• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
With many of your most loyal readers hashing out a massive peace settlement for TT over private messages, I'm not surprised reactions have somewhat dwindled here. You may have shot yourself in the foot with that ambitious peace conference...
Haha, that’s actually good to know, because all the private back-channel traffic on TT is largely hidden to me. I don’t mind at all if that’s the case.
I'm seconding Rover's post, I've been so busy keeping up with Talking Turkey that I somehow missed the notification for this AAR! I'm glad I noticed it though, this was another interesting update.
That’s great - it’s what I had hoped would happen. They can catch up over here later (I can also hope).
I'm going to stop making predictions on what will happen, every time I do things turn around for you. I will say I am impressed at how well the AI is holding ground against you. Where do you think they're pulling troops from? I'm assuming the Romanian front was getting stripped to support Turkey and central Europe as you advanced in those areas earlier, but it seems like at some point they can't keep stopping you everywhere (*knocks on wood).
Well, those last ten days were a bit harder to advance in than I thought they might be. The Allies have so many troops I can never know exactly where they will turn up. The AI always does better with large numbers and mainly a single front. They could be producing lots of new units too, for all I know: I deliberately never tag to find out ‘illicitly’, so I can be surprised almost as much as you guys.

The big changer we’re hoping for, rather like Germany in 1918 or the Soviets in winter 1941/42 is that the coming reinforcements from the east can turn the tide. But they may be too little too late, even with more nukes dropped, to turn the tide decisively. I really have no idea. o_O
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
Reactions:
xVbsR9.jpg
The historic Tu-4 was a (badly) reverse engineered B-29 copied from the handful of planes that had to force land in Soviet territory. Given the problems the copies had during testing and service I dread to think how bad this native Tu-4 will be without a proper B-29 to copy from. I suspect it may join the inglorious ranks of weapons that kill more of their own side than the enemy!
 
  • 1Like
  • 1Haha
  • 1
  • 1
Reactions:
The historic Tu-4 was a (badly) reverse engineered B-29 copied from the handful of planes that had to force land in Soviet territory. Given the problems the copies had during testing and service I dread to think how bad this native Tu-4 will be without a proper B-29 to copy from. I suspect it may join the inglorious ranks of weapons that kill more of their own side than the enemy!
Just from looking at the little picture it looked very B-29 ish and I thought it must have been a copy. Thanks for confirming.
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
Just from looking at the little picture it looked very B-29 ish and I thought it must have been a copy. Thanks for confirming.
Some of the stories about the copying process are quite funny. The selected B-29 for copying had an extra tiny hole in the left wing, no connecting wires, not caused by damage and it had no matching hole on the right wing. A commission of Soviet aviation, metallurgy and manufacturing experts was assembled and after considerable study determined it was most likely a manufacturing error; an extra hole had been drilled in that panel during assembly by mistake and not filled as it would have no impact, certainly they could see absolutely no advantage or benefit to the hole being there and only on one wing.

The expert commission report was ignored because the order from Stalin was "copy that aircraft", so all Soviet Tu-4s included the same tiny hole in the left wing.


EDIT: On another thread the limitations of copying and licence building were/are being discussed and I think the Tu-4 is an extreme example of that. You can have all the plans and examples in the world, but if you lack the experience and knowledge then you won't really understand what you are looking at. None of the commission experts could hand on heart swear that the tiny hole had no purpose, because none of them knew exactly how the design had been done.
 
  • 4Haha
Reactions:
An advertisement here from your sponsor:

Almost by accident, with two of my AARs finishing their gameplay phase (Talking Turkey and Civis Romanus Sum), I have surprised myself and kicked off a brand new HOI4 AAR. Anyone reading this work may care to have a look. It will be a little bit of a 'Talking Turkey Light' format, obviously using the more political/event and focus driven HOI4 format, but with some modified history incorporated into it.

It will be a shorter, sharper format and chapter length than has become the norm with TT, and I plan to finish it sooner (the HOI4 format seems to lead in that direction too). But there will still be key battle summaries down the track, albeit in the new format.

For those interested here is the link, which is also now in my updated signature: Poles Apart – an HOI4 Ahistory.

I will do the usual comment feedback a little later, when I'm ready to start the next chapter of this piece.
 
Last edited:
  • 1Love
  • 1Like
Reactions:
It will be a shorter, sharper format and chapter length
I see you are branching out into comedy.
DYAEiOu.gif

than has become the norm with TT, and I plan to finish it sooner (the HOI4 format seems to lead in that direction too). But there will still be key battle summaries down the track, albeit in the new format.
I have no doubt this "new format" will soon grow and grow into the vast detailed epics we have come to know and expect from you.
For those interested here is the link, which is also now in my updated signature: Poles Apart – an HOI4 Ahistory.
Naturally I am rooting for this story to be one about deeper Polo-Japanese co-operation than OTL, Warsaw and Tokyo joining up to invade their mutual foe the Soviet Union. It obviously won't be that, but maybe it should?
 
  • 3Haha
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions:
I see you are branching out into comedy.
DYAEiOu.gif
It is to laff! :p
I have no doubt this "new format" will soon grow and grow into the vast detailed epics we have come to know and expect from you.
haha, I will be limiting the page length for each update, so if there's any excessive historical detail (which I would think you would feel most at home with) it will merely take longer to complete. But this one will indeed be a shorter form piece, especially as it involves HOI4.
Naturally I am rooting for this story to be one about deeper Polo-Japanese co-operation than OTL, Warsaw and Tokyo joining up to invade their mutual foe the Soviet Union. It obviously won't be that, but maybe it should?
Alas, with Japan going Communist, I'm thinking an invasion of Russia is far less likely now, however necessary and desirable it may be in the ATL. With the first session played through a good few years ahead, I can however report lots of zany HOI4 goings-on, with unexpected (implausible) alt-hist tangents.

To All: next chapter of this AAR up soon.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Chapter 58: 11 to 20 November 1948
Chapter 58: 11 to 20 November 1948

******

1. Asia

By 13 November, the Soviets had begun making inroads into Malaya. One division was sent north-west to secure the resource-rich Alor Setar. The other two divisions would strike south to Kuala Lumpur and along the coast towards the rubber plantations of Kuantan. If they were lucky, these three divisions may prove enough to secure the peninsula all the way down to Singapore. If not, reinforcements would be called in from the Far East reserve now moving through the recently opened northern Vietnam corridor.

47psNB.jpg

In Burma, the Soviets won a somewhat expensive defensive battle at Thanbyuzayat on 15 November and then countered with an attack on the British armoured divisions that had been attacking from Kyondo.

