Why are my robots producing less science than my normal pops?

  • We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

Haran

Private
Oct 28, 2017
23
7
I made intelligent robots hoping they can produce more research but turns out they don't. Specifically, the robots have a 55% bonus from "empire" (whatever that means?) while the normal pops have 85%. Why the difference?
 

Attachments

  • pop.jpg
    pop.jpg
    607,7 KB · Views: 0
  • robot.jpg
    robot.jpg
    589,7 KB · Views: 0
  • 1
Reactions:
Why the difference?

I notice the robot has stratum Robotic Servant instead of Specialist, even though the top part says it's a Full Citizen.

Might be a bug if you're paying Full Citizen upkeep but only getting slave-tier productivity.

I assume you have Droids but not Synths yet?
 
  • 2
Reactions:
I think that not being able to benefit from Happiness might be part of the answer.

Non-organic are worse because happiness.
which should not affect machines
but it does.
Happiness has no direct effect on pop output. Happiness affects stability, and stability affects output. You can see that both types of pop are benefiting from high stability.

I made intelligent robots hoping they can produce more research but turns out they don't. Specifically, the robots have a 55% bonus from "empire" (whatever that means?) while the normal pops have 85%. Why the difference?

The "empire" category of modifiers includes all of the tech-boosting techs (+20% x 3 per category, for 60% total) and presumably also some bonuses from traditions (ie +5% output to specialist pops, etc) but I'm not sure what the full list is. I'm also not sure how your robots could have only +55% since the techs add +60%, and that would mean they'd have to be suffering at least a -5% from somewhere. It'd be really nice if the tooltip broke down everything instead of lumping so much into "empire".
 
  • 3
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
I think the servant thing is a thing here. Some bonusses might not be applied to slaves and thus to robot servants.
 
Happiness has no direct effect on pop output. Happiness affects stability, and stability affects output. You can see that both types of pop are benefiting from high stability.



The "empire" category of modifiers includes all of the tech-boosting techs (+20% x 3 per category, for 60% total) and presumably also some bonuses from traditions (ie +5% output to specialist pops, etc) but I'm not sure what the full list is. I'm also not sure how your robots could have only +55% since the techs add +60%, and that would mean they'd have to be suffering at least a -5% from somewhere. It'd be really nice if the tooltip broke down everything instead of lumping so much into "empire".
You realize the final +20% is a pretty high-tier tech that comes WAY after droids, and often after synths, right? OP almost certainly only has +40% from techs, and the only reason I'm pretty confident it's that and not +20% is that there's no way you could push the other bonuses that high fast enough.

The actual problem is almost certainly that the robots are servants, not specialists, and are thus missing out on specialist bonuses. Some such bonuses:
  • +5%/+10% from Egalitarian/Fanatic Egalitarian
  • +10% from Meritocracy
  • +5% from Pursuit of Profit tradition
  • +25% from Clone Soldier Ascendant trait
  • +5% from Necrophage trait
  • +10% from Diverse Design modifier
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
Reactions:
The actual problem is almost certainly that the robots are servants, not specialists, and are thus missing out on specialist bonuses.

Yeah and he seems to have set them as Full Citizens, so being treated as servants appears to be a bug.
 
You realize the final +20% is a pretty high-tier tech that comes WAY after droids, and often after synths, right? OP almost certainly only has +40% from techs, and the only reason I'm pretty confident it's that and not +20% is that there's no way you could push the other bonuses that high fast enough.

The actual problem is almost certainly that the robots are servants, not specialists, and are thus missing out on specialist bonuses. Some such bonuses:
  • +5%/+10% from Egalitarian/Fanatic Egalitarian
  • +10% from Meritocracy
  • +5% from Pursuit of Profit tradition
  • +25% from Clone Soldier Ascendant trait
  • +5% from Necrophage trait
  • +10% from Diverse Design modifier
That's probably it. I have fanatic egalitarian +10, meritocracy +10 and creative collectives under the prosperity tradition +5. There's still another 5 missing, but it's probably another such bonus that only applies to specialists that are not robot servants. I don't know why they count as servants, the species is not set to servitude.
 
That's probably it. I have fanatic egalitarian +10, meritocracy +10 and creative collectives under the prosperity tradition +5. There's still another 5 missing, but it's probably another such bonus that only applies to specialists that are not robot servants. I don't know why they count as servants, the species is not set to servitude.
Maybe because they are droids? Can droids be full citizens?
I don't know, just guessing. Long time ago i have abandoned playing with robots. Maybe if they will start resettling themselves.