Would HIP or EMF be compatible with this Map Generator?

[crabby654]

I absolutely love HIP but the default world map is getting a tad stale. I'm curious if anyone knows if HIP or the EMF module will work with http://ck2generator.com/ . The only reason I ask is because I'm not sure if all the modules affect map stuff (obviously SMWF does).

It looks like a really amazing map generator, but still with bugs to be worked out.

 

[HandicapdHippo]

EMF likely no, too much stuff probably depends on culture, religions and titles that wouldn't exist anymore.

 

[zijistark]

The main issue in EMF would just be the stuff that depends upon titles/regions. Would kill a lot of functionality even at best, but I'd guess EMF would crash with it too-- can't be sure, though. I don't know enough about the alt-history generator to know how well it'd work w/ the SWMH map, but in theory, it should be able to read any map definition to use for its history generation.

If that tool gets sufficiently popular [since I have a very soft spot in my heart for such projects] and mature, I will definitely evaluate what it would take to make a version of EMF (and SWMH map) which would work with it and strongly consider it.

EDIT: In fact, if the author is writing that in a language that doesn't annoy me, and it's on GitHub with submissions welcome, I'd consider contributing whatever's necessary to close the gap between being able to run it totally streamlined with EMF and SWMH.

 

[crabby654]

The main issue in EMF would just be the stuff that depends upon titles/regions. Would kill a lot of functionality even at best, but I'd guess EMF would crash with it too-- can't be sure, though. I don't know enough about the alt-history generator to know how well it'd work w/ the SWMH map, but in theory, it should be able to read any map definition to use for its history generation.

If that tool gets sufficiently popular [since I have a very soft spot in my heart for such projects] and mature, I will definitely evaluate what it would take to make a version of EMF (and SWMH map) which would work with it and strongly consider it.

EDIT: In fact, if the author is writing that in a language that doesn't annoy me, and it's on GitHub with submissions welcome, I'd consider contributing whatever's necessary to close the gap between being able to run it totally streamlined with EMF and SWMH.

Thats awesome to hear! I really do love a lot of EMF's core functions but ya like I said I'd like to try a non-vanilla map with at minimum EMF. Would be cool to hear if anything comes out of this map generator though