By 17 November, the attack on Kyondo continued (+57% progress), while Soviet infantry was in Moulmein and heading north to Thaton. If they could secure it, this would cut off the British in Kyondo in an ‘infrastructure pocket’.

That was achieved early on the 20th, as other Soviet divisions moved to complete the encirclement to the east and west of Kyondo.

B7CiEw.jpg

Map showing provincial infrastructure levels.

As the period ended, the Soviets were happy with their progress, as the Far East Reserve force approached the Thai border south-west of Hanoi.

AsSSsf.jpg

The Asian Theatre as at 2300hr on 20 November 1948.

******

2. Middle East

The by now customary probes and air strikes on Bîr Gifgafa were launched, but none succeeded. The guerrillas in Hebron remained in place as the Soviet response force made its way to confront them from Adana.

3oH6H6.jpg

The Middle East as at 2300hr on 20 November 1948.

******

3. Central Asia

325 SD finally finished its long advance on Lamard on the morning of 13 November. This cut off the Allied troops on the Persian Gulf coast by land, but they did have two ports under their control and a wide-open northern flank.

gEdXxt.jpg

The determined defence of Mardian by the Red Army ended at midday of the same day, aided by continuous defensive air missions on Khanabad, which would continue right through the reporting period (Soviets 250/26,832; Allies 1,575/14,117 killed). Then at 2200hr that night, Afghanistan’s second city of Herat was liberated and a hasty Nepalese counter-attack brushed off.

A week later, the Soviets were ready to launch an attack on Bushehr, even as the Allies sought to advance from Behbehan on an Iranian division dug in at Yasuj. The Bushehr attack was on precisely even terms as it began, due to the favourable defensive terrain, which offset the superior tactics and heavy armour of the Red Army attackers.

OEiHdJ.jpg

The VVS raids on Khanabad were by far the most significant cause of Allied casualties during the ten-day period. Soviet gains at Lamard on the Gulf and in northern Afghanistan were partly balanced by Allied progress against the Iranians in the centre.

5ow66q.jpg

The Central Asian Theatre as at 2300hr on 20 November 1948.

******

4. Turkey

After the heavy activity of the first ten days of November, fighting was far more limited during this period. Mudurnu was occupied on the morning of 11 November, where the Red Army managed to fend off a determined Allied counter-attack by the 13th in the largest single battle of the period.

This laid the foundation for a successful attack on Tarakli, securing the river line and inching closer the Bosporus. Air preparation on Kandira was interrupted for a few days from 16 until 18 November, when the TAC group was diverted temporarily to support a new offensive in Romania. But they returned for the last few days, in an attempt the continue the softening up process.

Kandira was well defended, with German and other Allied troops dug in in mountainous terrain and with a river in front of them. Any further progress would be difficult. And elsewhere on the front, neither side had sufficient advantage to push the other from their strengthening defensive positions.

In the air war, an RAF STRAT raid on Majkop was intercepted and harshly dealt on 17 November, but not before its facilities were heavily damaged. The only air battle of the period occurred when three Luftwaffe INT wings tangled with a combined VVS force of 2 x INT and 2 x TAC over Kandira on 19 November. The other two VVS INT wings in Batumi had to be reserve hopped over to Odessa before they could be in range to offer addition support, which they were able to by the end of the dogfight. The German fighters were badly disorganised by the end of the dogfight, but one of the original escorting VVS INT wings was reduced to around 40% strength and had to be rotated out for a rested wing afterwards.

Tarakli had been taken and an Allied counter-attack almost defeated as the reporting period ended. But further progress was likely to be slow and bloody as the Soviet front again became stretched and the Allies took advantage of strong defensive lines. Once more, the VVS had caused the lion’s share of enemy casualties.

GkQ4Cp.jpg

The Turkish Front as at 2300hr on 20 November 1948.

******

5. The West

As before, the most intense action remained the bitter fight on the Western Front. It was concentrated into three quite specific areas: a river crossing attempt north of Breslau, a series of attacks and counter-attacks along the Slovakian-Hungarian border and the continued offensive in Romania. Given its significance, the air war in the west will be treated as a ‘fourth sector’.

******

5.a Germany-Poland

The great attack to secure a river crossing at the appropriately named Crossen finally ended in a bloody Red Army victory late on 11 November. A heavy air bombardment continued at Crossen and to its south-east along the area of the intended expansion of the bridgehead.

r2EWR5.jpg

On the 15th, the bridgehead was expanded south-east to include Grünberg (Soviets 2,818/75,836; Allies 3,590/27,219 killed). After that had been consolidated and more troops pushed across the river, the next attack was launched on Neusalz at 1700hr on 18 November, even as a major Allied counter-attack on Crossen played out.

The attack on Neusalz was far less expensive for the Soviets this time, with more troops already across the river and previous heavy air preparation. Neusalz was occupied very early on the 20th. More troops would follow, while the VVS concentrated on striking Glogau and Crossen still resisted the Allied attempt to oust them.

DnDUSD.jpg

At 0200hr, even as the defence of Crossen continued, the Allied attackers in Sagar found themselves under attack from three divisions in Grünberg as the Red Army now began trying to deepen the bridgehead in between Berlin to the north and Breslau to the south. The Soviets would find victory there by 1500hr that afternoon.

The Allies launched an attack on Neusalz from Glogau that afternoon, but the Soviets responded with a three-division cross-river spoiling attack on Glogau from Hernnstadt at 1700hr. As the day drew to a close, the defence of Crossen was finally won, but not before almost 11,000 troops from both sides had perished in the ground fighting alone.

0X45U1.jpg

The concentration of fighting in eastern Germany around the bridgehead operation is starkly illustrated below. Heavy ground fighting to take and then hold the initial lodgement at Crossen was accompanied by an expansion of troops so crossed to the south-east in phases, accompanied by extremely heavy VVS air preparation and occasional Allied responses. A summary of the air war is provided later.

sAsBkb.jpg

The German-Polish sector as at 2300hr on 20 November 1948.

******

5.b Slovakia-Hungary

This sector proved to be a very busy one, as both sides traded attacks, counter-attacks, spoiling attacks and ferocious defence and the line ebbed and flowed, with the Allies putting in a concerted effort to reverse Soviet gains.

The Soviets occupied Vazek at 0300hr on 11 November and were immediately counter-attacked by three Allied visions, but they would hold on to secure it, even as Dobsina (occupied in the previous period) to its immediate east continued to weaken under another Allied attack (-58%).

