• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

unmerged(19363)

Colonel
Sep 7, 2003
842
0
Visit site
Siege of France

Vichy France had fallen, it was now once again Free France, but the north of France was still under the Nazi boot, and the situation was a precarious one, as Eisenhower after such initial gains fully expected a complete counter attack any day. He gave the order for all troops to move to the borders and dig in. Patton's armor was ordered to halt its advance and station itself in Vichy. The 101st would join it in a day to man area around the vital city until the French could get troops there as well. Krueger's XLII Corps he ordered north to garrison the area around Limoges, while Truscott's XXIII positioned itself to hold the line from Auch to Perigueux. The Germans had a corps size force in both Bordeaux and La Rochelle which posed the most immediate threat.

The Resistance in the north soon began to report a lot of commotion on the Atlantic Wall. It seemed Hitler was quite serious about throwing back the advance in the south by stripping the Wall of considerable manpower. Eisenhower and Marshall began to wonder just how far Hitler would go in weakening this most vital spot.

Bradley's Eighth Army, still in garrison of the English coastline from Scapa Flow to Coventry, was still open for assignment. During their stay in Britain, Bradley's staff along with the English had long studied the French coast across the Channel, trying to draw up various invasion plans for the day they might become necessary. When Fourth Army was brought over to begin definitive offensive operations on the continent, once a Mediterranean entrance was decided upon, Eighth Army was on standby either to aid Fourth Army in Southern France, or to launch an invasion across the Channel to open up a second front. Bradley had concentrated his efforts since his arrival in planning for a cross channel invasion, in either Cherbourg or Normandy. As intelligence over time pointed towards Normandy as being the path of least resistance, his efforts were more fully focused on a landing around the Caen area.


Chess Match

With the reports of the coastal defenses being stripped for operations in Southern France, the Allies stepped up fighter reconnaissance along the coast to try to ascertain the full scale of the troop movement as well to decide where along the Channel to land Eighth Army in the event an amphibious landing was approved. With considerable Axis manpower being pulled off the Atlantic wall, Bradley frantically went over last minute details for a Normandy invasion plan, and at once it seemed all of England was abuzz and on standby.

The German intelligence was rather unsure of what the goal of Eighth Army was. With so much abuzz in England in the past week, they were aware something big was on the horizon. They had reports obviously of a landing across the Channel, increased reconnaissance flights over the area gave credence to this theory. However, they also had reports flowing in that Eighth Army would be reinforcing Fourth Army via the Mediterranean. German commanders in the area agreed that the Allies in their expanded front in southern France were overdrawn and did not have enough units to properly man their new extended front. This was indeed the case, especially in light of the large amounts of reinforcements the Germans were sending to the area. It seemed the logical choice that the two U.S. Armies would work side by side, better solidifying their lines.

One other item to strengthen this notion was the crosstalk American counter-intelligence allowed to get out, that Bradley would give up command of Eighth Army to Patton who was already in Southern France, while Bradley would then assume control of the fictional Army Group South as overall commander of American forces in Southern France. The Germans quickly bought into this, for it did not seem logical to them that what they perceived to be America's best general would be limited to the role of Corps commander in such a critical operation. This misinformation on the part of American counter-intelligence helped to ensure Hitler's stripping of the Atlantic Wall for a counter-attack in the south would continue full steam without concern of an Allied landing up north that might make them leave more defenders in Normandy.


Counterattack

The German response to Vichy's fall did not take long. On December 22nd, Gen. Von Hubicki attacked Limoges out of New Rochelle. The strike force was comprised of the 19. Lettische SS-Freiw Division and the Kraftfahrjagerdivision. Defending against the attack was MacGruder's 5th Armored Division, the same which had been repulsed from La Rochelle days before. In the first true defensive stand of the European campaign for the Americans their armor sadly proved no match for the German guns. The Germans were primed, well armed and well coordinated. The two divisions did a pincer movement on the sole defending division and after complete decimation MacGruder ordered a complete withdrawal.

A week later, Harzer's 41st Waffen Panzer Grenadiers attacked the American 37th and 95th divisions at Auch. The Americans were completely unable to thwart the attack, and had to retreat across the Garonne River back to Toulouse. On the same day the 11th South African Division was driven out of Chateauroux by Von Falkenhorst. The defensive lines were imploding back towards the Mediterranean. Only Patton's Corp held in Vichy France, and that would soon be under siege by the Germans as well. The Germans were wasting no time in sending in the counterstrike, and it was clearly to their advantage as the Allied troops were still consolidating and coordinating their command structure in the midst of replacing the government and overall administration of the area.


