i didn't save the PM, but Randakar was working with Davisx3m, and I think on night 3 he basically called out 4 guys that he thought were evil... and they all were.
i was rather impressed.
After I told Cymsdale that Euro was a scanned wolf and ordered him to switch his vote, there were a lot of signs that Cymsdale was evil. Starting with the fact that suddenly a lot of people jumped right on top of Euro for no apparent reason.
From that I surmised that *if* my hypothesis regarding cymsdale was correct we had a rather neat suspect list to gun for ..
(That being said, people jumping on Euro for no apparent reason that early in the game, especially if they are veterans, is already a sign of evilness imho ..
)
AVN and Cymsdale were both involved in Randakar's little wannabe JL. After AVN did both his outings, he got protected by BOTH doctors that night, giving us both those names.
Uh, according to the rules AVN could not have gotten those names *until the next day*. After his death, in other words.
We then later heard that Randakar had ordered Davis protected by the doctors.
So we knew he was probably important but not necessarily the Seer.
That was a tad of a gamble. AVN was looking pretty damn dodgy at that point, him being a cultist made a lot of sense, so I took a risk on Xarkan because of his behaviour in the thread.
Especially since a sorcerer was sitting on Davis the night before I felt it could not terribly hurt anymore. There was a good chance the wolves had pinged Davis because of his vote on Euro already, and I felt the chance of hooking him up with a doctor was more important than risking outing him even further.
Yeah, I was scared and paranoid beyond measure at that point. I panicked.
I scanned both you and the_hdk. I received Gigau's name from randakar, who also told me that Cymsdale was suspicious in his eyes (I don't understand then why randakar told Cymsdale that Davis had an important role).
I didn't.
Cymsdale gave me Xarkan, claiming Xarkan contacted Cymsdale out of the blue as the doctor who saved you that night.
I didn't trust Cymsdale. But Xarkan was another matter. Especially given that *any sensible seer* would have scanned Cymsdale ASAP.
Really, my main pitfall is just being too damn impulsive sometimes..
BTW I didn't know if Gigau and Cymsdale were packmates. I only knew Slinky.
Furthermore I received both names of the docs when I was saved (IMO not according the rules. They should have been given when/if I woke up).
Overall a very boring game for me and because it's nowadays very common for packs to neglect their cultists (BTW IMO a bad strategy) I have decided to skip all WW games in which the cultist doesn't get the names of all packmembers of the GM at the start of the game.
Good idea ;-)
