I'm afraid, General Mandrake, that you are completely wrong; the Grail, if it exists, should be destroyed (see reasons given earlier). And anyway, if we were to keep it, who should have it? How is it morally acceptable to allow the citizens of one country eternal life but no other? Is it morally right to prolong the lives of those in developed countries who will already live 5 times longer on average than those in other parts of the globe who could benefit more? How is it acceptable for one man, one government or one organisation to decide who lives and who dies based on their narrow moral outlook, that, with absolute power would surely tighten into authoritarianism? If we possessed the Grail, how could we prevent our country from becoming a theocracy governed by the bearer, where any act of non-conformity would end in the crushing of all that that person believed in? Was in not this wanton abuse of power that we went to war in Europe to prevent?
Now to many of you, this debate may seem frivolous, yet it is exactly the problem we could face in the years to come. How do we stop there being a bearer of absolute power in our society? It has happened before; in 1695, a small Massachusetts town gave absolute power to a group of young girls the power to condemn others to death. Salem is now famous for the injustices of its witch-trials (the fact that "God wills it", to quote General Mandrake, makes this analogy rather apt!) ((for those interested in further reading, I heartily recommend Arthur Miller's The Crucible, which looks at the witch-trials through the lens of McCarthy era America - but that hasn't happened yet...)) It continues to happen today, though at present we can be thankful it is restricted to the wealthy's grip over the lives of the poor, not a crazed murdering spree; yet it is foreseeable, that as America faces more serious threats abroad in the future, the government could seek to castigate a group of society seen to be un-American, and persecute them purely for their beliefs. We must act now to protect our citizens from persecution by misguided individuals onto whom immense power is bestowed.