• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

Chemo

Captain
54 Badges
Feb 7, 2012
356
6
  • Hearts of Iron III
  • Stellaris - Path to Destruction bundle
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mare Nostrum
  • Victoria 2: Heart of Darkness
  • Victoria 2: A House Divided
  • Semper Fi
  • Europa Universalis IV: Res Publica
  • Heir to the Throne
  • Hearts of Iron III: Their Finest Hour
  • For the Motherland
  • Europa Universalis IV: Call to arms event
  • Europa Universalis IV: Conquest of Paradise
  • Crusader Kings II: Legacy of Rome
  • Crusader Kings II: The Old Gods
  • Crusader Kings II: Sons of Abraham
  • Europa Universalis III
  • Europa Universalis III: Chronicles
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Divine Wind
  • Europa Universalis IV
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Europa Universalis IV: Wealth of Nations
  • Stellaris: Digital Anniversary Edition
  • Stellaris: Leviathans Story Pack
  • Stellaris: Ancient Relics
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Together for Victory
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rights of Man
  • Crusader Kings II: Monks and Mystics
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Death or Dishonor
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Expansion Pass
  • Stellaris: Humanoids Species Pack
  • Stellaris: Apocalypse
  • Stellaris: Distant Stars
  • Shadowrun Returns
  • Stellaris: Lithoids
  • Crusader Kings II: Reapers Due
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Cadet
  • Hearts of Iron IV Sign-up
  • Stellaris: Galaxy Edition
  • Stellaris
  • Crusader Kings II: Conclave
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cossacks
  • Crusader Kings II: Way of Life
  • 500k Club
  • Victoria 2
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Hearts of Iron IV: La Resistance
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Stellaris: Federations
  • Stellaris: Synthetic Dawn
Hello everyone, I've been an on-and-off poster around here for a while now, and a player of paradox games for a couple of years, with HOI3 being the first. Thus, I'm not the most experienced guy around, but I think I'm decent enough at it (long as it's against the AI, anyway) and I've got 400-ish hours of gameplay by now.

My favorite country to play has always been the UK, as I've played it several times by now and I never seem to get tired of it. I was just getting into the mood to play again, and I figured since I enjoy writing and talking about my games, why not make an AAR out of it?

This is my first attempt at writing an AAR, so it might be a bit shaky at first, but I hope you'll enjoy reading it as much as I'll enjoy writing it.

First update will cover peacetime, coming later today.
 
The Powderkeg of Europe


Obligatory 'This Is My Nation' Screenshot

Yep, that's definitely Britain all right. Now for the best part of any 1936 start: reorganizing the military. Woo! I organize my navy into SAGs of twelve ships or so: BB and DD, occasionally with cruisers as stand-ins for insufficient numbers. I also make a carrier fleet out of the RN's three fleet carriers and station it in the Mediterranean. The escort carriers are placed in destroyer squadrons, intended for sub-hunting (They might even sink one this time!)

First order of business during the New Year Cabinet Meeting is a report from London's Court Wizard. Prime Minister Baldwin was astonished when he was told about Farengar's latest creation, which is not only capable of detecting enemy aircraft, ground units, and submarines, but also possesses the ability to read the thoughts of any uniformed German between Edinburgh and the Maginot Line, allowing the British near-omniscience throughout northwestern Europe. This miraculous invention was called 'radar'. The Prime Minister immediately ordered construction of a massive radar station in Dover.

But an equally important concern was raised by the Chief of the Navy later that same day - the Royal Navy, while very large, consisted primarily of steel bathtubs armed with Maxim Guns. These so-called 'battleships' would likely be the equal of two Italian heavy cruisers. Considering the importance of the Mediterranean Theater, this was unacceptable, and so Baldwin ordered the construction of two new battleships to help supplement the Nelson-Class battleships, the only modern Dreadnoughts in the entire Navy.


The army was in an equally deplorable state. For some reason, despite having massive numbers of artillery available in WWI, all of the Royal Army's howitzers and field guns have somehow disappeared. Upon being asked by the bewildered Prime Minister where all their guns had gone, the Head of Intelligence insisted that they were 'probably stolen by the Germans or something'. Outraged by this revelation, Baldwin ordered the Head of Intelligence to step up counter-intelligence efforts throughout Britain and to establish a spy network in Germany. Unfortunately, that was all that could be done, as between the new battleship construction and the radar stations, there was no IC left available for use on military matters. As it was, much of Britain's IC was being consumed by the army upgrading it's WWI Lee-Enfield rifles to the exactly-identical WWII Lee-Enfield rifles, so additional production was not practical at the time.