The next day, the Allies won substantive victories in Ruzomberok and Dobsina at midday.

Fo47ly.jpg

But three hours later, the defence of Ruzomberok resumed as a fresh division pulled in to mount a hasty defence – against five full-strength Allied divisions attacking from Turciansky and Banská Bystrica.

The next major development came at midnight on 14 November, when the Allies reoccupied Dobsina, even as Kosice had been taken to its east and a strong Soviet attack (84%) mounted from there on Roznava to the south of Dobsina continued. One Soviet division attacked two worn ones in Dobsina (73%) within the hour, to see if the Allies could be quickly thrown back out.

But to the east, a superior Allied force had the upper had in an attack on Svalava (northern Hungary), with the overpowered defenders being withdrawn at 1500hr on the 17th (Soviets 3,024/15,993; Allies 1,642/34,736 killed).

By the end of that day, the battle for Roznava had been won and it had been occupied. This exposed both the advancing Soviet troops and the Allies still holding on in Dobsina to its north.

vfHX2f.jpg

Bulgarian troops occupied Svalava at 0300 on 18 November but were counter-attacked straight away, forced to retreat back south after a brief skirmish.

Meanwhile, to try to complete an encirclement of the Allies in Dobsina, the Soviets had struck south to Brezno, where they won the battle (with heavy air support) on 18 November and occupied it at 0100hr on the 19th, thus surrounding the Allies in Dobsina. But even as that was happening, a strong Allied attack on Kosice (-88%) was threatening to break the recently completed encirclement, while the most recent defence of Ruzomberok was also in some trouble (-66%). The battle for Kosice would be lost and the Allies retook it at 2300hr that night, but a Soviet counter-attack was launched straight away by two fresh infantry divisions, which defeated the recently arrived 12 Pz Div after another very brief skirmish.

The second defence of Ruzomberok was ended early on 20 November, as two more Soviet divisions (neither of them yet completely rested from earlier fighting) were returning to the fray to carry on the fight, as a soiling attack on Turciansky continued and the Allies tried to break out of Dobsina at Brezno.

4Uwdtp.jpg

But the spoiler on Turciansky was proving expensive, so it was called off at 0500hr (Soviets 3,538/26,994; Allies 2,337/55,660 killed). The third defence of Ruzomberok began an hour later (-40% initially).

As the period ended, Kosice was retaken by the Soviets, then it and Roznava were both attacked by the Allies an hour later, while the enemy also inched forward a little in Ruzomberok. The whole sector remained fiercely contested and the Allies generally on the attack and supply problems hampered the Soviets in and around Kosice.

ssyfGq.jpg

Overall, the sector had been very active during the reporting period, with six battles (five of them Allied attacks) in progress as it ended. Most fighting had occurred between Ruzomberok in the west to Kosice in the east, as the Soviets tried to maintain their encirclement of Dobsina then muster the strength to close it out, which they had not yet been able to do.

Tkr7OP.jpg

The Slovakian-Hungarian sector as at 2300hr on 20 November 1948.

******

5.c Romania

A battle was fought to take St. Georg (the Danube River delta) and won on 12 November, after which it was occupied. Then behind it Cetatea Alba, where the Allies had been encircled and surrendered some days before, was occupied on 13 November as Red Army divisions moved forward into starting position for the next offensive in the south of Romania, to force the next river crossings.

This began late on the 15th, with three simultaneous advances, one of them against the unoccupied Sulina, the rest against significant Allied defences and across rivers. Initial progress was slow in Macin and Tulcea, where air power was used to supplement the ground attack.

YtmrZ9.jpg

By the evening of 16 November, the two attacks were only slowly gaining momentum (Macin 42%, Tulcea 31%) while an Austria division was seen making for Sulina, which the Soviet armour approaching it had not yet arrived.

29 Tk Div won the race for Sulina and had brushed off a quick Austrian probe and then begun a flank assault on Tulcea from the south at 0100hr on the 17th, just as that attack had been losing steam (30%), as was that on Macin (38%).

It too until the early morning of 19 November to win the battle for Tulcea and occupy it, allowing a four division flank assault on Macin to aid that attack, where the Allies still defended staunchly. Then Topolog, to the south of Macin, was taken at 0500hr on 20 November, after three quick attacks on Allied units that had been retreating through it from Tulcea, followed by a fourth skirmish when it was taken and held by 2nd HArm Div.

Victory finally came in Macin late on the 20th after the toughest battle in the sector during the period and it was occupied an hour later. The VVS had caused a further 7,344 Allied casualties in Macin from 16-20 November and earlier in Tulcea had accounted for another 4,926 from 16-19 November (by the Odessa-based TAC group that had been temporarily diverted from the Turkish Front to assist the breakthrough.

2atlZS.jpg

As the period ended, the latest offensive had reached the east bank of the next river line at Macin and Topolog while forces pushed south towards Constanta, on the Black Sea border with Bulgaria, with forces having pushed as far south as Babadag.

Rw82Ik.jpg

The Romanian sector as at 2300hr on 20 November 1948.

******

5.d The Air War in the West

Once again, the relentless VVS bombing campaign killed far more Allied soldiers in the West than had been caused by ground combat. In fact, it just exceeded the entire combined ground combat casualties of both the Allies and the Soviets in the West during the ten-day period. So a short overview of what went on in the air is warranted, as the Allies were not passive during this time.

On 11 November, as the VVS bombing campaign was at a peak, four German INT wings (some in poor repair, but all fully organised) intercepted a large formation of bombers (2 x INT, 3 x TAC) over Crossen (while it was still under Soviet attack at that time). Another VVS fighter group (1 x INT, 1 x M/R) joined into the dogfight. And the mission was continued.

The same German fighter group then intercepted and mauled 2 x German CAS over Crossen on the 12th, after it had been occupied by the Red Army.

On 13 November, the second busiest day in the air for the period occurred as the Allies tried to disrupt the heavy Soviet aerial blitz. The German CAS were intercepted again over Crossen, when even though 2 x German INT came to their aid, one of the German CAS wings was apparently destroyed. At the same time the Hungarians (2 x INT) tried to return the favour on 3 x VVS CAS over Brezno in Slovakia. The latter turned into a full-on melee as 3 x German and 2 x VVS INT joined the dogfight.

Later that morning, the single remaining German CAS wing tried again over Crossen, without an escort, to be intercepted by the same three VVS fighter wings. The Germans had chosen … poorly. Then in mid-morning, 3 x German INT took on a Soviet formation of 2 x INT, 2 x M/R and 2 x TAC over Turciansky, where they were supporting the spoiling attack for Ruzomberok.

