Wait.. I thought that only the tank variants for the support company will get those breakthrough debuff. But do you mean whole SPGs for regular battalions also get those debuff? What about the TD variants?
Open Beta Patch 1.11.4 (Steam Only) (Updated Mk4) - Checksum b22c
- Thread starter MatRopert
- Start date
-
We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Portraits and characters, broken focuses in Polish, Portuguese, Spanish and Turkish focus trees, applying basic fixes for diplomatic alliances and policy "my enemy is your enemy, let's be best friends", for example
Divisions not joining orders they've been assigned to
Here's one I can't recall seeing reference to before. A week or so ago (when the French situation got a bit dire) I assigned five division from French North Africa to a fallback line in a somewhat desperate attempt to stem the German hordes. When I fired up the game today, though, I noticed they hadn't arrived yet and, on closer examination, noticed they hadn't even started moving. While a perfectly reasonable course of action if the virtual divisions have gone sentient (it's not a front I'd want to join), I can't see a sensible in-game reason why they're not moving. Note that this appears to be an isolated example - most divisions are doing what they're told.
As best I can tell, it's an "unable to find valid path to target" issue (but this isn't showing without giving the divs a 'kick'), but it's not clear why this is the case, given supply appears available, and even if it wasn't available, I would expect them to at least try and get as close to the target as possible.
As always, am very sorry if it's WAD, a duplicate, or I've messed up some othere way.
Game version: 1.11.4.69fb
Checksum: b4f8
Repro steps:
1) Load attached save.
2) Right-click on the fallback order to the immediate west of Met, and observe, as per the first screenshot, five divisions with suspiciously high org for divisions being mauled by the Wehrmacht - with no indication that they have any issues.
3) Right-click on one of the high-org divs in "Metropolitan Gn", and observe, as per the second screenshot, it's sitting in Africa.
4) Observe in the top bar that France has convoys available to transport division.
5) Press F2 and observe, as per the third screenshot, France is allowing traffic through the Western Med, and has naval superiority there.
6) Press F4 and observe, as per the fourth screenshot, there is still supply remaining in the province in question.
6) Advance time a day or so while observing the recalcitrant divisions, and observe they don't do anything.
7) Click on one of the recalcitrant divisions, and give it a movement order (click into an adjacent province) and then cancel it, and observe, as per the fifth screenshot, that they now get a "unable to find valid path to target" error.
8)
Screenies in spoiler to minimise post size.
Here's one I can't recall seeing reference to before. A week or so ago (when the French situation got a bit dire) I assigned five division from French North Africa to a fallback line in a somewhat desperate attempt to stem the German hordes. When I fired up the game today, though, I noticed they hadn't arrived yet and, on closer examination, noticed they hadn't even started moving. While a perfectly reasonable course of action if the virtual divisions have gone sentient (it's not a front I'd want to join), I can't see a sensible in-game reason why they're not moving. Note that this appears to be an isolated example - most divisions are doing what they're told.
As best I can tell, it's an "unable to find valid path to target" issue (but this isn't showing without giving the divs a 'kick'), but it's not clear why this is the case, given supply appears available, and even if it wasn't available, I would expect them to at least try and get as close to the target as possible.
As always, am very sorry if it's WAD, a duplicate, or I've messed up some othere way.
Game version: 1.11.4.69fb
Checksum: b4f8
Repro steps:
1) Load attached save.
2) Right-click on the fallback order to the immediate west of Met, and observe, as per the first screenshot, five divisions with suspiciously high org for divisions being mauled by the Wehrmacht - with no indication that they have any issues.
3) Right-click on one of the high-org divs in "Metropolitan Gn", and observe, as per the second screenshot, it's sitting in Africa.
4) Observe in the top bar that France has convoys available to transport division.
5) Press F2 and observe, as per the third screenshot, France is allowing traffic through the Western Med, and has naval superiority there.
6) Press F4 and observe, as per the fourth screenshot, there is still supply remaining in the province in question.
6) Advance time a day or so while observing the recalcitrant divisions, and observe they don't do anything.
7) Click on one of the recalcitrant divisions, and give it a movement order (click into an adjacent province) and then cancel it, and observe, as per the fifth screenshot, that they now get a "unable to find valid path to target" error.
