-
We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
You forgot to bold, gigau.
Vote Mr.G
Looks like the shoe is on the other foot now.
Vote Mr.G
Looks like the shoe is on the other foot now.
Oh please, you chose Boris over Morrell, killing a villager and saving a wolf. Chances are it was pure coincidence, but we still have to look into your case.
Guys, this is silly. If anyone is looking cleared right now, it's Mr. G. Voting your packmate at the start of day 1 is one thing, doing it while claiming to have seen him in a vision during the night is another thing entirely.
I agree.
Vote gigau
I agree.
Vote gigau
You were voting on day 1 for a wolf... and suddenly you switch off to a villager... and my vote makes no sense ?
On deadline, you seemingly want to go back to Morell... too late. And this is not suspect ?
Quoting you as Randakar is using this to make a case against me : what the hell are you talking about (missed that the other day) ?
I changed my vote twice : one for Morell when he was outed. The other was on first day to break a tie. And Snoop wasn't in the run up at that time. So either get your analysis right... or you are clever at making fake arguments to make villagers look bad.
And Randy, for using such posts to vote me, .... well, let's say you have been better at making analysis.
Oh, I have definitely been better at analysis. In fact, this attempt is half-assed at best. But for good reason.
You see: Your response is definitely instructive. As is the reaction of other people jumping on to you, given half a chance
Pray tell: Who do you believe to be the best suspect? And forget about Mr. G for a second - Yeah, he moved away from Morrell, but I don't think he's a good suspect at all. For two reasons:
1) His argument against Morell was very likely to get Morell killed. Or scanned, at the very least. He must have known that.
2) He moved back to Morell at the end of the day. Yes, I know that that was too late. But Occams Razor applies in cases like this 9 times out of 10: Which is more likely, a honest snipe failure, or some convoluted attempt to make himself look good?
The simplest explanation is that he just failed at sniping.
So: Mr. G isn't it. But who then? General Hannibal? Thandros? Nautilu?
You see: Your response is definitely instructive. As is the reaction of other people jumping on to you, given half a chance
Pray tell: Who do you believe to be the best suspect? And forget about Mr. G for a second - Yeah, he moved away from Morrell, but I don't think he's a good suspect at all. For two reasons:
1) His argument against Morell was very likely to get Morell killed. Or scanned, at the very least. He must have known that.
2) He moved back to Morell at the end of the day. Yes, I know that that was too late. But Occams Razor applies in cases like this 9 times out of 10: Which is more likely, a honest snipe failure, or some convoluted attempt to make himself look good?
The simplest explanation is that he just failed at sniping.
So: Mr. G isn't it. But who then? General Hannibal? Thandros? Nautilu?
Nautilu has been lynched and proven villager, so that's not it.
Thandros' record is lousy at best. Not sure what to make of him.
general_hannibal would be a lousy wolf after mouthing a lot against Najs and then Najs gets hunted. Being new, i'll give him some leeway for now.
But there are also you who is quite hell-bent on defending Mr G (sorry, but your point 2 isn't good enough... and i don't see how a day 1 excuse can get Morell killed being all random jokes and all), Kingepyon who make lousy accusations, the_hdk who is really silent without forgetting to vote, Rendap who is quite silent and possibly drunk enough to mistake a parity (but a lot of people do that nowadays).
Snoopdogg spoke for JL and outed a wolf, so he's got to be the most cleared of us all.
And regarding my reaction... that's not a good defense but : we've played quite a few games now. How many times have i been lynched for jump-reacting like this ? almost each and every game. Can't prevent it... feeling in danger blinds me and i react before thinking things through. I realise this doesn't exhonerate here, but think it through. You should have more to lynch me.
Thandros' record is lousy at best. Not sure what to make of him.
general_hannibal would be a lousy wolf after mouthing a lot against Najs and then Najs gets hunted. Being new, i'll give him some leeway for now.
But there are also you who is quite hell-bent on defending Mr G (sorry, but your point 2 isn't good enough... and i don't see how a day 1 excuse can get Morell killed being all random jokes and all), Kingepyon who make lousy accusations, the_hdk who is really silent without forgetting to vote, Rendap who is quite silent and possibly drunk enough to mistake a parity (but a lot of people do that nowadays).
Snoopdogg spoke for JL and outed a wolf, so he's got to be the most cleared of us all.
And regarding my reaction... that's not a good defense but : we've played quite a few games now. How many times have i been lynched for jump-reacting like this ? almost each and every game. Can't prevent it... feeling in danger blinds me and i react before thinking things through. I realise this doesn't exhonerate here, but think it through. You should have more to lynch me.
I forgot to add that i react like this mostly when i'm a villager... but you know that already.
Good. That's what I wanted to hear.
We'll have to agree to disagree on Mr. G right now. Honestly, if he's not a wolf he's bound to get hunted sooner or later. Probably sooner.
So let's not try to lynch him right away. Even if he looks suspicious (to you). We have better targets.
Unvote Gigau
Vote Thandros
There's newbie leeway, but that has to end somewhere.
We'll have to agree to disagree on Mr. G right now. Honestly, if he's not a wolf he's bound to get hunted sooner or later. Probably sooner.
So let's not try to lynch him right away. Even if he looks suspicious (to you). We have better targets.
Unvote Gigau
Vote Thandros
There's newbie leeway, but that has to end somewhere.
I don't think Mr. G has joked about his packmate being a wolf before. He's semi-cleared to my mind.
Vote Thandros.
I'd like a different candidate in the mix today.
Vote Thandros.
I'd like a different candidate in the mix today.
Vote Mr.G
Guys I'm no baddie if you want to win look somewhere else. No wait just Kill me if you really want to. In game Death is nothing next to In game Vindication
Guys I'm no baddie if you want to win look somewhere else. No wait just Kill me if you really want to. In game Death is nothing next to In game Vindication
Sorry, snoop on that particular post was a mt for boris. I got it right the second time, which would have been a better one to post.
Yes, you just happened to switch from Doombunny - the count at the time right when you voted doombunny:
To Boris, who was just pushed into a tie with Morrell, and who was also the only one you could vote for to help Morrell. The part that makes me suspicious is you decided to break the tie right away. At 3 hours remaining. Lots of time and no real reason to switch except that there was a tie. If you're a villager there's no reason to be jumpy about a tie at that length of time to the deadline. You, however, were quite quick to decide that the tie was bad and you chose Boris to lynch.
So now the coincidences start to line up. Did you just happen to be a villager whose votes were helping Morrell in every place you put them? Did you really think that tie needed to be broken 3 hours before deadline? In the 50% chance that you would have chosen a wolf in breaking that tie (because you did say the choice was random)
So you voted doombunny to tie him with morrell. Then you very quickly changed your vote, when doombunny was put out of the running, to boris who was the only one left in the running with Morrell. Too many coincidences, too little explanation. A random vote to break a tie changed from a vote that was helping a wolf, to a vote that was helping the same wolf.
Last edited:
What I find odd is that while gigau is defending for himself, Mr. G just writes a few words and randy and King argue for him. And this is what stands out to me:
randy, we both know people have been lynched for less than this and no-one really believes you unless you firmly state that it is an outing.
Unvote Mr. G
Vote randakar
You've always said you were bad at being a wolf. I think this qualifies as bad.
randakar said:
randy, we both know people have been lynched for less than this and no-one really believes you unless you firmly state that it is an outing.
Unvote Mr. G
Vote randakar
You've always said you were bad at being a wolf. I think this qualifies as bad.
I don't think I've said anything on Mr. G.
I also don't really agree with Randy's "clearing" of Mr. G either, but I don't think that's good enough of a reason to suspect him. Randy would be more willing to lynch his packmate, rather than protect him.
Unvote Mr.G Vote randakar
Don't try and run up the Innocent it will only lead to more trouble.
Don't try and run up the Innocent it will only lead to more trouble.