After the Allies largely came off second best in these exchanges, there was a lull until 15 November, when a single dogfight occurred over Kezmarek as 2 x VVS INT intercepted 2 x Italian TAC who were trying to disrupt the attack on Dobsina that continued at that time. The Italians caused 146 ground casualties but were deterred from returning.

On the 16th, the air war reached a new level of intensity, as five dogfights were fought out on the one day. Two of these were Soviet interceptions of Allied raids and three saw the Allies trying to disrupt VVS bombing missions. After the early morning round, recon reports indicated that 13 Allied air units were in the Berlin air base, which had been fully repaired by that time. A V2 strike was ordered to ensure their repairs would be severely hindered for the coming days.

XK0CFE.jpg

After another dogfight over Turciansky from 0700-0900hr, one of the escorting VVS M/R wings was almost destroyed, being detached mid-fight and only just limping back to base at 3% strength! The bomber group continued into the evening, but after more fighting that reduced the strength of the two TAC wings to 61% and 55%, with even lower organisation, the whole group had to be taken off-line for the rest of the period, which started to decrease the casualties being caused. And in two dogfights over Grünberg, two unescorted German TAC wings managed to cause 273 ground casualties, but one of their wings came close to destruction and their raids there were discontinued.

After this frenzy, there was no aerial combat on 17-18 November as the remaining VVS bomber groups continued to work away in all three sectors of the Western Front. On the 19th, German and Hungarian interception of VVS bombing raids led to another escorting INT wing being severely damaged (31%) and taken off-line. But thanks to reserve wings being repaired, some (not all) of these losses were replaced by fairly fresh wings returning to duty. A third engagement that day saw the Luftwaffe (1 x M/R, 2 x TAC) successfully fight through a VVS interception (1 x INT, 1 x M/R) to bomb Crossen during the Allied counter-attack, causing 437 casualties.

Then on the 20th, the Luftwaffe (1 x M/R, 2 x TAC)also managed to get through to Terchova despite an interception (2 x INT) to cause 567 casualties there. But otherwise, Allied bombing raids still found it difficult to penetrate Soviet air superiority, causing just over 2,000 total casualties in the West over the ten days. By contrast, even though the rate of effort dropped markedly on the 19th and 20th, the VVS managed to inflict almost 90,000 ground casualties over the same period.

xSmCA8.jpg

The Western Front as at 2300hr on 20 November 1948.

kcXUFv.jpg


******

6. Strategic, Research, Industry

On 16 November, the latest wing of new STRAT, started a long time back, was deployed to work up in Kiev. They may still be needed in time when the Soviets once again resorted to nuclear strikes (as they inevitably would).

During the ten-day period, two new research advances were completed, both in land doctrine where the teams would continue their work.

eu8Aa2.jpg

The general situation showed that on all fronts, the tempo of land combat had intensified somewhat where casualties were the measure, especially in very heavy airstrikes in eastern Germany supporting the bridgehead offensive. The increased aggression of the Allies in stemming the Slovakia offensive kept the total number of attacks launched in their favour, despite the Soviet offensive operations north of Breslau. Overall. The progress was slow and grinding, with a new bridgehead gained into Germany but no massive breakthrough yet in evidence.

NtKttS.jpg

More widely, the next tranche of reinforcements making their way from the Far East to the Western Front had still not passed north of the Aral Sea.

tugbpA.jpg

Another five divisions heading to the Central Asian Theatre were getting closer, with three of them now passed over from Mongolia back into the USSR.

Zy2V75.jpg

And the last (and largest) group of units heading back to the West had now passed Ulaanbataar, with the lead elements well into the Soviet Union by now.

rcvBRu.jpg

STAVKA would see whether these influxes of units, still some way off being able to join their respective fronts, would be enough to really turn the tide in the main theatre of the war. If they didn’t, a slow attritional fight dragging on for years was unlikely to be sustainable (or very interesting to report).
 
Last edited:
  • 6Like
Reactions:
It looks like the Balkans might be the next theater the Soviets can crack open. There are a lot of Allied units there, but it seems like most of them in reserve are actually HQs. The breakthrough in Romania is also promising, and it seems to have opened several options. It's too bad you don't have an extra mobile army to shift down there and exploit!

Knocking out Hungary could also be very valuable since they seem to have a decent sized military. I'm wondering if the Allies stripped the Balkans to stop you in Germany?

And of course Asia is steadily going in your favor, although you have a long ways in bad terrain before you reach anything else that's important.
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
Reactions:
5.b Slovakia-Hungary
Glad to see the important front getting the attention it deserves and the Allies putting great effort into this crucial sector.
DYAEiOu.gif


I gather some other fighting occurred as well, but it all seemed a bit 'secondary theatre' compared to the main event.
 
  • 2
  • 1Haha
Reactions:
It looks like the Balkans might be the next theater the Soviets can crack open. There are a lot of Allied units there, but it seems like most of them in reserve are actually HQs. The breakthrough in Romania is also promising, and it seems to have opened several options. It's too bad you don't have an extra mobile army to shift down there and exploit!

Knocking out Hungary could also be very valuable since they seem to have a decent sized military. I'm wondering if the Allies stripped the Balkans to stop you in Germany?

And of course Asia is steadily going in your favor, although you have a long ways in bad terrain before you reach anything else that's important.
It does seem that a chance for some opportunistic advances may be on the cards - the coming chapter will reveal how feasible that may be. The added incentives there are twofold: to help link up with the Turkish offensive pressing on Istanbul; and diverting Allied troops from sectors to the north where they have managed to solidify their lines. The problem though is that too elongated a line in the south will also be hard for the Soviets to maintain, and will make the lines defending the rivers to the north of the breakout in southern Romania thinner and thinner.

Knocking out Hungary would be great, but at this stage the Allies are defending that area quite aggressively and have good terrain to play with.

Asia is definitely going well and the influx of mainly 'leg infantry' forces now approaching central Thailand via the recently opened land route through northern Vietnam will also help.
Glad to see the important front getting the attention it deserves and the Allies putting great effort into this crucial sector.
DYAEiOu.gif


I gather some other fighting occurred as well, but it all seemed a bit 'secondary theatre' compared to the main event.
Oh, they have clearly been watching your comments and have stepped up their defence of the approaches to the Pan-European Capital of Bratislava. The rest is just by-the-by, of course. :D

You will also be happy to know that the format is going to get quicker and dirtier again, starting with this last ten-day report for November 1948. More below.

