Werewolf CXCVIII - Purgatorio OR: Make Werewolf Great Again

[The Super Pope]

Hmm.... Have some coloured voting.

Oil Company
Villagers
Goodies

Spoiler: Night 1/Day 1/Night 2

The wolves Hunt Jacksonian Missionary, The Hunter.

Gorgan: 5
Johho888 [341]
Yakman [323 wombat -> 362]
Hazbot [368]
Sleepyhead [342 JCan -> 382]
Npstr [344 Cliges -> 386]

kai: 5[/COLOR]
Cliges [324]
Hax [343]
K-59 [358]
Madchemist [326 Health -> 374]
LatinKaiser [302 alxeu -> 354 JCan -> 377]

Hazbot: 3
Alxeu [308]
Eternaly_Lost [338]
AVN [333 LK -> 356]

LK: 2
De Chatillon [305]
Rovsea [337]

aedan: 2
Tamius23 [347]
Gen. Marshall [336 Gorgan -> 385]

JCan: 1
Ithvan [340]

Health: 1
Audren [335]

Hax: 1
Daird [309]

daird: 1
Comm Cody [311]

E_L: 1
Aedan777 [313]

k-59: 1
DeathbyWombat [322]

Aziz: 1
Health [329]

AVN: 1
The Super Pope [334]

MC: 1
JCan [339]

Ithvan: 1
Wagonlitz [359]

Marshall trid voting Gorgan in 388, but deadline had passed.[/COLOR]

Not voted: 7
Delta21 []
Ultikana Re []
Kaisersohaib []
RepBentley []
Gorganslayer []
Emperor Ike []
Al-Aziz []

You lynch Gorganslayer the Cursed Villager
You lynch Kaisersohaib the Village Council member (villager) (I cannot get rid of the formatting here iunno why)[/COLOR]
The wolves hunt tamius23 the Brutal Priest's Apprentice

Spoiler: Day 2/Night 3

Pre self-outing of E_L
E_L: 5
Health [525]
The Super Pope [520 Marshall -> 534]
LatinKaiser [544]
De Chatillon [538 Bentley -> 548]
Audren [578]

delta: 5
Madchemist [454]
Al-Aziz [485]
Npstr [509 Utica -> 554]
Daird [556]
RepBentley [586 E_L -> 591]

Ultikana: 5
AVN [507]
Hazbot [517]
Delta21 [425 Wagon -> 434 unvote -> 563 Utica -> 572 unvote -> 575]
Gen. Marshall [438 delta -> 580]
Wagonlitz [528 Hazbot -> 590]

Bentley: 4
DeathbyWombat [489]
Aedan777 [503]
Yakman [508 Marshall -> 540]
Eternaly_Lost [512 Utica -> 541]
LK: 3
Cliges [472]
Sleepyhead [516]
Hax [458 Ithvan -> 515]

Wagon: 3
K-59 [418]
Comm Cody [457]
Ithvan [552]
Chat: 1
Emperor Ike [440]

alxeu: 1
Johho888 [531]

Cody tried voting Hazbot in 529, but he was already voting Wagon

Not voted: 4
Alxeu []
Rovsea []
JCan []
Ultikana Re []


Post self-outing of one of the Beard Twins.
E_L: 13
Health [525]
The Super Pope [520 Marshall -> 534]
LatinKaiser [544]
De Chatillon [538 Bentley -> 548]
Audren [578]
Delta21 [425 Wagon -> 434 unvote -> 563 Utica -> 572 unvote -> 575 Utica -> 596]
RepBentley [586 E_L -> 591 delta -> 597]
Wagonlitz [528 Hazbot -> 590 Utica -> 598]
Johho888 [531 alxeu -> 599]
Hax [458 Ithvan -> 515 LK -> 600]
Gen. Marshall [438 delta -> 580 Utica -> 601]
Aedan777 [503 Bentley -> 605]
Ithvan [552 Wagon -> 608]

delta: 4
Madchemist [454]
Al-Aziz [485]
Npstr [509 Utica -> 554]
Daird [556]

Ultikana: 3
AVN [507]
Hazbot [517]
Eternaly_Lost [512 Utica -> 541 Bentley -> 593]

Bentley: 2
DeathbyWombat [489]
Yakman [508 Marshall -> 540]

LK: 2
Cliges [472]
Sleepyhead [516]

Wagon: 2
K-59 [418]
Comm Cody [457]

Chat: 1
Emperor Ike [440]

Cody tried voting Hazbot in 529, but he was already voting Wagon

Not voted: 4
Alxeu []
Rovsea []
JCan []
Ultikana Re []


You lynch Eternaly_Lost, the Spying High-Sorcerer's Apprentice.
The wolves hunt Ithvan...
...the High-Sorcerer.
JermanTK is now subbing for Alxeu. Working on getting one for @Ultikana Re.

Hmm... Not much to go on. @Rovsea and @JCan Could you explain why you chose not to vote?

Its interesting when you look at the placement of those votes pre-outing, momentum was clearly moving away from E_L to Ulti, which makes his self-outing seem especially stupid. I think Marshall and Wagon's votes are especially interesting, coming in rapid succession and moving Ulti into a tie, and with every chance of lynching him whilst saving E_L. As I said yesterday, I don't see an especially strong case on Ulti, so why did they move him up towards the end of the day's voting?

Vote Wagonlitz

 

[Gen. Marshall]

I don't see an especially strong case on Ulti, so why did they move him up towards the end of the day's voting?

He refuses to even visit the forum after signing up for the first time and I'll vote for him again if there's no replacement.

Also, your case is bollocks. There's no reason to think that the High Sorc would have been in contact with any baddies and IIRC you've been tunneling on Wagon yesterday as well.

 

[The Super Pope]

^ Even if the wolves did not know E_L was on their side, I still think this effort to lynch a newbie on day 2 is insightful

 

[The Super Pope]

He refuses to even visit the forum after signing up for the first time and I'll vote for him again if there's no replacement.

Also, your case is bollocks. There's no reason to think that the High Sorc would have been in contact with any baddies and IIRC you've been tunneling on Wagon yesterday as well.

If he doesn't, let him be auto-lynched and someone else sub.
How defensive Marshall? I don't believe I mentioned Wagon at all yesterday. I certainly didn't vote him at any point

 

[Gen. Marshall]

If he doesn't, let him be auto-lynched and someone else sub.
How defensive Marshall? I don't believe I mentioned Wagon at all yesterday. I certainly didn't vote him at any point

Oh. Yeah, I think I mixed you up with someone.

However, I'm not keen on waiting for inactives to be auto-lynched. If a sub shows up tomorrow we've missed a full three days of analysis on a player who - if he's a wolf - will likely stick around until the endgame.

 

[Audren]

Thank you to Madchemist for digging up the other post from Marshall that struck me as odd. He seemed awfully and uncharacteristically hostile towards Ultikana, on top of his strange spat with Yakman. I couldn't vote him yesterday, but I still find him a suitable candidate today.

VOTE MARSHALL

 

[AVN]

He refuses to even visit the forum after signing up for the first time and I'll vote for him again if there's no replacement.

Agreed. Non voters are bad for analyzing.

Also, your case is bollocks. There's no reason to think that the High Sorc would have been in contact with any baddies and IIRC you've been tunneling on Wagon yesterday as well.

I agree that Wagonlitz most likely wasn't in contact with the sorcerer. But is it possible that he wanted to save one of the other vote leaders at that moment? I'm thinking of Bentley or Delta.

 

[Health]

Well considering that it is Day 3, we might have to throw away the newbie protections. @npstr What do you have to say to defend your previous actions?

 

[npstr]

Your attempt at building my case lacks any foundation.

 

[Health]

I was asking you to explain your votes and behavior, which considering that you are new can be considered newbish instead of wolfish. However taking a leaf from EURO's Book of Defenses is also fine.

 

[De Chatillôn]

As for today, I will

Vote De Chatillon

My suspicions of delta haven't really abated any, and LK is a likely baddie by probability, so if anyone else feels like running up either one I'm more than fine with that. DC has simply been far quieter than usual, at least to my reckoning, so I'll throw something his way and await further developments.

Nonsense. You know I can write even more as a wolf than as a villager.

 

[npstr]

Dude, you have to do your research. I explained my actions and I don't make an habit of quoting myself. If you want more from me I expect a solid case first.

 

[johho888]

However, I'm not keen on waiting for inactives to be auto-lynched. If a sub shows up tomorrow we've missed a full three days of analysis on a player who - if he's a wolf - will likely stick around until the endgame.

Yeah, so

vote Ultimus Zombius

 

[The Super Pope]

Yeah, so

vote Ultimus Zombius

Will he not be auto-lynched tonight anyway? It'll be three missed votes

 

[npstr]

I feel we have better cases than voting an inactive, which is probably getting subbed.

 

[The Super Pope]

I feel we have better cases than voting an inactive, which is probably getting subbed.

I agree. There's a case made above that if let Ulti go that he'll get subbed and escape longer if he is a wolf. On the flipside, if we bandwagon him today, its an entire day of voting wasted on an inactive player, and it will tell us nothing, just giving the wolves another chance to hunt without eating one of their own

 

[Health]

Dude, you have to do your research. I explained my actions and I don't make an habit of quoting myself. If you want more from me I expect a solid case first.

So you want a case against you? Fine, your posts don't contribute much, though that is to be expected of somebody playing the game for the first time, but you are damn well acting like you are perfectly innocent and that others need to prove that you are a wolf. First lesson, Everybody but confirmed non-wolves, and even then they are to be thought to be suspicious, and yourself are possible wolves. This is a game of paranoia and you acting like you are to be though of as clean is either pointing to a wolf or somebody that feels really comfortable in their position due to that position being a supposed goodie.

I approve voting based on signup numbers.

Vote Cliges

for flying only half as high as me.

Ties are great.

Unvote Cliges
Vote Gorgon

I'm new to the forum and attached an image instead putting the link in it. I corrected that mistake right away. The vote has not been changed and wouldn't make any sense since the picture says I love ties and my vote did make a tie.

I thought editing a vote was bad practice (which I didn't), not a post. My apologies for causing some trouble.

I definitely did make myself suspect as fuck.

My plan wasn't to make that tie in the last minute, some minutes earlier. The graphics programm just needed way longer to get going than I thought, and having that picture in my post seemed most important to me. Although I would love to be treated as an equal without any fledgling bonus, I have to admit that I did not even think about the consequences auf voting a tie in the last minute. Lesson learned (and get faster software ).

A day one vote with not much reasoning is to be expected unless something like the horrible event in the Big by Daffius, which ended up giving up nearly a full wolf pack, it is weird how the village still lost that game but understandable due to there not being many avenues of attack left on suspicious characters. However a TIE on Day 1 is often unreasonable, all that I see to defend it is that, "I want to be treated equally and without the newbie defense, but well this rule of politeness exists, so I am not going to bother to defend myself, with a proper reason, rather blame it on Software." - Wolfish, maybe not, but damn well worth looking into.

Vote Ultikana Re

I don't think God belongs into Purgatory, especially one that seems to be in hibernation.

On the other hand, it's now easy for the baddies to set me up as a future lynch target.

Sounds compelling. Lets keep another suspect in the race.

unvote Ultikana
vote Delta

Now on Day 2 you choose to ignore the self-outing despite being on during it and instead choose to vote for Delta, who is another case entirely and deserves to be looked at decently as well, away from a semi-RP vote on an inactive player. Not much to go on from there as well.

So what did I get from your posts that actually seem to matter is a lot of bravado and foolish moves, which make me question whether or not you are a wolf. Now I can not say it with certainty, but considering how defensive you got when I asked you to defend your actions and considering that you are new, but you do seem wolfish.

With that in mind, would you mind explaining your actions, I'll stop voting you if a better case should come along or if your explanation seems satisfactory as there is not a lot here.

VOTE NPSTR

 

[Health]

Oh, yeah I forgot I was a cat girl.

 

[The Super Pope]

Further to what @Health says, when I mentioned in passing that I think npstr is wolfy while voting for someone else he responded:

On the other hand, it's now easy for the baddies to set me up as a future lynch target.

Maybe there is a benefit of the doubt to a new guy with the editing shenanigans, but he is certainly defensive. Attempting to frame future investigation as a wolfish trick though?

 

[Health]

Also as long as it is relatively quiet. Wasn't @EUROO7 supposed to run this game or did something catch up to him in real life?