Soviet-Germany B1 - Prelude
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
BOOK I
THE SOCIALIST EXPERIMENT
1933-1939
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Prelude
Death of Democracy:
National Socialists and Communists
1931-1933
Established after defeat in the Great War and on the brink of revolution in 1918, the Weimar Republic faced a number of challenges during its lifespan. Strong anti-democratic atmosphere, bitterness for the dreaded Versailles Treaty and economic crisis led to that anti-democratic parties and radical political movements gained much strength. Support for Adolf Hitler’s National Socialist Workers Party (NSDAP) rose from year to year during the 1920s at the same time as the German Communist Party (KPD) was one of the strongest in Europe. National Socialist paramilitary forces, the
Sturmabteilung (SA) and its communist counterpart, the
Rotfrontkämpferbund (RFB) encountered each other in bloody street fights regularly and the parties constantly threatened the democratic order in their speech. During the first years of the 1930s, the great depression hit the German population hard with unprecedented deflation and unemployment rate reaching the peak of 42% in 1932. In times of extraordinary crises the appeal to extremism increases. Street violence got tougher and the people’s trust in the Weimar Republic was diminishing rapidly and just as the unemployed working class rallied around the KPD, the frightened middle class increasingly flocked around the NSDAP.
Both parties had one thing in common; they were bent on destroying the Weimar Republic, with or without the help of elections. The democratic way was not the KPD’s natural way to power, while the NSDAP had learned the hard way that they could not seize power without the consent of the army. After the elections of 1930, the NSDAP and KPD combined number of seats in the parliament amounted to nearly 30%. With Hermann Müller’s “Grand Coalition” in pieces and so many parliament seats in the hands of non-democratic powers, the
Reichstag was unable to form a majority government. In the eve of political stalemate, the aged president Paul von Hindenburg took the right to form a government by a presidential degree. These powers were provided to the president in case of emergency according to article 48 of the constitution. Hindenburg had Heinrich Brüning form a cabinet with a lukewarm support from the
Reichstag.
In February 1931, as Adolf Hitler was returning to his car after a meeting in the outskirts of Berlin, an adjacent truck stacked with explosives blew up. Hitler and two other party leaders were killed by the blast. The authorities and the National Socialists blamed the communists for planning the act but the KPD denied allegations. Either way, Hitler’s assassination was a serious blow to the National Socialist party which was felt immediately. The party had lost its unifying figure; the popular demagogue who guaranteed mass support, and the
Führer, whose persona was the base of National Socialist ideology. Party factions soon battled each other; the so-called National-National Socialists under Josef Goebbels and the Socialist-National Socialists under Gregor Strasser fought for ideological dominance. In the middle was Hermann Göring, the new party leader; powerless as the SA under Ernst Röhm became semi-independent with all its physical power. The SA, bitter and uncontrolled, retaliated against the communists. Street fights and political violence, murder and sabotage skyrocketed across Germany. The capital virtually became a civil war zone throughout the remainder of the year. In August, Chancellor Brüning managed to get the SA and the RFB banned but the police was unable to execute the ban. The paramilitary forces had become the real political force in Germany and would remain so, lest President Hindenburg with the German Army by his side took matters in his own hands.
The Hindenburg Dictatorship
And this he did. In April 1932, chancellor Brüning offered his resignation since his government was unable to take on the social and economic problems of the nation. What really set him off though was the Reichstag fire, three days earlier; an act organized by Goebbels in order to stage an ill organised coup, from which he backed down immediately. Now Hindenburg had only two options before him; have the dismantled NSDAP form a government, probably under Göring’s weak chancellorship or have the army restore order under himself. He went with the latter choice; to bid the communists to form a government was never a possibility. For the second time in his life, Hindenburg headed a military dictatorship in Germany, with himself as president and head of the army and General Kurt von Schleicher as chancellor.
April 22, 1932: President Hindenburg announces
the establishment of a military dictatorship in Germany.
Hindenburg’s first act was to release the army upon the SA and the RFB. Of course, the organizations continued to function underground but membership was severely cut with mass arrests of members. In order to cripple the Communist Party, Ernst Thälmann, the party leader, was arrested and dragged before a court. Despite the lack of evidence, he was sentenced to 15 years of imprisonment for the organizing of political violence and for Hitler’s murder. For violence and the burning of the
Reichstag, a few top leaders of the National Socialists, including Goebbels himself were also sentenced to jail. To tackle the SA, its ruthless leader, Ernst Röhm was virtually bought by the Army. He was offered the position of a Mj.General with far-reaching benefits. Fearing a worse fate, he accepted, leaving the SA headless. Having lost Hitler, Goebbels and Röhm, the Nazi movement was paralyzed. The SA declined in numbers each month, and Göring had lost what little trust as party leader he had had. In September, Heinrich Himmler, who had taken over the remnant of the SA, left the movement and formed a new party; National Storm, and Strasser left with the left-wing faction and joined the newly formed Socialist National Front (SNF). Göring’s weak NSDAP now differed little from the other right-wing nationalist parties in the
Reichstag. Strasser however became a leading figure in the anti-democratic SNF, a party which included mostly former Nazis and nationalists, too socialist for the NSDAP, and socialists, too nationalist for the traditional Marxist parties.
In December 1932, the eighty-five year old president Hindenburg died, thus ending his military rule. The army was left in command as chancellor Schleicher remained the head of government without a head of state. The junta had managed to bring stability to Germany, but the economic problems were still unsolved. Unemployment had reached new heights and the socialist parties who gained enormous support, cried out for a change of social system. In the parliamentary polls as well as in the labour unions, support shifted from the Social Democrats (SPD) to the radical anti-democratic movements; the KPD, Strasser’s SNF and other minors.
The death of Hindenburg created a power vacuum in the government which seemed hard to fill. It was clear that there was no will, nor practicality in returning to full parliamentarianism, yet Schleicher understood he must keep some elements of democracy intact to keep the organised labour from initiating a general strike. Schleicher decided to step down, but keep the army in power with a political cabinet in reference to the elected
Reichstag. Thus in January 1933, elections were held, where, much to the army’s dissatisfaction, the KPD emerged as the victors with 26% of the votes. The political stalemate continued. The national-conservative
Reichswehr leaders could not have Göring form a government, since the NSDAP had dropped down to a minor party, as were the other right-wing parties. To have the KPD form a government seemed out of the question and the SDP refused to participate in a military government in a coalition with either right-wing parties or communists. The KPD was the strongest political movement in the country but they were far from having a parliamentary majority, and its leadership, still shaken after Thälmann’s imprisonment, was in no way able to seize power from the
Reichswehr in vanguard revolution.
The Strasser Cabinet
From Hindenburg’s death until March 1933, an unusual series of events took place that led to a revolutionary change in government. Some voices in the
Reichswehr leadership claimed that in order to keep the labour unions from striking, the KPD must enter government, under military surveillance to hinder it from staging a coup. Schleicher understood this but reluctantly dragged on. He continued hopeless negotiations for a possible majority government of the right-wing parties and the SPD. In January 1933, the Socialist People’s Front (SPF) was formed; a league of non-democratic socialist and communist movements in Germany including the KPD, the Socialist National Front and others (note: not a party but a coalition of parties and movements). The socialist nationalist and former associate of Hitler, Gregor Strasser hated the communists but when he was offered a future chancellorship, his resentment turned into cooperation.
The Socialist People’s Front was a well planned KPD strategy. The coalition had a wide range of supporters encompassing people who, previously would never had supported the communists. Second, it demonstrated to the army leadership that the KPD was ready to enter government in a coalition with other socialist parties, thus not only representing themselves and the mother party in Moscow. Schleicher finally gave in and entered negotiations with the SPF on the precedents that he himself would take on presidential duties. Many constitutional breeches had been made since the
Reichswehr took power in 1932 and this was only one of them. But by doing this, Schleicher was trying to slowly move back to constitutional legality without losing the army’s grip on government. By keeping the presidency for himself as an army representative, he could, according to the emergency laws still in effect since 1930, remove the government if he found it taking too drastic socialist measures. Elections were delayed until after the political crisis had been dealt with. Some democratic voices rejected heavily, but the events since 1930 had shown that the economic and political crisis would not be solved by elections. The new government was announced on February 2 1933 as General Schleicher became a non-elected head of state and Strasser, a former National Socialist, became Chancellor
General Kurt von Schleicher (left) was the army-backed head of state in
Gregor Strasser‘s (right) nationalistic-socialist government formed on february 2, 1933.
Offering chancellorship to the non-communist Strasser was a twofold strategy by the KPD. First, it appeased Schleicher who would never have let the KPD in government without having a nationalist non-communist as its head. Second, the idealist Strasser, knowing this was his only opportunity ever to gain such power gladly agreed to give the important posts of the defence and security ministers KPD members. The army was satisfied and withdrew from active government duties. The Strasser government lasted roughly a month, during which communists consolidated their grip on the security police and through the ministry of defence, incorporated RFB members and other loyal communists into the army and lower officer corps.