Hitler is too stubborn to feel defeat, but I see that he's doomed.
I also feel a future US-CSA war... dunno why...
I also feel a future US-CSA war... dunno why...
Kurt_Steiner said:Hitler is too stubborn to feel defeat, but I see that he's doomed.
I also feel a future US-CSA war... dunno why...
Brian Roastbeef said:Yeah, I have to agree with Kurt. If the USA has the potential to drive in the final nail, then that means Hitler must already be in the coffin...(Negrin, certainly, is finished.)
A lot of potential for story lines once that happens, and plenty of gameplay time left too. Will it be CSA vs. USA, or CSA vs. the Commies, or CSA vs. Commie USA...? I look forward to seeing where you take it.
I see a British landing near Marseille. What's going on there? Any headway against Italy? Hopefully its relieving some pressure from the Balkan front.
kingmbutu said:Like always the US comes late to the party just so they can claim to be the life of the party
gamer15436 said:I have just caught up, and I must say, this is the best AAR I have ever read hands down! I was a little worried last night. I got sucked into this AAR and forgot I had a huge test on the play Julius Casear. I only read half the play, so I was gonna post that this AAR was so good, I flunked a test for it. But thank god for sparknotes I think I got an A.
I really love all the detail you are putting into these, but I have a few suggestions just to improve it. I am not flaming you, I just noticed two things that sorta confused me.
First, what is happening inside the CSA? Years have went, and the political story has taken a second seat to the war, which is understandable, but I wish I could get a little more info on that. The political story is what sucked me in.
And secondly, can you please try to squeeze in the dates somewhere. I am guessing it is somewhere in 1942...but I am not sure. I am guessing this because the last date I remember reading was in 1941, but then you stated the Germans made a spectacular winter offensive. So maybe put in a date here and there please.
I really hate pointing out those, because I don't wanna sound like I want to tell you how to do things...I mean I never even started an AAR, plus I think this AAR is almost perfect!
Now to the story itself...in a future update, could I please get a little bit of info about the army's size and where it is currently located. Approx how many divisions are in the homeland, the CPA lands, and Europe. Also what kinds of divisions are you using mostly? I'm guessing motorized infantry and armored divisions in Europe, and basic infantry in the homeland.
Also what is the future plans for the CSA militarily speaking...is the Navy going to get their essential improvement? I am also wondering about Canada. Are they in the war? And politically, who do they generally side with...CSA or USA?
I really like the invasion in Spain and soon to be the German territories. The Balkan wars aren't looking promising. I think Romania and the UK can still pull through though. As long as Germany has the USSR on their backs, the war should be getting easier. It is just a matter of time. It would suck to be Germany right now with a three front war.
I saw how there may be a future war with the US, USSR, or a Commie US. Well I think it would make for a great storyline where something happens to Earl and the CSA actually becomes an all out Fascist country. Maybe turn their back on the UK, or screw them altogether. So it would be cool to see a CSA vs Allies vs Commie vs US war.
Well, great AAR! I will be following from now on...Bookmarked!
asd21593 said:finally a realistic CSA AAR, no CSA conquers North America, no CSA fights againsts fascist USA (or vice versa) !
a great, well written CSA AAR that seems real for once!
asd
trekaddict said:Well if the American Civil War ( as the war is known over here in krautland ) had been won by the south then IMVVHO the CSA is the mroe likely candidate for goign facist. But that is just my opinion and I might be wrong.
Brian Roastbeef said:Trek, I think Europeans see the CSA as a likely fascist candidate because of the similarities in racial beliefs. The failure in this, in my opinion, is that it ignores the strong Confederate beliefs in liberty. The Confederacy wasn't about the fascist rhetoric of "these races don't have rights because they're inferior, so we want to keep them as slaves," so much as it was about "we don't think that any central government should have the authority to tell us that we shouldn't have slaves." It can't be looked at one-dimensionally. They rejected Lincoln's arguments of equality, but that doesn't mean that they'd automatically embrace Fascism seventy years later. Whatever Huey Long's influence would have been in the CSA, I think the libertarian and Christian tendencies would win out and reject the authoritarian tendencies of the Axis.
Furthermore, most alternate historians see the avenue to Confederate victory including, at some point, British and French recognition and diplomatic pressure on Washington. That would keep them diplomatically tied to Britain and France, Wilson's probable influence and the ethnic makeup of the South would likely keep them similarly inclined through WWI. Its hard to see a diplomatic realignment before WWII. I think Volga's avenue of making them an early ally is quite plausible.
Gamer15436, you know this AAR actually got its start in Victoria right? If you didn't, check out the first half of it.
Volga, this really has been an excellent AAR. If I were to ask one thing, as a part of feedback, it would be the occasional inclusion, maybe every year or two of game time, of some overall maps. Just a general look at Europe overall, and maybe what's going on, if anything, in Asia.