The argument that you shouldn't build a fleet that will die is silly. It means France shouldn't, Denmark OR Hansa shouldn't, Sweden shouldn't... It also ignores that IF they dow during hyw, and had a remotely reasonable fleet instead of their bugged landlocked cap nothingness, burg+france probably COULD sink the English. It ignores that they usually war france repeatedly, instead of the single-ever English fight for Calais, and they could obliterate France navy vs navy and not always have the big blue boats parked in their single useful sea zone, effectively nailing almost all of their ports because burgundy is too dumb to set sail.
It's also just the token obvious example. How many other nations start or end up with a landlocked cap and coastal land, but don't build ships?