War ends suddenly if I invite an ally to it and he accepts

[iShurik]

Playing a Duke in the HRE I wanted to declare War on another Duke and I did so. Then I invited all my Allies to the war, one of them accepted. After he accepted the war suddenly ended without a reason. I tried reloading the game -> same problem. So inviting allies seems to be impossible. I guess it's a Bug.

My Savegame:
View attachment Brunonen.zip

 

[Duckee]

Anyone know if 1.5d fixes this issue? I saw people saying another alliance bug is still there, so I expect this one will still be present too.

 

[unmerged(278620)]

Anyone know if 1.5d fixes this issue? I saw people saying another alliance bug is still there, so I expect this one will still be present too.

I also would like to know this.

 

[Duckee]

1.5e still has this issue I just called started a game as the Duke of Holland, started a war and called on my ally the count of Oldenburg and war ended inconclusive when he answered the call.

 

[Sleight of Hand]

Sounds like this issue?

Could be the problem I'm having. I'd never thought about allies causing it but I can't remember if I invited allies into either war. I can't think I would have bothered in order to take down a countess with two provinces.

 

[WankoStankins]

I'm not sure if this issue is fixed but I too got it in 1.5c as the count of western iceland pressing my claim on the county of eastern iceland. When I called in a north english duke to help me the war would end inconclusively.

 

[Sleight of Hand]

I'm pretty sure this hasn't been fixed.

 

[Kalmar8]

I guess it doesn't change much, but I'm yet another victim of this bug.

http://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/showthread.php?604749-War-gets-peaced-out-when-I-invite-an-ally

If needed I can provide a savegame too.

 

[unmerged(278620)]

Is there any update to this in the internal bug forum?

This bug still happens but not as much as in the previous hotfixes.

 

[Mammoet]

Is it maybe the same issue as I reported here ? Where the ally in question is actually a vassal of your enemy.

 

[LostScout61]

This bug is not fixed by the latest patch. 1.05e. I'm the king of Mauritania, within the HRE, and when my brothers or uncles rebel to replace me, as soon as they start losing the war they try to call in some of our fellow dynasty members to help, and as soon as they get a response the war ends inconclusively. I don't know if it's from one accepting or one declining, because there are multiple invites and the responses all come in at once.

 

[NiklasLun]

Okay, more savegames would be much appreciated from those of you still experiencing this. It would greatly help in tracking down all aspects of the bug.

 

[blub2]

just start a game as a duke of the hre, declare war on somebody in hre and than invite an ally. if he accepts the war is over. just play 2 in game weeks and you will find the bug.

 

[LostScout61]

I would love to attach a savegame, but my Zip file is 9686 kb and the attachment upload manager limits me to 976.6 kilobytes. The upload fails, and I don't know how to get around this. Help?

 

[iShurik]

You could upload it to a external site and post the link here, just google for "upload files" or try " http://www.file-upload.net/ " .

 

[iamjmph]

well, sorry no save game, i accidently corrupted it(tried loading the save when running faniciful titles mod, but i accidently used the ck2+ ftt version, save was corrupted, crashed the game evreytime i tried to load it).

I was started as king of denmark, got lucky with a marriage and some assassinations to pick up matilda's holdings, conquered corsica, and won Crusade for Jerusalem(HRE and France never joined, just me, pope and some irish dukes...). My Queen kept getting sick but surviving, so i moved my capital to corsica, and for some reason my primary title changed to KoJ... everything was fine up till that point

now... after this point i stop expanding. I go to join one of my allies wars but a strange thing happens. While it says i will join my ally, looking at the Victory conditions(where it shows what you get/lose for victory, white peace, surrender) it seems as if ill be joining the enemy(win=enemy +, ally -), confused, i dont join. Then the HRE invites me to join them in Holy War in Iberia, as soon as i accept it ends inconclusively.

I get my heir married(regular) to the Queen of Sicily. One of her dukes plots to take a county from her that is his de jure... and at the same time Muslim Palmero Declares holy war. She asks for help. I agree. As soon as my troops start to seige enemy Sicily surrenders(-5 and -20 war scores respectively....)... dont know if its the same but....

 

[NiklasLun]

I would love to attach a savegame, but my Zip file is 9686 kb and the attachment upload manager limits me to 976.6 kilobytes. The upload fails, and I don't know how to get around this. Help?

Like iShurik said, you can always upload the file externally and provide a link. It would be much appreciated, since actual cases of this to look at is invaluable for our devs in trying to track the bug down completely.

well, sorry no save game, i accidently corrupted it(tried loading the save when running faniciful titles mod, but i accidently used the ck2+ ftt version, save was corrupted, crashed the game evreytime i tried to load it).

I was started as king of denmark, got lucky with a marriage and some assassinations to pick up matilda's holdings, conquered corsica, and won Crusade for Jerusalem(HRE and France never joined, just me, pope and some irish dukes...). My Queen kept getting sick but surviving, so i moved my capital to corsica, and for some reason my primary title changed to KoJ... everything was fine up till that point

now... after this point i stop expanding. I go to join one of my allies wars but a strange thing happens. While it says i will join my ally, looking at the Victory conditions(where it shows what you get/lose for victory, white peace, surrender) it seems as if ill be joining the enemy(win=enemy +, ally -), confused, i dont join. Then the HRE invites me to join them in Holy War in Iberia, as soon as i accept it ends inconclusively.

I get my heir married(regular) to the Queen of Sicily. One of her dukes plots to take a county from her that is his de jure... and at the same time Muslim Palmero Declares holy war. She asks for help. I agree. As soon as my troops start to seige enemy Sicily surrenders(-5 and -20 war scores respectively....)... dont know if its the same but....

Wow, lots of info here. That also means lots of parameters, so I'd really like to have a look at it myself. You're sure you don't have an autosave or something lying around?

 

[iamjmph]

no... and this all happened before i found this, and i deleted it all out of frustration. I don't normally post bugs, cause i'm never the first one to find one, and i doubt the devs and mods like reading about the same problem over and over.

Im not even sure why i posted on this one... i was exhausted when i did, must have messed with my decision making abilities

 

[iShurik]

Is it fixed with 1.05f ?

 

[iShurik]

It seems to be fixed!!! Just tried a savegame from 1.05e. Very nice, thanks!!

 

[NiklasLun]

Good times! If anyone still experiences this, I'd be very thankful for any savegame provided.