• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Yep, both comments are correct in that by design, IC is the limiting factor for the mod. Most countries that fought in the war didn't have problems finding recruits until near the end. Their major problems were due to lack of equipment (look up the origin of the term Jerry-rigged). That's where the US is supposed to come in and solve the Allies and Comintern's equipment problems, but the game engine makes modeling Lend-Lease difficult.

The UK will probably be fine in East Africa, but I've seen Iraq do very well before and grab the Suez, so Iraq might be a good place to send troops to. Fix a small problem before it becomes a big problem.

Iraq is a good all-around target although I can't say I've ever seen them take Suez. With British Egypt free of obligations I'm expecting them to win, but nothing's certain until Australia gets involved, for sure. I'm glad that IC is my current limiter, and I don't foresee any manpower troubles until much later in the timeline, if at all. I'll probably start to feel it once I push for that 200 brigade army I need to become a Major Power. It is a pity that Lend-Lease is difficult to model but I'm glad the mod at least attempts to model the war as it should be. There's a reason it's my favourite out there!

The real problem was the decreasing quality of recruits. This was very evident in case of branches of service which required specialised training, e.g. the air force. The difference in quality of Japanese and German pilots from 1941 and 1944 is simply staggering. However, this concerned the land forces as well, as both the Soviets and the Germans had MP shortages in the late-war period and during the whole war the big question was how many men should be working in the factories and how many should be sent to the frontline, i.e. the ratio of workers to soldiers.

In theory that should be represented by unit experience, but it's difficult to model that outside of the engine as it exists, I believe. The shortages weren't just a matter of men available, but also of equipment, training to be offered and as you said, the worker-warrior ratio: look at organizations like the Volkssturm, a last-ditch attempt to raise manpower for the country even though it couldn't afford to mobilize or train these people as full-time soldiers for tons of reasons. It's a really delicate balance to try and model in a game, but I think that HPP has done a pretty good job so far.

-----

Update coming tonight!
 
Ah, yes, now we get our war with Japan!!! :)

Just about there! I've got to transfer forces first, of course.

lmasbanner.png

Chapter 2.10 - Shadow over the Pacific

britishtroopreformation.png

Britain remains the last hope of resistance. Although many formations were able to escape, this was all that could escape - a number of scattered divisions, lacking military equipment and drawn from several different militaries. The British Army was weak and the Home Islands vulnerable to attack should the North Sea Fleet fail.

The British Empire had been thoroughly defeated. There was no great escape for the British Army, and few of her forces were able to escape unharmed. Two divisions of Frenchmen and three divisions of the British Army were able to escape with most of their equipment intact. Under heavy pressure from the Germans, most of the later evacuations took place under fire and without a great deal of heavy cargo capacity. Most troops were simply loaded onto ships as quickly as possible, and not everyone was lucky enough to make it out of France. In all, the Germans captured over one million British and French forces in western and southern France - heavy losses that the Allies could not afford.

yugoslavianwar.png

The Germans were quick to issue a declaration of war on the Yugoslavians. It was believed that Hitler was dissatisfied with Mussolini's performance in the Mediterranean, but also that he was displeased about the previous backtracking of the Yugoslavians out of the Axis' alliance. This gave them the potential to solve both problems in one fell swoop, and would put increasing pressure on the Allies as more and more friendly territories slipped out of their grasp.

greekyugoslavianfronts.png

Yugoslavia did not fight alone, but was joined by the Greek Army.

Although resistance was deemed futile, the Yugoslavian and Greek States had to make a strong stand against German and Italian Imperialism. Greece honoured a guarantee upon their Yugoslavian neighbour and their army was mobilized for war even as Slavic and Italian forces clashed in Dalmatia. Italy claimed much of the Croatian coastline as theirs and the Germans claimed large tracts of Slovenia, due to German populations leftover from the Austro-Hungarian Empire. They would have to pay for it in blood.

fallofhongkong.png

On October 14th the news broke: Hong Kong had surrendered to Japanese troops with the loss of almost 9,000 men garrisoning the city. Malaya held only thirty thousand men to defend herself and the all-important naval base at Singapore. British Command sent an urgent message to the Australians begging for reinforcement and the next day, Australia responded. It was planned to take spare forces from Sardinia and Libya to reinforce the East Asian front as soon as possible.

sicilianfront.png

Aerial Reconaissance revealed few signs of Italian forces beyond Reggio.

