so time to pass this over .... one good thing about moderating (demi) is seeing a far greater range of posters than just those who share threads you pay particular attention to. Made me very aware of the range of people who comment dilligently, wittilly, pithily and intelligently (& some manage them all) on a wide range of AARs. Which makes nominating someone none the easier ... so, I'll pass it on to Derehan, who has recently started a number of AARs using the clever idea of late start dates or specific wars in EU3 (all of which are entertaining) and comments widely ... meeting all the criteria above. But I could have easily passed it to 5-6 regular posters.
so, meet your new fan of the week: Derehan