• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
I going to guess that the Spanish campaign takes 4 months. Also, are you hitting your fuel reserves since you are motorizing much of the Wehrmacht?

4 months is fine, as long as that includes the capture of Gibraltar. With Nordlicht on hold, there is no demand for more troops. I have at least 8 Korps available for Romania. The Luftwaffe has bomber units doing nothing.

I am banking on a break in combat of 4-6 months before Barbarossa to allow for upgrades and increased prod'n of infantry. So I want to wrap up Romania by say October 1940.

Fuel is still fine: 89k in reserve, with 42k oil to be converted.
 
Looks like you've broken through in the mountains! congrats. Removing that extra Korps seems to have freed a ton of supplies and done the trick. I woudnt cancel the Gebirgs yet though, you might find them useful sweeping up.

I agree with you on the topic of Tac and Cas, not only can they soften up the battlefield, their use can turn a loss or holding attack into sweet victory. I ALLWAYS add a multiroll fighter to a flight of 2 bombers as escort and try to litter the front with lvl4 airfields for them. the fighter may reduce the Tac range (until the research comes through) and add a stacking penalty but without them my fleets spend way too much time in their hangers. I hope along with all that infrastructure in the east you have also added air fields.

With intercepters however I think flights of 2 work best with smaller overlaping areas of operation. I try to hit the bomberstreams at least twice before they reach their targets and then again on their way out. Flights of 2 dont acrue big stacking penalties and if you promote one or both of the generals they can cover the command ratio. Now if only all those flak towers actually worked (still not fixed in SF, in my opinion).
 
Good updates, Uriah. Spain should go fairly quickly now. Try to get some overflights or mayby a uboat peak at the rock area, that will give you an idea of what is going on and allow you to plan.
 
Forgot you were using your interceptors on AI :) which makes the process a "bit" more challenging.

4 month in Spain sounds like a long time, but then again just moving to Gibraltar takes some weeks.
 
EDIT: to pre-empt any queries, I don't think that the Italian AI will declare war on Greece twice in a normal game. It has happened in this AAR because I replayed the game (twice) to accomodate large updates .





Rank and File
A Clerk’s War​

Monday 26th April to Thursday 26th April 1940

The only topic of conversation in the Reichsluftfahrtministerium is the incredible rate at which we are losing planes and pilots. Both the RAF and the FARE seem prepared to throw wave after wave of fighter and bombers at us, day and night. Our 12 Jagdgeschwader are not able to counter all the threats, and the cost of replacements is starting to impact our economy. There are solutions, but all will require time. Of course, there is no lack of incentive for guilt to be apportioned, but even Göring realises that a show trial or two will not staunch the steady drain on the Luftwaffe. The bottom line is that Luftwaffe leadership did not anticipate that the RAF would be so aggressive, and our military intelligence did not realise the size of the FARE.

Urgent telegrams have been sent to all army commanders in OB West and OB Nord: air operations are to be purely defensive in nature. For the moment at least, our aircraft are to be conserved for protection. Personally I don’t think this will work. With a fighter pilot as a brother, I know the sort of man that joins these units. They will bend the rules so far that they will consider a strafing mission on Buckingham Palace as a defensive measure.

It will be at least four months before any new aircraft can roll off the Messerschmitt production line: with the end of Unternehmen Stahlknüppel it was believed that we had sufficient interceptors. We had outfought both the Armée de l’Air and the RAF: there was no air force in the world to match us. While we rested on our laurels, the British improved their aircraft and must have dedicated a large section of their industrial base to fighter production. We have heard that the British appointed a Canadian, Lord Beaverbrook, to be Minister of Air Production. This sounds very odd, but if true, this man has worked wonders. The RAF, in just a matter of months, has changed from an ineffectual group of antiquated aircraft to a force that has nearly brought the Luftwaffe to its knees.

bf109final.jpg


A new contract for Messerschmitt Bf 109 fighters has been signed, but it will take months for the first of these to be ready for assignment to a frontline unit.

The dismal news continued. All morning 5th Jagdfliegerkorps fought Portal’s three RAF Fighter Groups, and did fairly well, losing 19 aircraft while downing 16. By noon, however, Bogatsch could only guarantee 130 planes for the afternoon, and Waber’s 6th Jagdfliegerkorps was ordered to patrol the Channel. For an unknown reason, Portal did not reappear, but that didn’t help “Udet” and “Pik As”. Fairey Albacores and Fulmars from a Carrier Air Group somehow managed to surprise them, and “Udet” lost four aircraft before Waber ordered them to pull back to the coast.

airdover2am234final.jpg


5th Jagdfliegerkorps has lost heavily, and was forced to fight a much larger force over Dover

aireenglsihchannel5pm23.jpg


6th Jagdfliegerkorps took over in the afternoon, and was immediately in action against a carrier air group in the Eastern English Channel. It was essential to keep the enemy planes busy, as von Nordeck with II Unterseebootsflotte was nearby, and he would not like the Royal Navy fleet of 2 aircraft carrier, two heavy cruiser and 4 destroyer squadrons to locate his U-boats.

Dominating the news on Monday, however, was the news from Rome: at midnight Mussolini had issued an ultimatum to the Metaxas government in Athens. Cutting through the “diplomatese”, Il Duce demanded free access for the Regio Esercito to the entire country and the use of Greek air bases and ports. Refusal would mean war. During the day it was as if the Foreign Ministry had nothing else to do but to wait for the Greek response, but privately every expert on Greek affairs predicted that Metaxas would never agree to the terms, which really meant allowing his country to be occupied without a struggle. The memory of the invasion last July, which had led to a stalemate, was still fresh in the minds of the Greeks, and they would be reluctant to concede after having held the Italians and forced them to peace. (The surrender occurred while I was in hospital recovering from my injuries received in the Patch 1.3 conspiracy assassination attempt).

Late in the afternoon came the telegram that everyone expected: General Metaxas rejected the ultimatum entirely. No offer to negotiate, no embroidery with diplomatic phases. A simple no. Within an hour our military attaché in Rome was on the telephone to OKW, confirming that Italian infantry and armour were crossing the Albanian border into Greece, and that the Regia Aeronautica was already bombing target in border provinces. It is a safe assumption that every Italian naval squadron in the Adriatische Meer and the Ägäisches Meer is on the lookout for Greek shipping.

greece234final.jpg


Albania and Greece at the moment that the Italians declared war: the Regio Esercito massed at the border

The news was not welcome in Berlin. OKH has been trying for some time to encourage the Italians to concentrate on pushing to Egypt. Closing the Suez Canal to the Royal Navy has been a key objective not just of the Kriegsmarine but our entire armed forces. Forcing the British to reroute every troopship, supply ship and merchantman around the Cape of Good Hope would be a triumph in itself, but to also fragment their defence forces would push their logistics to breaking point.

bridgefinal.jpg


Italian sappers strengthen a bridge to allow tanks and heavy trucks to advance: roads are virtually non-existent and motorised and armoured units face lengthy delays

Not only will this Greek adventure distract the Italians but it will also drag us into another conflict. Much of the Italian invasion force is marching through Yugoslavia and Minister Schacht is already complaining about it using vast amounts of supplies. I heard that General von Blomberg, usually a man in control of his emotions, threw his telephone at his office door. Von Ribbentrop, always far more excitable, launched a tirade of abuse at Il Duce. Fluent in both English and French, he impressed his staff with epithets not only in those languages, but also with some choice words in Russian, Polish, Spanish, Italian and Hungarian. He must have some interesting diplomatic exchanges. The rumour is that the Führer was also displeased, but it is far more difficult to find a source for scandalous stories about the Reichskanzler.

cavalleriafinal.jpg


Italian cavalry move into Greece, their mobility a distinct advantage in the rugged terrain

As we have now come to expect, little news of progress in the Greek campaign came from the Italians. Our Embassy in Rome has been ordered to send a few experienced officers to Albania to observe, but it will take a while to get the necessary approvals. Count Ciano has been assisting, and has made it clear that he was not in favour of this expansion of the “Empire”. It has been driven purely by Mussolini, wanting to make a name for himself.

So Tuesday the interesting events were from Spain. Even the RAF held off, with just one clash in the Channel, late at night. Waber had an inconclusive air battle with 14th and 15th Carrier Air Groups. No losses on either side were reported, with the overcast conditions that night making almost impossible to locate targets.

airwenglishchannel8pm24.jpg


Air Battle of the Western English Channel on the night of 24th April. Another British fleet is present, this one containing an escort carrier, two battleships, a battlecruiser, two light cruisers and two destroyer squadrons.

The first news from Spain was that Nehring’s 1st Panzer Division had triumphed in Soria. He lost some tanks and quite a few of his motorised infantry (a total of 200 men) but the more than 20,000 defenders are pulling back, having suffered 856 casualties. Nehring must have breathed a sigh of relief: General Rommel had emphasised that crossing the Duero was essential to maintain the tempo of the advance. He would not have relished having to advise the Commander of the Sud-Frankreich Army that his panzertruppen had failed.

The only other item of importance was that the Battle of Tudela has commenced. 2.Infanterie (mot) is currently embroiled in quite serious fighting with 1a Division, led by General Líster Forján. General Petersen has every regiment at full strength and his 10,000 men are rested and have no lack of supplies, so they should soon force the 6,000 defenders to retreat to Zaragoza.

tudelafinal.jpg


Battle of Tudela

Early on Wednesday Waber reported that the British were back and his fighters over the Channel Approach were engaging air units from at least two carriers. As the morning progressed, the battle flowed east, and the enemy was replaced by a mixed force consisting of Fulmars from another carrier and the land-based 211 Fighter Group. “Udet” lost 6 aircraft during the morning, while “Pik As” was untouched.

airwenglishchannelnoon2.jpg


Air Battle of Western English Channel : noon on 25th April

Two battles began in Spain on 25th April, and one battle was won.

The first battle involved “Wunsdorf” tank regiment, so once again I was on edge as I thought of Heinz pushing his PzKpfw II forward, leading the advance. There is no way any of the new PzKpfw 38(t) vehicles could have reached 3rd leichte Panzer yet. I scoured the meagre information received from von Manstein’s headquarters, and was relieved to see the opposition in Almazan was categorised as “cavalry: no support”. One thing had remained constant during Unternehmen Stierkampf: the Spanish infantry and cavalry had no anti-tank weapons worth speaking off. The enemy commander was known to be Pozas Perea, a man who had commanded cavalry units through the Civil War, but who had a reputation as being quite impetuous and a risk taker. During the Civil War he had been associated with several disastrous attacks, costing the lives of thousands of his troops. Could he fling his men forward, regardless of casualties, in an attempt to break our lines? Then I relaxed completely when I saw that to get to Almazam from Anguiano we would have to cross the River Duero. Assuming all the bridges had been blown by the Spanish forces, by the time a bridge strong enough to bear the Panzers was constructed, the enemy would be long gone, using their horses to get a head start on our fast light tanks.

almazamfinal.jpg


Battle of Almazam

I spent much less time examining the details of the other battle: an attack on Abejar by General Curtze and 20.Infanterie (mot). This was no doubt very unfair, as Curtze’s operation was far more dangerous. But that’s life: if you don’t know anyone involved, it doesn’t matter as much. 20.infanterie (mot) were also attacking from Anguiano, and also had the Duero barring their way forward. But there the similarities stopped. Rather than 6,000 cavalry led by a general with a questionable record, Curtze faced the Russian General Batov, whose reputation for strong and capable leadership had only been enhanced by recent battles. Batov had 14,000 men, including 1 Brigada Montana, a crack unit that we have encountered before. The evaluation from Rommel’s headquarters puts the chances of 20.Infanterie (mot) making a successful crossing at less than 50%, though this may improve if the Luftwaffe can get good conditions for low level bombing.

abejarfinal.jpg


Battle of Abejar

The battle won was in Tardajos. Blaskowitz, as he had suggested in his pre-battle report, had a routine victory, the Spanish fighting hard initially, but rapidly crumbling as 29.infanterie (mot) brought more and more firepower to bear. What had disconcerted him was the numbers of enemy encountered. Although our initial view was that Tardajos was held by about 11,000 men, this was a gross underestimate. At the end of the battle Blaskowitz had evidence that he had faced in excess of double that number, and believed that many of the extra troops were the survivors of the Battle of Burgos, fleeing west along the northern bank of the Duero. As a result his losses, at 206 men, were higher than expected, while the enemy casualties (682) reflected the disorganised nature of the fighting. It is not often that General Batov suffers such a loss ration when in defence.

All day Thursday there was nothing but messages and updates about air battles. I have never been so glad to think of Ernst sitting with his leg up, unable to fly. It is selfish, but the past few weeks have seen horrendous losses in fighter pilots, and I feel grateful every time I see a list of lost and missing pilots, knowing that Ernst is safe and well. I am sure he does not feel the same way; he will be increasingly frustrated at the slowness of his recovery, particularly as “Schlageter” geschwader has suffered high losses.

“Schlageter” and “Richthofen” were mentioned in the first item for the day, taking off before dawn to drive off carrier aircraft bombing 20.Infanterie in Salas de los Infantes. They spent most of the day flying back and forth from Bayonne, as Gore-Sutherland-Mitchell led his two carrier air groups in a series of bombing missions. 2nd Jagdfliegerkorps lost 8 Messerschmitts over the course of the day, but they managed to keep our losses on the ground below 100 men, as well as destroying 11 enemy aircraft.

airsdelosi10pm264final.jpg


The last battle of the day over Salas de los Infantes: a success for 2nd Jagdfliegerkorps

The other area of air combat saw the Luftwaffe on the defensive. Generalleutnant Dörstling had been given orders to support the attack by 3rd leichte Panzerkorps, and his Ju 88s were busy blasting the Spanish out of their redoubts and earthworks overlooking likely crossing points over the Duero. The task was difficult enough as low cloud and some local thunderstorms made flying dangerous, so the arrival of Hidalgo de Cisneros with 275 fighters just before midday was particularly unwelcome. 6th Kampffliegerkorps was already understrength, and the escort geschwader, “Blitz”, could only muster 89 fighters. “Storch” and “Reiher” between them had only 169 bombers. 1er, 20 and 3er Grupo de Caza returned two more times during the day, and the losses mounted. By the end of the day, 6th Kampffliegerkorps had lost four fighters and nine more bombers. Spanish losses are believed to be only three aircraft. There is not as much laughter in the halls of the Reichsluftfahrministerium about the I-15 biplanes of the FARE.

airalmazam11pm244final.jpg


Air Battle of Almazam: despite the losses the Luftwaffe kept up the attacks until 11PM, aware that our infantry relied upon them to clear the way across the Duero. For Heinz’ sake I hope they succeeded.

The final news of the day came from Minister Schacht: a simple one line press announcement, but one fraught with meaning. All contracts involving the provision of military supplies to the Soviet Union have been cancelled, with effect from midnight. This will throw our budget into a huge deficit, as the cash for military goods pays for much of our oil purchases from the Russians. I know that we captured huge amounts of foreign currency in the past few months, but this will not last forever. Someone must have done the calculations and decided that we need the supplies more than the money. The first drumbeats of the “Drang nach Osten” have been heard.


Bombing Summary

Luftwaffe

Soria: Kesselring with 1st Schlachtfliegerkorps (2 x Ju 87B): 71, 197, 141, 67, 139
Tadajos: Sperrle with 1st Kampffliegerkorps (1 x Bf 109E, 2 x Ju 88): 54, 131, 273, 192, 186, 21
Tadajos: Dörstling with 1st and 6th Kampffliegerkorps (2 x Bf 109E, 4 x Ju 88): 227, 226, 244, 214
Tudela: Kesselring with 1st Schlachtfliegerkorps (2 x Ju 87B): 49, 194, 156
Tadajos: Dörstling with 6th Kampffliegerkorps (1 x Bf 109E, 2 x Ju 88): 157
Abejar: Kesselring with 1st Schlachtfliegerkorps (2 x Ju 87B): 154, 86
Almazam: Dörstling with 6th Kampffliegerkorps (1 x Bf 109E, 2 x Ju 88): 167, 47, 54


RAF (Royal Navy Air Arm)

Salas de los Infantes: Gore-Sutherland-Mitchell with 16th and 17th Carrier Air Groups: 12, 34, 21, NIL


Unterseebootsflotte Activity Report

Agadir Canyon: 1 transport (UK): Dover – Diego Garcia: Wolf with 4th U-flotte
South Eastern Azores Fracture Zone: 1 transport (Spanish): Cádiz – Boston: Wolf with 4th U-flotte
Eastern Madeira Plain: 1 transport (Greek): Athina – Halifax: Wolf with 4th U-flotte
Cape St Vincent: 1 escort (Spanish): Cádiz – Boston: Wolf with 4th U-flotte
Southern Azores Biscay Rise: 2 transports (UK): Dover – Kuala Belait: Aßmann with 1st U-flotte

greecefinal.jpg


The Italians are making progress in Greece, doing far better than they did in their ill-fated July 1939 offensive. Led by elite Alpini and armour units, they have already taken the provinces of Kastoria and Florina.

libiafinal.jpg


Unfortunately the success in Greece has not been mirrored in Libia. The abject retreat continues, with a single infantry division blocking the way to the major port and airbase at Benghazi. Every other unit is fleeing at full speed.

tojinanfinal.jpg


The news from China is looking up, as the Imperial Japanese Army and its Manchurian allies are finally co-ordinating attacks to the east, pushing along the coast and the important city of Jinan.

indochinafinalt.jpg


Nearly half Indo-China has been captured by Guangxi forces. Another Japanese division has arrived, albeit only garrison troops. Realistically, however, two divisions will hardly slow the advancing Chinese.

spaintempfinalend.jpg


Unternehmen Stierkampf: the first unit of 2nd Gebirgsjägerkorps has almost reached Bayonne. Behlendorff’s 6th SS Freiwilligen-Gebirgsjäger Division “Nord” is urgently needed as the expanding length of the front is proving hard for the Sud-Frankreich Army to adequately control.
 
Last edited:
I hope that the Greeks will quickly submit to Rome. Italian elite units would be far more useful in North Africa.
 
Looks like you've broken through in the mountains! congrats. Removing that extra Korps seems to have freed a ton of supplies and done the trick. I woudnt cancel the Gebirgs yet though, you might find them useful sweeping up.

I agree with you on the topic of Tac and Cas, not only can they soften up the battlefield, their use can turn a loss or holding attack into sweet victory. I ALLWAYS add a multiroll fighter to a flight of 2 bombers as escort and try to litter the front with lvl4 airfields for them. the fighter may reduce the Tac range (until the research comes through) and add a stacking penalty but without them my fleets spend way too much time in their hangers. I hope along with all that infrastructure in the east you have also added air fields.

With intercepters however I think flights of 2 work best with smaller overlaping areas of operation. I try to hit the bomberstreams at least twice before they reach their targets and then again on their way out. Flights of 2 dont acrue big stacking penalties and if you promote one or both of the generals they can cover the command ratio. Now if only all those flak towers actually worked (still not fixed in SF, in my opinion).

Pudd1nator: I think the removal of 2nd Pzkorps was long overdue: looking back they did virtually nothing. I hope the supply situation in Yugo is better: at least it is not a narrow pipeline.

And I agree wholeheartedly with your comments re fighters: my TACs were spending more time getting repaired before I realised they needed escorts. I don't use them for CAS: they are cheap enough to rotate around.

For most games I have found 2 interceptors enough, but I haven't played a lot with the new AI. I suspect that I will have to increase my Air korps to 3 to counter the more aggressive RAF. But I will also soon upgrade from Bf 109Es: let's see how the RAF handle more advanced aircraft.

