Werewolf CXLI: The Eurovision Song Contest

[reis91]

You're shifting the goalposts, though. An invisible smoke field would be disguised perfectly. It wouldn't cover anything, though

 

[EUROO7]

You're shifting the goalposts, though. An invisible smoke field would be disguised perfectly. It wouldn't cover anything, though

Do you have a goatee?

 

[esemesas]

My reasoning being that denoting that the werewolf killed was part of "Pack A" then there is probably at least one other pack with at least one other person, the fact that he was third in command say there was at least two other werewolves in his pack, making the at least total come to three. It's not inside knowledge, it's just intuition.

Is this his first game or can we go lynch him now?

 

[Cliges]

You're shifting the goalposts, though. An invisible smoke field would be disguised perfectly. It wouldn't cover anything, though

Yeah, but if you were trying to hide invisible smoke, visible smoke would work. Now, you can't see that which is invisible in the first place-but the visible would hide it anyhow. On the other hand, if you tried to disguise the visible with something invisible, it won't work.

 

[johho888]

My reasoning being that denoting that the werewolf killed was part of "Pack A" then there is probably at least one other pack with at least one other person, the fact that he was third in command say there was at least two other werewolves in his pack, making the at least total come to three. It's not inside knowledge, it's just intuition.

"Third in command" is a trait that any player can have, it doesn't mean that there are three wolves in a pack. For example the leader (1st in command) could be a villager, the 2nd in command a cultist and the 3rd in command a wolf etc.

Is this his first game or can we go lynch him now?

I never seen him in a Big game before. Doesn't mean we can't lynch him now though.

 

[Falc]

My reasoning being that denoting that the werewolf killed was part of "Pack A" then there is probably at least one other pack with at least one other person, the fact that he was third in command say there was at least two other werewolves in his pack, making the at least total come to three. It's not inside knowledge, it's just intuition.

Ah, I see the flaw in your reasoning.

See, 'Third in command' is not something internal to the pack. Those traits are spread out over all the players.

Typically, you'll find a Leader Villager, then second and third in command in the packs, 4th in command back in the village.

As we can tell from last night's hunt, there is probably a pack B and while pack A got the first hunt, we can assume pack B got the second in command.


UNVOTE JACK

You're getting the newbie benefit of the doubt.

 

[Adamus]

Vote The Split

not voting in a game with this many players is just plain wrong. Should be auto lynched. Ill give the newer players the benefit of a second chance.

 

[jpr123]

Vote THE_SPLIT

 

[Valhallas Call]

Vote The_Split

not voting in a game with this many players is just plain wrong. Should be auto lynched. Ill give the newer players the benefit of a second chance.

Yeeaaaaahh I'm really sorry, I had a very busy weekend and I forgot about this thread. :sad: Here is some more Epic Sax Guy to make up for it!

 

[reis91]

voting Zombiesplit seems good enough to me.

vote ZombieSplit

 

[Falc]

Guys, voting a zombie is nice and all but this is the sort of bandwagon that doesn't give a lot of substance to go on for analysis later on...

 

[jpr123]

Well if you have any better ideas about who we should be lynching we would love to hear them!

 

[tamius23]

Votecount, 3 hours 7 minutes to deadline

SPLIT (5) - Citizen, Adamus, jpr, Valhalla's Call, reis
walrus (4) - ese, Cliges, RepBentley, Jack118

Not voted: Salik, SPLIT, johho, The Super Pope, walrus, Falc
Missed one vote: Salik, SPLIT, Valhalla's Call
In line for autolynching if they miss today's vote: Salik, SPLIT

 

[The Super Pope]

Vote Citizen

If it turns out Split is a wolf, Citizen is the one who saved hime

 

[reis91]

Guys, voting a zombie is nice and all but this is the sort of bandwagon that doesn't give a lot of substance to go on for analysis later on...

Hardly a runaway bandwagon with walrus in contention now, is it?

@ Superpope : Know something we don't?

 

[The Super Pope]

Hardly a runaway bandwagon with walrus in contention now, is it?

@ Superpope : Know something we don't?

By breaking the tie, Citizen saved Split. Also, it seems enough people are voting Split and Walrus, so I figured Citizen wasn't a bad call

 

[Cliges]

But citizen was also the first to vote the split for the current vote.

 

[reis91]

Which is something he might do as a packmate, knowing Split might be autolynched.

 

[Falc]

Which is something he might do as a packmate, knowing Split might be autolynched.

Ah but Citizen voted Split in #171 while Split only asked for his sub in #173 and Tamius announcing the possible autolynch in #174. So unless Citizen can see the future, this argument holds no water.

Also

VOTE WALRUS

We need more votecounts so I don't have to rely as much on my memory.

 

[esemesas]

Unvote walrus
Vote Falc

I reckon this gives the most info and I feel a little less bad if SPLIT gets lynched normally.