8)
Screenies in spoiler to minimise post size.
- 4
Out-of-supply information not appearing in division pop-up
As always, sorry if dupe/WAD/etc (and sorry for the double-post as well). One of the great things a historical playthrough as France allows for is testing being encircled - in this instance and a few others I've noted on the map having either "mild" (the boxes) or "extreme" (the boxed and a red exclamation mark) alerts for out of supply units, but when bring up the unit tooltip through the Army UX element, it doesn't display any out of supply information.
Game version: 1.11.4.69fb
Checksum: b4f8
Repro steps:
1) Load attached save.
2) Find the two Heavy Divisions encircled near Chateuroux, as per the first screenshot.
3) Press F4 to bring up the supply mapmode.
4 )Hover over the divs and observe as per the first screenshot that they're only receiving 12% of their necessary supply.
5) Click on the divs to bring up the Army UI, as per the second screenshot, and observe there are no out-of-supply indicators showing.
6) Hover over either of the encircled divs to bring up the tooltop.
7) Observe as per the second screenshot, not out-of-supply information in the tooltip.
8) Change tack to the encircled units at Rouen (I know, I'm at the peak of my game here
) and click on them, and observe that the supply info is shoing in some situations, as per the third screenshot.
Screenies in spoiler to make visible post size smaller.
As an aside, I love how the cutting of the rail lines affects the French supply network (as a gameplay mechanic - obviously for my poor French army in this playthrough, it's more of a bittersweet thing!)
As always, sorry if dupe/WAD/etc (and sorry for the double-post as well). One of the great things a historical playthrough as France allows for is testing being encircled - in this instance and a few others I've noted on the map having either "mild" (the boxes) or "extreme" (the boxed and a red exclamation mark) alerts for out of supply units, but when bring up the unit tooltip through the Army UX element, it doesn't display any out of supply information.
Game version: 1.11.4.69fb
Checksum: b4f8
Repro steps:
1) Load attached save.
2) Find the two Heavy Divisions encircled near Chateuroux, as per the first screenshot.
3) Press F4 to bring up the supply mapmode.
4 )Hover over the divs and observe as per the first screenshot that they're only receiving 12% of their necessary supply.
5) Click on the divs to bring up the Army UI, as per the second screenshot, and observe there are no out-of-supply indicators showing.
6) Hover over either of the encircled divs to bring up the tooltop.
7) Observe as per the second screenshot, not out-of-supply information in the tooltip.
8) Change tack to the encircled units at Rouen (I know, I'm at the peak of my game here
) and click on them, and observe that the supply info is shoing in some situations, as per the third screenshot.Screenies in spoiler to make visible post size smaller.
As an aside, I love how the cutting of the rail lines affects the French supply network (as a gameplay mechanic - obviously for my poor French army in this playthrough, it's more of a bittersweet thing!)
- 4
- 1
I've noticed the same playing SOV with 1.11.4 b4f8. Chalked it up as a fluke at the time.
- 2
Ships in port can still block hub supply in Allied ports
This looks to be the same as or at least a related issue to the one that cropped up with the initial launch build, but only in Allied ports (I haven't noticed it in my own ports).
Game version: 1.11.4.69fb
Checksum: b4f8
Repro steps:
1) Load attached save, and scroll the map to Asmara in Eritrea.
2) Press F4 to bring up the supply map.
3) Hover over the province (not the division with the "mild" supply alert) and observe, as per the first screenshot, there is plenty of available hub supply in Asmara.
4) Hover over the French division in Asmara and observe, as per the second screenshot, that the division is only receiving "state" supply.
5) Press F2 and switch over to the naval map.
6) Select the French fleet in Asmara, pop a 'hold' order on, and order them out to see, as per the third screenshot.
7) Start time, and advance until the French fleet are happily at sea, and give it a few days so the supply calcs are re-run.
8) Press F4, and hover over the division in Asmara again.
9) Observe, as per the fourth screenshot, the division is receiving hub supply.
Screenies in spoiler:
This looks to be the same as or at least a related issue to the one that cropped up with the initial launch build, but only in Allied ports (I haven't noticed it in my own ports).
Game version: 1.11.4.69fb
Checksum: b4f8
Repro steps:
1) Load attached save, and scroll the map to Asmara in Eritrea.
2) Press F4 to bring up the supply map.
3) Hover over the province (not the division with the "mild" supply alert) and observe, as per the first screenshot, there is plenty of available hub supply in Asmara.
4) Hover over the French division in Asmara and observe, as per the second screenshot, that the division is only receiving "state" supply.
5) Press F2 and switch over to the naval map.
6) Select the French fleet in Asmara, pop a 'hold' order on, and order them out to see, as per the third screenshot.
7) Start time, and advance until the French fleet are happily at sea, and give it a few days so the supply calcs are re-run.
8) Press F4, and hover over the division in Asmara again.
9) Observe, as per the fourth screenshot, the division is receiving hub supply.
Screenies in spoiler:
- 4
- 1
They need to add a toggle to the Strike Force to determine what kinds of enemy ships it should respond to.
- 5
- 1
As I say before, a little bit of madness or overconfidence is absolutely fine. Bad decisions in history? Yeah, they exist, many of them, but whats the point for the game? Most of your examples are also operative decisions, not strategic ones. The AI make decisions here, that end the campaign on the strategic level and that is bad for the game. It's not fun when the AI turns the major enemy or possible strong enemy in the campaign to some kind of joke, with some unnecessary, suicidal war declarations.
I talk about major strategic decisions that are not comprehensible and that are easy to avoid for the AI, if the devs implement some "if-then-else" choices, so the AI can react - just a little bit - to actual gameplay. I don't talk about a mastermind AI, that also fix every operative decision with ease... But the AI should be able to make some simple strategic decisions (delay war X for at least Z months, because I need troops for Y), based on simple tresholds. That will not lead to perfect decisions, but perfection is not the point here.
- 1
I hope you can fix https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...e-path-than-best-available-for-ports.1501910/ before releasing 1.11.4, because it breaks whole supply system over sea mechanics and is literally game breaking. Had to stop my Japanese run because of it as it is objectively impossible to get supply from capital with it.
- 3
The AI loves spamming fighters and nothing else except for a littel cas. the majors should at least try to harass each others naval supply lines with NAVs and TACs
- 1
As an aside, I love how the cutting of the rail lines affects the French supply network (as a gameplay mechanic - obviously for my poor French army in this playthrough, it's more of a bittersweet thing!)
I adore this feature too, although I discovered what was going on the hard way
I now seek to understand the map much more thoroughly before engaging. Terrain, weather and supply are the biggest hurdles, as they were historically.
- 1
- 1
- 1
Navy supply system absolutely broken:
Close navy region and your fleet cant supply.
I cannot fight in a region through which I have forbidden the passage of a merchant convoy???
Little fleet stay in Sherbur (UK in my alliance) and naval from karrier take 67% penalty from supply. 82.3% lack of fuel btw.
Close navy region and your fleet cant supply.
I cannot fight in a region through which I have forbidden the passage of a merchant convoy???
Little fleet stay in Sherbur (UK in my alliance) and naval from karrier take 67% penalty from supply. 82.3% lack of fuel btw.
- 4
- 1
- 1
Mass Charge tactics still available for Mobile Warfare and may be other doctrine? This bug exist quite a long time. From the ss it says it is not unlocked.
- 4
- 2
Fleet management broken:
Select any ships and click to any provinces/port in yellow/red region. ONE click without shift+click.
Select any ships and click to any provinces/port in yellow/red region. ONE click without shift+click.
Last edited:
- 2
- 1
- 1
You people should really be posting these bug reports in the dedicated bug reports part of the forum, instead of this one thread.
- 9
Any word on the 2D models in the tank designer not properly automatically reflecting the parts added to a chassis? In my testing I kept on getting my "Use Best Match" option defaulted to a casemate TD/SPG despite not building anything close to the sort. I've already written a bug report on it, but I'm not sure if it was seen or not. Sorry to bother!
Attachments
- 1
- 1
The Gobi Gambit increase consumer goods factories by 4% instead of decreasing it by 1%. So now its 5% CG to 9% in 1.11.4 instead to 4% like in 1.11.2 was 10% to 9%.
Probably due to fixed value of 5 year plan. Please check if its working as intended (but i am pretty sure its not),
Probably due to fixed value of 5 year plan. Please check if its working as intended (but i am pretty sure its not),
- 3