Siding with Germany - the above happens anyway, plus Poland is in the camp of the defeated Axis and likely gets smaller. And the war is longer, so even more people in Poland get killed.Seems like a total failure to me. Poland chose neither and ended up being invaded by both, had 15% of its population killed and was turned into a Russian puppet for 50 years anyway. If that was the result of a realistic foreign policy, I shudder to think what an unrealistic one would have precipitated...
Siding with Soviets in 1938-39 means it is likely, at this early historical point without any constraints for SU that doesnt have to manage a whole load of puppets, Poland ends up as 17th republic.
That the history was rather horrific doesnt mean it couldnt be worse.
Fifth /nitpick.German third column would have been significant in some areas