Australian commanders regretted the lack of manpower at her disposal; the opportunity to land near Bari and cut Calabria off from the rest of the country was, in Bingham-White's words: "...too good to resist." The British were unwilling to spare troops for such an offensive, citing the heavy pressure from Iraq and Ethiopia as well as the entrance of Japan into the war. Surviving manpower was prioritised to garrison England against any invasion attempts by the German, however foolhardy those attempts were regarded. The mauled RAF and thinly-stretched Royal Navy also offered little support to the operation, and Australia was forced to maintain defensive lines for the time being.

tortolilandings.png

Australian troops land at Tortoli and move to strike Cagliari for the last time. Bingham-White feared that these repeated actions could lose an entire Corps, but Sardinia simply had to stay out of Italian hands for the safety of British shipping through the Southern Med.
thirdcagliaribattle.png

Major General Dougherty was placed in overall command of the offensive on Cagliari despite the presence of two men of equal rank in the offensive. Although the Italians had brought more men than their previous attempts, the speed and mobility of Robertson's cavalry combined with the raw firepower of the Australian infantry left little hope for the entrenched men at Cagliari. It was obvious that within a few days, the city would fall and Australia would have yet another mass of prisoners to deal with. Australia's prisoner of war camps were growing quite sizeable as Italian and Ethiopian soldiers were deported from the front lines to the Home Country itself where they could contribute to Australia's industrial needs under careful guard.

ethiopianfront.png

Ethiopia was a difficult battleground, where lack of infrastructure made fighting more like a series of bloody skirmishes than open field battles.

In East Africa, the British and Free French were slowly regaining the initiative; despite great losses in the south, reinforcements from Egypt had halted the Italian advance into Sudan and the French had secured Eritrea, giving the Allied forces easier access to supply lines. Although the front was far from won, the situation for Britain was stabilizing; this was a breath of fresh air for the thinly stretched Australian Army, who had only so many forces to deploy across the world. The Italians, although poorly supplied, continued to fight defiantly against all odds.

tunisianpush.png

ANZAC troops push up into Tunisia, hunting down surviving an estimated three Italian divisions.

Italian forces were offering little resistance in Tunisia. Several brief skirmishes were fought but they had few supplies and like in the central desert, they were soon drive into a corner...

battleofsilliana.png
battleofmahres.png

tunisianvictory.png

Two battles - two easy victories. Few Italian units put up a fight, most simply surrendered after being surrounded by fast-moving New Zealand infantry. The ANZAC forces would soon have free reign of the region as two full divisions were captured at Mahres and Silliana near the borders of French controlled territory. Only a single Italian division continued to put up a real fight, but it wouldn't be much longer before it surrendered. The surrounded division put up a fight for merely an hour before issuing its surrender. The Battle for North Africa was a complete victory.

italiangroundattacks.png

On October 16th, news reached Mediterranean Command that Italian bombers had pierced the Commonwealth's air cover east of Sardinia and made it to the island. They began a series of bombing runs that caused heavy casualties amongst the attacking Australian divisions, delaying the capture of Cagliari. Between the bombers, the artillery and the street fighting, the city had become heavily damaged and most of the inhabitants had fled to the countryside.

cagliarivictory.png

By the 18th, Cagliari fell. The Italians suffered thousands of casualties in the battle and most of those who weren't wounded or killed were captured by the Australian Corps. Although the HMAS Vanguard was in the area, the Italian fleet managed to escape the area unharmed by her planes. On the evening of the 20th, thousands of soldiers were being loaded onto transports at Cagliari and Tripoli; their destination: Asia. Roughly 30,000 men had been allocated to reinforce the British at Malaysia and they would be transported to Singapore under the cover of the HMAS Vanguard and her squadron.