Instead, the army was reorganized like the navy. Corps were renamed and many headquarters were disbanded, with all of the Royal Army's frontline divisions, barring the Scottish Command (later to be the Home Guard) were grouped into four-division Corps throughout England under the command of a single army, called 'First Army'. Of course, it was also the only army, but that name would be less impressive.

Speaking of impressive appearances, the Prime Minister also requested a report on the UK's only real ally, France.


If only they could hold the Maginot Line like that during the actual war.

France was powerful at the moment, but the rapidly rearming Germany would quickly surpass it. Long gone were the days of millions of brave Frenchmen standing guard at their borders, trading blows with the strongest army in the world and never giving an inch. Now they'll be lucky to to make it to 800,000 soldiers by the time Germany's ready for round two. Well, Britain will stand by their side regardless, at least for the twenty minutes that the campaign will last. Got to get our Tommies some experience somehow, right?

Research is prioritized on the navy - in particular, the merchant fleet had bitter memories of the German U-Boat campaign during the Great War. Thus, despite the constant protests from Britain's researchers that this technology was absolutely impossible to research for at least another two years, research was ordered on the development of anti-submarine warfare equipment for the navy's destroyers. Slightly more practically, other teams began work on upgrading the navy's massive 15-inch guns to the somehow-more-powerful 14 inch guns for the next generation of Dreadnoughts, along with armor and engine upgrades to match. Destroyer development was also underway, in order to make the expendable warships slightly less expendable by the time Germany's million-man peace envoy was sweeping through France.

On land, the army's outdated doctrines, still of the 'walk slowly in neat lines toward enemy machine guns through artillery fire with the officers out front' variety were also being reconsidered, despite arguments that if that method failed the first 400 times the Germans would never expect them to try it again. The naval methods were very much up to date, however, so that was suspended for now. The rest of Britain's leadership was invested into aircraft, both training and the development of more modern equipment.

Many protested such an extensive rearmament campaign during the midst of an economic depression, but they were quickly vindicated by the German Army invading the peaceful nation of, uh, Germany.


Well, that doesn't seem so bad. Did they at least shoot at the French soldiers on the border or something? No? Well, just have our spies in Germany spread rumors that they did, same thing.

In 1937, the Spanish Civil War begins, and the Germans, Soviets, and Italians all intervene. Baldwin also suggested involvement in the form of material and financial aid, but his cabinet pointed out that his party wasn't popular enough to do such a thing. Haven't these people ever heard of covert ops? It's right there in the intelligence screen.

It turned out to be a mistake, as the rebels in Spain won in only a few months, replacing the Kingdom with a Fascist dictatorship. Well, at least it wasn't communists right?

That same year, in a move that utterly shocked the world, a militaristic nation that has been aggressively expanding into China for decades declares a war of aggression on China. Much to the Kingdom's concern, the Japanese forces were making rapid progress against a numerically superior enemy. If China fell, India may very well be next.


The cabinet briefly considered a military intervention, but since the British Pacific Fleet consisted of a toy submarine the commander of the Indian Army played with in the bathtub, the idea was shot down faster than the Chinese air force. With no foreign aid coming, China gave in a few months later and surrendered the majority of their coastline to Japan. Well, at least the Japanese still didn't have a land border with India. That was all we cared about anyway.

But Prime Minister Baldwin, who was getting on in years, resigned not long after, citing "You bloody imbeciles are going to run our empire deep enough into the ground to strike oil! I'm leaving the country while I still can!" as his reason. The country briefly mourns his loss, but a brave soul, Neville Chamberlain, steps up to the plate.

While Chamberlain was not keen on another war, he was not blind. He could see that Britain's Military, while in a deplorable state, was rapidly improving under Baldwin's policies. Chamberlain therefore took a 'hands off policy' in regards to the military, electing instead to focus on foreign relations while the cabinet ran military matters.

It wouldn't be long before he faced his first real test: The Munich Agreement.


Giving a power-hungry dictator a territorial concession without any resistance whatsoever? How could this possibly go wrong?

The game is using my shtick - even the events are tongue-in-cheek now. Fortunately, this undeniable act of peaceful aggression, with careful manipulation by the British Press, managed to steel the resolve of the population. They were willing to accept the Germans stationing soldiers in part of their own country, but taking territories from other nations was too much. Britain and France would allow this small concession, especially since it didn't actually require them to sacrifice anything themselves, but not a single square inch more (probably).

With events in Europe coming to a head, the British doubled their military expansion and began preparing for war. While Chamberlain desired nothing except peace (unless there was no chance of defeat of course), he wasn't too keen on German soldiers marching into London in a few years either, since that's where all his stuff was. Thus, Europe teetered on the edge of war, and a single spark could trigger an explosion at any time.
 
Last edited:
This is nice, although I don't like that you won't use the walk in line towards enemy Machinr guns with officers in the front doctrine; I like it! Oh and the quote in your sign is epic ;)
 

Sounds interesting, good luck!

Thanks! Hope you enjoy what's happened so far.

This is nice, although I don't like that you won't use the walk in line towards enemy Machinr guns with officers in the front doctrine; I like it! Oh and the quote in your sign is epic ;)

Indeed, it was a controversial decision. If it makes you feel any better, Prime Minister Chamberlain insists on costly assaults against German tanks in unfavorable terrain to make up for it :)
 
Indeed, it was a controversial decision. If it makes you feel any better, Prime Minister Chamberlain insists on costly assaults against German tanks in unfavorable terrain to make up for it :)

Well, if the Brits fought properly it wouldn't be fair now would it?

I'm liking this so far, sill be following.
 
The Second World War

In the aftermath of the Munich Agreement, Europe settled into an uneasy Détente. While most were thankful that war had been averted, it had come at a great cost. Peaceful expansion or no, a rapidly rearming nation that actively worked to expand its borders made people nervous, almost like they were afraid of being invaded or something.

Fortunately, the treaty, whether or not it was justified, seemed to have averted war, and so Chamberlain believed that, while unfortunate for the Czechoslovakians, the Munich Agreement was worth the cost. And surely, the Germans would uphold their end of the bargain, right?


Well...This is awkward...

Well, that's rather impolite, and it doesn't reflect very well on us either. In fact, it kind of makes us look like ineffectual backstabbing scumbags willing to sell out other nations to save our own skins. While that is absolutely the case, we don't look very prestigious when we do it too often. Quick, everyone try to look competent!








Whew, that was a close one. At least we look like we're ready for a war now. Over the past three years, the British have greatly expanded the size and firepower of their military, raising additional infantry divisions (both foot and motorized) plus armored units. A heavy armor division is on it's way and will be done in March 1940, which will complete the First Army.

However, while Europe seems to be on the brink of war, Germany seems reluctant to escalate the situation further, giving Britain a few more precious months to prepare. However, it is obvious what Germany's next target will be. German forces were massing on the Polish border, and it was obvious to the cabinet that an invasion was soon to follow. In a final bid to avoid another costly war, Britain guaranteed the independence of Poland in hopes of deterring a German invasion.

Despite this bold action, Britain was still not prepared for war, especially in the Mediterranean. When Italy signed the pact with Germany, additional forces were raised and dispatched to Malta in case the Italians attempted to seize it, but little else could be done. While Britain's Mediterranean Fleet was powerful, it was horribly outdated, as the Home Fleet had priority for modern warships. It would be a long time before new ships trickled down to the Mediterranean, and army units would have to wait until the war in France was over.

On September 1st, 1939, Germany declared war on Poland.


Yay for historical accuracy!

Britain honored the alliance immediately, the cabinet arguing that they didn't have to actually do anything in order to participate in the war (blockade, anyone?). Nonetheless, Chamberlain insisted that they at least try and pretend to care about helping Poland, so the First Army was shipped to France and positioned along the Belgian border. The French would hold the border with Germany, and if Germany attempted to outflank the Allies by invading Belgium, British mobile units were prepared to advance and blunt the offensive before it could enter France proper.


My completely original and novel strategy for fighting the Germans

No one thought to ask what Belgium thought about being a battlefield, but considering their history of being a road for the German Army it was a pretty safe bet that they'd be in the Allies sooner or later. As long as we insist that we're doing it to protect Belgium rather than keep the Wehrmacht out of France, we should be able to pass it off as heroic.


Oh...So close. Only off by three days.

Poland fell less than a month after the beginning of hostilities. In a surprising move, Germany split Poland with the Soviet Union. Figures that the communists would be involved somehow. Wait, why are they working together anyway? Didn't Hitler write a whole book about how he's going to conquer the Soviet Union and hates communists? What is Stalin smoking?

Well, it doesn't matter at the moment since the collapse of Poland means that the Wehrmacht is going to be moving west. The Maginot Line is strong, but the real test will come in Belgium. As proven by the Polish Campaign, Germany knows better than to attack someone it can't defeat, so the British Army is prepared to enter Belgium at any time while the French army group in charge of staring at the Germans will continue holding the Maginot Line.

However, Europe falls surprisingly silent after Poland's collapse. Weeks pass, and the Wehrmacht attempts no attack on either the Maginot Line or Belgium. In fact, the first move comes as a complete surprise - a declaration of war on Denmark.


Denmark is unable to offer any meaningful resistance against the Wehrmacht, and their army collapses within days as battle-hardened soldiers storm across the border. Within a week, German forces are on the outskirts of Copenhagen, the last remnants of the Danish Army desperately holding on to their capital.

Of course, Britain is never going to miss a chance to keep the war as far away as humanly possible, so they lend assistance to Denmark by landing the Gurkha Corps in Copenhagen before the Germans were able to seize it.


Furious counterattacks bore no fruit, however, resulting in high casualties without dislodging the entrenched Germans. Not helping matters was the fact that, despite a total blockade of the island by the Royal Navy, the Germans were able to teleport supplies and reinforcements, steadily increasing their strength on the island while Britain had little to spare.

Also during this period of time, the Germans declared war on Norway, indicating the reason for their invasion of Denmark was to gain a springboard for their push north to secure the iron ore coming from Sweden. Upon spotting a German invasion force near Narvik, the Royal Navy's battlecruiser squadron sortied to intercept.


One of several naval battles so far, and the most significant one in terms of losses.

The battle was a tactical success for the British, sinking the German Navy's flagship along with several transports, but unfortunately the fleet was unable to prevent the landing of a limited number of troops. With no forces available to assist Norway with the looming German attack on the West, Norway was left to fend for itself.

Denmark, however, could still be saved. As the French Theater was still quiet, the cabinet decided that a little extra punch was just what the Gurkhas needed to tip the scales in their favor. Britain's armored units were detached from the First Army and deployed to Copenhagen. A few days later, yet another attempt to dislodge the Germans was launched, this time with tanks spearheading the assault and Royal Navy battleships bombarding enemy positions from the Baltic.


However, the Germans offered stubborn resistance, and the armored units were rapidly worn down by the numerically superior Germans. Determined to force the Germans off Zealand, the British escalated the battle, gradually committing more and more forces until, finally, the German lines were broken and their forces retreated in disarray, again somehow through a massive fleet of battleships and destroyers guarding the strait.


The Germans repeatedly attacked across the strait, but the attacks were easily put down by stubborn resistance and gunfire support from the Royal Navy.




With Zealand secured, the Royal Army's tanks were returned to France, where they would be much more needed in the coming clash with the German Army. With no anti-tank guns to speak of and outdated infantry anti-armor weapons, British armored units were vital to help even the odds. A British Crusader tank was the match of any German equivalent, but the Germans had many more to spare, so every division counted. However, this proved to be a mistake, as without armored support the exhausted Gurkha divisions were unable to survive repeated German assaults, and eventually the line broke and they had to retreat. They were evacuated from Copenhagen shortly after and returned to France, leaving Denmark to it's fate.

A key weakness was identified in the Gurkha divisions as a result of the Battle of Zealand. While excellent in rough terrain, simply put they were too small and lacking in firepower to fight in a modern war. As a result, paratrooper brigades began training in order to supplement them without removing their airborne warfare capabilities, but it would be some time before they were ready to deploy. Until then, they would simply have to rely on heavier units for support.

In the summer of 1940, Germany finally made it's move. Minister Chamberlain is reported to have rubbed his hands together while cackling about how everything was proceeding according to plan.


Immediately, the First Army advanced into Belgium toward their predetermined positions along the country's rivers. While Belgium offered resistance to the German incursion, they were no match for the Wehrmacht's firepower, and so steadily fell back. Fortunately for the Allies, the British armored and motorized divisions easily reached their objectives and began digging in before the Germans managed to completely collapse the Belgian Army. The Wehrmacht ground to a screeching halt as they ran into determined British defenders. Once the Belgians had recovered, they joined the British in the defense, leaving Germany in control of only a handful of provinces.

Before the British were fully entrenched, the Germans did have limited success in open terrain.


But the front stabilized not long after, with neither side willing to commit to a general offensive without a significant numerical advantage.


The air war was similarly at a standstill. After several costly clashes in the skies, both sides grounded their aircraft, conserving their strength for when it would be most needed. British and German aircraft were evenly matched, and any attempt to bomb the other side's army was met by furious resistance from their respective interceptors. For a few weeks, the Luftwaffe and the RAF traded blows in the skies above Belgium, some of the larger battles involving as many as 2,000 planes at a time, but ultimately there was no decisive result. Eventually, both sides, by unspoken agreement, allowed the other air parity and decided to commit their planes only when supporting bombers during major attacks.

Desperate to avoid a repetition of the Great War, the cabinet decided on a limited counteroffensive using armored units as a spearhead, more as an experiment than anything. While the theory of using armored divisions to create a breakthrough had been discussed for some time, it had never been put into practice. A prime location for the attack would be Luxembourg. It was heavily forested, and while that would make it difficult to take, it would also allow the British infantry to hold it when the Germans attempted to retake it later on. Thus, the Battle of Luxembourg began, with British light armor, infantry, and the Gurkha Corps launching a coordinated assault from three sides. After more than a month of grueling battle, the British were successful and drove the Germans from their most recent conquest.


The battle was costly, but successful, and the British began digging in to hold the province against potential counterattacks. The French were given political control over the province, and they decided that the restoration of Luxembourg's government would wait. Right now, the war was chaotic enough without having any pesky third parties complaining about a massive army consuming all its resources and brutally suppressing their citizens to 'protect' them.

However, Germany finally decided it had enough and called upon it's major ally, Italy:


Wow, they'll let anyone into the Axis these days...

Fortunately, Britain had been expecting this sooner or later once Italy had allied itself with Germany, and was at least somewhat prepared in North Africa, where the 15,000 soldiers of the Middle Eastern forces had been assembled and dug in along the Libyan border.


The Italians almost immediately launched an offensive, their elite Alpini infantry spearheading the effort and concentrating on the Africa Corps' southern flank in hopes of pushing them back and outflanking the coastal garrison. However, a counterattack launched by the 7th Infantry Division was able to hinder them enough to allow the 8th Division to hold the line, albeit barely.

Seizing the opportunity, the Africa Corps immediately counterattacked, the Mediterranean Fleet's battleships offering fire support for the 7th Division. After an epic confrontation lasting almost fifteen minutes, the Italian lines collapsed and the exhausted British Infantry crossed into Libya. However, with both divisions on the verge of collapse, they advanced only around 50 kilometers before digging in. Full conquest of Libya, and later Italy itself, would have to wait until later. Until then, North Africa would remain a sideshow to the events unfolding in Belgium and France.
 
Last edited:
Nice start, will be following this one. Good luck!

Nice start. Good luck against the Wehrmacht.

Thanks! I've played up to 1940, and so far I'm up to October/November or so and the lines are holding steady. France is doing surprisingly well in this game, as for once they haven't given an inch on the Franco-German border.

I'm very much enjoying how well this is working out. Belgian and British forces are holding the Germans in Belgium, while France is competently holding the Maginot Line. It's not often you get a good situation like this playing as the UK.

And the gigantic air battles are especially fun.

Well, if the Brits fought properly it wouldn't be fair now would it?

I'm liking this so far, sill be following.

Indeed. I've found that being outnumbered and facing impossible odds but somehow winning anyway is the typical British game in HOI3. It would be completely unfair if I actually had numerical parity with the Germans :happy:

Now, an open question for everyone. Do you prefer the narrative style, or would you rather it be gameplay? Or a little bit of both?

And the other major aspect, the humor - more or less? It got a lot more serious around the actual war, but I don't want to overdo it either way. Thoughts?
 
Now, an open question for everyone. Do you prefer the narrative style, or would you rather it be gameplay? Or a little bit of both?

And the other major aspect, the humor - more or less? It got a lot more serious around the actual war, but I don't want to overdo it either way. Thoughts?

Keep going like you've done so far. I've read both chapters in one go and had a good laugh a few times :)
 
Keep going like you've done so far. I've read both chapters in one go and had a good laugh a few times :)

Appreciate the feedback. It's early 1941 now, and the BEF has reached somewhere around 350,000 soldiers, and the stalemate in France and Belgium has continued. I'm honestly surprised at how well the French are doing in this game. The Maginot Line is impenetrable and they're even rolling back the Italians in North Africa (whereas I can only hold the line).

But it wouldn't be a fun AAR if that was all that happened, would it? I'm almost tempted to just pull my forces out and let France fall, but that just seems improper considering I haven't lost the campaign there. I wonder if Germany will DoW Switzerland or something? That would certainly mix things up.
 
Try dowing Switzerland

A bit too gamey for my tastes, especially for an AAR (if it wasn't for that, I might not have fought in France at all). If I had to guess, I'd say that sooner or later Germany will attack through Italy or Switzerland on its own. If not, I might have to make a 'tactical withdrawal' at some point to keep things interesting.

There are other theaters though - East Africa comes to mind (you'll see in the next update).
 
Nice kick off! I haven't played with the UK yet but with this AAR as a "way of playing" along side could help me actually give it a go with them. Keep it up!

EDIT: oh.... and subbed :D
 
East African Campaign

With the entry of Italy in the war, it became painfully obvious that the United Kingdom, despite vehement insistence that it was prepared for a war with Italy, was completely and utterly unprepared for a war with Italy. This was apparent in the fact that there were only 15,000 soldiers, with no artillery support, available in all of North Africa and the Middle East. East Africa was even worse - a single brigade of regular infantry, and two brigades of Ugandan Militia, who had more experience with knives and spears than they did rifles.

While the North Africa garrison was able to offer surprisingly stiff resistance to the Italian invasion, the East African territories were both expansive and almost completely undefended. For some weeks, the Italians and their puppets, the Ethiopians, ran rampant throughout the region, occupying British territory without so much as a shot fired on either side.


However, the British did have one trick up their sleeve. The 18,000 Gurkhas, light infantry specially trained for a variety of harsh environments such as that of East Africa, hastily boarded a large fleet of transport planes and were shipped to Mombasa, the headquarters of the so called 'African Army'. After a few days of waiting for supply to catch up to them by sea, the Ghurkas were ready for the first airborne operation in human history.


Operation Anvil

The Ugandan Militia would advance North, occupying the westernmost areas of Italian Somaliland where there was expected to be minimal, if any, resistance. Their job was to open a vital land route to the Ghurkas' landing zones to keep them supplied. Once the Italian port city of Mogadiscio was surrounded, a joint assault would be carried out by the entire corps to secure the location. This would cut the Italians off from a major source of external supply, making future operations easier for the British in addition to providing them another port of their own.

The airborne assault was carried out flawlessly, the Ghurkas landing as a single coherent unit with sufficient supplies to sustain themselves until a land route back to Mombasa could be opened by the Ugandans. Not wasting any time, the 5th Indian Infantry began digging in, while the 2nd and 1st Gurkha divisions pushed northeast, swinging around in a left hook to envelop the Italian port and trap the local defenders in the city. It took some time to fully surround the city, as the territories were vast and largely untamed, but the defenders made no effort to break the encirclement or retreat. They were confident that, since they were dug in and supplied by sea, they would be able to withstand the offensive.

They could not have been more wrong:


Despite the defenders being heavily dug in and prepared for the assault, they were no match for the elite Indian infantry, who swiftly conquered the city and seized the port, allowing British convoys to begin shipping in fresh supplies. The local militiamen were taken prisoner and put to work clearing Italian minefields in Libya.

The Gurkhas, though their first independent operation was a resounding success, took no time to celebrate and immediately moved to take up positions along the Ethiopian border. However, with no Italian counterattack forthcoming from the east, Operation Anvil was revised to reflect the Cabinet's new priority:


Ethiopia would be defeated first. In a truly astounding show of confidence, the defeat of an entire nation was placed into the hands of a mere 18,000 soldiers and a handful of local militia. Needless to say, while surprised at the weight of the duty that fell to them, they were more than eager to take on the task.

The revised operation commenced a few days later. Both the Ethiopians and Italians offered resistance to the British invasion, but they were no match, having very little food or ammunition as well as being demoralized by the seemingly undefeatable Indians that opposed them. Mountains, jungles, forests and deserts offered no obstacle to the talented soldiers, who conquered terrain just as they conquered their enemy, and soon they were on the outskirts of Addis Ababa.


However, before the Gurkhas could deliver the coup de grâce, news came from home of a political crisis. In short, the Empire's Prime Minister was believed to have overstayed his welcome. Both the military and his own party had no confidence in his continued leadership and wanted him gone. His advocacy of the Munich Treaty, despite his good intentions, was now seen by most as a foolish endeavor and a sign that he was not fit to lead their nation. Chamberlain, despite his grumblings that the people were a bunch of ungrateful sods considering how Britain had needed the extra time to finish rearming themselves anyway, was forced to resign. Days later, Winston Churchill was appointed in his place, the man promising to lead Britain through the troubling times and to victory.


This event is evil. Is there anyone who didn't click the Churchill option thinking that's who it would appoint?

Fortunately, the political shakeup had no effect on the impending battle, and the Gurkhas launched the final assault on Addis Abada. After a brief one-sided engagement, the Ethiopians were driven back and their capital occupied. The government collapsed, and a day later, fled to Rome, dividing the area between the British, French, and the few remaining Italian holdouts.


Unfortunately, this did not end the campaign, as the remaining Italians in the area refused to surrender, and continued to fight despite being completely cut off from supply and reinforcements. While they stood no chance in the long run, it nonetheless took the Gurkhas and the French colonial forces several months to round them all up and fully secure the region. By the summer of 1941, East Africa was completely under Allied control, the Italians having lost their puppet, colonies, and several divisions for their trouble.

North Africa remained a stalemate for much of this period, as the Italians seemed reluctant to commit significant forces to the front, possibly due to the risk of the Royal Navy blowing them up the second they left the safety of a harbor. However, over many weeks the Italians were able to gradually build up their forces in the region, and by the spring of 1941 outnumbered the British enormously. It wasn't long before the token defensive forces in the area found themselves under heavy attack by a force much larger than the one they had fought previously.


The Middle Eastern forces were driven from Libya and back into Egypt, falling back in disarray before managing to establish a new defensive line approximately 80 kilometers from the border. Another offensive, or indeed, even a successful defense would require reinforcement. But until the fighting in Europe was over, they were likely going to be a long time in coming.

Fortunately for them, however, there were rumors of an impending British counteroffensive in Belgium. The scale and objectives were not known, but British armored divisions had been conspicuously absent from Allied lines during recent days.
 
Last edited:
Nice kick off! I haven't played with the UK yet but with this AAR as a "way of playing" along side could help me actually give it a go with them. Keep it up!

EDIT: oh.... and subbed :D

Welcome! I'm not the most experienced player around, but I've played the UK quite a bit and I'd like to think I know my way around it, if nothing else. That said, I hope this AAR will be of some use to you.

There's definitely something special about the UK - the freedom to do whatever you want, and yet lacking the sheer numbers to do it all at once. It takes a deft touch for a while, at least until the mid-game when you've built up your armies.

I can tell you of two major pitfalls though. Number one, convoys - you need a lot of them. Two, be patient. If you do too good a job of trolling Germany, they won't get around to launching Barbarossa and it will make your life difficult. Other than that, you can do whatever you please, and that's the true beauty of a game as the UK :)
 
Operation Futility

With the stalemate continuing in Europe, and the general reluctance of the Germans to commit to a general offensive against the British Expeditionary Force, it was believed by the cabinet that the Wehrmacht was not as powerful as they initially believed. The Battle of Luxembourg, although a difficult fight, proved that armored spearheads supported by motorized infantry were extremely effective, especially in open terrain. Thus, despite the deadlock of the European Theater, it was believed that a counteroffensive, using these tactics, had good odds of succeeding. Thus, the cabinet ordered the Royal Army High Command to draw up plans for an offensive in Belgium and the Netherlands.


The offensive was named 'Operation Futility', naturally because any German resistance would be futile, and certainly not because the plan was likely to fail completely and result in nothing except extremely high casualties. In short, the first and second Royal Armored Corps, comprising eight armored divisions between them, would force two separate breakthroughs in northern Belgium. Heavy and medium tanks would spearhead the assault, paving the way for light armor and motorized divisions to exploit the breach in the line. The mobile units would adopt a 'leapfrog' strategy, in which two divisions would advance while the other two rested and prepared to continue the attack.

It was believed that the Germans had few reserves in the area, choosing instead to adopt a static defense doctrine not unlike the Great War, a situation that was forced by the numerous rivers in the area that made armored offensives largely ineffective. Therefore, it was believed that once the initial breakthroughs had been achieved, the Germans and Italians in Holland would collapse completely. The ultimate goal of Operation Futility was to liberate the Netherlands and trap the occupying Axis forces against the sea, where they would be either captured or destroyed.

The operation began with a massive bombing campaign carried out by the Royal Air Force. Hawker Hurricanes and Supermarine Spitfires took to the skies, flying sorties over German-occupied territory to occupy their interceptors while light and medium bombers bombarded German positions along the front. However, the Germans were heavily dug in, and the British were forced to wade across one of Belgium's many rivers in order to advance. The initial breakthrough was a long process, and very costly on both sides. The initial success came in the east, when Churchill heavy tanks managed to breach German lines in Turnhout after heavy fighting. British light tanks and motorized units were quick to exploit the gap, while foot infantry moved up to occupy the territory and cover the advancing spearheads.


The other spearhead targeted the Belgian province of Breda, at the time defended by Italian motorized units. The British therefore believed that it would be a relatively simple task, but they turned out to be mistaken due to stiff Italian resistance and the requirement to cross a river while under fire. Thus, the western portion of the offensive proceeded behind schedule, but ultimately the excellent British concentration of force facilitated the breakthrough, although at a very high cost.


Unfortunately, the troubles did not end there. Furious German counterattacks against the BEF's eastern flank brought the offensive to a standstill, and it was difficult to move reinforcements to the spearheads while the supply lines were under constant assault. German bombers added additional difficulties as well, as most of the RAF's fighter strength at the time had been spent covering bombers during the initial attack, therefore leaving the skies to the Luftwaffe for the time being.