To All: Apart from anything else, the game itself has taken longer than I thought it would to resolve itself, one way or another. My original thought had been the end of 1948 would have seen things resolved one way or another.

As it happens, the Far East took way longer to resolve than anticipated (by me, anyway). And while things are still moving and there have been some interesting side-campaigns in East Asia, Central Asia and Turkey, the main Western theatre has been an interesting (to play, at least) but quite closely balanced grind for some time now.

The most recent format I've been using has been quite labour-intensive to compile and have ended up providing lots of nerd-worthy info, but it takes time and with the pace of things, I'd rather invest the extra time in progressing the game. And I'd also like to get things back more to the original concept of Q&D. Plus make the chapters more consumable (ie shorter) while still illustrating what has happened and retaining a more general metric of casualty rates and comparisons.

I've also decided to generalise the air combat reporting further, using a couple of graphs and tables to replace most of the detailed descriptive language on the air battles. As we have seen with the reintroduction of the casualty reporting, in terms of casualties air power has had a disproportionate effect for the Soviets and may have been the only thing really keeping them moving on the Western Front. So I think its valid to focus on it there, but in more general terms.

You'll see my latest format tweak shortly. I do hope it works for whatever readership the AAR retains and would appreciate any 'proof of life' of the readership (ie short comments or reactions at least) so I know there's the readership out there to justify continuing in that much (albeit reduced) detail.
 
  • 5Like
Reactions:
To All: Apart from anything else, the game itself has taken longer than I thought it would to resolve itself, one way or another. My original thought had been the end of 1948 would have seen things resolved one way or another.

As it happens, the Far East took way longer to resolve than anticipated (by me, anyway). And while things are still moving and there have been some interesting side-campaigns in East Asia, Central Asia and Turkey, the main Western theatre has been an interesting (to play, at least) but quite closely balanced grind for some time now.

The most recent format I've been using has been quite labour-intensive to compile and have ended up providing lots of nerd-worthy info, but it takes time and with the pace of things, I'd rather invest the extra time in progressing the game. And I'd also like to get things back more to the original concept of Q&D. Plus make the chapters more consumable (ie shorter) while still illustrating what has happened and retaining a more general metric of casualty rates and comparisons.

I've also decided to generalise the air combat reporting further, using a couple of graphs and tables to replace most of the detailed descriptive language on the air battles. As we have seen with the reintroduction of the casualty reporting, in terms of casualties air power has had a disproportionate effect for the Soviets and may have been the only thing really keeping them moving on the Western Front. So I think its valid to focus on it there, but in more general terms.

You'll see my latest format tweak shortly. I do hope it works for whatever readership the AAR retains and would appreciate any 'proof of life' of the readership (ie short comments or reactions at least) so I know there's the readership out there to justify continuing in that much (albeit reduced) detail.
I'm still alive and reading... and as much as the nerdy details and long-winded prose are nice to have, I'd be ok with a quicker and dirtier end to this AAR which has become quite slow and pretty clean all things considered.
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions:
I am here as well. I figured that aside from a particular campaigns' wins/losses etc, the details can be left aside. Think a high school survey versus the post-grad deep dives.
 
  • 1
  • 1
Reactions:
I'm still alive and reading... and as much as the nerdy details and long-winded prose are nice to have, I'd be ok with a quicker and dirtier end to this AAR which has become quite slow and pretty clean all things considered.
I am here as well. I figured that aside from a particular campaigns' wins/losses etc, the details can be left aside. Think a high school survey versus the post-grad deep dives.
Thanks guys, let's see how the latest format goes.
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
Chapter 59: 21 to 30 November 1948
Chapter 59: 21 to 30 November 1948

******

1. Asia

Kuala Lumpur was occupied by Soviet marines on the morning of 21 November, as the Red Army’s advance down the Malayan Peninsula seemed to lack any serious ground opposition.

In southern Burma, the two isolated British armoured divisions in Kyondo were surrounded when Thaton was occupied early in the period. The subsequent Soviet attack was a bloody one, but by midnight on the 24th, the British defence was over and more than14,000 surviving troops surrendered in a major Soviet triumph.

O1MOI8.jpg

The only opposition in Malaya came from two British CAGs which bombed 324 SD in Cukai on 24 November as they pushed towards Singapore. One wing of VVS M/R fighters provided some interception from 0700-1400hr but took enough damage to have to break off, the ground troops taking 261 casualties in three raids that day.

The same day, in the north British STRAT, later with fighter support, carried out some logistical strikes and supply and fuel dumps in Kyondo and then Moulmein, until discouraged that night by two VVS INT wings flying out of Phet Buri.

As quickly as it had begun, the British air campaign in East Asia finished, with no more engagements before the end of the month.

With the need to reduce and occupy Kyondo in the north and slow movement through jungle terrain there and in Malaya, only modest gains territorial gains were made during the final ten-day period.

ZTGlq5.jpg

The Asian Theatre as at 2300hr on 30 November 1948.

******

2. Middle East

The usual smattering of probes and air strikes on Bîr Gifgafa made no substantial impact, as the Soviet garrison division from Adana finally drew near to the rebels in Hebron.

sqZhpm.jpg

The Middle East Theatre as at 2300hr on 30 November 1948.

******

3. Central Asia

The air base in Stalinabad was upgraded again, to Level 7, at 0000hr on 21 November and the next level commenced.

After a tough battle with heavy air support, the Soviet attack on Khanabad finally succeeded on 27 November. The air raids had commenced back on 11 November and carried all the way through to the 27th, killing 11,350 defenders over that time, 4,424 of those in the current period.

6o9rqF.jpg

Late that night, the second CAS wing that had been repairing in Cheshme redeployed to Stalinabad to join a new mission striking Sheberghan, where a new attack was commencing.

At 2300hr on the 29th, 38 SD arrived in the oilfield province of Ahvaz just in time, forestalling an advance by British marines from Behbehan. The defensive battle was won the following day. Soviet forces to their south had won an attack on Bushehr on 23 November and were driving north to Behbehan, hoping to trap the divisions in the Allied salient and then destroy them.

In the ten-day period attacks had been won by the Soviets in Bushehr, Khanabad and Sheberghan but none of the three had been occupied as the month ended. No territory had been exchanged.

hHH7Ti.jpg

The Central Asian Theatre as at 2300hr on 30 November 1948.

