this AAR. It looks like you've come a long way so far, and you've had a great deal of invaluable assistance from the other readers. I'm looking forward to getting caught up, and hopefully I can pass on some of what I've learned as well when the situation calls for it.
Great to have you reading through Specialist290, look forward to any future contributions :)
 
I wonder if raising a tribal army via prestige counts as a raised levy for declaration purposes or (as I would hope) it’s event based and therefore exempt. I’m thinking (after my previous mercenary raising miscalculation) that it’s organisation would need some time to get up to speed, and whether it would be possible to raise it in advance of a DoW. Either way, looks like I’d have to make simultaneous declarations before raising my demeaned levies.

Tribal Armies do not count as raised levies but are treated similarly to event troops. You can only raise them while at war, but if you pause the game while the target surrenders, you can dismiss your levies, declare a new war, and the Tribal army will still be there so long as no time passes while at peace.
 
Tribal Armies do not count as raised levies but are treated similarly to event troops. You can only raise them while at war, but if you pause the game while the target surrenders, you can dismiss your levies, declare a new war, and the Tribal army will still be there so long as no time passes while at peace.
Very useful, thanks. :)
 
You can start as many as you want so long as you have no levies raised and no War Declaration Committee in my experience.
bloody hell-I never realised that. How annoying. All this time I have been playing that aspect of the game wrong grrr
 
Ch 16 Q2: Where next? General views on these or other options not contemplated by Rurik (he’s looking to consolidate in the north first before tackling some of the larger interior chiefdoms to the south – where some large armies have been seen battling to and fro with each other over the last year or two). Raid? Conquest and Subjugation? Two at once? Stick to personal levies or call up the tribal army now? Or better to spend the prestige on military buildings?
Subjugation only if you need those land to then immediately form the kingdom. Otherwise you will find yourself with two ducal title, which will be split upon your death between your sons (once again I can't remember if you have other male sons right now). Conquest is a safer bet until then. If you want to attack both, you can, but make sure that you can win.
I would say raiding would be nice but then again after what happened in my AAR I don't feel like always blindly say "Go raiding".

Ch 16 Q1: Subjugation of Peers. OK, following up on previous questions re not investing other vassals with Dukedoms (and equivalents), my assumption here is that if I win a war of subjugation and bring Miemo in as a High Chief, he still ranks below and would be a subordinate to Rurik, as the Petty King of Holmgarðr. Because he is a High Chief and I have never exercised this mechanic before, I’m just trying to avoid another of those newbie faux pas.
As said above, subjugation would make you new high chief. Which is kind of a problem if you have more then one son).
 
bloody hell-I never realised that. How annoying. All this time I have been playing that aspect of the game wrong grrr

Lol you made me second guess myself. I started a new game as the Chief of Hordaland in the 769 start, set ambition to "King of Norway" and immediately declared against the rulers to both north and south (Nidaros and Ryljafiki (sp?) IIRC) just to confirm - yes, you can declare multiple offensive wars in succession with no levies raised.

I'd argue that in most cases being involved in multiple ongoing offensive wars at once isn't the best idea, so I wouldn't say that you've been playing wrong this whole time per se, it's just that in this particular case, for a Tribal Army snowball fight, multiple wars are not a bad idea. I also seem to recall having found it highly useful when holy warring a strong but fractured faith like the Sunnis (as Byzantium... that cursed SPQR achievement lol) in the 867 start. They're all going to gang up on you anyway if you just go after one of them, so you may as well just DOW them all and take a duchy from all of them at once. :D
 
Lol you made me second guess myself. I started a new game as the Chief of Hordaland in the 769 start, set ambition to "King of Norway" and immediately declared against the rulers to both north and south (Nidaros and Ryljafiki (sp?) IIRC) just to confirm - yes, you can declare multiple offensive wars in succession with no levies raised.

I'd argue that in most cases being involved in multiple ongoing offensive wars at once isn't the best idea, so I wouldn't say that you've been playing wrong this whole time per se, it's just that in this particular case, for a Tribal Army snowball fight, multiple wars are not a bad idea. I also seem to recall having found it highly useful when holy warring a strong but fractured faith like the Sunnis (as Byzantium... that cursed SPQR achievement lol) in the 867 start. They're all going to gang up on you anyway if you just go after one of them, so you may as well just DOW them all and take a duchy from all of them at once. :D
Fantastic-thanks so much. This will certainly change how I play going forward-amazing that even after years playing you learn new tricks haha
 
Still working my way through. One thing caught my attention, as I noticed it got discussed but I don't know if the point I'm about to raise got mentioned later:

As Rurik takes stock of his new conquest, he notices the effects of the fight and occupation on the chiefdom of Torzhok. The effect of the imposition of a new administration appears set to last almost 20 years! The even more extreme (but shorter term) effects of recent conquest will last for around a year. A check of the Toropets showed a similar outcome.

bOLQAw.jpg


I don't know the exact numbers off the top of my head, but the "New Administration" penalty varies in length depending on how closely the conquered province's religion and culture match your character's. Obviously an exact match results in the shortest duration, while being in completely different culture and / or religion groups has the biggest one (though I'm unsure of exactly how they're calculated).

Hope it helps :)
 
Still working my way through. One thing caught my attention, as I noticed it got discussed but I don't know if the point I'm about to raise got mentioned later:


I don't know the exact numbers off the top of my head, but the "New Administration" penalty varies in length depending on how closely the conquered province's religion and culture match your character's. Obviously an exact match results in the shortest duration, while being in completely different culture and / or religion groups has the biggest one (though I'm unsure of exactly how they're calculated).

Hope it helps :)

https://ck2.paradoxwikis.com/Levies#Recently_conquered_holdings

Ask and you shall receive!
 
I don't know the exact numbers off the top of my head, but the "New Administration" penalty varies in length depending on how closely the conquered province's religion and culture match your character's. Obviously an exact match results in the shortest duration, while being in completely different culture and / or religion groups has the biggest one (though I'm unsure of exactly how they're calculated).

Hope it helps :)
Yes it does!
As does this. You guys are great! :D
 
Where Next for the Rurikids? (A summary of advice for Chapter 16 - August 873)
Where Next for the Rurikids? (A summary of advice for Chapter 16 - August 873)

A summary of advice and learnings from the recent episode - through which even seasoned campaigners were able to learn new aspects of the game and pass them on for our collective benefit.

ᚔ ᚱᚢᚱᛁ ᚲᛁᛞ ᚔ

Ch 16 Q1: Subjugation of Peers.
OK, following up on previous questions re not investing other vassals with Dukedoms (and equivalents), my assumption here is that if I win a war of subjugation and bring Miemo in as a High Chief, he still ranks below and would be a subordinate to Rurik, as the Petty King of Holmgarðr. Because he is a High Chief and I have never exercised this mechanic before, I’m just trying to avoid another of those newbie faux pas.
Q1. If you subjugate a Duke, he loses the duchy title. You either usurp it or it is destroyed, I can't remember which but fairly sure you usurp it and he is then a count level vassal.
Doesn't he get some de jure claims instead? (Though those would probably leave his new vassals with their duke tier titles, i.e. votes for Ruriks succession.)
Yes, to all. But subjugation gets you all of their territory while de jure claims only work on territory that is de jure Kingdom of Rus. Saves a bit of work in the long run as there are a couple of rulers at the 867 start that have lands both within Russia and outside.
As said above, subjugation would make you new high chief. Which is kind of a problem if you have more then one son).
OK, thanks all, will have to consider the more-than-one-son aspect, as there is one. But as this is a learning AAR and I want to get the Kingdom together quickly, I may still consider doing a few subjugations when the rival High Chiefdom has two or more de jure Rus counties in it, then see what happens! :oops::)

ᚔ ᚱᚢᚱᛁ ᚲᛁᛞ ᚔ

Ch 16 Q2: Where next?
General views on these or other options not contemplated by Rurik (he’s looking to consolidate in the north first before tackling some of the larger interior chiefdoms to the south – where some large armies have been seen battling to and fro with each other over the last year or two). Raid? Conquest and Subjugation? Two at once? Stick to personal levies or call up the tribal army now? Or better to spend the prestige on military buildings?
My gut feeling would be to do another raid ... but then I rather like raiding so I am hardly an unbiased commentater there.
I'd like to as well, given the benefits, but also know the clock is ticking on Rurik and his astronomical martial (and other) stats. Trade-offs to be considered and balanced! :confused:
Q2. I still advocate calling up the Tribal army, wrecking every de jure vassal of Russia, creating the Kingdom, and then raiding to consolidate. You lose the free subjugation CB when you create the Kingdom, so you should subjugate everyone first. Never be at peace and never dismiss the Tribal Army until you're done.
This sounds persuasive to me. And involves plenty of blood and battle, which is also in keeping with the zeitgeist of the AAR. ;)
I'd say if you can afford more conquest, go for it. You are getting older and having a kingdom would be useful for succession. And those Finnish chiefs look like easy pickings.
Indeed, was thinking something similar. You never know how long you will get, especially if you have your lead character in battle a lot (which I will continue to do - use those martial stats, or deny yourself their nebefit, now I have an heir and spare).
I'm tentatively inclined to agree with the subjugation idea. My only qualm is that I'm a builder and would prefer to see you using that prestige to build up your holdings more. But subjugating the realm would give you a better, more secure, foundation on which to build your prestige and do so.
I did use the first 600-odd accumulated prestige on building, so have at least done that much. The toss-up now is declare an ordinary war and call up the levies one after another, or muster the tribal army and either each one quickly (including keep-storming where possible with those extra numbers to speed things up, as Rurik did in Pskov) or even do two at once. Though I got bitten the last time I got over-ambitious, and lost more time than I gained! :(:oops:
xxx
Thought I'd track this exchange through separately and in order, as it was really gratifying to see even experienced players being able to use the AAR as a vehicle to swap notes, confirm fine points and raise new aspects of gameplay! :D:cool:
Pretty certain you can’t start 2 wars at once...
You can start as many as you want so long as you have no levies raised and no War Declaration Committee in my experience.
bloody hell-I never realised that. How annoying. All this time I have been playing that aspect of the game wrong grrr
Lol you made me second guess myself. I started a new game as the Chief of Hordaland in the 769 start, set ambition to "King of Norway" and immediately declared against the rulers to both north and south (Nidaros and Ryljafiki (sp?) IIRC) just to confirm - yes, you can declare multiple offensive wars in succession with no levies raised.

I'd argue that in most cases being involved in multiple ongoing offensive wars at once isn't the best idea, so I wouldn't say that you've been playing wrong this whole time per se, it's just that in this particular case, for a Tribal Army snowball fight, multiple wars are not a bad idea. I also seem to recall having found it highly useful when holy warring a strong but fractured faith like the Sunnis (as Byzantium... that cursed SPQR achievement lol) in the 867 start. They're all going to gang up on you anyway if you just go after one of them, so you may as well just DOW them all and take a duchy from all of them at once. :D
Fantastic-thanks so much. This will certainly change how I play going forward-amazing that even after years playing you learn new tricks haha
Thanks both of you for teasing this aspect out! :) Now I just need to find some way to apply the knowledge without stuffing it up by clicking the wrong button in a newbie elementary error! :eek:
xxx
Subjugation only if you need those land to then immediately form the kingdom. Otherwise you will find yourself with two ducal title, which will be split upon your death between your sons (once again I can't remember if you have other male sons right now). Conquest is a safer bet until then. If you want to attack both, you can, but make sure that you can win.
I would say raiding would be nice but then again after what happened in my AAR I don't feel like always blindly say "Go raiding".
As per above, yes, there are two sons, but I need at least two duchies to form the kingdom anyway (could do Pskov now if I had the money). I may take the risk, but as mentioned will only subjugate when its 2+ counties of de jure Rus at stake. Conquering them one at a time would simply take too long for Rurik, and that multiple subjugation CB is there for a reason, I'm thinking. I will give it a try I think and we'll see how it goes and how the longer-term consequences pan out! No big gain without a large risk. ;)

ᚔ ᚱᚢᚱᛁ ᚲᛁᛞ ᚔ

Supplementary Question re Tribal Levies

I wonder if raising a tribal army via prestige counts as a raised levy for declaration purposes or (as I would hope) it’s event based and therefore exempt. I’m thinking (after my previous mercenary raising miscalculation) that it’s organisation would need some time to get up to speed, and whether it would be possible to raise it in advance of a DoW. Either way, looks like I’d have to make simultaneous declarations before raising my demeaned levies.
Tribal Armies do not count as raised levies but are treated similarly to event troops. You can only raise them while at war, but if you pause the game while the target surrenders, you can dismiss your levies, declare a new war, and the Tribal army will still be there so long as no time passes while at peace.
Very valuable info. If I do raise the tribal army, I'll be sure to try that tactic out (which I think isn't gamey at all, but logical if the purpose is a prolonged war of conquest for the kingdom, and the event troops will eventually wear down).

Other Points
Still working my way through. One thing caught my attention, as I noticed it got discussed but I don't know if the point I'm about to raise got mentioned later:

I don't know the exact numbers off the top of my head, but the "New Administration" penalty varies in length depending on how closely the conquered province's religion and culture match your character's. Obviously an exact match results in the shortest duration, while being in completely different culture and / or religion groups has the biggest one (though I'm unsure of exactly how they're calculated).

Hope it helps :)
This exchange too - bravo! :)

ᚔ ᚱᚢᚱᛁ ᚲᛁᛞ ᚔ

Thanks once again everyone for your collective wisdom. Now back to figuring out what to do next in the game. Wish Rurik luck - he'll probably need it! :confused:
 
:p
Where Next for the Rurikids? (A summary of advice for Chapter 16 - August 873)

A summary of advice and learnings from the recent episode - through which even seasoned campaigners were able to learn new aspects of the game and pass them on for our collective benefit.

ᚔ ᚱᚢᚱᛁ ᚲᛁᛞ ᚔ

Ch 16 Q1: Subjugation of Peers.
OK, following up on previous questions re not investing other vassals with Dukedoms (and equivalents), my assumption here is that if I win a war of subjugation and bring Miemo in as a High Chief, he still ranks below and would be a subordinate to Rurik, as the Petty King of Holmgarðr. Because he is a High Chief and I have never exercised this mechanic before, I’m just trying to avoid another of those newbie faux pas.



OK, thanks all, will have to consider the more-than-one-son aspect, as there is one. But as this is a learning AAR and I want to get the Kingdom together quickly, I may still consider doing a few subjugations when the rival High Chiefdom has two or more de jure Rus counties in it, then see what happens! :oops::)

ᚔ ᚱᚢᚱᛁ ᚲᛁᛞ ᚔ

Ch 16 Q2: Where next?
General views on these or other options not contemplated by Rurik (he’s looking to consolidate in the north first before tackling some of the larger interior chiefdoms to the south – where some large armies have been seen battling to and fro with each other over the last year or two). Raid? Conquest and Subjugation? Two at once? Stick to personal levies or call up the tribal army now? Or better to spend the prestige on military buildings?
I'd like to as well, given the benefits, but also know the clock is ticking on Rurik and his astronomical martial (and other) stats. Trade-offs to be considered and balanced! :confused:
This sounds persuasive to me. And involves plenty of blood and battle, which is also in keeping with the zeitgeist of the AAR. ;)
Indeed, was thinking something similar. You never know how long you will get, especially if you have your lead character in battle a lot (which I will continue to do - use those martial stats, or deny yourself their nebefit, now I have an heir and spare).
I did use the first 600-odd accumulated prestige on building, so have at least done that much. The toss-up now is declare an ordinary war and call up the levies one after another, or muster the tribal army and either each one quickly (including keep-storming where possible with those extra numbers to speed things up, as Rurik did in Pskov) or even do two at once. Though I got bitten the last time I got over-ambitious, and lost more time than I gained! :(:oops:
xxx
Thought I'd track this exchange through separately and in order, as it was really gratifying to see even experienced players being able to use the AAR as a vehicle to swap notes, confirm fine points and raise new aspects of gameplay! :D:cool:




Thanks both of you for teasing this aspect out! :) Now I just need to find some way to apply the knowledge without stuffing it up by clicking the wrong button in a newbie elementary error! :eek:
xxx
As per above, yes, there are two sons, but I need at least two duchies to form the kingdom anyway (could do Pskov now if I had the money). I may take the risk, but as mentioned will only subjugate when its 2+ counties of de jure Rus at stake. Conquering them one at a time would simply take too long for Rurik, and that multiple subjugation CB is there for a reason, I'm thinking. I will give it a try I think and we'll see how it goes and how the longer-term consequences pan out! No big gain without a large risk. ;)

ᚔ ᚱᚢᚱᛁ ᚲᛁᛞ ᚔ

Supplementary Question re Tribal Levies


Very valuable info. If I do raise the tribal army, I'll be sure to try that tactic out (which I think isn't gamey at all, but logical if the purpose is a prolonged war of conquest for the kingdom, and the event troops will eventually wear down).

Other Points


This exchange too - bravo! :)

ᚔ ᚱᚢᚱᛁ ᚲᛁᛞ ᚔ

Thanks once again everyone for your collective wisdom. Now back to figuring out what to do next in the game. Wish Rurik luck - he'll probably need it! :confused:
Good luck O king! :D
 
:p
Good luck O king! :D
My thanks oh brave paladin! :) The scholars’ translations of the contemporary records have been completed and the coming months of the Rurikid Saga will be published soon-ish. Suffice to say there will be blood and battle! ;)
 
My thanks oh brave paladin! :) The scholars’ translations of the contemporary records have been completed and the coming months of the Rurikid Saga will be published soon-ish. Suffice to say there will be blood and battle! ;)
Brilliant. Looking forward to that. Now back to your Turkish Magnus opus hehe (at some point I should write the next chapter of my own Wessexian tale for which many thanks my friend for your vote in the Q4 ACAs)
 
(at some point I should write the next chapter of my own Wessexian tale for which many thanks my friend for your vote in the Q4 ACAs)
And many will look forward to that. Welcome re the vote. :)