December 31, 1943 - The Wall is Breached

The French population had been under the boot of their German oppressors for several years now. Their way of life turned inside, the conquerors showed little mercy to opposition or resistance. With all the personal goods shortages a foreign occupation in the midst of a war brings, along with the curtailment of certain liberties, there was very little reason or will to celebrate things as the people had done in times past. For the people of southern France, Christmas 1943 was indeed a memorable one, the first one with British and American soldiers garrisoning their towns rather than Germans. While their southern brethren celebrated, the people along the northern coast could only be envious and wait their turn. They of course had a much quieter, less joyful Christmas, with little expense put into it. As the New Year approached, they likewise planned their smaller, more subdued celebration of that holiday as well.

For those living along the coast, looking out into the Channel it was not unusual over the past few years to see the British Navy sailing past, at times lobbing shells at some of the German fortifications, or making war with a U-Boat. Occasionally a squadron of British fighters could be seen to fly overhead as well, many times doing battle with their German counterparts. But on New Year's Eve, what greeted the eyes of the French civilians along the Normandy coast was quite different. People from Bayeux to Ouistreham and even LeHavre lined up to look out at the immense armada of the American Navy which had appeared off the horizon. Larger than any mass of ships they had yet seen, many made note this fleet was not moving nor passing by. It was coming nearer.

Planes, the sounds of planes suddenly, British planes, far more than they had heard in some time, appearing from above the ships and quickly flying inland over their heads. Anti air batteries began spewing their flaming lead into the sky while the British pilots began firing back at the German fortifications as well. While some dove to drop their bombs near the beaches and inland, other more fleet ones circled high above the battlefield, like great protectors, looking for any German resistance from the air to shoot down. There was very little German air resistance, as most had been knocked down in this area over the recent months, or transferred to the battle in the south of France.

As the ships moved ever closer to shore, ever more visible, the British planes dropped their last sorties of bombs and returned across the Channel for home. The fighters then flew above the approaching fleet as guardian angels. Now in the evening darkness, the New Year but a few hours away, the absolute darkness was quickly destroyed by flares high overhead, illuminating the entire coastline like day. With a clear view of their target, the massive guns of the American Navy began to open up on the German defenses with everything they had. To confuse the defenders as to where the actual invasion would come, the American navy hit the entire coastline, from Cherbourg all the way east to Dieppe. But the brunt of the shelling took place along the coast near Bayeux and Ouistreham.

It is safe to say that no New Years eve celebration in Normandy has before or since has come close to the fireworks show that was displayed that night. The sky was lit by flares, by rockets, by the fires of ruined buildings up and down the coast.

In America's War of Independence, while the English and Hessian troops celebrated Christmas, rather than celebrating the holiday themselves, General Washington had his troops cross the Delaware that night, and attack the over imbibed enemy in a surprise attack. New Year's Eve, 1943 saw General Omar Bradley, commander of the U.S. Eight Army take a chapter out of history and duplicate it. The defending enemy having spent guard duty on these shores for four years without incident, with such little risk they had grown used to letting their guard down on certain holidays. Despite in war time mode, complacency set in, as it would for any garrison which spent its past four years looking at nothing but open water. Between taking time out to celebrate the holidays, and Hitler stripping so many troops from the Normandy defense in the past few days, suffice to say the Germans were completely ill prepared for what was coming.

Rather than waiting until the first light of dawn to launch the invasion, Bradley wanted to capitalize on the situation, as limited troops began making their way ashore in Caen just as the new year struck. Intelligence had confirmed that the coast in lower Normandy from Omaha Beach to Le Havre had nearly been completely stripped of its entire defenses by Hitler, most of which were now marching south past Orleans. Minimal manpower was left to man critical machine gun nests and anti air in these regions, but it was hardly enough to put up a fight against what the Allies would be throwing at them. The opening wave at midnight consisted of three total divisions. On the right flank Bradley's 35th Infantry division began coming ashore. It landed three regiments abreast, the 134th to the right on Omaha, 137th in the center and 320th on the left flank. General Rankin's 26th Infantry landed to the west of Ouistreham. Also landing three regiments abreast, the 101st was on the right, 104th in the center and 328th on the left, with orders to land and then secure Ouistreham.

NormandyInvasionD0.jpg

First Wave of the Assault - Midnight

Nearly as soon as the first boats came ashore, the sound of many planes could once again be heard in the night, with a much deeper drone to them. It was an enormous amount of planes that approached, all in formation like a bombing run. Much slower moving than fighters or dive bombers, the citizens at Caen looking up at them in the darkness soon realized they were not there to carpet bomb the German defenses. White parachutes as far as the eye could see began descending down around the Normandy capital. Lt. General Matthew Ridgeway's 82nd Airborne Division were making the first ever American parachute drop behind enemy lines.

