Hi yall,
was looking at the famliy tree of Cétchathach and it seems like there are some discrepancies not too hard to find out.
Wikipedia lists "Áed mac Cináeda" as the father of Constantine II. This checks out since the father of "Áed mac Cináeda" is listed as "Kenneth MacAlpin" (King Cináed IV in CK3) which is the brother of Domnall mac Ailpín (King Domnall in CK3).
The problem is that "Áed mac Cináeda" is not in the game. Instead "King Cináed IV" is listed as Constantine IIs father, which is incorrect.
Also, according to Oxford Reference, Constantine II (King Causantín II) is the father of Indulf. Nowhere is a kid called "Domnall MacCausantín Ailpin" mentioned.
Checking https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/08/ScotlandMonarchs.png it also lists Indulf as the son of Constantine II.
So:
The father of Constantine II (Áed mac Cináeda) is missing from the game.
The son of Constantine II (Indulf) is missing from the game.
"King Cináed IV" is listed incorrectly as Constantine IIs father.
"Domnall MacCausantín Ailpin" is incorrectly listed as the son of Constantine II.
There are more inconsistencies in the Scottish tree, but I don't have more time to spend at this.
Thoughts/Comments?
//Carl
was looking at the famliy tree of Cétchathach and it seems like there are some discrepancies not too hard to find out.
Wikipedia lists "Áed mac Cináeda" as the father of Constantine II. This checks out since the father of "Áed mac Cináeda" is listed as "Kenneth MacAlpin" (King Cináed IV in CK3) which is the brother of Domnall mac Ailpín (King Domnall in CK3).
The problem is that "Áed mac Cináeda" is not in the game. Instead "King Cináed IV" is listed as Constantine IIs father, which is incorrect.
Also, according to Oxford Reference, Constantine II (King Causantín II) is the father of Indulf. Nowhere is a kid called "Domnall MacCausantín Ailpin" mentioned.
Checking https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/08/ScotlandMonarchs.png it also lists Indulf as the son of Constantine II.
So:
The father of Constantine II (Áed mac Cináeda) is missing from the game.
The son of Constantine II (Indulf) is missing from the game.
"King Cináed IV" is listed incorrectly as Constantine IIs father.
"Domnall MacCausantín Ailpin" is incorrectly listed as the son of Constantine II.
There are more inconsistencies in the Scottish tree, but I don't have more time to spend at this.
Thoughts/Comments?
//Carl
Attachments
- 1
Upvote
0