narrowsairbattle.png

The bombings did not go without response. RAAF fighter squadrons intercepted the bombers returning from one of their raids on the morning of the 18th. Exposed and vulnerable, dozens of Italian bombers were shot down in the battle, resulting in a massive defeat for the RA. The Italians had lost most of their experienced bomber crew at this point and the efficiency of Italian bombing campaigns had dropped drastically.

majorairbattle.png

Italy responded in force. RAAF forces were met by a large force of Italian fighters. The ensuing fight was short and violent; faced with overwhelming numbers and few options, the Australian fighters were forced to retreat back to Sicily proper. For the first time, Italy shot down more fighter planes than Australia, but only just - it was a minor victory, but one that the Regio Aeronautica had been in desperate need of.

eastasiantheater.png

East Asian fronts had not changed much...intelligence suggested the IJN was heavily occupied by clashes with the United States Navy.

October 30th, news reached the world that the Thai government had, under enormous pressure, accepted a difficult and restrictive treaty with the Empire of Japan. Officially, Prathet Thai was an independent state. Unofficially, the treaty reduced her to nothing more than a puppet state. Forced to grant the Japanese Military full access to the country, the Thai Army was placed under Japanese command and Thai diplomacy was forcibly aligned to match that of Japan. The last free country of mainland East Asia was reduced to nothing more than a puppet of the Empire. Now, at last, Japan had easy access to Burma and Malaysia on the ground. The difficult terrain of the Chinese-Indian border had resulted in brief but bloody battles and a Great War style stalemate. In spite of that, the war was expected to gain momentum soon in the Jungles of southeast asia.

singaporecorps.png
australiansquadron.png

HMAS Vanguard and veteran ANZAC troops arrive at Singapore, ready for action.

On November 6th, Australian forces landed at the key city of Singapore. Lieutenant General Alan Ramsey was put in charge of the Australian Malaysian Forces. He was given a clear objective: neutralize the threat of the Thailand at any cost.

October 12th-November 6th
Royal Australian Army:
853 soldiers killed in action
Royal Australian Air Force:
22x Hawker Hurricane fighters lost
7x Supermarine Spitfire fighters lost
Regia Esercito:
2,474 soldiers killed in action
38,659 soldiers captured
Regio Aeronautica:
19x Fiat G.50 Freccia fighters lost
8x Macchi MC.200 Saetta fighters lost
79x Savoia Marchetti SM.79-II bombers lost​
 
Last edited:
Not the greatest of news out of Britain, but on the other hand, North Africa has been cleaned up, Cagliari has (yet again) fallen into Australian hands and Singapore looks a lot safer with 30,000 Aussies and Kiwis manning the front lines. I wonder how long it will be before they are tested...
 
Great AAR, very nicely written and very entertaining!

Lately I've mostly been interested in Vic2 AARs, but this one pulls me right back to my "favorite" period of history, and so far the whole story has been quite plausible.

Personally I enjoy seeing France fall. In my eyes, the Axis should become very strong so it is a struggle to defeat them, that makes for a much more interesting game and read than when you keep Germany at bay early on. The German war machine should be unstoppable for a couple of years, untill the output of the allies can finally grind them to a halt. (And ofcourse some well placed Ozzies who'd give the axis a good run for their money)

/Krogzar
 
With the struggle in North Africa finished, I must say I'm glad to see the Austrailians returning to the Pacific theater. I've got a feeling they'll be needed very soon.
 
Not the greatest of news out of Britain, but on the other hand, North Africa has been cleaned up, Cagliari has (yet again) fallen into Australian hands and Singapore looks a lot safer with 30,000 Aussies and Kiwis manning the front lines. I wonder how long it will be before they are tested...

Not long, I imagine. I'm more wondering how I'm going to make an impact in multiple theatres...

So a switch of focus to the Far East where it looks like there will be a lot of Japanese pressure quite soon! And at last a real test for the Australian divisions and HMAS Vanguard!

The Kwangtung Army is my biggest worry, I imagine it's marching down into Indochina and headed for Malaysia as I write this... :s Australia must be strong! Now that we're fighting in Asia, though, things start to play a little more into my favour. I didn't take Infiltration Doctrine for nothing!

Great AAR, very nicely written and very entertaining!

Lately I've mostly been interested in Vic2 AARs, but this one pulls me right back to my "favorite" period of history, and so far the whole story has been quite plausible.

Personally I enjoy seeing France fall. In my eyes, the Axis should become very strong so it is a struggle to defeat them, that makes for a much more interesting game and read than when you keep Germany at bay early on. The German war machine should be unstoppable for a couple of years, untill the output of the allies can finally grind them to a halt. (And ofcourse some well placed Ozzies who'd give the axis a good run for their money)

/Krogzar

Thank you, it's great to have you here! I have to work with the game but when things happen that don't make much sense I do my best to shift the story to a more plausible timeline. HPP helps me with a lot of that, but there's only so much a game can do.

Although I was annoyed at the AI for letting France fall in such a woefully incompetent manner, I enjoy it more and even wanted France to fall. I could have built a large army and ignored my navy/air force and, consequentially, I could have held the line against Germany without too much difficulty. I thought this would make for a more interesting AAR, and so far I'm feeling I was right.

With the struggle in North Africa finished, I must say I'm glad to see the Austrailians returning to the Pacific theater. I've got a feeling they'll be needed very soon.

It's a logical feeling; we'll see how this goes, though. War is an ever-changing prospect!
 
Wooooo Singapore.

It's okay, if you lose that one there's always Sydney.
 
That map of Asia looks terrifying for the Allies. At least HPP has India as a separate state, with hopefully its own sizeable forces to hold off the combined might of Japan, China and pretty much the rest of the southeast.
 
Wooooo Singapore.

It's okay, if you lose that one there's always Sydney.

Sydney shall always remain the implacable fortress of all things Green and Gold! Hopefully Singapore won't fall though, that'd be a total pain.

That map of Asia looks terrifying for the Allies. At least HPP has India as a separate state, with hopefully its own sizeable forces to hold off the combined might of Japan, China and pretty much the rest of the southeast.

Asia's a dangerous theater, but the Indian Army is quite sizeable and shouldn't fall easily. It'll all depend on how many men the Japaneses send into Burma and how many stay behind to watch the Soviet Bear and the Home Islands.

-----

Minimal progress on the next update, working on my other AAR right now, but once that's done I have quite the update planned here.

For anyone who isn't yet aware, the AARland Choice AwAARds 2012 are in full swing. Consider dropping by to vote for your favourite AARs over the last three months and put a smile on some writer's face! :D
 
Are you committed to holding the Mediterranean gains at all costs, or would something motivate you to pull out and send them to the Pacific?
 
What's with the Rocket Test Site in Malaysia?
 
Are you committed to holding the Mediterranean gains at all costs, or would something motivate you to pull out and send them to the Pacific?

I am willing to sacrifice the Mediterranean in order to:
1) Save Britain
or
2) Save Australia

If abandoning the islands is necessary to accomplish one of those two objectives, then I'm fine with doing so.

What's with the Rocket Test Site in Malaysia?

The AI doesn't think very defensibly when placing upgrades, in my experience they tend to pick a random IC province and just go with it. They seem to be investing in a lot of rocket sites this time around, so apparently they don't feel like they have anything more important to build!

British AI with unused IC that prefers rocket test sites in Singapore over Radars in Dover.

Indeed, very little Radar sites out there in general. At least I have an excuse: low IC count.
 
Seems like you are getting ready to defend SE Asia against the Imperial Army.

(Was wondering if you where going to do a semi Industrial update? aka. What your building, researching and how your resource situation is)
 
Seems like you are getting ready to defend SE Asia against the Imperial Army.

(Was wondering if you where going to do a semi Industrial update? aka. What your building, researching and how your resource situation is)

I was planning to very soon. Maybe not the next update due to some unexpected game events, but certainly the update after that.
 
Unexpected? That doesn't sound good...

Pessimism will reward you with low expectations, especially in this case. Either it goes horribly wrong and you're not surprised, or it goes right and you're pleasantly surprised!

Unless the Axis have just surrendered.

Wouldn't count on it though.

I wouldn't either. That'd be a hell of a push to cover in one update. ;)
 
Last edited: