• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

L. Jzn. Koster

Grand Admiral
105 Badges
Jan 25, 2013
49
12
  • Sengoku
  • Hearts of Iron III
  • Hearts of Iron III: Their Finest Hour
  • Hearts of Iron III Collection
  • Heir to the Throne
  • Leviathan: Warships
  • March of the Eagles
  • Europa Universalis IV: Res Publica
  • Victoria: Revolutions
  • Semper Fi
  • Cities in Motion
  • Cities: Skylines - Snowfall
  • Victoria 2: A House Divided
  • Victoria 2: Heart of Darkness
  • Stellaris - Path to Destruction bundle
  • Tyranny: Gold Edition
  • Cities: Skylines - Natural Disasters
  • Europa Universalis IV: Pre-order
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cossacks
  • Cities: Skylines - After Dark
  • Europa Universalis IV: Wealth of Nations
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Crusader Kings II: Charlemagne
  • Crusader Kings II: Legacy of Rome
  • Crusader Kings II: The Old Gods
  • Crusader Kings II: Rajas of India
  • Crusader Kings II: The Republic
  • Crusader Kings II: Sons of Abraham
  • Crusader Kings II: Sword of Islam
  • Darkest Hour
  • Europa Universalis III
  • Europa Universalis III: Chronicles
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Divine Wind
  • Europa Universalis IV: Art of War
  • Europa Universalis IV: Conquest of Paradise
  • For the Motherland
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Colonel
  • Hearts of Iron IV Sign-up
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Cadet
  • Stellaris Sign-up
  • Crusader Kings II: Horse Lords
  • Europa Universalis IV: Common Sense
  • Crusader Kings II: Way of Life
  • Mount & Blade: With Fire and Sword
  • Europa Universalis IV: El Dorado
  • Hearts of Iron IV: No Step Back
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Europa Universalis IV
NfAMZRu.png

Home of the Free
A Silver Legion USA AAR

Version: Hearts of Iron IV v1.2.1 'Sunflower'
Mods: none
Difficulty: Normal, but with bonuses applied to several nations
Historical Focus: On, to make this a more believable alternative history

My first After Action Report, how exciting :p. Though I've never written a full AAR down, as a player I often try to create a narrative in my games, and do a little roleplay. Paradox Development Studio's games are really good for that.

I'm not sure how this will works out, so this will be an adventure. As for the style, I think a historybook-like style suits my writing best (less gameplay-focused), but this is my first AAR so I probably will be a bit searching to find the best pace. So please come along for the ride and we'll see how it goes. Any feedback is welcome!

Table of Contents
Chapter 1 - The 1936 election
Chapter 2 - The Silver Revolution
Chapter 3 - The Giant Wakes (March - August 1939)
Interlude - The Blue Corps
Chapter 4 - Blitzkrieg (September - October 1939)
 
Last edited:
4FByiQr.png

Chapter 1 - The 1936 election

The United States of America had been hit hard by the stock market crash of October 29, 1929. This Black Tuesday signalled the start of the Great Depression. Unemployment rose to never seen levels, and international trade plunged. It was no suprise that incumbent president Herbert Hoover was defeated in the 1932 election by Democratic governor Franklin D. Roosevelt. Roosevelt promised a "New Deal" to the American people. In the following years many parts of this policy where implemented. The Public Works Administration (WPA), established by Roosevelt, spent billions to create new projects, which provided employment and economic benefits.

This high spending resulted in criticism of the Roosevelt administration. While some people advanced in living standard, many were still poor and unemployed. Roosevelt continued the capitalistic policies of his predecessors, which had caused the Great Depression. Some people stood up against this injustice. One of them was Charles Coughlin, an influential catholic priest. Each week millions tuned in to his radio broadcasts to hear someone who would call out against the rich bankers.

-- Excerpt from "The Silver Revolution", 1965


The 1936 elections turned out to be one of the most contested elections in recent history. Many expected Senator Huey Long to run, the man who created the Share Our Wealth program. His politics went farther than Roosevelt's. But Long was assassinated in 1935, thus paving the way for a re-election of Roosevelt. Unexpectedly, however, Senator William Borah, until then member of the Republican Party, announced a candidacy on the premise of Long's program and backed by radio preacher Charles Coughlin. While Republican candidate Alf Landon didn't really campaign, Borah attacked Roosevelt on his policies, stating that they were only benefitting the rich. This message resonated with a lot of people, and resulted in a very close election.

