Claiming that westernization is materially more immersion killing than coalition mechanics, war score, or even the war leader concept is bogus, and vexing because you're essentially arguing against a mechanic that is put in place to make disadvantaged positions more competitive (while still markedly inferior overall) as the major source of immersion killing. I don't know your stance on other mechanics of course, but westernization in this capacity shouldn't be altered without also altering the game systems that surround it.
No No I agree that history can be broken, but to see it every single game is immersion breaking in terms of Europe not being dominant. ROTW didn't start to advance quickly until the Vicky 2 period, and the game should reflect that by being a higher possibility of Europe being dominant most times. Yes, say 1 times out of 5 a ROTW nation should break the mold. But it still falls down to the technology mechanic itself, it needs to be overhauled entirely in my opinion, it needs to change to suit ROTW better.
And yes I have strong opinions on those problems but I personally consider this issue to be on par with them.
And yes this event could easily be turned into some sort of decision where India gets a free claim on Goa if certain things are in place but thats it.
In 1444 Europe was well positioned to become the technological leaders and indeed dominate the world. But it was by no means inevitable. European dominance both in technological and other aspects occurred primarily as a result of events and decision made during the EUIV time period (along with a large helping of luck). For Europe to always end up dominant, regardless of what happens (barring direct player involvement), and with no real effort, is stupid.
Although I do agree - India shouldn't "westernise" by 1600. Because by 1600 there was very little about "the West" that India would've aspired to. Copying them at that time wouldn't have been "advancing". It was only well into the 17th century that European dominance came into being.
See above for my answer.
- 2
- 1