-
We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
So in your opinion, Bagricula is essentially an "obvious" cleared villager for posting a case, which in my opinion, is quite minor (note:without actually voting him!),
But:
I, who actually put my money where my mouth is and actually voted Dexander a few posts down (bringing Dex from 2-2 to 3-2) is a likely wolf? At least try to be consistent.
Votes can be switched. Cases can't be unsaid.
EDIT: And by your own admission you bandwagoned him based of Aedan's case. So, it's possible you thought Dex was done for either way.
I'm hesitating between Bagricula and k-59. I've been drinking and I'm going on a visit to a brewery so before things get too bad I will Vote k-59
Although I am unnerved by k-59 defending me, I honestly cannot square him as a wolf. The Day 1 and Day 2 votes against him from Dexander and then the lack of anything else suspicious on him in the voting record or posts, really leaves me with no way to see him as a wolf. If he is one, he'll have played a masterfully high-risk game, and one at a much higher level of play than I would expect from this pack's performance.
For Arrowfiend / Euro, there is very little to go on here. He is my current other suspect for a wolf. His only redeeming point is that he voted Madchemist very early on Day 1, which while possible suggests a level of wolf play inconsistent with his experience and inconsistent with the performance of this pack so far.
If not for the DutchGuy / Comm Cody thing, I would have continued to find Aedan most suspicious, but given that no Friend has stepped forward to deny his story, I'm pretty sure he is telling the truth. This doesn't wholly clear him, as the Friend could have made a mistake and there's little reason for him as a wolf not to play along, but it does make it much less likely that he is a wolf.
You, Tornadoli, are my other primary suspect. Your redeeming point in my eyes is your co-vote with Madchemist on Day 2 (IIRC).
Overall, it is hard for me to pin a particular individual as the most likely wolf, but it is relatively easy for me to say that Lord_D and k-59 are not wolves.
Going into a meeting. See you all in an hour or so.
Torn: 3
Bagricula (558)
k-59 (590)
Euro (Bagricula 582->609)
Bagricula: 2
Aedan (524)
Torn (586)
k-59: 1
Lord_D ( Aedan 545->Unvote 556->607)
Not-voting: 1
Dutchguy
3 hours, 20 minutes to deadline.
Bagricula (558)
k-59 (590)
Euro (Bagricula 582->609)
Bagricula: 2
Aedan (524)
Torn (586)
k-59: 1
Lord_D ( Aedan 545->Unvote 556->607)
Not-voting: 1
Dutchguy
3 hours, 20 minutes to deadline.
Not listening to you. Only Happycats. Cause he's smart, handsome, charming, just, strong and did I mention handsome. Oh, yes, yes I sure did, silly me, but you know... he is the man (cat) everyone wants to be like. Happycats for President!
(can I join instead of DG?)
At least k-59 made a unique case, you just parrot exactly what he says.
You keep babbling on about voting records, etc., but you ignore that I made a very critical vote on Dex yesterday. How can you seriously use Day 1 and Day 2 throwaway votes by Dexander on k-59 (none of which put k-59 in ANY danger whatsoever, and could have been orchestrated by wolves exactly to clear them later in the game), but totally and utterly ignore my crucial votes? Aedan is right, you pick and choose what to tell to suit your case.
Also, why do you think Comm Cody is cleared? This is a question for @k-59 as well by the way. At the end of yesterday, he was apparently the most likely packmate of Dexander, now he is cleared all of the sudden because of the aedan outing? I'm pretty sceptical why a friend would contact aedan to reveal his friend-mate tbh. Plus, why would you WANT a friend to step forward? Do you want them to be hunted or something? Why would a villager ask for a friend to step forward?
DG has already been outed as friend, him confirming it doesn't give any information to the wolf. It only allows us to test the truthfulness of Aedan claim.
If you read the read the thread you would see I am skeptical of Aedan's claim, but until more evidence is given it is best too assume the simplest case.
@DutchGuy , are you actually playing the game? We require your presence.
EDIT: And if you are wondering why I am not a wolf, that's simple. Euro was hunted the first night.
What were you expecting?
Let Daffius play, he'll sort this mess out in no time AND also the spam ends. Everybody wins...
I'm not subbing someone out who has not requested to or has not missed a vote. And if I do sub them out I'm using the sub list.
This is, of course, the right thing to do, even if it harms the game.
Edit: He shouldn't have been allowed to sub in the first place. Also, fyi, I don't think you are handsome anymore. Daffius out.
