son-of-conchra said:Even Sweden?
Probably as quite a few generals disobeyed orders and the king was most likely assasinated by command of the Swedish generals.
son-of-conchra said:Even Sweden?
Ermac said:This is downright unrealistic why would china have any real reason go to war with its single largest trading partner when all that would bring is a grinding halt too their growing economy which last time i checked is Beijings top priority. If your just gonna spam all the Major Powers world versus the USA then thats not gonna make a very good AAR.
Thinsulate said:Sigh. China is not in the war yet.
jacob-Lundgren said:Don't take this the wrong way please but....if you wont even be using an actual game for much/most of this its not really an AAR is it? It sounds more like a what-if story
Admiral Yamamot said:There is a whole bunch of AARs which don't contain ingame screens!
And a lot of them are awesome!!
So please DON'T abandon this!!
jacob-Lundgren said:I said don't take this the wrong way hoping to encourage you to put some more graphics up, really of any strategic kind. Some maps, production reports something other then pictures of flags and politicians and words. You sadly enough did end up taking it the wrong way. :wacko: :wacko:
edit: I bet you would have taken my criticism in stride if I had a different flag up however Maybe next time look at the words and not who said them
Thinsulate said:Well some people enjoy this writing style. I may close this AAR and make a new one of the same style on a different war/topic, this seems to be very unpopular with all the Americans.
Again, I did not ask him to stop it I simply asked him to expand on it more. If he is not going to do it with pictures or maps or graphics of any sort and no in game screen shots then the least he could do is some greater detail into the battles beyond what has currently been posted. A really good story has great detail. If it is not going to come from graphics of any kind then its hardly flaming for me to ask for greater detail in some other fashion. I am not sure how to clarify this further.TreizeV said:I personally believe that this situation would not happen in the real world, and that the US at this point cannot lose any war it fully commits to.
But so what? This is an AAR, a hypothetical situation. It's a fun situation, Yet I want to see how Putin and Europe will cooperate with each other, I want to see how bush could screw this up and how America recovers, I want to see what changes happen in America and the Pacific. This is very well written, and I am enjoying it thus far, isn't that what we read AARs for? To suspend our disbelief? Thats the point of fiction, heck, my AAR is about aliens! How realistic is that?
In any case Thin, don't close the AAR, continue. Please. That's your decision alone, not anyone elses.