[The Resistance] Game 48: The Sabotage of Stalingrad

[madchemist]

There is a risk though.

Not from picking me for a team, there isn't.

But fine, conceding your point for the moment, this is a game where every team selection carries with it some amount of risk. The job of every player is to work on figuring out which risks are most likely to pay off by thinking logically about who is and who is not a likely spy. Lazy lines of argumentation like that are either the actions of a spy or work to their benefit.

 

[EnvyDemon]

Not from picking me for a team, there isn't.

But fine, conceding your point for the moment, this is a game where every team selection carries with it some amount of risk. The job of every player is to work on figuring out which risks are most likely to pay off by thinking logically about who is and who is not a likely spy. Lazy lines of argumentation like that are either the actions of a spy or work to their benefit.

TBH you were on both sabotaged missions. You have to admit it is suspicious.

 

[Health]

I feel kind of odd being on this team, though I have not been on previous missions I can understand where the paranoia about me comes from, due to the proposition and the weird approvals. I seem to be the wildcard on this mission and I don't see a reason why Audren should've put me on this team, besides what he said. Besides me of course this team seems decent. Ironhide seems clean for now and so does wombat due to the previous mission. I have no ideas about Audren though. Though because I am on it I'll.

APPROVE

 

[Ironhead 5]

Ironhide seems clean for now and so does wombat due to the previous mission. I have no ideas about Audren though.

What does this mean? Ironhide seems clean "for now"??? And wombat is clean due to the previous mission??? What, the one that failed?

 

[Health]

What does this mean? Ironhide seems clean "for now"??? And wombat is clean due to the previous mission??? What, the one that failed?

Wombat is possibly clean due to his card being support, I have no trust for anybody at this point, especially not my self. wombat is currently clean due to opening up to Ironhide, if Ironhide turns out to be a spy then the chance of wombat also being one shoot through the roof. Ironhide seems currently clean due to being a person that has revealed information, again if he turns out to be a spy then more of my possible theories fly overboard.

 

[madchemist]

TBH you were on both sabotaged missions. You have to admit it is suspicious.

Not when you take basic math and logic into account, no.

Wombat is possibly clean due to his card being support,

You have no way of knowing this. (Possibly you mean aedan?)

I have no trust for anybody at this point, especially not my self.

Why on earth would you not trust yourself?

wombat is currently clean due to opening up to Ironhide, if Ironhide turns out to be a spy then the chance of wombat also being one shoot through the roof.

True.

Ironhide seems currently clean due to being a person that has revealed information, again if he turns out to be a spy then more of my possible theories fly overboard.

Revealing information has no bearing at all on a player's spyhood (or lack thereof). Since not revealing information received in cards only helps the spies, every player who receives such information has to reveal it or else is assumed to be a spy.

 

[EnvyDemon]

General Newb Question.

Can spies opt out of sabotaging to make themselves look innocent?

 

[Team Wombat]

General Newb Question.

Can spies opt out of sabotaging to make themselves look innocent?

yes. So there might have been multiple spies on one/both of the previous missions, but only one spy chose to sabotage.

 

[EnvyDemon]

yes. So there might have been multiple spies on one/both of the previous missions, but only one spy chose to sabotage.

Alright then. I'll take this into account.

 

[Jacksonian Missionary]

Audren's mission of himself, Ironhide, health, and DBW is rejected 4-6

Approved: audren, Ironhide, jerman, health,

Rejected: aedan, mc, dbw, IH, luftwafer, falc

@Ironhide G1 , you propose the next mission

 

[Ironhide G1]

Ohhh... Now comes the worst Resistance leader in history. I would like to ask you all for suggestions for the team, so I don't end up making a horrible decision and ruining the game.

 

[EnvyDemon]

Ohhh... Now comes the worst Resistance leader in history. I would like to ask you all for suggestions for the team, so I don't end up making a horrible decision and ruining the game.

You know Wombat is resistance so I'd use him.

I know for sure I'm resistance, I'd recommend that I'd come, however it probably won't be approved that way.

 

[Ironhide G1]

Well I do know myself and deathbywombat. Still have no idea on the other 2 though

 

[Jacksonian Missionary]

Ohhh... Now comes the worst Resistance leader in history. I would like to ask you all for suggestions for the team, so I don't end up making a horrible decision and ruining the game.

The confidence here is overwhelming

 

[aedan777]

I should be on the team, since it's confirmed I didn't sabotage the mission two team. The fourth member of the team is tricky, but I think Ironhead's the best bet. He's been less suspicious than everyone else, and has a decent record of voting, I think.

 

[Team Wombat]

Ohhh... Now comes the worst Resistance leader in history. I would like to ask you all for suggestions for the team, so I don't end up making a horrible decision and ruining the game.

Please stop saying things like this (you and every other player who plays the I'm a noob card), which make me and everyone else want to ignore you. You're solid in real life resistance games, so I know you have the ability to analyze effectively.

As for the team...

You and I have to be on it, obviously. Aedan I'm inclined to agree should be on the team as well, as it would have been hard to coordinate a sabotage with that card being played on Aedan when Audren proposed the team, (especially with Ironhead trying to hide it in plain sight - clever). The way Ironhead played that card makes me want to trust Ironhead as well.

 

[EnvyDemon]

I'm not going to be approving a team with Ironhead on it, as I am suspicious of him.

 

[Ironhide G1]

OK team:

Ironhide G1
deathbywombat
Aedan777
JermanTK

APPROVE

 

[aedan777]

Oh for the love of- why put Jerman on it? Seriously, why?

Reject

 

[EnvyDemon]

Oh for the love of- why put Jerman on it? Seriously, why?

Reject

Why do people always assume I'm a spy.

I trust this team, the only way we can fail is if you are a spy, which I hope isn't the case.

Approve