My fixed flak doesn't last long enough to see if it works: I only have level 2 in most places and they get creamed inthe first hit. I would like to increase them but there is a limit on what I can do at one time. Maybe I should have done more in the pre-war. AA brigades definitely work, though I haven't any real figures, just observations.

Good updates, Uriah. Spain should go fairly quickly now. Try to get some overflights or mayby a uboat peak at the rock area, that will give you an idea of what is going on and allow you to plan.

Forster: Thanks for the encouragement. I am on a roll at the moment, four updates in 8 days I think. There is some bad news coming in Spain but you'll have to wait until 4th May (I am 10 days ahead for a change - usually about 2!).

My subs have crused past Gibraltar but all the info I got was that there are at least 4 units, one a garrison.

Forgot you were using your interceptors on AI :) which makes the process a "bit" more challenging.

4 month in Spain sounds like a long time, but then again just moving to Gibraltar takes some weeks.

Surt: I am sure many people forget that I am not actually directing anything below Theatre level. All the mistakes are the AI, not me!!!

I don't think it will take 4 months - I meant that I could handle 4 months if it did take that long. I would like to start taking troops out by Nov/Dec at the latest.
 
I hope that the Greeks will quickly submit to Rome. Italian elite units would be far more useful in North Africa.

That was quick - I had barely posted the update!

I think the Italians are better prepared this time, but even if all goes well I think they will find it hard to push the Brits back to Egypt.

This could be time for (drumrolls) - THE AFRIKAKORPS!!!

(Well, when I have Spain including Gibraltar).
 
If you can complete the war with this level of drama and detail this will rival Rome AArisen as the best AAR I have read on these forums. Between the excellent first person narratives and the technical details (and pictures!) your AAR is an engrossing read. Keep it up!


edit: For your consideration - You could post more if you slept less. I'm just sayin'. ;)
 
Most excellent! Will def. follow this!
 
Uriah: Thanks BoemsiBoemsie (I had wondered if you were still reading).

Yeah, I was away for some time, as I became a father two months ago with the birth of my son. And that has taken up almost all my time. But dont worry. I am a very loyal reader, Uriah. I wouldnt miss your AAR for the world. :)
 
I did my best ! :D



I don't want to sound pessimistic but the British forces could have reached Tripoli by then ! :D

I think you are confusing pessimism with realism :)

Strange that the Spanish army still exists. Proper armed forces would have already driven over them. :p:rolleyes:
Yeh, just blame the terrain...

I don't just blame the terrain - I also blame the weather, the AI, and anything that comes to mind other than my skill.

And are you implying that my armed forces are improper?

If you can complete the war with this level of drama and detail this will rival Rome AArisen as the best AAR I have read on these forums. Between the excellent first person narratives and the technical details (and pictures!) your AAR is an engrossing read. Keep it up!


edit: For your consideration - You could post more if you slept less. I'm just sayin'. ;)

Thanks Sarayakat. I haven't played much CK so I went and had a quick look at Rome AARisen. I don't think I am at that level of historical knowledge and writing, but thanks for the compliment.

No doubt true, but over the years I have grown attached to sleeping. It may be too late to change the habit of a lifetime.

Most excellent! Will def. follow this!

Thaks PhilleP: I am always impressed by people who can read the huge number of posts to get up to date.

Now, *there's* an idea ! I second the motion... ;)

See above - given the way the Red Sox are going I am prepared to abandon baseball in a few weeks.

Uriah: Thanks BoemsiBoemsie (I had wondered if you were still reading).

Yeah, I was away for some time, as I became a father two months ago with the birth of my son. And that has taken up almost all my time. But dont worry. I am a very loyal reader, Uriah. I wouldnt miss your AAR for the world. :)

See comments above about giving up sleeping: what is your opinion?:rofl:

Congratulations: the youngest two of my three daughters are teenagers but I can still remember being a young father. A few peaceful hours with HOI3 should calm the frazzled nerves. But be careful: in my experience young mothers don't see it quite the same way.




I had hoped another update today but probably tomorrow. Have been struggling with Japanese supply. Trying to see why they are having so many problems in China, I noticed they are not producing any infantry (in queue but not being built). They are spending about 60IC on supplies, but have 56K in Tokyo and 80K in Hamhung. Also fuel is low (1971) but there is 18K in Hamhung. They have a port in Dagu but all supply in the mainland is from Hamhung.

First try was to shift (via savegame file) 40K supply and 17 K fuel from Hamhung to Tokyo. All this did was start to starve the whole of Asia as the AI tried to rebuild the stockpile at Hamhung.

Next I moved another 40K supply and 500 fuel from Hamhung to Dagu. Intention was to allow diffusion of supply/fuel to troops in combat in China. No way: 39K supply started to migrate NE, troops in China starved.

OK - all the above basically neutral: same stocks, just different places. If the AI is determined to keep huge stockpile at Hamhung for no real purpose, then fine. Replaced original stockpiles at Hamhung, left Tokyo and Dagu at increased level and created an extra 40K supply and 10K fuel at Nagasaki (supply base for Dagu). Obviously no longer neutral but I felt that it just offset the wasted stockpile in Korea. Ran for several days: all supply and fuel on mainland moving to Hamhung, all supply/fuel in Japan moving to Tokyo.

I have given up: what can I do to persuade the Japanese AI to feed its frontline troops in preference to storing up vast quantities in the rear? As far as I can see there is no real shortage: the Japanese have plenty of supply and adequate fuel (at least for now), but their storage policy is creating artificial problems. This leads to low efficiency in attacks, and diversion of production to supplies.

Any suggestions? I know some of my readers have much more insight into supply than I have. I work on the basis that supply should "seep", a bit like osmosis, from areas of "high pressure" to "low pressure. so that areas consuming supply should exert a continual draw. This seems to work for Germany in Europe, but not for Japan.

EDIT: I think the problem is that Japan will prefer to stockpile in a "core" province like Hamsung. So "excess" supply drifts back that way. Excess being anything not actually consumed. This wouldn't be so bad, except that Manchuria has an average infra of about 35%, which means that when all the supply gets to Hamhung, it struggles to get back to where it is needed. I may see if I can find how to make Dagu a "core": but I worry if this might solve the supply problem and create others.

Just to make it clear: I am not trying to make things easier for myself, I am trying to work around what I see a bug. Why would Japan store milllions of tonnes of fuel and supply in Kore and set up truck convoys across some of the worst roads in Asia when it has several perfectly good ports close to the front (Dagu, Darian)?
 
Last edited:
Congratulations ! An increase in manpower is always a good news. ;)

+1. Congratulations ! :)

Concerning the Japanese supply problem, I have no workaround solution for the bug, but maybe you could edit your savegame file ?
 
Thanks all you guys for the congratulations. He is a beautiful, happy and healthy boy and I hope he will play HOI in the future as well, just like his dad. And yes, in this greying old place called Europe, every little increase in fresh manpower is welcome. ;)
 
+1. Congratulations ! :)

Concerning the Japanese supply problem, I have no workaround solution for the bug, but maybe you could edit your savegame file ?

I have been editing the savegame files, but with the results as given. As I said in the EDIT, the problem is more the position of the supply source for all mainland Asia.

A supply source has to be a core province with an IC (as far as I can determine). I have tried making Dagu a core province but I believe that there can only be one supply soure for every series of linked overland provinces. Whether that is true or not, the supply source remains Hamhung.

I tried deleting the factory in Hamhung and creating one in Dalian (a Japanese core). While sort of successful (Hamhung ceased to be the supply source) the AI set up a new supply source at Pusan in preference to Dalian. And Pusan has just as much rubbish infra in between it and the front.

I am not sure why Pusan was chosen over Dalian, perhaps because Pusan had more factories? (but Hamhung has fewer) perhaps because the port is bigger (but Hamhung's is smaller) perhaps some complex algorithm re supply usage?

I don't know and have spent too much time trying to find out. Back to writing.

If anyone has any ideas, let me know.