this post has been destroyed, sorry, i didnt think that me saying that would effect anything.
Last edited:
-
We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Xaldin, Now that you are dead (a ghost) you shouldn't tell us living players that kind of information. And you should post in color like this.
Indeed - Xaldin, please edit your post and use color.
I have let Cakravarti's haunting comments slide, but this is just past the line.
1. the_hdk
2. Steed as Mongo
3. Johho888 as Zeb Macahan
4. Snoopdogg as a Banker from the Oregon Trail
5. Telesien as Sam Hawkins
6. Randakar SUBBED by Falc2
7. Nautilu
So, we have the magnificent 7 left..
Boris, Paendrags votes might point to the last Red if we are lucky.. Time to scan the list again.
2. Steed as Mongo
3. Johho888 as Zeb Macahan
4. Snoopdogg as a Banker from the Oregon Trail
5. Telesien as Sam Hawkins
6. Randakar SUBBED by Falc2
7. Nautilu
So, we have the magnificent 7 left..
Boris, Paendrags votes might point to the last Red if we are lucky.. Time to scan the list again.
So 7 left with likely 3 baddies? That doesn't add up, since we lost three baddies last turn. With ten people we had to have no more than 4 baddies, which means only one is left. Or correct me if I am wrong.
yeah I though I read that too. if 3 are left what are they? is there an unaccounted hunt there?
True, but they can't be here, otherwise we would have already lost, wouldn't we?
As we are in the End Game, I kindly ask all ghosts to refrain from any comments that MIGHT be used for information.
Feel free to haunt and taunt - But no information please, including anything that might or might not be public knowledge.
I'd like to give both sides as big a chance of winning this as I possibly can.
Daeg - Could you please moderate your latest post in this light? Thanks.
Feel free to haunt and taunt - But no information please, including anything that might or might not be public knowledge.
I'd like to give both sides as big a chance of winning this as I possibly can.
Daeg - Could you please moderate your latest post in this light? Thanks.
By letting the Settlers play this out without any other information that what can be analysed from the thread....
Ghost Comments is not part of that...
Think this is where Deag turned?
Xaldin is in black as was pretty much redundant.
Last edited:
1. the_hdk
2. Steed as Normal Goodie
3. Johho888 as Zeb Hunter
4. Snoopdogg as a Hunter (Pretty much say hes no Red)
5. Telesien as Sam Hawkins
6. Randakar SUBBED by Falc2
7. Nautilu
2. Steed as Normal Goodie
3. Johho888 as Zeb Hunter
4. Snoopdogg as a Hunter (Pretty much say hes no Red)
5. Telesien as Sam Hawkins
6. Randakar SUBBED by Falc2
7. Nautilu
This has turned out surprisingly well for such a disastrous start. I'm glad I signed up.
Speak for yourself mate, this game wasnt any fun for me...
Will no one get rid of those bastards Johho and Nautilu for me? Wolfies?
the_hdk =>unknown
Steed => rival to the GA
Johho888 => hunter
Snoopdogg => hunter
Telesien => unknown
RandakarFalc => me
Nautilu => rival to the Seer
So...
I cannot imagine making wolves the rivals of of important goodies. So Steed and Nautilu are out as possible wolves and as possible attached-from-the-start cultists. Cultists, yes, possibly. That does mean the only way they might have attached themselves to a pack is after Boris' public request for contact, in which case they're red pack. But red pack can't be 4 people big since we're still playing...
Hunter wolves? Okay, I find that a bit less unlikely. It's a bit like Brutal, after all.
My conclusion?
The missing wolf is either hdk or Telesien.
If both packs started with 4 wolves, then johho and snoopdogg are both also wolves.
We should lynch hdk AND telesien to be certain.
Yes, that is quite risky. If I miscounted, we end up with 4 people and it's enough that red pack has two people left for them to win.
Steed => rival to the GA
Johho888 => hunter
Snoopdogg => hunter
Telesien => unknown
Nautilu => rival to the Seer
So...
I cannot imagine making wolves the rivals of of important goodies. So Steed and Nautilu are out as possible wolves and as possible attached-from-the-start cultists. Cultists, yes, possibly. That does mean the only way they might have attached themselves to a pack is after Boris' public request for contact, in which case they're red pack. But red pack can't be 4 people big since we're still playing...
Hunter wolves? Okay, I find that a bit less unlikely. It's a bit like Brutal, after all.
My conclusion?
The missing wolf is either hdk or Telesien.
If both packs started with 4 wolves, then johho and snoopdogg are both also wolves.
We should lynch hdk AND telesien to be certain.
Yes, that is quite risky. If I miscounted, we end up with 4 people and it's enough that red pack has two people left for them to win.
the_hdk - throw away two days ago (Boris vs tamius), voted Boris yesterday but could be a sell-out - Possible Red
Steed was very vocal in getting Boris lynched, probably more so than necessary for an alibi vote, rival of GA so IMO unlikely wolf - I think he is good.
johho888 - thought Boris was a goodie, was voted by Slinky the Red, a wolf hunter, isn't that unlikely? - I know I'm good but can you?
snoopdogg - the only surviving Boris voter from day before yesterday, voted Boris again yesterday, a wolf hunter, isn't that unlikely? - My guess is he is not a Red and not a wolf
telesien - hard to talk into voting any of the baddies yesterday, asks very newbielike questions, wouldn't his packmates help him if he had any? - My gut feeling says goodie
Falc2/randakar - voted Deagh against gigau with Paen and Boris - would the Reds pile all votes on the same guy in a race where they had no contestant? voted Xaldin to possibly save Boris yesterday - possible Red IMO
Nautilu - rival of the seer, wouldn't that make him an unlikely wolf? voted Xaldin to possibly save Boris yesterday. Voted tamius over Boris - possibly Red but in that case a cultist
I think the_hdk and Falc2 are the most likely Red wolves.
Today 7 players. Assuming 1 red wolf, 1 red cultist and 1 yellow. 3 baddies out of 7 players < 50% -> no parity.
Yesterday with the same assumptions there were 2 red wolves + 1 red cultist + 1 sorcerer + 1 yellow wolf + 1 yellow cultist = 6 baddies of 10 players > 50% BUT since there were more than one pack left, parity rules don't apply. One pack needs to eliminate the other pack before parity is reached.