Werewolf Lite CCCLXIII: Ace Attorney

[EUROO7]

Why Najs?

Because he doesn't fit spectacularly with Wombat, but is still a possible wolf.

Knowing both their roles should give us insight into who the last wolf is. I say this feeling fairly certain that a wolf exists between them. If Wombat is the wolf, Marty needs lynching. If Najs, we look at whoever he fits with.

Lynching Marty AND Wombat is following a lead to its conclusion instead of investigating it carefully.

 

[aedan777]

Because he doesn't fit spectacularly with Wombat, but is still a possible wolf.

Knowing both their roles should give us insight into who the last wolf is. I say this feeling fairly certain that a wolf exists between them. If Wombat is the wolf, Marty needs lynching. If Najs, we look at whoever he fits with.

Lynching Marty AND Wombat is following a lead to its conclusion instead of investigating it carefully.

While true, I think following it to its conclusion isn't such a bad idea. Particularly since we have a tie currently, and not much time is left to the deadline to make a whole new tie, since voters might not be online. And I think a Marty/Wombat pack is the most likely eventuality at this time, more so than any other alternative. If it's partially wrong, at least by lynching both of them we end a potential distraction.

 

[marty99]

Not even remotely true in regards to me. I mentioned Tamius as a likely wolf, have repeatedly made commentary on possible wolves and unlikely wolves, and I did not mindlessly vote Deathbywombat, I gave clear reasoning for it.

Well of course you mentioned him as a likely wolf...there are only a handful of players who left who can reasonably be called suspects. But when you get to the crunch time of a game, someone being your third or fourth choice 'likely wolf' doesn't really matter. You can't clear him, because there is nothing to clear him. But you can completely leave him out of danger, and likewise he is doing the same to you

I felt your reasoning for voting wombat was essentially a hackneyed copy of what already been said. You know better than to just vote without any text, but there was little substance to it, IMO.

 

[aedan777]

Well of course you mentioned him as a likely wolf...there are only a handful of players who left who can reasonably be called suspects. But when you get to the crunch time of a game, someone being your third or fourth choice 'likely wolf' doesn't really matter. You can't clear him, because there is nothing to clear him. But you can completely leave him out of danger, and likewise he is doing the same to you

I felt your reasoning for voting wombat was essentially a hackneyed copy of what already been said. You know better than to just vote without any text, but there was little substance to it, IMO.

Well considering I'm advocating a tie between you and wombat, then if Tamius and I were wolves, I'd be in the position tomorrow of having Tamius as my 1st or second choice for wolf, which is significantly more dangerous. And my reason for voting Deathbywombat as based off the initial case against him, but also the added elements of his reaction to said case, which were more wolfish than villagerish in their idiot-bashing and sternness.

 

[EUROO7]

While true, I think following it to its conclusion isn't such a bad idea. Particularly since we have a tie currently, and not much time is left to the deadline to make a whole new tie, since voters might not be online. And I think a Marty/Wombat pack is the most likely eventuality at this time, more so than any other alternative. If it's partially wrong, at least by lynching both of them we end a potential distraction.

The prospect of being left alone in endgame with you after lynching villagers wombat and marty makes me hesitant to lynch both at the same time.

I'd hate for that to happen.

 

[Rovsea]

OK, this on needs some explanation. Suffice it to say that Marty looked at his role PM, scowled, and decided to make things interesting. He messaged the late Mr. Spockyt, saying that he was, indeed, the seer, and in so doing hit a streak of bad luck which I believe shall carry over to today. Obviously, Spockyt, not marty, was the seer, and marty is therefore more or less 100% confirmed wolf. I like to think that I learn from my mistakes, so this outing has been a bit later, as I have been available a bit later. For what it's worth, the Seer was more or less a dead man walking when Day 1 started, although this in no way excuses the JL's terrible play yesterday. Also, I have absolutely no idea what Wombats on, but I'd like some, because somehow he is assuming (?) that Gen. Marshall is in the JL. I think that this TIE is a fine idea, if we can have teh villagers online to make sure that, should there be any last minute hijinks, marty dies. Here is a PM regarding marty contacting our revered Seer.

Marty however, is either a wolf, or a massive, massive idiot.


"Hey, so I scanned you last night. Nothing special, I just haven't played with you before so I didn't think I'd be able to read you, and you're apparently a villager. I'm thinking of scanning Najs tonight as I don't think he'll be hunted soon. If you have any thoughts on what to do, keep me advised. Hopefully this can be the start of a wonderful collaboration!"

-Marty99


(I don't know how to quote in PM's.)

marty99, the Werewolf, will die Today​

 

[marty99]

I was wondering when this was gonna happen. Thank fuck.

Unvote wombat Vote Marty99

What were the fucking odds.

And by the way, you guys have never, ever, have succeeded in lynching me without a JL outing.

 

[Gen. Marshall]

Oh Marty.

That PM even *smells* forced

 

[Team Wombat]

Wow. I'm an idiot. A major, colossal idiot.

Unvote Najs
Vote Marty

 

[Gen. Marshall]

We should keep the votes where they are though. Let Marty decide if wombat's worth killing.

 

[EUROO7]

I say we tie both Wombat and Marty now.

 

[marty99]

Oh Marty.

That PM even *smells* forced

Nah. I mean that's easy to say in hindsight, but when you get a pm from the seer in Lite you don't tend to read that deeply. I had a 1/12 chance of being fucked, I knew that, and there are posts in my pack convo to prove that, and I hit the 8.33%. What're you gonna do.

I was actually thinking though, given Rovsea couldn't make it online at deadline yesterday, that there was a chance I could hunt him and maybe the evidence trail might end there. Or indeed, that Spocky failed to pass it on in the first place. But that would have been too incompetent even for this JL, as it turns out.

 

[tamius23]

We should keep the votes where they are though. Let Marty decide if wombat's worth killing.

Regardless of whether wombat's his packmate, Marty wouldn't choose to kill him.

 

[aedan777]

I say we tie both Wombat and Marty now.

Seconded.

 

[Gen. Marshall]

Nah. I mean that's easy to say in hindsight, but when you get a pm from the seer in Lite you don't tend to read that deeply. I had a 1/12 chance of being fucked, I knew that, and there are posts in my pack convo to prove that, and I hit the 8.33%. What're you gonna do.

Yeah, it may have been a viable strategy, I was just amazed at how you typed up that seer PM xD

Regardless of whether wombat's his packmate, Marty wouldn't choose to kill him.

Then that's fine.

 

[Audren]

And by the way, you guys have never, ever, have succeeded in lynching me without a JL outing.

marty99 (Hobbit) was lynched by the hobbits.

*ahem*

UNVOTE MARTY
VOTE MARTY

 

[aedan777]

*ahem*

UNVOTE MARTY
VOTE MARTY

Marty thinks he's only impossible to lynch as a baddie.

 

[Gen. Marshall]

Marty thinks he's only impossible to lynch as a baddie.

I just thought of an amazing way to test if marty's a baddie

 

[Rovsea]

*ahem*

UNVOTE MARTY
VOTE MARTY

I think there was meant to be a "would" in there. Also, I agree that a DBW/marty TIE is a good idea, although possibly that's just me not wanting to die.

 

[tamius23]

*ahem*

UNVOTE MARTY
VOTE MARTY

"You've never succeeded in lynching me without an outing." = "Please lynch me more often."