******

4. Turkey

A foolhardy Allied attack on Tarakli, cross-river on mountainous ground, was finally called at the start of 22 November. All the while, a heavy air preparation of Kandira had continued, where any Soviet attack would also have to be into mountains and over a river. It was hoped the softening up would lead to success, as the Soviets shifted a few divisions north from Tarakli to get the attack ready.

tf5xnk.jpg

The big attack on Kandira began exactly two days later, at 0000hr on 26 November. It would be won fairly easily on the 27th (Soviets 175, Allies 506 killed) as the air preparation had done its job, with continuous raids from 19-27 November killing 15,894 Allied troops.

Kandira was occupied at 1600hr on the 28th and then subject to a determined but futile Allied counter-attack, which was not defeated until the 30th (Soviets 73, Allies 1,769 casualties).

Meanwhile, a series of attacks on Polatli and Sülüklü from 24-29 November had seen both provinces retaken for Turkey by the end of the month. And with the counter-attack on Kandira defeated and more troops reinforcing it, the ground and air effort had shifted to Izmit, where the attack was making good progress (and with 4,600 casualties from air strikes inflicted from 27-30 November).

bdi4jE.jpg

The Turkish Theatre as at 2300hr on 30 November 1948.

******

5. The West

The location and intensity of the main action in the last ten days of November was similar to the previous period, but the results were different. Overall, the Soviets had some useful results, even when ground had to be given in one sector.

******

5.a Eastern Germany

The fight to expand the bridgehead into Silesia continued, as the Red Army ground out its offensive with heavy air support. With Sagar soon secured, the next major bridgehead victory came at Glogau on the evening of the 24th, even as a heavy air preparation of Cottbus prepared it for the next expansion target.

TlfIZA.jpg

Glogau had been secured and the next big attack begun on Bunzlau at 1500 hr on the 26th, even as the Allies launched many heavy counter-attacks against the provinces in the bridgehead. Victory came at Cottbus later that day (Soviets 998, Allies 4,359 killed, and at Bunzlau on the 27th, and it was subsequently occupied, linking up with forces from Neusalz to start an attack on Lauban that was still in progress as the month ended.

Meanwhile, Leignitz was attacked and the Allies forced to retreat on the morning of the 30th, the Soviets yet to occupy it as the day ended. The same had occurred at Görlitz. An attack on Lübben, just south of Berlin, had also begun, but was meeting stiffer resistance.

lYZ0J7.jpg

The German Sector as at 2300hr on 30 November 1948.

******

5.b Slovakia-Hungary

The Allied forces trapped in Dobsina were trying hard to break out while their comrades also sought to relieve them from the south at Roznava and Kosice from 21-24 November. A series of Soviet divisions in Kosice would be forced to retreat in the coming days, but each time were replaced by fresh troops that were able to maintain the encirclement.

mvf2VJ.jpg

Soviet air effort was increased, at the expense of the Silesian bridgehead, in an effort to slow down these desperate Allied attacks. Brezno and Ruzomberok also came under pressure at different times, while the Red Army tried to retake Humenne to the east.

But enough time had been bought for sufficient forces to be assembled – or recover – north of Dobsina to allow an attack at 1800hr on the 25th. As it happened, the Allied defenders were exhausted by then and 15,000 prisoners surrendered without further bloodshed as soon as the attack began.

Oo3GUg.jpg

With the Dobsina pocket crushed, the desperate and now failing defences of Kosice and then Roznava (Soviets 2,901; Allies 3,018 killed) were abandoned on the 27th to allow a defensive line to be consolidated under continuing Allied pressure.

By the end of the month, Humenne had been retaken and remained under Allied counter-attack but Kosice and Roznava lost. A Soviet attack to retake Svalava was also nearing completion.

rY0FdD.jpg

The Slovakian-Hungarian Sector as at 2300hr on 30 November 1948.

******

5.c Romania-Bulgaria

After overcoming some supply problems throughout the ten-day period that hampered a more rapid advance, the Soviet armoured spearhead broke through in southern Romania in the first few days of the period and by the early morning of 25 November were in open country, with 28 Tk Div boldly striking west towards Bucharest from Fetesti, while Constanta had been secured on the Black Sea coast.

H38Igo.jpg

Encountering only light resistance but slowed by patchy supply, the Red Army crossed the border into Bulgaria as far as Varna after a short skirmish, before encountering more substantive resistance at Burgas, which was overcome on the 30th (Soviets 77; Allies 558 killed).

But inland, while the Soviets had closed on and attacked Bucharest, it still resisted strongly by the end of the period. 28 Tk Div had not received reinforcement earlier, due to a failed attempt to dislodge a strong Allied defensive position to its east in Slobozia, which was finally called off on the morning of the 30th (Soviets 2,094; Allies 2,179 killed).

The attack on Bucharest persisted despite fairly poor odds, as 28 Tk Div’s casualties were being limited by its armoured advantage, though more supply problems (which had led to the ending of the Slobozia attack) further delayed reinforcement.

DNRO62.jpg

The Romanian-Bulgaria Sector as at 2300hr on 30 November 1948.

******

5.d The Air War in the West and Summary

A heavy program of raids was maintained across the Western Front for the ten-day period. An up-tick in Allied interceptions caused some wings to be withdrawn for repairs from 25-27 November, but the rate of effort built up somewhat following that, before tapering off again by the 30th.

gp5JU6.jpg

In this period, the heaviest and most consisistent VVS bombing missions concentrated on defensive air support for the Slovakian sector at Lucenec, Banská Bystrica, Secovce and Sop, plus offensive air support to soften up Dobsina, Svalava and Humenne. By comparison, the support provide in Silesia at Cottbus, Liegnitz and Glogau was relatively minor. None was provided in Romania after the last raid on Macin on 21 November.

Air combat was at a somewhat reduced level compared to the previous ten days, reaching its height on 26-27 November. As mentioned above, it was enough to dent the otherwise heavy VVS ground support campaign for a few days.

GSGFzo.jpg

Overall, good progress was made in eastern Germany and better in Romania. While some ground had been given in Slovakia, this was only after another small but useful encirclement had been completed in Dobsina. Once more, as it did for the month overall, VVS action cause about two thirds of the Allied casualties during the reporting period.

alk5va.jpg

The Western Front as at 2300hr on 30 November 1948.

