• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
The Steppe Crisis
Quick question to readers: is there any way to release a country as your vassal that isn't a colonial subject? If so, how?


In December 1490, Dristar declared war on Haixi. He was pissed at the fact that their former subjects weren’t accepting Romano-Mongol rule, and he hoped that annexing them would stop the revolts. This war declaration is widely thought to have been one of the worst mistakes in history - it’s thought that it kicked off the Steppe Crisis, which nearly destroyed the Romano-Mongol Empire entirely.

In January 1491, forces loyal to Yeren gathered in Birija. These forces would ultimately result in a temporary loss of territory to Yeren. These forces would take control of all the territory that Yeren had lost by November. The actual rebels would finally be defeated in August 1495, and a third of the revolting territory would be recaptured, but two-thirds of it would be temporarily lost to Yeren.

In February 1491, an army that wished to see a more decentralized Romano-Mongol Empire seized control of Ejin. Another army espousing the same ideas besieged Hami, but they were defeated in July by an army under Toghrul Okhunut.

The Haixian army would ultimately be defeated at Sartu in March. Some of the Haixian army survived, though, and that proved problematic. Some of this remnant army was defeated at Yumen in December of 1491. In January 1492, the last area under Haixian control fell. The Haixian army would make repeated attempts to pay off the Romano-Mongols after this, but Dristar refused all of them. Haixi would be annexed, although they refused for the moment. This is likely because they hoped that their allies in Donghai would bail them out (never mind the fact that Yeren had defeated Donghai before, so they clearly couldn’t compare to Romano-Mongol might).To be fair, Donghai did manage to take some Romano-Mongol land temporarily, but that didn’t last long. Donghai would be defeated in January 1493 at Cicigar. The remnant army of the two allied states would be defeated again in September 1493 at Alchuka. Kubur Borjigin would defeat the alliance again at Tunhe, which was ironic because nobody involved in the war actually controlled the battleground there. Another confrontation with similar irony occurred at Ningguta, although Borjigin had died by that point (see below).The capital of Donghai was besieged after this. This city, Deren, would last almost a year before surrendering in May 1495.

Haixi would finally accept peace after this point. Haixi lost its independence, and Donghai was forced to become a Romano-Mongol vassal. Unfortunately, the end of the war didn’t include the countries that actually controlled the area between Donghai and the Empire proper - Udege and Yeren. This effectively trapped more than half of the Romano-Mongol army - more than 30,000 men - in a vassal that no one could access from the actual Empire.

Kubur Borjigin died in late January 1494. Many wonder what might have happened had he survived. They theorize that he could have helped prevent the Crisis from getting as bad as it did, perhaps even by taking over the Empire. This is possible, considering that he was a successful military leader and descended from Genghis Khan. Considering the fact that many Romano-Mongols wanted to depose Dristar entirely later in the Crisis, this is possible.

In July, an army that supported the annexation of ex-Haixian lands by Haixi rose in Maolian. The area would fall as August ended. They took Edala in December of 1491. They would take more land after this, but they were comprehensively defeated at Alchuka in March 1491. Kubur Borjigin led the Romano-Mongol forces there.

By the early 1490s, the Romano-Mongols had begun colonizing their northern borders. The natives didn’t like this and 4 native revolts would have to be put down - 2 in Jugjur (March 1492 and May 1495) and 2 in the area north of it (December 1500 and April 1503).

In August 1492, an army that wanted an independent state of buryat arose and began to besiege Hulunbuir. To make matters even worse, an army espousing independence for Korchin rose in January 1493. They managed to take Taining in February. Thankfully, a Romano-Mongol army managed to defeat them later that month. The area was retaken by April. Unfortunately, Hulunbuir fell in late July 1493. A Romano-Mongol army under Olkhunut would defeat them in October 1493, but they then had to settle in for a siege. The city would only be retaken in late September 1494, managing to hold out for more than a year.

Mongol separatists would rise in Hohhot in May 1494. That area would fall by June. They would be finally defeated at Datong. These rebels were, however, led by Engke Borjigin - who some believe was Kubur’s brother. This is often a reason stated why some believe that Kubur surviving could have led to the destruction of the Empire. Of course, this revolt was kickstarted by an Imperial decree demanding that all Mongols move into cities.

To top all of that off, Chinese advocates for two separate dynasties arose in July and August, 1495. In September, Lanzhou fell to one of these factions. Datong fell to the other in March 1496. Thankfully, Olkhunut would defeat the faction at Datong in May 1496, and Datong would fall by April 1497.

To make matters even worse, an army demanding Solon be regranted its independence arose in Urkan in August.They took Urkan in August. October would see their defeat.

Beginning in September 1495, in the west, armies that wished to restore the Oirat Khanate and return lands to the Uzbeks rose. They would occupy almost the entirety of the Empire’s west at one point. By October, Kazakhs would revolt, too, but these weren’t as much of a threat to the Romano-Mongols. These armies would be defeated at Kobdo in March 1498. That battle would be followed by a mopping up of all revolters in the West.

Meanwhile, the stranded 30,000 men would occupy their time by moving south to uninhabited land, where they would defeat natives at Sakhalin.

By February 1496, it was quite clear that Dristar was insane. He’d previously issued a decree that demanded all Mongols live in cities and stranded more than half of the Empire’s military. What really proved his insanity, though, was when he issued a decree that simultaneously declared war on the Ming, made all of the Steppe tribes move into the cities, banished the Chinese peoples from living in cities at all, and gave permission for Romano-Mongols to enslave anybody they wanted for any purpose. In response, the military seized control of the Imperial Palace and imprisoned Dristar. They also took effective control of the war effort - and repealed all of Dristar’s decrees. This act probably saved the Empire entirely.

In February 1496, two provinces defected to Yeren. The new Ruling Council declared war in response.

Koreans revolted in April 1497. They would manage to take most of Romano-Mongol Korea for two reasons. The first was that, if worst came to worst, the Ruling Council figured that they could negotiate a Korean state that still answered to the Romano-Mongols. The second was that it was hoped that they would also attack Japanese Korea in the South.

The Haixians would rise in December 1497 at Yehe. They were defeated in March 1498 before they could take the city.

Most of Yeren had been taken by June 1499, but Yeren had launched a surprise siege of Khara Narin Ula. This would succeed in June 1499, but that would prove irrelevant. In December, however, Udi - the capital of Yeren - would fall to a besieging Romano-Mongol army. Yerenese Peasants would take most of the territory the Romano-Mongols had gained, however. Thankfully, the Romano-Mongols defeated these peasants and took the land they had occupied at the Battle of Kuru in February 1500. Meanwhile, the official army of Yeren defeated the revolting Koreans for the Romano-Mongols.

Peace was signed in August 1500. Yeren was reduced to its capital and land controlled by peasants that weren’t even loyal to Yeren.

The Korean rebels were finally defeated in July 1501. Despite this, they wouldn’t be completely defeated until Ganggye was recaptured in September 1503.

In February 1502, 2 peasant revolts broke out. They were in Sainshand and Setsen. Both provinces would fall to the revolters, but they would soon be defeated. One group was defeated at Khara Narin Ula in January 1503. The other was defeated at Kherlen, although Setsen wouldn’t be reclaimed until June 1504.

The Ruling Council had restored order to the realm. They, therefore, decided that another humbling of the Ming in China was in order.

Romano-Mongol 5.png

(map of the Romano-Mongol Empire and surrounding area, vassals are outlined in red)


Also, next update will be a state of the world at the turn of the century update. Just as an FYI
 
The World In 1504 AD
By the dawn of the 16th century, the world had changed much from the mid-15th century. The Romano-Mongols had expanded, but history doesn’t happen in a vacuum. Here’s a brief overview of what happened in the rest of the world.

In the Steppe, the Romano-Mongol Empire ruled much of the area. The Chagatai Khanate paid it tribute, although they were unhappy with this arrangement.

The Uzbeks ruled the area west of the Romano-Mongols. However, the Kazakh Khanate was a new state in the area. It was founded when Kazakh rebels defeated the Chagatai and the Uzbeks. They attempted to attack the Romano-Mongols as well, but they were defeated. The Uzbeks had recaptured Khiva after their war with the Romano-Mongols, and they retained it after the Kazakh War of Independence. To the west, the Nogai had occupied Astrakhan, and Muscovy had some land. The small Kazan Khanate also existed. All of these states were previously part of the Golden Horde, except for Muscovy, which had paid it tribute.

In Persia, the Timurids had managed to mostly recover from Timur. They ruled most of eastern Persia. The west of Persia and Mesopotamia were ruled by many tribal states. Transoxiana remained in personal union with the Timurids, although that situation was unlikely to last.

Steppe and Persia 1.png

(map of the Steppe and Persia)

China, meanwhile, was still mostly dominated by the Ming. The Romano-Mongols controlled small portions of the North, however. Lan Xang ruled much of Southeast Asia, but other states did exist in that general area.

Malacca controlled much of the archipelago south of Southeast Asia proper. There were other states in that archipelago, but none of them are worth noting.

Tsang controlled most of Tibet. The Romano-Mongols were eyeing it as a possible target once the Ming were dealt with.

Japan had mostly united, but many of the southern islands were subject to the separate state of Kono. The Japanese had annexed southern Korea, and the Romano-Mongols wanted that area. The Japanese, for that matter, wanted northern Korea. However, neither side wanted to engage the other, so there was merely a tense border… for now.

In India, many states fought. The most notable of these were Mewar in the west and Orissa in the east. The Delhi Sultanate seemed on the verge of total collapse.

India, China, and Southeast Asia 1.png

(map of China, Southeast Asia, and India)

Hormuz ruled a large part of Arabia. They seemed to have been largely a trading power. The Mamluks dominated much of the Muslim World, but they were entering a period of unrest at this point. Tunis and Morocco had effectively partitioned Algiers between them, as well.

In Europe, Castille and Aragon had a personal union, but they haven’t done much yet. The Holy Roman Empire remains as much as a patchwork of states as it has ever been.

Austria, for its part, had annexed almost all of Venice’s territory. Surprisingly, the other Italian states didn’t seem to care about that much.

France had been almost totally divided between England and Burgundy by this point. Brittany benefitted from France’s collapse, and a few small states seem to have emerged from the French ruins.

In the ex-Ottoman and Byzantine lands, Anatolia reigned supreme. They had crushed the Ottomans and taken control of much of Greece. While the Ottomans seized Constantinople before this point, the Byzantine Empire was reestablished during the Anatolians Conquest of the Ottomans.

Anatolia and the Ottomans had also partitioned New Bulgaria, but this didn’t last. When the Turkish Alliance broke down, the Bulgarians established the independent states of Bulgaria and Wallachia from their lost lands.

While Anatolia was besieging Constantinople, Karaman had occupied most of the Anatolian lands in Anatolia proper. Anatolia was faced with a choice: give up much of Anatolia or abandon their siege of Constantinople… Ultimately, the choice was made for them: the Bulgars took Constantinople.

The Empire of Trebizond and Hellas were the last remnants of the Byzantine Empire. Of these states, Trebizond seemed the most suited to survive in the long run. There was a remnant of the central Byzantine government in Crimea.

Crimea and Cumania ruled the lands north of Anatolia. A state of Armenia also existed during this time.

Southern Europe, North Africa, and Arabia 1.png

(map of Southern Europe, North Africa, and Arabia)

Poland and Lithuania hadn’t changed much from the mid-15th century.

The Kalmar Union had collapsed by this point. Sweden and Denmark were at war. Denmark controlled Denmark proper, Iceland, and Norway. Sweden controlled Sweden proper and Finland. The war seemed to be at a stalemate… who would win was anyone’s guess.

England and Scotland were fighting as well. The Scots had occupied a portion of English Ireland, but, otherwise, no territory had changed.

In Ireland, Thromond ruled most of the Isle, and it may yet unite it. A united Ireland could be a problem for both England and Scotland…

Northern Europe 1.png

(map of Northern Europe)

In the northern portion of North America, many tribes controlled portions of land. The most powerful state by far - and the only one worth noting - was New Atlantis. This state had been founded by refugees from Atlantis before it sank, so it was naturally very powerful.

Northern North America 1.png

(map of the northern portion of North America)

In the southern portion of North America, land was similarly very divided. While this area was traditionally the home of large empires, the most recent of these empires had already collapsed.

Itza, a Maya state, seemed to rule the most land here. There was another expansive state, but we don’t know what it was called.

No foreign powers have settled in the New World yet, but it is only a matter of time…

Southern North America 1.png

(map of southern portion of North America)
 
Look at that North America. Curious what it will mean for the future.
 
Look at that North America. Curious what it will mean for the future.

Perhaps New Atlantis will prove a strong native state. It’ll be hard to colonize, anyway.
 
To all readers: really sorry about this, but the next update will probably be Monday instead of today... due to Real Life
 
The War In China, Part 1
The Ruling Council declared war against the Ming in August 1504 AD. The war began badly for the Romano-Mongols. A Ming general, Youyi I Zhu, defeated a Romano-Mongol army at Badain Jaran in May. Toghrul Olkhunut led the Romano-Mongol forces and he only barely survived this battle. Unfortunately, he would die as the army retreated.

In November, the war began to turn around for the Romano-Mongols. Alp Genghisid-Justinian, the heir to the throne, defeated a Ming force at Xuanhua. Youyi himself would be defeated at Tsetserleg in March 1507 AD.

Unfortunately, the war against the Ming inflamed old passions. Revolts broke out. Independence fighters, particularists, and zealots all fought each other, the Ming, and the Romano-Mongols alike. It has long been theorized that the Ming influenced these rebellions, but recent studies have cast doubt on this claim. As has already been mentioned, the rebels attacked the Ming. Far more importantly, most Steppe tribes despised the Chinese, and it is therefore unlikely that the rebellions were directly caused by the Ming.
Particularists were defeated in January 1506 AD at Boduna, but they were far from destroyed. Indeed, they had captured Hami by December. Ultimately, the Ruling Council surrendered to the particularists in May 1509 AD.

In February 1506, the merchants demanded privileges, knowing that the Ruling Council wouldn’t refuse them from fear of revolt. Later, however, their influence would be curbed due to the war - the military council is said to have justified that with “a warrior has no use for scholarly pursuits”.

Beijing would finally fall in October 1507, after a siege that lasted almost two years. Alp defeated Youyi at Chengde in November, as well. Alp would relieve the capital of the Empire, Khara Narin Ula, in January 1508 AD. This would be followed by a victory at Hohhot in March. A Ming army would also be defeated at the Second Battle of Xuanhua, which occurred in August. The aftermath of Xuanhua is generally regarded as the high point of the “First Phase” of the First Chinese War.

Youyi would defeat multiple Romano-Mongol armies and hold his siege of Beijing. The first army was led by Alp himself, and it occurred in September. The second battle occurred in June 1509, and the poorly led Romano-Mongols faced heavy casualties. The third confrontation featured an army led by Alp, but he was defeated. This battle was successful in one of its chief goals, however. The Ming army took such great casualties - in both men and morale - that it abandoned Beijing.

Dristar the Mad would perish in September 1509, and Alp would assume the throne. However, Alp reaffirmed the Ruling Council’s leadership, as he wished to lead armies against the Ming and local rebels in person.

Alp then decided to send spies to the Ming court. These spies successfully convinced the Ming Emperor to declare war on Tsang and Japan. This action led to an enormous amount of dissatisfaction in China, but no revolts emerged… yet.
 
The War In China, Part 2: Peace
Emperor Alp knew, or at least suspected, that the Ming were on the verge of collapse. The unfortunate truth was that he couldn’t take advantage of that fact. The Romano-Mongol Empire had already to those that demanded greater autonomy, but they proved unwilling to actually aid the Emperor and the Ruling Council. To make matters even worse, numerous armies that wished to be free of Romano-Mongol rule were ravaging Romano-Mongol territory.

The rebels also fought with themselves and the Ming, but that wasn’t helpful to Alp at all. All it did was further ravage Romano-Mongol and the last century hadn’t been kind to civilization in the Steppes.

The Ruling Council didn’t do anything. Most of them followed a mentality of “victory or destruction”. Actually, those that followed this mentality were only barely a plurality, and nowhere the majority, but none of the other factions could agree on anything.

Alp knew that. It was with that in mind that he decided to march to just south of Beijing. Strangely, he didn’t engage the Ming army in battle. The two armies disliked each other, but both were heavily loyal to their leaders.

These two leaders were Emperor Alp, of course, and Youyhi I Zhu. Now,Youyhi was the Ming Emperor, and he was a militarist emperor, but he knew that the Romano-Mongols would defeat him eventually. As such, he agreed to negotiations with Emperor Alp.

Their conversation is recorded in the famous text:”The Dialogue between Emperors”. The two emperors both knew that their realms were on the verge of collapse. The dialogue begins with the two rulers exchanging pleasantries.

However, it soon continues onto the negotiations. The goal of both rulers is quickly made clear: peace. In addition, both emperors knew that they were some of the only people in their empires who wanted peace.

The initial proposal of a status quo ante bellum - proposed by Emperor Youyhi - was quickly rejected. Emperor Alp was perfectly aware that such an arrangement would destroy any authority that he still had with his subjects. Alp’s initial counter proposal of a Romano-Mongol annexation of Beijing was also rejected.

The early negotiations allegedly got nowhere, and tempers flared. The meeting was temporarily ended, but the two rulers agreed to meet again in the same spot the next day.

This meeting went much better for both sides. While an agreement wasn’t made yet, a number of palatable suggestions were made, and the two rulers were quite clear on what terms were unacceptable to the other ruler. Emperor Youyhi I was unwilling to cede territory to the Romano-Mongols, whereas Emperor Alp refused to come away empty-handed.

On the third day of negotiations, an agreement was finally reached. The Ming would pay a small sum to the Romano-Mongols on an annual basis. In return, Emperor Alp promised that the Romano-Mongols wouldn’t attack the Ming anymore and would also defend the Ming against any attackers, although they wouldn’t aid the Ming in their offensive wars.

The Treaty of Beijing defined relations between the Romano-Mongols and the Chinese for generations. In addition, it provided both realms time to regroup and expand - something they desperately needed.

Author's Note: Images will return next update.
 
My apologies, but the next update is delayed until tomorrow...

Edit: Never mind. I'll post a long chapter on Saturday to make up for the lack of a chapter this week. Really sorry about that!
 
Last edited:
The End of the Empire
Emperor Alp immediately sent a letter to the Ruling Council. The letter demanded that the Council give up its authority, or he would force it to. It ruled on his authority, and he could order it to disband on his authority.

It agreed, but Alp didn’t have much luck on crushing the rebellions. The west was pacified temporarily, and the east was besieged by the royal army. It was too little, too late.

Almost the entire eastern half of the Empire was lost to newly independent states. Alp wanted to prevent this from happening elsewhere, so he named local vassal rulers in the Chinese provinces and the former Oirat Khanate. Even that wasn’t enough.

By this point, the citizens of the Romano-Mongol Empire were thoroughly tired of war. They rose up in large numbers. Alp’s desperate decree of official toleration only led religious zealots rising against him.

The Ruling Council had finally had enough. They seized control of the capital and most of Mongolia proper. They demanded that Alp let them rule, and he had little choice but to agree. Unfortunately, the horrible state of the realm meant that no one felt obliged to pay tribute to it. The Ming and the Chagatai both cut off tribute payments. To make matters even worse, the Jin, Shun, and Oirats established independence.

Not even Alp’s family stood with him. Rebels who wished to restore Solon offered a sibling of his the crown of their new nation, and he accepted.

A grand alliance of rebels emerged. They would defeat the Emperor’s troops, and many new nations would be born due to their revolt. The Ruling Council saw this, and they realized that Alp couldn’t rule. He had previously been a good ruler, so they weren’t sure of why Alp couldn’t rule well anymore. Indeed, historians still aren’;t aware of what, exactly, Alp’s problem was. Some theorize that he had nightmares over the war in China. Regardless, they had had enough.

They took the capital of the Empire and found a Mongol who was descended from Genghis Khan’s line and a capable ruler. They crowned him as Khan of Mongolia, and Alp was killed.

His son, Mongke, assumed the throne. He knew that the Empire had lost the Steppes, so he attempted an evacuation of loyal Romano-Mongols to the new colonies, from which they could establish a new empire. A new capital was set up, and it was named Romagol.

Romano-Mongol 6.png

(map of what remained of the Empire at Alp’s death)

Unfortunately, most of Asia was pissed at the Romano-Mongols, and this was their chance to get revenge. An enormous alliance attacked Romagol, and Mongke knew that he was doomed.

To their credit, the Romano-Mongol Empire died as it had lived - in war. The Siege of Romagol lasted a century, and, by the time it fell, most Romano-Mongols had been evacuated to New Atlantis, which had agreed to take them in. Their knowledge would allow New Atlantis to become an even greater power than it had already been, but that’s a story for another time.

(And that's a wrap! I didn't do well, but I hope the story was still interesting! Thanks for reading. And, no, there won't be a sequel as New Atlantis.)
 
It's not always fun, but its a change of pace to have an AAR ending in loss.
 
It's not always fun, but its a change of pace to have an AAR ending in loss.

True. Still, the fall of the Romano-Mongols is a real shame.
 
I really hoped for a New Atlantis game, well hope your next AAR goes better, its sometimes good to see defeats too, otherwise it would be too easy. It reminds me of an AAR of mine, many years ago, while i played as Austria in DH trying to forge a different path and keep the indipendence in 1933. I managed to achieve much but in the end the enemies were so powerful i simply was defeated but i remember as one of my best games ever, it was truly a fight to the last man and even the defeat left a great feeling of accomplishment
 
Such a tragic end to the Empire.
 
I really hoped for a New Atlantis game, well hope your next AAR goes better, its sometimes good to see defeats too, otherwise it would be too easy. It reminds me of an AAR of mine, many years ago, while i played as Austria in DH trying to forge a different path and keep the indipendence in 1933. I managed to achieve much but in the end the enemies were so powerful i simply was defeated but i remember as one of my best games ever, it was truly a fight to the last man and even the defeat left a great feeling of accomplishment
Such a tragic end to the Empire.

Indeed, it is very tragic.

If you do want more set in this universe, my newest AAR is a long poem about everything from Dristar's reign to the end of the Empire.
 
This is phenomenally cool. Thank you for sharing.

You're welcome. The other AAR set in this universe is mentioned above, if you want more Romano-Mongol info!