AirJump1.jpg


Many of the planes found themselves off course in the darkness, and as a result the paratroopers were much more spread out than had been originally intended, but because of the lessened German garrison in the area, it did not prove detrimental. Scattered over a wider range, the defenders estimated them to be considerable more than what they were, forcing the Germans to give them additional attention.

The first few waves of the 35th and 26th infantry came ashore in the darkness with but the lightest of casualties, the defenders clearly not being there in sufficient numbers. Quickly moving inland to secure a beachhead, they tried to set up a proper defensive perimeter well advanced of the water while the next waves of boats came in. Both divisions found little trouble in achieving their objectives, quickly forming an advanced perimeter, the 35th covering the far right flank of the invasion against any incursion by the Hungarians and Romanian forces in Cherbourg. The 328th Regiment, 26th Division focused on securing the left flank of the operation by seizing the town of Ouisterham, while the 104th Regiment moved inland toward Caen to link up with the paratroopers of the 82nd Airborne. As the first lights of dawn began to spread across the sky, and the Romanian commanders in the area tried to make heads and tails of what was happening, the lead elements of both landing divisions had moved inland two miles while the armor began to come ashore. There were no Panzers to greet them at the water, all German armor was on its way towards Vichy at the moment.



The 82nd Airborne did what it was supposed to do, cause complete confusion among the rear echelon defenders. So few in number, this made the American's task so much easier. A division falling out of the sky behind them, the Romanian commanders hesitated at sending their troops towards the shore to fight the invasion, and by time they made up their mind to do so, it was too late to make a difference. Special demolition units of the airborne instantly began working deeper inland looking to wire bridges and cut lines to further delay any enemy reinforcements. In all, every one of the seven divisions of Eighth Army were ashore by the end of the day on January 1st, with merely 250 casualties among ground troops due to enemy fire.

NormandyInvasionD1.jpg

Rest of Army Comes Ashore - Morning Jan 1

A landing on the well fortified Atlantic Wall with only 250 battle casualties was something none of the American field commanders could ever have envisioned. Suffice to say after working on the Wall's defense for years, Rundstedt, Rommel and Heinrici could also have never believed so few Allied casualties in a successful breach of the wall. Such was the will of Hitler, that when he said retake Vichy at all costs, it meant leaving considerable stretches of the Atlantic Wall completely undefended, against all common military logic. Somebody had to break the news to Hitler that his direct order to strip the wall had resulted in a nearly unopposed landing by the Americans who now had a full Army in Normandy. Having been relieved of his command the week prior, Rundstedt sat in his room in Berlin with an early morning glass of brandy thanking the good Lord that it was not his task to send this message to the Fuehrer.


With the resistance on the coast nearly non existent and the tanks ashore without a hitch, Bradley thought to seize the opportunity while the Germans' backs were turned. He immediately ordered the tanks to advance "with all speed" to the south, 3rd Armored heading for Orleans and Crittenberger's 4th Armored to head for the jewel of France, undefended Paris. The 82nd Airborne, now gathered up on the ground and reorganized were ordered to follow the 4th Armored into Paris to help strengthen its defense. Freeman's 5th Motorized Infantry was sent east across the Seine to seize Rouen. Bradley wanted to take as big a bite out of northern France as he could in the opening days, so the Germans heading south took notice and wheeled around, potentially saving the collapsing pocket of Fourth Army. He knew most of the gains, particularly Rouen and Orleans were temporary gains, as they had not the sufficient force to withstand a German counterattack. His hope was to delay the German advance towards Normandy to afford the British time to ferry reinforcements across the Channel to help with the beachhead. As it turned out, the race to seize Rouen was lost, as the 5th Motorized faced serious obstacles laid down by the Germans, and the delays afforded Manteuffel the opportunity to rush out from Lille and take up defensive positions before the Americans arrived. After a very brief battle, outnumbered and overpowered, Freeman turned his division around and returned to Caen.


Battle of Vichy

On January 5th, the attack on Vichy finally came. It was in the midst of an extreme cold front that the Germans attacked, ice covering most of the roadways. On the Allied side, the defense was made up of Patton's 5th Armored Division, the 101st Airborne, the 76th Infantry, and the British 66th Infantry under Heath. Because of the rapid fall of Vichy and the quick allied advance coupled with the poor weather in the south, as well as snares and foul ups in the logistics departments, supplies had been slow to trickle into the city, and the defenders were already feeling the pinch both in food and ammo before the Germans even arrived. On the Axis side, five divisions were used in the attack, led by Hungarian Field Marshall Horvath. It was comprised of one Panzer division, a Panzer Grenadier, one Hungarian and two Romanian infantry divisions. Several of these divisions weeks before had been doing coastal defense along the Atlantic Wall, consequently they were well put together and well armed.

Despite the weather, it was a very one sided affair. Without time to properly use the defenses of the city to their proper advantage as well as in the midst of setting up a change in the government of the capital, they were ill prepared for so soon an attack. The American troops took considerably heavy casualties on all fronts and Patton called a complete retreat within a few hours, vacating the city. The Germans now had Vichy, and the Americans held Paris.

FranceJan41944.jpg

Situation in France - Jan 4, 1944
 

unmerged(34173)

Sergeant
Sep 10, 2004
63
0
Yes fortunate about the weather.....

I can't imagine being a poor ground pounder in some landing craft in the middle of the channel being pounded by rough seas, frozen from the sleet and snow, and then landing to face any sort of resistence on the beach.

I am sure that this move has to have some sort of severe response from the Germans. Let's hope the British AI is smart enough to assist and land some reinforcements on the new beachhead to secure it for a breakout to link up with the forces in the south.
 

unmerged(28944)

Would-be King of Dragons
May 10, 2004
4.445
6
Great update! It's nice to see American troops kicking some big time but for a change. I was concerned there for a moment thinking that Patton might end up getting taken out by the Germans, but I was much relieved to see that he was able to withdraw to save his troops.

I can only imagine how Hitler takes this fiasco of his own creation! That ought to be fun to watch, HA! :rolleyes:

Sooo, what's next on the agenda for the brave American fighting soldier? :D
 

unmerged(19363)

Colonel
Sep 7, 2003
842
0
Visit site
Ladislav:
imagine trapping all the german division in western france in a huge pocket!
Well I think both initial advances in north and south have run out of steam. Lack of manpower really. Its on to the defensive for now.

Wilhelm IV: For now the British have a toehold in the south of Italy, so that front already exists, I just don't have the manpower for a third landing in Italy now that we've landed in Normandy

Mettermrck: I think if a real life General had attempted D-Day at night in January he A) would have been courtmartialed B) been mutineed by his troops. AI soldiers are so loyal and obedient!

Bigcat: The English refuse to return my phonecalls. For the meantime Normandy is a purely American Affair :(

Draco Rexus:
Sooo, what's next on the agenda for the brave American fighting soldier?
Dig in and pray... we just threw two rocks at beehives, and boy them bees seem angry!


I think overall I'll have a hard time making inroads into the continent once I'm ashore. The first few battles show the Germans far more stout than the Japanese. At least I have help in this one with the Allies, but the Germans are still succeeding in the eastern front as well. I think American presence will be best utilized "slugging it out" with Germany, winning through attrition and production rather than battlefield victories. Not the outlook you want to hear if you're one of the groundtroops :)
 

unmerged(19363)

Colonel
Sep 7, 2003
842
0
Visit site

Battle for Paris - January 9th


As soon as Bradley's landing in Normandy became known, the German command was thrown into complete turmoil. So many troops had been stripped from the wall to be sent south to face Patton and Eisenhower's advance. Many of the troops were ordered to make a complete u-turn and head back north towards the coast. Those still along the coast soon began to march towards the American landing area. Many interior troops were quickly redeployed to help fight off this latest threat as well. The Americans having already advanced inland to seize Orleans and Paris before the Germans could respond, the German command now saw these two cities as the first ones to assault, as they were both lightly defended by only a division or two each.

On January 9th, the counterattack finally came, centered on Paris. General Schorner's attack force was made up of the 502nd and 506th Panzer Grenadier Divisions. The 82nd Airborne had just recently arrived to help White's 4th Armored to defend the City. It was a cold wintery day, extremely cold with ice covering the streets and making maneuver extremely difficult. It was a considerable task to keep equipment from freezing up, and the soldiers on both sides had a tough time facing the elements and warding off frostbite.

In the American's favor, the attacking Germans had to cross the Seine, made only riskier by the wicked temperatures which bogged down the crossing leaving their troops more vulnerable during the extended crossing. As they began to first cross the river, American field artillery began to open up with everything they had, doing considerable damage to the enemy. During the first half of the 9th it was indeed a very one sided affair as the German troops were still trying to get across the river under artillery fire while trying to form up a beachhead on the far bank before beginning the actual assault. Eventually as their numbers grew they began to return fire, and into the 10th the battle began to grow more even, both sides well dug in within the cover of the city and surrounding towns. As the weather cleared, only then could the German air support move in. The American armor was quite vulnerable to the quite capable attack of the German pilots, and it was the Stukas that began to turn the tide of the battle.

FranceNorthJan91944.jpg

Extent of American Advance in Normandy

As the first set of German troops made their attack on Paris, Bradley looking at the situation map of Normandy realized the vulnerable position he was in. Intelligence clearly showed the Axis noose tightening around his expanded beachhead from all directions. Between six and eight divisions were estimated to be moving in on Caen. With merely four divisions guarding this critical center, if it fell to such a large attack, the troops in Paris and Orleans would be surrounded and cutoff. He began to discuss with his staff whether to abandon Orleans, and return the 3rd Armored to Caen to help boost the defenses and avoid the armor from being cutoff.

On top of that reports had up to three divisions descending on the Armor in Orleans itself. The debate to withdraw them picked up intensity as some argued that risking the armor in Orleans, only to have it retreat to Caen anyway would only hinder it in its defense of Caen, being much weakened from a lost battle. However with the way the 4th Armored and 82nd Airborne were fighting so tenaciously against the invaders in Paris, with the severe winter weather hampering Axis offensive operations, Bradley felt maybe the weather was playing into his hands. He was reluctant to give up any of the key territory his initial advance had gained.

He also was still lobbying the British for troops to help defend Caen. As from the start, the British remained non-committal to helping with the Normandy beachhead. Churchill insisted all British manpower was needed to sustain the campaign in southern Italy as well as in southern France. The American soldiers unloading supplies on the beaches of Normandy could see the British transports on the horizon full of recruits from Portsmouth and Southhampton, sailing right past them for the Meditteranean. It was clear Churchill was making the Americans sweat it out: The Americans had not sent any ground forces to help their English Ally for several years, now perhaps it was time to let the Americans know exactly what that felt like.

Bradley's decision to leave the 3rd Armored in Orleans soon came under fire, as on the 11th, while the battle in Paris still raged, the Romanian General Lascar assaulted Orleans from LeMans with the 1st Romanian Infantry Division, and a Hungarian Division. The two Eastern European forces were well coordinated and on the first day were able to put a significant hurt into White's 3rd Armored. As the losses began to mount he began to lobby Bradley for permission to retreat to Caen. Before Bradley could make a decision, the attackers made his decision easier, as on the next morning the 7th and 8th Romanian Infantry joined in the battle, making it a full four division attack force. The retreat order was given and the 3rd Armored with a significant amount of damage began pulling out its tanks, headed back to the rest of Eighth Army in Caen.

By the early morning hours of the 12th, the forces in and around Paris were still slugging it out for the 4th day. The Americans had had the full advantage early in the battle as the Germans tried to cross the river and draw up battle lines under intense artillery fire. Now that all their forces were across it was a slow, slogging fight. Only the powerful damage inflicted by the Stukas were able to shift the battle in the German's favor. Both sides had begun to tally up significant losses, and in the morning hours of the 12th, it was clear the Germans were gaining the upper hand and the American battalions were becoming unglued. The Stukas returned during the day, and the sortie once again inflicted a tremendous amount of damage on the defenders, both to the armor and the airborne. With the loss of Orleans on their flank, and the battle beginning to turn against them, Bradley ordered the 4th Armored and 82nd Airborne to retreat from Paris and return to Caen. It was not with much pleasure that he handed the prized capital back to the Germans, but with the growing storm coming towards their landing point in Caen, inland gains were becoming secondary to securing the actual beachhead itself. As he called for the retreat from Paris, and the first troops from Orleans began to return to Caen, Bradley couldn't help thinking of how much this situation resembled Fifth Army's debacle at Xiamen.

FranceNorthJan121944.jpg

Eighth Army Perimeter after Fall of Paris

In the south of France, the situation was not much brighter. In recent weeks the massive German Counterassault had snipped off the perimeter gains of Fourth Army. By early January they had managed in retaking Auch, Limoges, Chateauroux, Vichy, and Saint Etienne. Regrouping and resupplying the returning troops, the Allies were now bracing for the next push of the Axis counter-assault, which seemed poised to centered its strike around Clermont-Ferrand. While Fourth Army was clearly fighting a delaying action in its retreat, at least the situation did not resemble the Normandy situation. Unlike Bradley, Ike had the service of British and French forces to help defend the area, and was far more confident that the German advance would finally stall.

FranceSouthJan121944.jpg

The Collapsing Pocket in Southern France
 

Allenby

Custom User Title
8 Badges
Apr 4, 2003
7.170
5
  • Europa Universalis IV
  • Cities: Skylines
  • Cities: Skylines Deluxe Edition
  • Hearts of Iron II: Beta
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rights of Man
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rule Britannia
  • Cities: Skylines - Parklife Pre-Order
  • Cities: Skylines - Parklife
Two of the most well constructed updates of any AAR I have ever read. :)

Firstly, the graphical detail provided is both easy on the eye and visually impressive, not to mention helpful. Secondly, the arrestive narrative demonstrates that you have an excellent command of the subject, and is a fitful reflection of the hard work that you have evidently put into this AAR.

I shall take time to read the whole thing. Eventually. Many congratulations. :)
 

unmerged(34173)

Sergeant
Sep 10, 2004
63
0
What is so impressive is that this AAR shows that if you fight with a school of thought similar to what was used at the time the AI can really give you a run for your money. As long as you are not fielding Sherman 75's by 39 or 40 it is going to be a difficult fight when you finally intervene in Europe and China.

Thanks for the great updates!!! Can't wait to see the next chapter. Can operation Cobra be in the works??? I doubt it with the current German counterattack but we will all have to wait and see.
 

unmerged(28944)

Would-be King of Dragons
May 10, 2004
4.445
6
I see that the ground pounders in Europe are just as lacking in air support as their brethern in China were/are.

That, and like you said, the Germans are as stout, if not more, than the Japanese.... this is definetly a nasty little slugfest of a war! So when does American technology start paying off and giving the fighting man some extra firepower?
 

unmerged(19363)

Colonel
Sep 7, 2003
842
0
Visit site
RCP7: "Ouch"
Hey, there might be a bigger ouch coming.... <gulp>


Metal: I hope your soldiers hold out in Normandy...

So do they! :)


Allenby:
Thank you sir, now that we're fighting on two continents the intensity has certainly stepped up, as well as the indigestion from all these failed offensives. Grrrr.


Draco Rexus:So when does American technology start paying off and giving the fighting man some extra firepower?
Apparently not soon enough!!!!

Bigcat: What is so impressive is that this AAR shows that if you fight with a school of thought similar to what was used at the time the AI can really give you a run for your money.
I don't know if its 1.06 or what but I really did not expect such a struggle this late in the war, and I certainly can't beleive the Germans outclass us so badly.

Mettermrck: Though it's rough seeing you defeated, I'm glad to see such challenging warfare in Asia and Europe.
In a way I agree with you, last time I played as America, once 1944 came around I was about invincible, its much more exciting this way, but certainly more frustrating!

Wilhelm VI What about an landing on the Italian coast ?
My staff has repeatedly lobbied for Italy... Unless we can put a stop to the Axis rebound in France, this might be our next option.
 

unmerged(19363)

Colonel
Sep 7, 2003
842
0
Visit site
Thursday the 13th

With Paris and Orleans besieged and lost, General Bradley fully expected Caen itself to come under attack by a considerable force within the week. Reports had Romanians, Hungarians and Germans moving in from every direction. The Axis had shown themselves to be quite superior in battle in the recent weeks, collapsing the southern Allied pocket back down after initial advances, and had simply devastated the American armor in Orleans and Paris.


White's 3rd Armored had just returned to Caen in time to get rearmed, still not up to full strength they were given reserve duty along the coast for the western corps. The 4th Armored and 82nd Airborne were on the long road back to Caen from Paris, having been soundly defeated, and in many battalions, decimated. Their ammunition and supplies all but gone, it was a race for time to get back to the Allied troops before the enemy closed in around them to isolate and finish them off. They were in no shape for another fight in their condition, so when the 4th Armored began to run into the lead elements of the Axis attack force, they knew they were in for a rough ride.

The fight became known as the Battle for Caen, but for the soldiers, it was known as simply as Thursday the 13th. January had thus far been shaping up as a very cold one, and on the 13th the storms moved in ahead of the attacking forces. Winds picked up, temperatures plummeted, and the snow began to come down very hard. It was near whiteout conditions, so strong was the blizzard. It was the absolute worst of conditions to fight a well coordinated battle, for either side. The side that proved to be better at coordinating attacks would in the end prevail.

CaenJan13.jpg

The Axis Moves in With the Storm


The attacking host was comprised of six infantry divisions total. Under the overall leadership of Alfred Jodl, it was made up entirely of non German troops. The troops under German command came from the south in Rennes and Le Mans, while the northern corps under Dimutrescu attacked from the Cherbourg peninsula.

The Axis battle plan was simple, focusing primarily on the western flank of the American defenses. Out of Cherbourg in the west, the Romanian 72nd and 73rd would move eastward, the 72nd driving east along the coast, while the 73rd would assault St.Lo from the west. In a combined pincer movement, the Hungarian 2nd would drive simultaneously on the city from the south. The Hungarian 3rd would cover the 2nd's eastern flank, acting primarily in reserve. The 197th and 221st Romanian divisions under direct command of Jodl would focus their efforts on the defenses at Caen.

As the lead elements of the 221st on the right flank began to meet up with the American 4th Armor retreating from Paris, Jodl ordered them off the attack on Caen to focus fully on this beaten force. Bradley realizing the critical nature of this situation on his eastern flank, ordered Freeman's 5th Motorized in Ouistreham out of reserve to face the Romanians head on, to act as a defensive barrier, allowing the 4th Armored and 82nd Airborne an opportunity to slip behind them and escape encirclement.

CaenSituationmap1.jpg

Axis Plan of Attack and American Adjustments

This tactic had its difficulties in the harsh weather however, as two divisions were trying to go in opposite directions, crossing paths, all while under assault from a fresh enemy. Confusion reigned supreme in the American maneuvers as the 5th Motorized and 4th Armored became tangled up and bogged down in bottlenecks as the hard to find, narrow snow covered roads became clogged with thousands of troops heading in different directions. Considering the difficult task assigned him, Freeman did a remarkable job getting his forces through the tangle and into a firm battle line. His task however was made harder by the fact that his division was still feeling the effects from their failed battle in Rouen days earlier. Despite the attempt to cover their flank, 4th Armored continued to take considerable fire from the Romanian 221st, and as the 82nd then arrived on the scene, they too came under the same devastating fire.

Bradley's 35th Infantry Division was responsible for the defense of Caen, and with Jodl breaking off one of the divisions to go after the retreating American troops from Paris, that left merely the 197th to assault the city. Dug in, the 35th was able to thwart the attack, although in the blizzard the enemy was able to conceal themselves in the weather until they were close upon the defenses, and much hand to hand and small arms fire broke out within the town. The weather held one great advantage to the Axis: They knew where the American forces were, while the Americans were unable to pin down the exact location of the mobile, advancing enemy. Axis artillery was able to center on critical regions of the defenses, while in return the American artillery was unable to return anything more than blind pot shots, which did little damage.



In the early hours of the battle, it was clear that despite the horrible weather, the attackers were well equipped for fighting in such conditions, and it was well apparent the Americans were not. On the western flank the Romanian Corps under Dimutrescu smashed eastward towards St. Lo. Their leftmost brigade tasked with attacking Omaha beach however was thwarted by Arnold's 78th. Omaha was a key position that was well guarded by the Americans, as securing the coast was vital to its supplies coming in. The attackers had the most success around St.Lo, where the pincer attack was way too much for Rankin's 26th Infantry to handle. Sensing a gap in the lines between St.Lo and Caen, Jodl ordered up the reserve Hungarian 3rd to advance between the two towns. White's 3rd Armor in Bayeux was called up to help fill this vital gap and stem the advance. Like the 5th Motorized, they were not in prime shape for the attack after their defeat in Orleans, but did remarkably well considering the makeshift circumstance they were thrown into.

CaenJan14.jpg


St.Lo was however the weak point. With the 3rd Armored now committed to their east, Rankin realized he did not have any reserves to fall back on. Taking considerable damage from the combined attack, he relinquished the city relatively early in the fight and began to fall back towards Bayeux.

With the precarious position Fourth Army was in, surrounded on all fronts, combined with the weather not playing to their advantage as he thought it might, Bradley called for the American fleet on the English coast. Recognizing in advance the possible need to evacuate, it had been off the British coast in Coventry prepared for just such an action. By the morning of the 14th, the big guns and the transports all began to arrive in a hasty and disorganized fashion, but at least now if the battle did go wrong, the troops would not be stranded.

The big guns blasting away from offshore were no doubt an inspiration to the men in the trenches. First order of business for the American left flank was to continue covering fire for the retreating 4th Armor and get them behind the lines into reserve and onto the safety of the transports if possible. They were of no use in the battle anymore.

Around midnight on the 14th, the 82nd Airborne returning from Paris likewise came upon the force that was focusing on eliminating the 4th Armor. By now the 5th Motorized had come under such heavy attack in defending the 4th Armor's retreat they themselves were completely unfit for battle. Now completely out of ammunition the general retreat for 5th Motorized in tandem with the 82nd division back behind the lines toward the coast was given.

The 26th Infantry under Rankin continued to retreat, despite Bradley's orders to hold at all costs. If they fell back, the defenses at Omaha would become vulnerable to an Axis flanking attack. Unhappy with the performance of the 26th during the battle, and outraged at the continued retreat, Bradley relieved Rankin of command, replacing him with the assistant commander Mj.Gen. Blackmore. This did little to change the tide though as the 26th in their retreat had become unglued and were decimated by artillery fire, breaking ranks on many fronts. Inevitably they were pulled from the front, and Arnold's 78th on the coast had to commit their leftmost regiment to cover the front vacated by the 26th. Down now on manpower, his division began to feel the heat from a 3 division attack, and now began to crumble and fall back as well.


By noon Saturday, four divisions had been pulled from the lines and began embarking in the severe blizzard onto boats in the icy high seas, to be loaded onto the larger transports further out. This left the 3rd Armored, the 35th and 78th Infantry as the only ones on the front, trying against hope to hold off 6 nearly invincible divisions, buying time for the other divisions to be boarded and saved.

CaenJan15.jpg

By 2 p.m, it was clear all was lost. The final defense around the town of Caen was abandoned and a rear guard action was begun towards the coast where there was a frantic pace to scramble onto anything that floated and paddle out to the fleet. The big guns of the American and British navies began pounding the area just ahead of the rear guard elements which afforded them some distance from their pursuers. The majority of the fleeing forces were in this way able to retreat to the ships safely as the big guns seemed to concentrate their fire on anything that approached the beaches. Due to the stormy conditions on the sea coupled with the frantic and haphazard retreat from remnants of 7 divisions, several hundred men were lost as boats were sunk or capsized. German field artillery being pulled within range began to focus on the beaches and the water close by. It was a terrible, one sided affair.

Bradley himself, completely distraught at how his entire campaign had so swiftly come apart, ordered his 35th HQ division to be the final division to be withdrawn, trying to hold off the advancing enemy, affording a rearguard for the 78th and 3rd Armored to clamor aboard the ships.

With continued fire from the big guns, the 35th Division finally began its retreat to the ships. Merely the logistical confusion of an overly swift advance coupled with the whiteout conditions caused the enemy from pursuing and decimating the remaining divisions. By the end of the day, it was over. The region of Caen now was occupied by six Axis divisions, with an enormous amount of carnage littering the area. From their hasty retreat, the Americans had left behind an enormous amount of tanks, vehicles and supplies. As he boarded the ships and looked back at the carnage on the shore behind, it came to Bradley: Eighth Army had only stood on European soil for 15 days.


The Fallout of Eighth Army's Demise


As after every disaster or large defeat, change will always come as a result of it. When the European Expeditionary Force was first formed, it was created completely from what was either home guard forces or those regiments just being activated. There were no divisions or commanders included which had fought and gained experience in the Pacific. The whole of Eighth Army in effect was green when it landed in France. Wanting experienced soldiers to help the green troops and commanders in Eighth Army, when the troops were back in England, Marshall decided to bring over some veteran leadership from the Asian campaign. General Adams, who had commanded VI Mountain Corps in Kowloon was given command of the much disheveled 25th Infantry Division, with Gen. Blackmore returned to assistant CO. Despite his quite capable leadership during the fighting near Omaha, General A.V. Arnold was relieved as CO of the 78th Infantry, and was replaced with General Simpson, another veteran of the Pacific.

However the most important replacement, and probably most expected came shortly after the troops returned to England. Historians may argue it was a matter of choosing a scapegoat for such a horrendous defeat, that Bradley was quite a capable leader and administrator. But the fact of the matter was, as commander of an entire seven division Army, his forces dug in with a fierce winter storm to aid the defense, were completely routed with over 38,000 soldiers either killed or taken prisoner, unable to get back to the boats. Thousands more were in English hospitals recovering from their battle wounds. The toll on equipment was equally devastating. Hundreds of tanks were destroyed in a line from Paris to Caen. Large ammunition dumps left behind were demo'd and destroyed. Because of the quick exit from the continent, the majority of equipment that was not on peoples back was left behind or burned. In the confusion of the retreat no doubt more than a few important command papers were left for the advancing Romanians to find.

From battle reports afterwards it was pieced together that despite the horrid losses incurred on the Americans, they inflicted very little on the attackers. All Axis units were still in fine fighting form after they had regained Caen. In short, the entire operation was a complete and utter disaster. And to boot, these were not crack German troops that had run over the Americans, this was done by primarily Romanian and Hungarian forces. It was simply the biggest black eye for the United States in the war.



BradleyStillwell.jpg

Stillwell replaces Bradley at Eighth Army


General Bradley had been unable to coordinate with his British counterparts despite spending nearly a year on the island, unable to convince them to lend a hand in a joint operation in Normandy. He had pushed for a landing in Normandy despite getting no help or much needed manpower from the Allies as would be necessary to defend against what would be a massive retaliation by the Germans. While it was true Marshall gave the final order to invade, it was Bradley's task to coordinate with the English, and his relation with the English command and with Churchill had been severely strained. The most telling fact of his failure was that his Eighth Army had stood on Continental soil for merely 15 days! Omar Bradley was replaced as commander of Eighth Army by Vinegar Joe Stillwell, he who had commanded Fifth Army in Xiamen during the long stalemate. Bradley was sent back to America completely disgraced, and after standing before a review board, was demoted in rank to Major General.