Thoughts and notes as I reread the thread.
alxeu won the shamvoting.
Night 0 had no one die, curse, blessed, GA or wolves forgetting to hunt on night 0. We can likely exclude the last, and GA would be lucky. Assuming Blessed or curse was it not for the no hunt on night 2 as well. If it was a curse hit they hunt someone else and would have missed again. If it was a blessed hit they likely go for the same person and thus kill someone. Could be a GA that got lucky on night 0 and decided to protect the same person again on night 2.
Gen. Marshall claimed an outing 4 minutes before the deadline, then immediately withdrew saying it was not an outting. We don't know the role of the person he outted as Panzer Commader is still alive, but that a rather risky move for a wolf. Since doing an outting and your outted person not being a baddie is grounds to be lynched immediately.
The fact he managed to stay alive and the person he outted is still alive, is extremely interesting. The fact there was a no hunt the following night (night 2), means that the wolves that hunted that likely believe he was genuine. Since there is no point to hunting someone that would likely be lynched the next day for his actions.
The wolves might have then just hunted him since they knew every scanner was going to scan him. The pack that hunted night 1, might not have been online when he made that post, or did not believe him. Or decided it was too risky as any GA that saw that post would protect him.
It fairly safe to assume that the night 2 hunt was targeted at Gen. Marshall, knowing he would be scanned, and he was GA protected that night.
Gen. Marshall was swung up day 2 as to be expected after his actions on day 1. Very easy vote for wolves to jump on, as was pointed out in the thread, and we know at least one wolf, Daleksbane, did so.
johho888 jumping in to bring up Daleksbane hints to me that he might have scanned Daleksbane and wanted to get him lynched without having to do an outting.
Reading though this, I wonder if Gen. Marshall is our priest and he did the fake outting to get in touch with the roles in the village.
And maybe if it was not even a fake outting, but a real one. He could have scanned Panzar night 0 and found a cultist or a Sorcerer, but I would not expect him to leave the Sorcerer alive and back out on his outting.
All in all, we have a solid JL that is headed by Gen. Marshall.
Now on to who to vote for.
jeray2000 is giving me the most wolfish vibes right now, and here is why.
Gen. Marshall is probably a goodie, a baddie wouldn't attract such attention to themselves. There's a case to be made that he's my packmate and he did that fake outing to try to save me, but since 1. I'm not a baddie and 2. that'd be a really dumb idea that'd get us both lynched if we were packmates.
That a very good post at directing the village to think of jeray2000 and Gen. Marshall together. Exactly what a wolf would want to do after he was almost lynched then saved the last minute by a third party. His other posts do nothing to help redeem him, so he currently my number 1 suspect for a wolf.
.png){kind=avatar}
