"Never trust anyone" is so boring and frankly detrimental. People often tell the truth even when they are working against you. And making assumptions about whether or not you can trust or predict others is an important part of the werewolf finding process.
But you should always distrust everyone. How is that different you ask? Never trusting anyone means you just reject whatever they say and remain a paranoid recluse who never shares information or works with others. Distrusting everyone means working with them, but being careful of who knows what, and never taking their allegiance for granted. You can never be sure of someone else's role, so don't accept what they say without keeping in mind what they might have to gain from it if they were working against your interests. Paranoia is good in moderation, but take it too far and you're a recluse who doesn't contribute to your side since you won't share information.
Of course that's all good in theory, but in a game it often isn't clear where the line between healthy and excessive paranoia is. So it'll be up to individual judgement, but if anyone's really in doubt they should PM everything they known and ask me for help.
But you should always distrust everyone. How is that different you ask? Never trusting anyone means you just reject whatever they say and remain a paranoid recluse who never shares information or works with others. Distrusting everyone means working with them, but being careful of who knows what, and never taking their allegiance for granted. You can never be sure of someone else's role, so don't accept what they say without keeping in mind what they might have to gain from it if they were working against your interests. Paranoia is good in moderation, but take it too far and you're a recluse who doesn't contribute to your side since you won't share information.
Of course that's all good in theory, but in a game it often isn't clear where the line between healthy and excessive paranoia is. So it'll be up to individual judgement, but if anyone's really in doubt they should PM everything they known and ask me for help.