Vassals not giving occupied lands

[Secuter]

As if they had a choice, they don't give it to me. I understand, that if they have a core they have legit reason not to give it.
I have Novgorod as a vassal, who is determined to own all of Russia... But still, I owe them regardless of their ambitions, but they don't hand over any provinces they take, which is rather bothersome.

 

[Wizzington]

Vassals only hold on to cores and claims when sieging. This is WAD.

 

[Secuter]

Vassals only hold on to cores and claims when sieging. This is WAD.

Novgorod defies your rules it would seem. They held on to large parts of Russia, even places that they've never set foot before.

 

[semaphore]

Novgorod defies your rules it would seem. They held on to large parts of Russia, even places that they've never set foot before.

Maybe you should post a screenshot.

 

[kontinos]

Same problem but with allies. I don't own the Cossacks yet, however it seems weird that war allies won't transfer occupation of provinces you have a claim on and they don't.

 

[Oahkoah]

In one of Arumba's Albania videos it shows Leinster which is a vassal of England having occupied most of Burgundy without transferring the occupations to England

 

[Wizzington]

If you have a case where you feel the AI really should be transfering occupation to you and isn't, please post a bug report along with save.

 

[Wizzington]

In one of Arumba's Albania videos it shows Leinster which is a vassal of England having occupied most of Burgundy without transferring the occupations to England

This sounds like a bug for sure. Would need a repro case.

 

[pphair]

I feel like if its an allies war, vassals should transfer occupation to overlord.
I just based this on the time I got a coalition from my ally giving my vassal a high dev claim from (I think)a non-co-belligerent.
Was a bit of a pain.

 

[kontinos]

Is there any chance that for those without the DLC, AI has provinces of interest that we can't obviously see, which determines their behavior in transferring occupation?

 

[Oahkoah]

This sounds like a bug for sure. Would need a repro case.

It's in this video about 20 seconds in,

Though obviously without being a save file it may be hard to know the true cause.

 

[MrParadux]

Novgorod probably set those provinces as are of vital interest (maybe because are the same religion and culture?). I noticed that subjects can set these vital interests, too and thus won't transfer occupation

 

[Frederick_Will]

Had this happen a few weeks ago with my allies. I was the war leader. I got tired of the ottomans eating up germany and the netherlands so i cut them in half.

Spoiler

Spoiler

Then poland gave provinces to Spain.

Spoiler

 

[Seiska]

Yup this happened on my bengal ironman run yesterday, delhi occupied 2 orissa provinces that had my core and claim and did not transfer occupation, holy shit that was irritating. Seems to happen with the current build only, did not notice this with the 1.14 beta build.

 

[Wizzington]

According to QA this is fixed in 1.15 already, but we'll do some internal testing to be extra double sure.

 

[Chief of Staff]

Can confirm same thing happened with my England/Great Britain game... I get strange case where provinces in India were transferred to British West Indies by my Indian protectorates that captured it in my colonial war there. I fixed it with controll console command where appropriate but obviously anyone playing ironman would not be able to use that workaround.