Reject
Aedan did a lot of the legwork re the Daffius/Audren claims, but there's a few things to add. Let's assume Daffius is right and Audren is a spy. Then Falc has to be a spy also. Mission 1 passes to throw people off the scent. Mission 2 crashes and burns, and Daffius is set up as a fall guy for proposing the mission. So far, so good. The problem is that round 3 Falc votes down a proposed mission (aedan's team: audren/jackson/aedan/deathbywombat) that would pass with his vote (it failed 5-5) - a proposed mission with AT LEAST one spy on it (Audren). Maybe he knows that I'm a spy and will propose a bad mission next round, but Panzer Commander took Falc's no confidence card, and said he was going to do so. Maybe he knows that Panzer Commander is a spy, will take the card, and will sabotage the next mission if it goes bad. Maybe Panzer and I are both spies, but why on earth would I propose a mission with 3 spies, especially since it's my first game and I don't know the coordination rules? Falc is taking a highly unnecessary risk by voting down a sure sabotage if he's a spy. Also, Daffius apparently voted for my proposed mission in PM, rejecting it publicly yet approving it in private. Why would he do that?
Add this to the fact that Ironhead used the KACEOY card and said that Audren voted a clean mission. Is he lying too, and therefore a spy? I suppose it's possible - this would essentially mean the spies have had every card this entire game, in which case, all I can say is well played. The spy team would likely be Audren/Falc/Ironhead/Panzer (or myself, I suppose) in that case.
Also note that Panzer now has at least one No confidence card, which he took from Falc with the Take Responsibility card. (Audren has the other one now, fyi - so we might want to get a move on a team...) This seems to indicate that he doesn't know Falc's role. However, he (Panzer Commander) believes Audren over Daffius, even though that requires Falc to be a good guy, and now puts him on a team. Odd, if you ask me. Add to that the fact that he gets on a sabotaged mission that passes 8-2 with 4 votes switching to his side... I have to conclude that he's a spy, and that putting him on any mission or accpeting any mission of his would be borderline lunacy.
Aedan did a lot of the legwork re the Daffius/Audren claims, but there's a few things to add. Let's assume Daffius is right and Audren is a spy. Then Falc has to be a spy also. Mission 1 passes to throw people off the scent. Mission 2 crashes and burns, and Daffius is set up as a fall guy for proposing the mission. So far, so good. The problem is that round 3 Falc votes down a proposed mission (aedan's team: audren/jackson/aedan/deathbywombat) that would pass with his vote (it failed 5-5) - a proposed mission with AT LEAST one spy on it (Audren). Maybe he knows that I'm a spy and will propose a bad mission next round, but Panzer Commander took Falc's no confidence card, and said he was going to do so. Maybe he knows that Panzer Commander is a spy, will take the card, and will sabotage the next mission if it goes bad. Maybe Panzer and I are both spies, but why on earth would I propose a mission with 3 spies, especially since it's my first game and I don't know the coordination rules? Falc is taking a highly unnecessary risk by voting down a sure sabotage if he's a spy. Also, Daffius apparently voted for my proposed mission in PM, rejecting it publicly yet approving it in private. Why would he do that?
Add this to the fact that Ironhead used the KACEOY card and said that Audren voted a clean mission. Is he lying too, and therefore a spy? I suppose it's possible - this would essentially mean the spies have had every card this entire game, in which case, all I can say is well played. The spy team would likely be Audren/Falc/Ironhead/Panzer (or myself, I suppose) in that case.
Also note that Panzer now has at least one No confidence card, which he took from Falc with the Take Responsibility card. (Audren has the other one now, fyi - so we might want to get a move on a team...) This seems to indicate that he doesn't know Falc's role. However, he (Panzer Commander) believes Audren over Daffius, even though that requires Falc to be a good guy, and now puts him on a team. Odd, if you ask me. Add to that the fact that he gets on a sabotaged mission that passes 8-2 with 4 votes switching to his side... I have to conclude that he's a spy, and that putting him on any mission or accpeting any mission of his would be borderline lunacy.
Last edited:
.png){kind=avatar}
) when I was a spy: