Shouldn't this whole discussion be in the WW planning thread? Discussing the specifics of some of these questions here could end up giving away information that might directly impact the game. IMO, a more generalized discussion on these topics would be better pursued in the other thread.
Since no roles had been send out at that point, discussing specific traits or roles is pretty much fair game as far as I'm concerned. Except for "how much of this stuff is in the game", of course.
Especially considering that ww general discussion threads don't really help if the next GM didn't read them.
IMO, too much meta information that your characters would have no way of knowing would have a negative effect on the game.
I hope you find this reasoning acceptable.
Oh, I don't want you to tell us how much of anything is in the game at all. I just want to make sure that these rules don't contain all of the old well-known defects.
Why discuss the rules now when you can moan about them after they've been finalised? You guys...
Because the flaws in the rules annoy me, and I'd like to see them fixed up front rather than moan about it afterwards and see the next GM ignore the complaints completely.
I'd offer my opinion on the rules, but I don't think 'remove the GA, doctor and seer, make four villagers hunters and the packs slightly smaller to compensate' would be popular.
I'm sure such a game would be terrific fun
- Pack setup will be done following the White Daimon School of Thought, Randy.
Now that is both intriguing and heartening
Getting a Doc save on someone right now is worse then a Guardian Angel save.
I like the learn an attacking wolf, it was basically what the Doctor gave up in a trade off. That why the person could not vote or pm or take any actions. Now the Guardian Angel make the Doctor look like a joke.
Different power levels between traits: Not a problem.
Overpowered justice leagues: A problem.
So, to quote EUROO7: Suck it
Don't I always?
.. said the snake
Deadline Night 0 20:00 EST 24:00 GMT
Right. I'm definitely not going to be around then.
To my fellow shapeshifters. I've got a favour to ask. Please do hunt Randakar so he can go to where he belongs.
.. err. What? Why?
Vote Randy
If we can t get the wolves to hunt him we can always just lynch him!
Ah

The Resistance people want me in their game, of course. I told them I won't play both games at once .. so .. here they are
So he rather have his resistance game.... very well. Noted
Actually, I told them that if they dare arrange to hunt me night 0 I will sub back in to get back at them. Just for the record
(You aren't supposed to talk about The Resistance AT ALL outside of the proper thread. We're setting a bad precedent by even acknowledging that it exists.)
No such restriction exists for people who aren't even playing that, though
Fixed
Of course the Priest/GA/wolf of the
other pack might disagree...
No worries, as your resident seer/priest/cultist/padre/lover/hunter/thief I have no problems killing you both to restore balance to the force.