In the end, Alf Landon was ironically the one who benefitted the most. Probably because Borah took a lot of votes from Roosevelt, or maybe because Landon seemed a safer choice, Alf Landon won the elections with only the smallest majority possible of 266 electoral votes, and in January 1937 was sworn in as the 33rd President of the United States. This to the dismay of both Democrats and Coughlin and his supporters, who didn't want a rich businessman such as Landon as the country leader.

dw4hF5w.png

Results of the 1936 election. Blue denotes those states that were won by Roosevelt/Garner, red states won by Landon/Knox, green states won by Borah/Lemke.

After the election, Coughlin became separated with Borah because of the former nationalistic views. There were however more and more Americans who tuned in to his radio broadcasts, due to the ever progressing Great Depression, something Landon did even worse to combat compared to Roosevelt. Without political support in Washington, Coughlin had little influence on the nation and it seemed America would be a poor, weak nation for a long time to come. It was not until he met William Dudley Pelley, leader of the nationalistic (and some say, fascistic) Silver Legion of America, that the radio priest revitalised his political aspirations.

Coughlin and Pelley found a lot of common ground in their aversion of both communism and Wall Street. Pelley, who ran unsuccesfully for president in 1936, wanted a strong, interventionist America. The current and previous government, he said, were controlled by rich bankers and other powers. Both men shared their sympathy for foreign leaders Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini. Hitler dragged Germany from the Great Depression by building a new German army. A policy Pelley supported fully. The American military was neglected for too long, and Japan was rapidly building a new fleet which would outclass the outdated American navy. By creating a large army and founding a weapons industry, Pelley thought, America could both combat unemployment and raise income and taxes.

bbJU4fb.png

A meeting of Silver Legion members during the 1930s. Note the Roman captal L's on the silver shirts.

With the support of the Silver Legion, Coughlin was backed by an ever growing organization. Membership of the Legion surpassed 10 million at the beginning of 1938. In every state a local chapter was founded. The paramilitary part of the Legion, the Silver Shirts, attracted lots of unemployed young people and veterans of the world war. The Communist Party of America, never really big, was quickly suppressed by the armed Silver Shirts. This of course was not legal, but the government turned a blind eye to the increasing powerful organization.

With the Great Depression still a large problem and tensions rising in Europe, in the spring of 1938 many party members called for an armed uprising against the indecisive Landon government. Pelley and Coughlin however wanted a democratic revolution, to give legitimacy to the new goverment, comparable to how Hitler took power in Germany. Then, they thought, they would have support of all layers of society, and they could build a new, strong America. An America which would be prosperous and the leading world power.
 
Last edited:
subbed, looks interesting
 
4FByiQr.png

Chapter 2 - The Silver Revolution

"I will not allow this goverment to take right in its own hands and let the army kill people exercising their constitutional rights."
-- General Douglas MacArthur to president Landon, as quoted in "The Silver Revolution"

During 1938 the Silver Legion of America continued it's explosive growth, fuelled by the increasing distrust of the goverment. Some influential businessmen declared their support for the party or Charles Coughlin, who attracted even more listeners to his radio broadcasts. William Dudley Pelley traveled through the country to speak at mass rallies. At the beginning of 1939, membership had rised to a staggering 30 million. More and more supporters called for action against the government.

The Landon administration became increasingly paralyzed over the issue of how to deal with the Silver Legion. While some members advocated some sort of coalition, others suggested to take action against the paramilitary Silver Shirts. The Democratic Party, while not happy with Landon and how he was dealing with the large economic issues, shared their aversion of the Silver Legion. "We must never allow a fascist group to take over these United States", former president Roosevelt declared. This, however, had the result that Silver Legion members more and more began to distrust the political system.

A seemingly small issue eventually sparked the beginning of what later would be called "the Silver Revolution". In a lawsuit against Standard Oil of California some information surfaced about contacts between the company leadership and president Landon's entourage. While it was not clear if this was some sort of corruption where Landon was bribed by Standard Oil, Charles Coughlin took this opportunity with both hands. In his radio broadcasts, Landon was called a mere puppet of large companies, who willingly let the Great Depression endure. While not calling directly for Landon's resignation, Silver Legion members didn't need any more encouragement. On the 22nd of January, 1939, in California Silver Legion members and supporters took to the streets to demand Landon's resignation. During the next week, protests spread like wildfire throughout the country.

kcBuOPJ.jpg

Protests and irregularities in New York

On 27 January the news broke that the government wanted to forbid Coughlin's broadcasts "to prevent hate speech and spreading rumors against government officials".

On the 28th, William Dudley Pelley spoke to an enormous crowd of at least a hundred thousand people in Washington DC. He condemned the 'corrupt' government and called for action. Thousands of people then took up the call and marched through the streets in the direction of the White House. They where blocked by army and National Guard troops, who the goverment had called up out fear for an outright revolution. A tense situation developed, which could easily have ended in a bloodbath. Silver Shirts from the vicinity of Washington rushed to the city to defend their fellow Legionairies. In the evening, general Douglas MacArthur, a famous World War I general and recently reinstated as Chief of Staff, took to the barricades and announced the government's willingness to step down, if that could prevent bloodshed. He ordered the army to not take any action against the peaceful protesters.

qMA6ixc.jpg

Protesters and Silver Shirts march to the White House

On the 29th of January, 1939, Alf Landon spoke to the nation in a radio broadcast. While he clearly showed disgust by the turn of events, he announced that, having lost support of both the army and the people, he and Vice President Knox would step down and hand power over to the President pro tempore of the Senate, Robert La Follette. The next day La Follette announced elections for the following month, to take place on the 1st of March.

With the Republican Party shattered, the only opposition to the Silver Legion came from the Democratic Party. Former president Roosevelt vowed to prevent a "fascist coup" by any means necessary. However, support for the Legion was overwhelming and time too short to assemble a real campaign. Silver Shirts intimidated voters to stay home. Houses of communists and other 'leftists' where smeared. In this climate of fear, the 1939 elections took place. They resulted in a landslide victory for the Silver Legion of America. On March 10, 1939, William Dudley Pelley was sworn in as the 34th President of the United States.
 
Last edited:
One picture doesn't work.

Nice update. Fascist USA, let's see what's coming next.
 
"I will not allow this goverment to take right in its own hands and let the army kill people exercising their constitutional rights."
-- General Douglas MacArthur to president Landon, as quoted in "The Silver Revolution"

And here we see that MacArthur has had an epiphany of sorts; mere six years after his infamous crushing of
"The Bonus Army" on the streets of Washington. Strange times indeed!
 
"I will not allow this goverment to take right in its own hands and let the army kill people exercising their constitutional rights."
-- General Douglas MacArthur to president Landon, as quoted in "The Silver Revolution"

And here we see that MacArthur has had an epiphany of sorts; mere six years after his infamous crushing of
"The Bonus Army" on the streets of Washington. Strange times indeed!

I see it as an opportunistic action from MacArthur: he sees the threat of a possible civil war and rather has a fascist goverment in power than let the American slaughter themselves again. And of course his actions directly leading to the downfall of the democratic goverment will probably not be forgotten by the new leadership...
 
Rumors abound throughout Washington that MacArthur's recent actions, duly noted by President Elect Pelley
may in fact lead to his appointment as Chief Of The Army. Is it possible for the administration to comment
or confirm/deny said rumors at this time?
The new government certainly needs to secure the support of the army. What this means for MacArthur? You'll see in the next chapter...
 
4FByiQr.png

Chapter 3 - The Giant Wakes
March - August 1939


"I will do whatever it takes to make America prosper again. Other nations will look to us again as a beacon of prosperity and stability. We will defend our freedoms, which were so hard fought, by any means necessary. The enemies of the republic want to undermine our great nation, but we will not let them succeed. America will prevail!"
-- William Dudley Pelley, in his inauguration speech

The new goverment went energetically to work. New funds for the development of arms, airplanes and tanks were granted, and army training programmes were extended, though they remained small in nature. While the effects of the Great Depression were still feeled, many expressed hope that the Pelley administration would solve the situation quickly. Within a few months, many government officials were replaced by Silver Legion supporters. Douglas MacArthur, who famously ensured the downfall of the Landon government by refusing the let the army take action against the Silvershirts, was lauded as 'Hero of the Revolution'. He would remain as the Chief of Staff, thus ensuring the support of the army. Charles Coughlin, now Secretary of Information in the Pelley administration, became one of the most influential men after the president. Congress gave Pelley many temporary powers to build the economy as quickly as possible. It became clear that though it was always denied by Pelley and Coughlin, the Silver Legion in reality was an organization with increasing fascistic tendencies.

qePdcEW.png

William Dudley Pelley's official presidential portrait as a post-war painting

Though the previous Landon and Roosevelt governments had continued the United States' isolationist policies, they were close to the democratic countries in Europe, especially Britain. This relationship grew cold quickly when Pelley undertook effort to establish more co-operation between America and Germany and Italy. He never made a secret of his admiration for the leaders of both countries. This culmunated in the much publicised visit of Adolf Hitler to the United States in June 1939. Together with other high-ranking German officials the German leader visited cities on the east coast including Washington and New York, and was warmly welcomed by many Americans.

xnJvkcY.jpg

Adolf Hitler in New York

While no official treaties came out of this visit, it showed the changed political climate in America. Former president Roosevelt was allowed to emigrate to Britain, a move the government would later regret as it allowed him to continue criticizing the Silver Legion government.

With Germany's recent annexation of Czechoslovakia, Pelley also began to look over the borders. On April 5 he secretly ordered the start of an operation to support his ideas in both Canada and Mexico, under supervision of Information secretary Coughlin. Dedicated Silver Legion members were to cross the border and search for and fund local parties who supported the Silver Legion. Pelley hoped that this could spark a similar revolution as had happened in the United States in the neighboring countries and thus protect America's borders from all sides from a potential attack. During the June visit of the German delegation, Coughlin openly announced American support for the Canadian Unity Party, until then a marginal political movement. Americans in Canada were encouraged to join the organization. Of course the Canadian government strongly objected to this, but with tensions rising in Europe it was not of great concern to Britain and France.

ygqmzr6.png

On June 15, when Hitler and his delegation were on the way back to Europe on board the heavy cruiser (or as they called it, 'pocket battleship') Deutschland, news came out that Germany and the Soviet Union had concluded a pact. What this so-called 'Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact' (after the Soviet and German foreign ministers) stipulated was not entirely clear, but that the Germans had concluded a diplomatic deal with the communist power and enjoyed closer ties was obvious. Pelley, a fervent anti-communist, was reportedly very angered by this. The German ambassador to the United States ensured that his government would never trust the Soviet Union but that this treaty was a short-term necessity to prevent Germany from facing a two-front war. Though Pelley accepted this explanation, his trust in Germany would never fully recover.

Quickly after this, another pact was concluded, this time between Germany and Italy. While Mussolini and Hitler had some disagreement in the past years over several issues such as Austria, this new Pact of Steel binded their two nations together to 'protect common interests'.

CyKd38S.jpg

Signing of the Pact of Steel

This new alliance had the potential to shake up Europe and the United States' government, while still wary about the pact with the communists, would become closer and closer to the two powers.

Road to war
On August 23, 1939, the German Reich presented an ultimatum to the Polish government with very harsh terms. Poland was to hand over Danzig, which separated the German mainland from East Prussia, immediately and negiotiate further terms. The Polish refused as it was obvious, as they pointed out, that the Germans wouldn't be satisfied with Danzig alone but would demand more land. In the early morning of August 24 German troops crossed the border with Poland after 'much provocation of the Polish army', as the Germans stated. Once again there was war in Europe.

6uavKGm.png

On the August 27 the most disturbing news came. China, which had been at war with the Empire of Japan for almost two years, couldn't withstand the enormous pressure the Japanese had been putting on for the last months. Having lost the coast and most of the inland, the government fell apart. In an internal coup, Chiang Kai-shek was deposed an replaced by Wang Jingwei, a close associate of the late Sun Yat-sen. The new goverment asked for peace, which was reached under harsh terms. China was to cede it's entire coast to Japan and give up most of their national resources and army, effectively becoming a Japanese puppet state. The Chinese had no option but to accept. The communist rebels under Mao Zedong were quickly dispersed. The end of the Sino-Japanese War freed Japan to look for new targets, specifically the colonies of the European powers in Asia. What this would mean for peace in Asia and the American posessions in the Pacific and the Phillippines, only time would tell.

ZVf2NTu.jpg

Former Chinese leader Chiang Kai-shek, right, and new President of the Republic of China Wang Jingwei, left

In the United States, the government used these events to quickly pass new legislation which handed even more powers to the president. "If there will be a conflict, the United States will not be taken by surprise," Pelley announced in a public radio broadcast. "I have authorised a new, extensive program, of which the likes have never seen, to prepare us for a potential struggle, which could arise in the future. Every men and women needs to do his or her duty to defend their country. It is of the utmost importance." The United States economy would be completely subservient to this new armament effort. Important companies were nationalized or put under supervision by a new 'Committee for the Combined Army Effort', consisting of Silver Legion members and army leaders such as MacArthur.

mPlS9OR.png


Though the Germans stated that they 'only want to take what is rightfully ours' in Poland, and insisted that there was still a possibility to avoid an all-out European war, on August 28 the United Kingdom declared war on Germany, swiftly followed by France. Italy immediately honoured their pact and declared war on both countries. Once again a small European conflict escalated into a greater war. A war where the United States of America would not stand on the sidelines. The Giant had Waken.

njRn1mo.png

A local newspaper announcing the entry of Britain and France to the war in Europe

------
Author's note: Phew, a rather long chapter. But now that the war has started, expect more gameplay in the next updates, though it will still take some time before the United States gets involved.
 
Last edited:
A New Year for a New America!

I'm enjoying this AAR and I'm looking forward to see it unfold!
 
I look forward to see this America at war.