******

6. Strategic, Research, Industry

A new NAV wing was completed and deployed to Vladivostok for work-up on 24 November. This allowed some new builds to be commissioned: four infantry brigades for topping up existing standard rifle divisions and a new TAC wing, given how valuable they were proving.

zs7nVl.jpg

Three technical advances were made, all in various forms of air technology or training. Improvement of the NAV arm was continued, while computing also received a boost.

kA8d6c.jpg

Supply and resources remained in fairly good shape, allowing the upgrade and reinforcement programs to be fully maintained and a reasonable production queue supported.

pxVMQS.jpg

In overall terms, casualty rates on both sides had remained similar and steady in the first two ten-day periods of the month. The main difference that increased this (effective) rate in the last ten days was the prisoners taken in the two pockets liquidated in southern Burma and Slovakia, which added almost 30,000 to the total Allied losses. Otherwise, ground and air casualties throughout the month were quite consistent.

yCBBX0.jpg

As the month ended, the first Far east reinforcement tranche heading for the Western Front was passing to the north of the Caspian Sea.
 
  • 3Like
Reactions:
I much prefer this format, It's definitely quick, but not nearly that "dirty"!
 
  • 2
  • 1Love
Reactions:
Things are really looking up now. A promising bridgehead in Germany, POW's taken in Slovakia and both Istanbul and Bucharest are now under Soviet threat. And that's before the bulk of forces get back from the Far East.
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
I also like this format, especially if it is easier for you to write up and post. It looks like big things could happen in the Balkans, but supply is not good at all. Have you considered starting a convoy from Sevastopol or somewhere on the Black Sea to Odessa or another port closer to the front?
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Catching up on the last few updates. Not entirely sure how far off I am, but we'll find out soon enough and it's about time I caught up with something else now that TT is slowed down by talk of "peace" or some such nonsense.

dPdxE2.jpg

Situation in Germany as at 0100hr on 21 September 1948. Net advances made by the Germans since 10 September included Wolgast in the north-west and Wronki in the south-east. In battles since the previous summary for 14 September, the Soviets had defended Greifenberg and lost but then regained Stargard and Arnswalde. The Allies remained on the attack in the south-east at Poznan and Rogozno, but their general momentum had been slowed somewhat over the last ten days, with the return of Soviet air superiority being a key factor.
Seems that the line here is now stable enough to hold or slowly give ground while accomplishing a lot on other fronts. The Allied position cannot be tenable if they only win in one front and lose on all others.

The big news in the theatre came at 2200hr on 21 September with the liberation of Ankara. Turkey was immediately declared independent once more, this time starting with increased national unity, even while almost two-thirds of the key cities of the Turkish FSR remained under French occupation.
Vur ha! Vur ha!

The first few days of the month saw no combat as Soviet marines made for Phet Buri, the Thai port and air base west of Bangkok whose seizure would force Thailand to capitulate. 2. DMP reached it without incident at 1900hr on 14 October. The Thai King formally surrendered at midnight, beginning a two-year truce with the Allies and their joining of the Comintern.
Not that I'm usually a huge fan of Stalinist regime change, but maybe in this one case?

The running battle continued into the morning, as the British CAGs (especially the 10th) and Soviet ships absorbed heavy damage in the furious action. By the time the Soviets were able to break away at 0900hr, they had lost a total of five transports but their passengers were still all accounted for, for what appeared to be the British loss of one CAG destroyed.
And this, kids, is why we don't send out the transports into unsecured waters.

Overall, from Germany down to the Suez Canal and across to Central Asia, the gains had all been made by the Comintern since the start of the month (green line showing 1 October starting positions, yellow line as at 20 October, arrows changes from 21 to 31 October). In the last eleven days and over the whole month, Allied casualties on all fronts had been over four times those of the Soviets in combat between them, with air attacks making the single largest contribution to Allied casualties.

64Iyrm.jpg

Overall summary, plus the Middle East, as at 31 October 1948.
Capturing all of those prisoners is sure to make a big difference. Allied nations have to be running out of manpower soon, every division lost is one not being replaced.

Smushkevich! The only man to be twice declared a Hero of the Soviet Union, get two Orders of Lenin but still be executed by the Soviet state as a traitor. Clearly he has been rehabilitated and you must admit he flies very well for someone who has been dead for several years.
While usually I would blame Paradox here, in this case it is because Bullfilter has been playing the game since 1936, and Paradox understandably did not implement scripted leader deaths once a campaign is started (it might be historically accurate, but of the Italian pasta water sort of accuracy, methinks).

At 0900hr on 7 November, the Soviets started crossing the border to Kota Bahru. At that time there were 22 Royal Navy ships in the port. The province was occupied late on the following day, meaning the British ships would soon have to flee the port. VVS naval strikes were lined up to hit them as soon as they appeared in the Southern Gulf of Thailand.

4aVVYr.jpg

A short running engagement by the VVS NAV wings began at 0400hr on 9 November, an hour later the main British ships had escaped, the rest by 0700hr. Despite attempts to widen the patrol net, the Soviets were unable to make contact again.
Probably would have gotten more done by launching naval strikes before invading.

During the ten days, the Allies had conducted more attacks than they had been in October and won almost half the battles fought in the sector, all of those from Kulu south to Manavgat (a number of which were discontinued Soviet spoiling attacks). Only the incessant heavy support of the VVS TAC group shifted the casualty count heavily into the Soviets’ favour.

jHXaPi.jpg

Situation in Turkey as at 2300hr on 10 November 1948.
Looks like Stalin should send Zhukov and a nice, fresh shock army to the north of Turkey to push for the straits. Once the straits are blocked the Allied divisions in Turkey will be easy enough to finish off.

That’s great - it’s what I had hoped would happen. They can catch up over here later (I can also hope).
Reporting for duty, Cap'n!

2. Middle East

The by now customary probes and air strikes on Bîr Gifgafa were launched, but none succeeded. The guerrillas in Hebron remained in place as the Soviet response force made its way to confront them from Adana.
Seems this is the AI behavior that restricts moving forces between theaters. A human player would redeploy that air force to somewhere useful, but the AI sees that an air wing is needed and is present, thus makes no changes. As such, proud Soviet men die to bombs for no good reasons.

Kandira was well defended, with German and other Allied troops dug in in mountainous terrain and with a river in front of them. Any further progress would be difficult. And elsewhere on the front, neither side had sufficient advantage to push the other from their strengthening defensive positions.
Maybe we could go around to the strait and make a pocket?

5.b Slovakia-Hungary

This sector proved to be a very busy one, as both sides traded attacks, counter-attacks, spoiling attacks and ferocious defence and the line ebbed and flowed, with the Allies putting in a concerted effort to reverse Soviet gains.
Clearly the important theater has been identified by both sides.

As the period ended, the latest offensive had reached the east bank of the next river line at Macin and Topolog while forces pushed south towards Constanta, on the Black Sea border with Bulgaria, with forces having pushed as far south as Babadag.

Rw82Ik.jpg

The Romanian sector as at 2300hr on 20 November 1948.
Looks like potential for a big breakout along the Black Sea coast, which could if supported heavily enough reach through Greece and help to cut off the Allies in Turkey. I recommend the full force of Soviet reinforcements be thrown into this effort.

Thanks guys, let's see how the latest format goes.
I echo the other comments, I like it and it is getting back to the roots of the AAR. Frankly I sometimes wondered why the air war in particular merited so much detail compared to the ground campaign, although the relative casualty rates certainly have something to say about the matter.

The big attack on Kandira began exactly two days later, at 0000hr on 26 November. It would be won fairly easily on the 27th (Soviets 175, Allies 506 killed) as the air preparation had done its job, with continuous raids from 19-27 November killing 15,894 Allied troops.
Or that, that might work too.

Back on top of this one again, so looking forward to see where we go next. I can see a few different operations which could force something conclusive but we will have to see if the Soviet Union can muster the necessary force of arms - and if the Allies don't have any more nasty tricks up their sleeves!
 
  • 3Like
  • 1Love
Reactions:
Have played and been completing the spreadsheets and preparing the images for the next update, which I’ve started writing up. Using the new format and dialling back on a few more details, the plan is to at last return to a whole month being covered in a single chapter, without it being over long! And they said it wouldn’t be done! :p

So here is the comment feedback from the last chapter.

I much prefer this format, It's definitely quick, but not nearly that "dirty"!
Glad to hear it. Quick and clean, I hope. ;)
Things are really looking up now. A promising bridgehead in Germany, POW's taken in Slovakia and both Istanbul and Bucharest are now under Soviet threat. And that's before the bulk of forces get back from the Far East.
Yes, at last we’re starting to crack a few fronts open. I think air power has been the key, especially in the west, where it’s being used to prise open those difficult river crossing which the Allies have been defending pretty solidly. Pound away then eventually cross against weakened defenders. Sounds sadly familiar, but rather Soviet in nature (with air power substituting for artillery). Hopefully the eastern reinforcements will really allow a full offensive to be initiated.
I also like this format, especially if it is easier for you to write up and post. It looks like big things could happen in the Balkans, but supply is not good at all. Have you considered starting a convoy from Sevastopol or somewhere on the Black Sea to Odessa or another port closer to the front?
Thanks, yes it is. The southern Balkans is going to be an initial priority, but there are relatively few forces for exploitation, especially as the flank lengthens. Good idea re the convoys, watch this space …
Catching up on the last few updates. Not entirely sure how far off I am, but we'll find out soon enough and it's about time I caught up with something else now that TT is slowed down by talk of "peace" or some such nonsense.
Most appreciated. My HOI3 energy can now be concentrated on this one.
Seems that the line here is now stable enough to hold or slowly give ground while accomplishing a lot on other fronts. The Allied position cannot be tenable if they only win in one front and lose on all others.
This was the hope. And improved use (and rotation) of air power had proved decisive. The period of the big retreat from Berlin coincided with losing that superiority.
Vur ha! Vur ha!
I did enjoy it - our allies rescued after we dumped them in it earlier by bringing them in a little too early.
Not that I'm usually a huge fan of Stalinist regime change, but maybe in this one case?
To the extent the game lets you do it.
And this, kids, is why we don't send out the transports into unsecured waters.
Yes, though at the time it was the only way to get more forces through, even though the escort was pretty puny and NAV coverage not quite enough. Still, they did get all the troops through and the fleet was not of much use otherwise, so I think it was worth it in the end. Just.
Capturing all of those prisoners is sure to make a big difference. Allied nations have to be running out of manpower soon, every division lost is one not being replaced.
Some of them will be, for sure. What I’m not seeing are any/many US troops in Europe. There were more in China but not too many seen recently.
While usually I would blame Paradox here, in this case it is because Bullfilter has been playing the game since 1936, and Paradox understandably did not implement scripted leader deaths once a campaign is started (it might be historically accurate, but of the Italian pasta water sort of accuracy, methinks).
I think this is fair. One has to allow for sliding doors.
Probably would have gotten more done by launching naval strikes before invading.
Quite possibly, will bear it in mind if there’s a next time.
Looks like Stalin should send Zhukov and a nice, fresh shock army to the north of Turkey to push for the straits. Once the straits are blocked the Allied divisions in Turkey will be easy enough to finish off.
They might have to make do with what they have in theatre, as the first tranche of Far East troops are still a ways off and will probably be sent to the main western front.
Seems this is the AI behavior that restricts moving forces between theaters. A human player would redeploy that air force to somewhere useful, but the AI sees that an air wing is needed and is present, thus makes no changes. As such, proud Soviet men die to bombs for no good reasons.
No doubt. But lately it’s just been one or two Italian TAC wings and you’ll see they get up to some interesting stuff there in December.
Maybe we could go around to the strait and make a pocket?
That is the plan. Will see how far we get.
Clearly the important theater has been identified by both sides.
Hip flasks and sharpened pencils at 10 paces. ;)
Looks like potential for a big breakout along the Black Sea coast, which could if supported heavily enough reach through Greece and help to cut off the Allies in Turkey. I recommend the full force of Soviet reinforcements be thrown into this effort.
Again, that is the plan. The ideal for phase one is to try to link up with the army in Turkey, thus effecting that great big pocket (Which they can still resupply by sea).
I echo the other comments, I like it and it is getting back to the roots of the AAR. Frankly I sometimes wondered why the air war in particular merited so much detail compared to the ground campaign, although the relative casualty rates certainly have something to say about the matter.
Glad to hear it. Per above, I’m refining it to get back to the monthly format, even with the increased tempo of the current various offensives. You’ll have seen from the stats and also the key battles that air power has caused way more casualties in the west than ground combat, so for that reason I think has merited increased emphasis, though will now moderate that in line with the general dialling back of detail.
Or that, that might work too.

Back on top of this one again, so looking forward to see where we go next. I can see a few different operations which could force something conclusive but we will have to see if the Soviet Union can muster the necessary force of arms - and if the Allies don't have any more nasty tricks up their sleeves!
I’m hoping you will find the next update interesting and that it moves the story along a bit quicker. We need to fish or cut bait after these long years of WW3. And in the background but not forgotten is the growing nuclear arsenal, being kept in hand for future use if required.
 
  • 3
Reactions: