Werewolf CLXVI: Mob Rule

[Kaisersohaib]

We could do that, but as players of Werewolf, we are too busy grasping at straws.

Werewolf in a nutshell, I guess.

 

[jonti-h]

Vote Kaisersohaib

I think Cymsdale is on to something. Not sure why nobody else seems to notice.

Possibly because 1)we don't want to hang someone for getting off his arse and making an effort for a change 2)Cymsdale is usually wrong and 3)we nearly lynched Kai yesterday so running him up repeatedly is a waste of analysis.

If he acts suspiciously then fair enough, but Cymsdale's case is one that discourages newbs from doing anything.

 

[Daffius]

To be fair marty has been a likely hunt target ever since the day 0 shamvote gave him that trait.
Besides, if everyone is going to clamor for marty to provide that PM, how long do you think he'd be able to keep up this particular charade?

It wasn't directed at you specifically.

Of course I could be wrong, but I kinda doubt it. And I'm sure that smart wolves would have thought of this, too. If they don't simply have members of their pack in his guild to begin with. ;-)

Yes, he could be a wolf even as a guild member (especially with a N1 no hunt and him winning the sham voting). However until the guild is intact there is no point in pushing for him, as even as a wolf he can't really influence the guild (unless it's heavily skewed, but that would be a Johho balance issue). If anyone from the suspected 'other' guild is killed, then we can bring this back to the table.

So I say our best bet is still not to push for the guild and leave Marty alone.

 

[madchemist]

Anyone made a votecount recently?

 

[happycats517]

Possibly because 1)we don't want to hang someone for getting off his arse and making an effort for a change 2)Cymsdale is usually wrong and 3)we nearly lynched Kai yesterday so running him up repeatedly is a waste of analysis.

If he acts suspiciously then fair enough, but Cymsdale's case is one that discourages newbs from doing anything.

This. So much this.

Also, I think Marty has said enough about his contact and we learned the most important thing. There are multiple guilds out there. Each guild is probably quite small, with maybe only 4 members tops. I was curious since in the update EURO was revealed to be a plotter villager and a member of the "Morris' Dancers" guild. I wasn't sure if that was pure flavor or a hint of multiple guilds, now we know.

 

[Gen. Skobelev]

I know we really enjoy misinterpreting comments to make us feel safe about a lynch, but I've seen nothing that makes anyone a wolf so far. Combined with the fact that there have been no hunts and we have limited powers of analysis thus, we must conclude that any and all cases presented are suspect.

We could do that, but as players of Werewolf, we are too busy grasping at straws.

You know, for somebody who has no time and hasn't voted, you still manage to post metaphysical musings about the nature of werewolf game.

My personal guess for the name of that contact of his: Johho.
Let's all contemplate for a second what sharing that PM would achieve, exactly, if that were to be the case.

Well, yeah, now that it's in the open this is the conclusion I reached, too.

Someone remind me, why are we trying to provide hunt targets to the wolves? Can't we just leave this guild thing alone?

Right.

Vote Kaisersohaib

I think Cymsdale is on to something. Not sure why nobody else seems to notice.

He got run yesterday and won the vote (before PM & Alderman intervention). If he's genuinely upping his play, who are we to punish him immediately for his efforts.

To be fair marty has been a likely hunt target ever since the day 0 shamvote gave him that trait.
Besides, if everyone is going to clamor for marty to provide that PM, how long do you think he'd be able to keep up this particular charade?

Of course I could be wrong, but I kinda doubt it. And I'm sure that smart wolves would have thought of this, too. If they don't simply have members of their pack in his guild to begin with. ;-)

Yep. If anything, I'd have expected Marty to get robbed after that first night.

Possibly because 1)we don't want to hang someone for getting off his arse and making an effort for a change 2)Cymsdale is usually wrong and 3)we nearly lynched Kai yesterday so running him up repeatedly is a waste of analysis.

If he acts suspiciously then fair enough, but Cymsdale's case is one that discourages newbs from doing anything.

This.

So I say our best bet is still not to push for the guild and leave Marty alone.

And this. Seemed reasonable enough to doubt Euro claiming to be in a guild.

 

[Gen. Skobelev]

Arkasas: 6
Wagonlitz [1097]
Kaetje [1111 brovahkiin -> 1118 unvote -> 1119]
pjnlsn [1158]
alxeu [1168]
LatinKaiser [1179]
Kaisersohaib [1049 brovahkiin -> 1069 tamius23 -> 1121 unvote -> 1128 Yakman -> 1167 Arkasas -> 1180]

Yakman: 4
randakar [1044]
jonti-h [1050]
happycats517 [1190]
enkhuush [1057 Hax -> 1102 Arkasas -> 1205]

Rovsea: 3
aedan777 [1099]
Gen. Skobelev [1126]
tamius23 [1071 Kaisersohaib -> 1134]

randakar: 2
Nautilu [1122]
2kNikk [1074 happycats517 -> 1093 unvote -> 1142]

marty99: 2
Lemeard [1030]
THE_SPLIT [1189]

tamius23: 1
Rovsea [1056]

pjnlsn: 1
Yakman [1032]

THE_SPLIT: 1
Hax [1051]

madchemist: 1
Cymsdale [1092]

LatinKaiser: 1
madchemist [1088]

Cymsdale: 1
brovahkiin [1060 Arkasas -> 1094]

brovahkiin: 1
esemesas [1103]

esemesas: 1
J. Passepartout [1132]

Nautilu: 1
Daffius [1136]

Kaisersohaib: 1
Xarkan [1218]


not voted: 7
DutchGuy
Cliges
marty99 []
Arkasas []
Ithvan []
Dexander []
Panzer Commader []

 

[Cymsdale]

People seem to be confusing things. I'm not arguing that Kaiser is a baddie, I'm arguing that if he *is* a baddie, then he's a terrible player. Quite different.

 

[jonti-h]

Someone switch off Arkansas and onto Yakman

 

[Kaisersohaib]

unvote Arkasas
vote Yakman

Wolves or not, they are both better off dead. This is the only time a TIE is necessary.
Wow I sound cruel.

 

[2kNikk]

If Randy is baddie you are all getting the 'told you so dance'.

So as not to tunnel Unvote: randakar
Because I trust the names voting on this person moreso yhan the other two Vote: Rovsea

 

[jonti-h]

unvote Arkasas
vote Yakman

Wolves or not, they are both better off dead. This is the only time a TIE is necessary.
Wow I sound cruel.

Good boy

 

[Gen. Skobelev]

Someone switch off Arkansas and onto Yakman

How very surprising.

Wow I sound cruel.

[video=youtube;CsxhMAnglaE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CsxhMAnglaE[/video]

If Randy is baddie you are all getting the 'told you so dance'.

If he is (and it's perfectly possible), then he is. I think it's immaterial to the saving Euro.

 

[Arkasas]

You know, for somebody who has no time and hasn't voted, you still manage to post metaphysical musings about the nature of werewolf.

You can do weird things on your lunch break.

 

[jonti-h]

You can do weird things on your lunch break.

Dogging?

 

[Arkasas]

Dogging?

More like commenting on Werewolf metagame.

 

[johho888]

Official vote count, 3h 20min to deadline

Arkasas - 5 - Wagonlitz, Kaetje, pjnlsn, alxeu, LatinKaiser
Yakman - 5 - randakar, jonti-h, happycats517, enkhuush, Kaisersohaib
Rovsea - 4 - aedan777, Gen. Skobelev, tamius23, 2kNikk
marty99 - 2 - Lemeard, THE_SPLIT
randakar - 1 - Nautilu
tamius23 - 1 - Rovsea
brovahkiin - 1 - esemesas
pjnlsn - 1 - Yakman
THE_SPLIT - 1 - Hax
LatinKaiser - 1 - madchemist
madchemist - 1 - Cymsdale
Cymsdale - 1 - brovahkiin
esemesas - 1 - J. Passepartout
Nautilu - 1 - Daffius
Kaisersohaib - 1 - Xarkan

not voted - 7 - DutchGuy, Cliges, marty99, Arkasas, Ithvan, Dexander, Panzer Commader

requests sub - 1 - DutchGuy
missed one vote - 1 - DutchGuy, Cliges

 

[Arkasas]

Vote Rovsea

I like TIEs.

 

[Kaisersohaib]

Vote Rovsea

I like TIEs.

We noticed.

 

[happycats517]

Sorry guys. I have a four hour class I have to go to so I'll miss deadline again. Should be the last time this happens.