In the end, the province of Eindhoven would change hands several times, always at a high cost in lives, but fortunately the armored units further west were able to link up with the II. Armored Corps before they were cut off. The Corps itself was separated, however, as some of it's divisions were forced to retreat south rather than toward the spearhead, something that would slow the progress of the offensive even more. However, an encirclement had been averted, so that was a victory in itself.


With the situation contained, relentless attacks from all sides managed to push them back east, stabilizing the front.


The Germans were determined, however, and continued to attack the army's eastern flank. Turnhout, in particular, saw around eight separate battles during this period.


A 'typical' Battle of Turnhout.

But despite the gains of the offensive, not all was well in Europe. In the south, the French were collapsing as Italian and German army units launched a large joint offensive against the lightly defended frontier with Italy.


The French did not have enough units in the area to deal with the extended front, so were forced to pull units off the Maginot Line in order to deal with the incursion.

(AN: Despite how it looks, I am actually very impressed with France's performance right now. They took enough units from the Franco-German border to fight the offensive without compromising the Maginot Line. They handled it quite well, overall, but they just don't have enough troops to deal with both at once.)

However, this was all occurring many miles away from the showdown in Belgium, and the BEF did not allow itself to become distracted as it continued to force a path toward Amsterdam. Despite continued resistance and enduring constant bombardment from the Luftwaffe, the advance was steady. Particularly of note was the successful encirclement of several German divisions in Turnhout, which had fallen back into German hands following a successful counterattack.


Despite German efforts to relieve the pocket, it was destroyed after many days of constant attacks by the surrounding British.


They'll be missing those when it's time for Barbarossa.

The Italians made a move of their own during this time, landing a mountaineer division on undefended Cyprus in the Eastern Mediterranean. The move was unanticipated, especially since the Italians had previously been focusing their efforts on Malta, and so there were no ships in the area to intercept the invasion fleet before the troops could be landed.


This is what happens when you station all your ships in Malta. I was actually somewhat impressed by the Italians catching me off guard like this.

The British response was therefore somewhat belated, but decisive considering how far removed the area was from more pressing matters. The Gurkha Corps, having recently wrapped up the East African Campaign, was finally ready to be redeployed. As they were the nearest units to Cyprus when the Italians occupied it, they were the first choice to reclaim it. In a true Gurkha fashion, they were dropped from their transport planes directly on top of the entrenched Italian infantry.


Back in Europe, the BEF advanced all the way to the outskirts of Amsterdam, but sadly by then the armored spearheads and covering infantry divisions were utterly exhausted, having endured constant battle, bombing runs by the Luftwaffe, and extremely heavy casualties. German counterattacks forced a general retreat on the front, and the BEF was pushed almost all the way back to it's starting positions before they finally managed to halt the advance. Massive battles were fought all along the front as the Italians and Germans attempted to press their advantage and force the BEF out of Holland entirely, particularly on the western side of the front in Breda.


The bloodiest battle of the entire operation.

However, a renewed British counteroffensive, carried out by the recovered I. Armored Corps, successfully drove the Germans and Italians back once again, eventually stabilizing the front approximately 80 kilometers into Holland.

Overall, Operation Futility resulted in high casualties on both sides, but particularly for the Axis, as seven divisions were encircled and destroyed during the course of the offensive, including several armored ones, for a loss of approximately 66,000 Germans, not including combat losses.


Therefore, Operation Futility was a limited success. It did not achieve it's primary objectives of liberating the Netherlands or destroying a significant portion of the German Army. It did, however, result in moderate territorial gains and the destruction of 1-2 Wehrmacht army corps, including valuable panzer divisions that would surely have been needed in the ongoing war.

But the battle in southern France was what truly alarmed the Cabinet and the British High Command. France, despite it's best efforts, was being steadily overrun in the south. Despite sending massive reinforcements, the Germans and Italians had already built up momentum, and thus were only slowed, not halted. Shortly after the end of the British offensive in Holland, nearly half of France was overrun.


Although the French insisted that they had no intention of surrendering, the British could see the writing on the wall. Once the Germans had occupied Paris, France would collapse and leave the BEF in Belgium horribly exposed. It was decided by the cabinet that there was no choice - the British would carry out a courageous tactical withdrawal from Europe while they still could, leaving France and Belgium to their fates.

The BEF retreated in an orderly fashion, steadily falling back toward the Belgian coast and establishing a much smaller perimeter that would allow them to ship units back to the home island without compromising the line. Within weeks, the BEF had completely left Europe. Without their British allies to assist them, Belgium, and later France, fell not long after.


By the fall of 1941, Britain stood alone.
 
Last edited: