I did everything correctly installing it but when I try to load it says excel file not found
Karagin said:I weighed the options and went with nope sorry total conquest is the only answer. Well later I get this window saying that my army in Chattanooga has been wiped out and front line has broken open, well the CSA had no troops in Chattanooga and I didn't lose any units, not that I can tell. So what gives with the second message?
Also why is the CSA so free in sending troops and planes and ships to help the Brits? And never recalls them to help defend the CSA?
HMS Enterprize said:Could you give a bit more info...was this an 'your army has dissolved due to lack of supply message' (or something like that?)? Could you elaborate on what you mean by 'broken open' also.
I dont think there is anything event wise that should be coming into play here but the more info you can provide perhaps I can work it out.
Karagin said:The Army was newly formed, it had supplies and was moving through the area to link up with some units in Atlanta, which I had just captured. When the message appeared:
"Enemy Breakthrough" Enemy units have broken through the line in Chattanooga, your army was wiped out, front lines broken wide open.
That was in one of the normal message boxes. I will re-check the history file to see what else was going on.
Alright, I rechecked the history file and here is the message it shows:
1946-08-17 : 15:00 September 18, 1946 : Our army in Chattanooga has been completely annihilated!
That was the end result of the message I am trying to describe. Yet nothing happened. I didn't lose any units, and the CSA didn't coming charging through the area either.
FADM_Antonov said:Question;
How did you black out the Gulf of Panama? While I'm sure it's an interesting change due to the lack of the US having the ability to build it (blah blah CSA blah blah blah), I'd like to know how to put it back.
Karagin said:The Army was newly formed, it had supplies and was moving through the area to link up with some units in Atlanta, which I had just captured. When the message appeared:
"Enemy Breakthrough" Enemy units have broken through the line in Chattanooga, your army was wiped out, front lines broken wide open.
That was in one of the normal message boxes. I will re-check the history file to see what else was going on.
Alright, I rechecked the history file and here is the message it shows:
1946-08-17 : 15:00 September 18, 1946 : Our army in Chattanooga has been completely annihilated!
That was the end result of the message I am trying to describe. Yet nothing happened. I didn't lose any units, and the CSA didn't coming charging through the area either.
Agelastus said:Had you started to reorganise units in Chattanooga and then thought better of it?
That message appears when a human player has left a zero unit army formation in existence with no leader following a reorganisation, in my experience.
Karagin said:Shouldn't they make a go of trying to get some of them back either through alliances or out right invasions?
HMS Enterprize said:Well, in my imagination they would have had to recognise their former colonies sovereignty at the peace table. The UK (even a right wing one) doesnt really strike me as one that initiates agressive war without good reason (look how long Hitler got to stomp over Europe before we waded in!).
I also wanted to alter the perspective of most of the states in the game somewhat for this mod. ie- UK in this TL can focus much more, while Germany has taken up the OTL UK role of a dispearsed empire to protect.
I am tinkering with some ideas regarding India for the next release, if that counts!?
lwarmonger said:Hey, it has been a while since I've played this mod (or HOI 2 for that matter), but I was just rereading "The Grapple," and as I recall this mod had the confederates with aircraft carriers. That never made much sense to me, but I didn't recall the books mentioning it one way or another, however I just ran across something that would seem to say that they don't have them.
"As far as Sam knew- as far as anybody in the U.S. Navy knew- the Confederates had no airplane carriers. It made sense that they wouldn't; they didn't need that kind of navy. Land based air and coast-defense ships could keep the United States from mounting major operations against them and submarines let them strike at the USA from far away." The Grapple, page 172
Karagin said:Wasn't there something about them working on one? Or that could have been a smoke screen kind of thing.
lwarmonger said:Well, that quote came from about the time General Morrell started pushing into Kentucky, so if they hadn't started turning them out by then, I can't imagine that they would (what with everything going into the ground and air to stop the North). Besides, given the war that the Confederates were fighting, it wouldn't really make sense for them to have carriers, especially when the British and French have to have them to keep their supply lines open. For the Confederates they would be an expensive luxury.
Just think, in the actual WWII, only the United States and Japan had real carriers, and Britain was the only other nation to build even smaller models. I understand why more nations would have them in the Settling Accounts timeline, but it doesn't make a whole lot of sense for the Confederacy.
HMS Enterprize said:The whole carrier thing was covered in the latest readme but will be edited for the next version of the mod once 'In at the Death' comes out.
And that RL carrier info is not exactly true. Germany's carrier was near 90% complete, Canada operated the admitedly smaller escort carriers (Australia I think too) and the USA's real carriers certainly took much design inspiration from british builds.