Actually I'll continue to contribute now. Post counts for living players:
marty99: 125 (most active player award)
2kNikk: 100
Brovahkiin: 41
Kaetje: 26
happycats: 23 (subbed in for Skobie, near end of day 3)
Xarkan: 17
Suirantes: 16
My analysis on each player:
Marty: Lynched Wagon, very active, contributes constantly. One of my most cleared players. My only reservation up until now was his vote record, but that has been fixed.
2kNikk: Put a key vote on madchemist and put a vote on Wagon. My other most cleared player
Brovahkiin: Has acted suspicious, but was willing to die yesterday and kept his vote on Wagon when he could've sniped Xarkan. Only reason he wouldn't have tried that was if we somehow rolled up all three wolves yesterday, which I doubt. Decent post count, but I feel like a decent amount of those posts are him having to defend himself or being prompted to explain votes, although I can't really confirm that. All in all, there's better candidates. Sorry for still wanting to look at him earlier, wasn't thinking and I missed some stuff because my phone sucks.
Kaetje: Bad voting record. Only non-cleared players she has put votes on were marty (who I've already noted is someone who I consider to be about as close to cleared as one can be without a seer right now) and bro who is leaning to be a bad lynch right now. Also hasn't been active. Only things I remember seeing from her were votes, her defending herself, and reasons (excuses?) for being inactive. Have not seen much analysis from her at all. Also maybe I'm reading too much into this but post 947, she quoted Jonti saying he wouldn't make a three way tie and sounded sad about it. Was she maybe hoping to tie two villagers with Wagon to improve her chances of winning as a wolf? Even with losing Wagon the three way tie plus hunt would have brought us down to 5 players, two of whom would be wolves, which gives the wolves fair odds of winning if the village messes up.
Happycats/Skobie: Skobie had a good amount of activity when he was on (79 posts over 3 days) with a good amount of analysis and conversation and was also one of the first to move on madchemist at EURO's urging, which helps clear me somewhat. Since I've been on I'd like to think that I've been contributing as well as I can with discussion and analysis although I honestly haven't done much to clear myself.
Xarkan: Has been quiet, but that seems to be his MO, at least recently. Put the final vote on Wagon yesterday. There's a chance this could have been to sacrifice Wagon to stop both of them from being lynched, but I'm not convinced. The fact that Wagon was willing to put a vote down on him yesterday goes a long way to helping him out.
Suirantes: Super quiet. Almost nonexistent. Says it's due to school, but then he really should have asked for a sub. Ironically says inactives are the best targets and then votes brovahkiin, someone with twice the number of posts than him. Bad voting record over all. Yes MC put a vote on him day 1, but he was never in any real danger and it's a useful alibi vote.
Actually I concur with Xarkan. Sui and Kaetje are our best targets. Wait, guys. Maybe I'm looking too hard for something but look back at day 3.
792 to 801. Bro puts pressure on Kaetje and puts her and Ithvan into a 2-2 tie in 792. Five posts later Wagon responds and puts Ithvan ahead. Sui comes in just two posts later to put Ithvan even further ahead as Ithvan also swings to Kaetje soon after. It could be Wagon and Sui trying to protect Kaetje their packmate or it could be nothing. The biggest hole in this theory is that this all occurred seven hours before deadline, which makes it doubtful that the wolves were that worried about the votes as to do something so blatant. My only counter to this hole is that EURO's insistence on killing Ithvan gave them a good enough cover that they could get away with it. Posts below for reference:
EDITS: "I've honestly haven't". Ewwwww. Also changed Sui's analysis a little. When I said he "put a vote on Brovahkiin with twice the amount of votes than him", I meant "twice the amount of posts than him". Which makes a difference. Don't post while tired, folks.
marty99: 125 (most active player award)
2kNikk: 100
Brovahkiin: 41
Kaetje: 26
happycats: 23 (subbed in for Skobie, near end of day 3)
Xarkan: 17
Suirantes: 16
My analysis on each player:
Marty: Lynched Wagon, very active, contributes constantly. One of my most cleared players. My only reservation up until now was his vote record, but that has been fixed.
2kNikk: Put a key vote on madchemist and put a vote on Wagon. My other most cleared player
Brovahkiin: Has acted suspicious, but was willing to die yesterday and kept his vote on Wagon when he could've sniped Xarkan. Only reason he wouldn't have tried that was if we somehow rolled up all three wolves yesterday, which I doubt. Decent post count, but I feel like a decent amount of those posts are him having to defend himself or being prompted to explain votes, although I can't really confirm that. All in all, there's better candidates. Sorry for still wanting to look at him earlier, wasn't thinking and I missed some stuff because my phone sucks.
Kaetje: Bad voting record. Only non-cleared players she has put votes on were marty (who I've already noted is someone who I consider to be about as close to cleared as one can be without a seer right now) and bro who is leaning to be a bad lynch right now. Also hasn't been active. Only things I remember seeing from her were votes, her defending herself, and reasons (excuses?) for being inactive. Have not seen much analysis from her at all. Also maybe I'm reading too much into this but post 947, she quoted Jonti saying he wouldn't make a three way tie and sounded sad about it. Was she maybe hoping to tie two villagers with Wagon to improve her chances of winning as a wolf? Even with losing Wagon the three way tie plus hunt would have brought us down to 5 players, two of whom would be wolves, which gives the wolves fair odds of winning if the village messes up.
Happycats/Skobie: Skobie had a good amount of activity when he was on (79 posts over 3 days) with a good amount of analysis and conversation and was also one of the first to move on madchemist at EURO's urging, which helps clear me somewhat. Since I've been on I'd like to think that I've been contributing as well as I can with discussion and analysis although I honestly haven't done much to clear myself.
Xarkan: Has been quiet, but that seems to be his MO, at least recently. Put the final vote on Wagon yesterday. There's a chance this could have been to sacrifice Wagon to stop both of them from being lynched, but I'm not convinced. The fact that Wagon was willing to put a vote down on him yesterday goes a long way to helping him out.
Suirantes: Super quiet. Almost nonexistent. Says it's due to school, but then he really should have asked for a sub. Ironically says inactives are the best targets and then votes brovahkiin, someone with twice the number of posts than him. Bad voting record over all. Yes MC put a vote on him day 1, but he was never in any real danger and it's a useful alibi vote.
Actually I concur with Xarkan. Sui and Kaetje are our best targets. Wait, guys. Maybe I'm looking too hard for something but look back at day 3.
792 to 801. Bro puts pressure on Kaetje and puts her and Ithvan into a 2-2 tie in 792. Five posts later Wagon responds and puts Ithvan ahead. Sui comes in just two posts later to put Ithvan even further ahead as Ithvan also swings to Kaetje soon after. It could be Wagon and Sui trying to protect Kaetje their packmate or it could be nothing. The biggest hole in this theory is that this all occurred seven hours before deadline, which makes it doubtful that the wolves were that worried about the votes as to do something so blatant. My only counter to this hole is that EURO's insistence on killing Ithvan gave them a good enough cover that they could get away with it. Posts below for reference:
EDITS: "I've honestly haven't". Ewwwww. Also changed Sui's analysis a little. When I said he "put a vote on Brovahkiin with twice the amount of votes than him", I meant "twice the amount of posts than him". Which makes a difference. Don't post while tired, folks.
Last edited:
.png){kind=avatar}
