Writing with the StAARs: Judging Thread

[TekcoR]

Voting begins 5/8/11 at Midnight (GMT-6) and runs until 5/14/11 at Midnight (GMT-6). After 5/14/11, the votes will be tallied and winners announced.

Voting Criteria
Each voter gets three (3) votes.
Can only vote for one (1) AAR once.
Cannot vote for your own AAR [does not apply if you did not enter an AAR].
AAR with the most votes wins 1st place.
AAR with the second most votes wins 2nd place.
AAR with the 3rd most votes wins 3rd place.

The eligible After Action Reports are:

We Are Outnumbered - by Soulking
Arsenal of Righteousness - by BigBadBob
In the Shadow of the Iron Cross - by BigBadBob (2nd Entry)
Bloody Snow - A Finland AAR with WiF - by Hax
The countdown begins to destroy us all... - by Lighthearter
Teutonic Dreams - A Germany 1936 HPP - by TheBromgrev
Listening to Dönitz - a submarine-oriented Germany AAR - by umg
The Governator - A 'Hearts of Iron 3' Germany AAR - by Monnikje
Hordes of Evil: Italy WiF AAR - by Hax
The East AARfrican Union! - by Maldorians
The Star of New Orleans: A Louisiana AAR - by AllmyJames
Reversed Ways - by Aliasing
The Genghisid Imperial Family, A Golden Horde AAR - by Scholar
Penguin Classics: A History of the Vandals - by Alfred Packer
Always WAAR - A British Always War AAR - by TheCheeseMaster
Yin, Yang and the Ugly - by knul
Worst WritAAR: A Semi-Interactive AAR about how much I like other peoples money - by lordreaven448
It's Reigning Meatballs! - A Swedish AAR - by Badpojken
Republic of Russia: A Novogorod DW AAR - by Avindian
Hungary's Rise to Power - by EtzelHoveri
Duchy of Dioclea: it's a million-to-one chance, but it might just work! - by Cornelius Rex
Denmark - by olvirki[/QUOTE]

The Disqualified [CANNOT RECEIVE VOTES]:
I, Alexi - A Russian Modern AAR - by TemplarComander
Stalin Goes Commando - by KillerKlein
Југославија, Југославија! - A narrative YugoslAARv tale - by James Beli
A Tale of Two Central Americas by FireBlaze
North African Glory - A Morocco AAR - by Thandros
Workers of the World, UNITE! - The History of the CCP 1869-1935 - by Derahan
Kingdom of the Sleeping Tiger II: A Korean AAR - by Xanthippus
Legacy of Osman I, The Rise and Fall of the Ottoman Empire - by Derahan
God save our Island: An Irish WWM AAR - by Eire_Empire
Bread, Butter and Orange Jews: A Duchy of Khazars AAR - by Sylon

Correct Example on How to Vote
Bread, Butter and Orange Jews by Sylon
Denmark, 1836-1920 by glviriki
The Star of New Orleans: A Louisiana AAR by AllmyJames

Incorrect Example on How to Vote
The Star of New Orleans: A Louisiana AAR by AllmyJames
The Star of New Orleans: A Louisiana AAR by AllmyJames
The Star of New Orleans: A Louisiana AAR by AllmyJames

Any questions or needs for clarification please post in this thread or send me a private message.

 

[Aliasing]

I vote for: We Are Outnumbered by Soulking
(That's all I'm doing for now)

 

[Nikolai]

Links to the AARs in question would be nice.

 

[Nikolai]

I vote for: We Are Outnumbered by Soulking
(That's all I'm doing for now)

Voting doesn't start yet it seems. Why is that btw?

 

[TekcoR]

Voting doesn't start yet it seems. Why is that btw?

Gives people a chance to read the eligible AARs before voting on Sunday.

 

[Nikolai]

Gives people a chance to read the eligible AARs before voting on Sunday.

Ah, makes sense. Only lacks real links now. A lot of these I don't know and don't know where to look.

 

[Aliasing]

EARLY VOTE STILL STANDS
Either way I'm unavailable Friday, so it's enough

 

[TheCheeseMaster]

So anyone can vote now?

This thread needs to be more active guys.

 

[soulking]

NO!! the voting starts on Friday May 8th.

 

[TekcoR]

Voting begins May 8th (Sunday) ends May 14th (Friday). Votes before then will not be counted.

 

[cyberalien18]

Links to the AARs in question would be nice.

+1

 

[soulking]

List of eligible AAR's

We Are Outnumbered - by Soulking
Arsenal of Righteousness - by BigBadBob
In the Shadow of the Iron Cross - by BigBadBob (2nd Entry)
Bloody Snow - A Finland AAR with WiF - by Hax
The countdown begins to destroy us all... - by Lighthearter
Teutonic Dreams - A Germany 1936 HPP - by TheBromgrev
Listening to Dönitz - a submarine-oriented Germany AAR - by umg
The Governator - A 'Hearts of Iron 3' Germany AAR - by Monnikje
Hordes of Evil: Italy WiF AAR - by Hax
The East AARfrican Union! - by Maldorians
The Star of New Orleans: A Louisiana AAR - by AllmyJames
Reversed Ways - by Aliasing
The Genghisid Imperial Family, A Golden Horde AAR - by Scholar
Penguin Classics: A History of the Vandals - by Alfred Packer
Always WAAR - A British Always War AAR - by TheCheeseMaster
Yin, Yang and the Ugly - by knul
Worst WritAAR: A Semi-Interactive AAR about how much I like other peoples money - by lordreaven448
It's Reigning Meatballs! - A Swedish AAR - by Badpojken
Republic of Russia: A Novogorod DW AAR - by Avindian
Hungary's Rise to Power - by EtzelHoveri
Duchy of Dioclea: it's a million-to-one chance, but it might just work! - by Cornelius Rex

 

[TekcoR]

Thanks sir!

 

[Nikolai]

Great, thanks.

 

[olvirki]

I am a little puzzled here. I know that having all my chapters in a row was not enough (I made 15 posts to begin with that I could later edit), there were no comments between them. So in the old system I lost some points for that. But now my AAR cannot receive any votes but yet I am listed in the correct example on how to vote. So tell be, am I kicked out of the contest or not

Btw Tekcor, please take a quick look at my AAR. Was a table of contents really necessary ? I thought at first that I had made it unnecessary.

 

[olvirki]

Tekror, please awnser my question before Sunday. The question is in comment number 16, above thecheesmaster.

 

[TekcoR]

Olvirki, it was a mistake on my part. Apparently I cannot read my own handwriting on the list I made for disqualified/qualified. This has been fixed.

 

[olvirki]

Thank you ! Really, thank you !

 

[TheBromgrev]

Seriously guys, you feel that you have to actively advertise here, in the *VOTING* thread? Gee, I guess you guys haven't taken the "Secret Ballot" reform yet I'd recommend a moderator move all of these off-topic posts out of here, or TekcoR should make a new thread today so people can post their votes without being distracted.

 

[Aliasing]

Doesn't matter, just vote