The 1936 election crisis
The 1936 election was hotly contested, and it only grew fiercer as the day approached. All three candidates had devolved from policy debates to personal attacks on one another by September. By November they were reduced to name calling. Truman called Long an uncompromising white elitist who would reduce America to a one party dictatorship, and Long in turn accused him of being a religious fanatic who would help "blacks, browns, and yellows" gain equal rights but would do nothing for the poor white man on the street. Borah called both of them destructive radicals who would wipe out American freedom and democracy if they were permitted in power. Long responded by calling him, along with the rest of the Republican party, a corporate fatcat.
Long delivering his famous "Republican fatcats" speech
The election day itself was incredibly chaotic. Kingfish were mostly responsible for the chaos, but not the sole cause. Huge numbers of blacks blockaded voting booths in Northern and Western cities, refusing to let anyone through who did not promise to vote for Truman (who had promised to expand civil rights, among other things). A pro-Republican newspaper in Massachusetts printed a false story that Long had been assassinated and the election postponed. Rumors of bribery by every party were present in every state. Members of The Militia intimidated and assaulted Jews and businessmen as they came to vote. Members of the SOWS led "election marches" to support Long, many of which devolved into riots.
The SOWS on an election march
New York was were the election was most violent. All three parties had a base of active support in the city. Blacks led marches to support Truman, Henry Ford's branch of The Militia roamed the city, and hundreds upon hundreds of posters supporting Borah were printed by the city's newspapers. If that was not enough, a fire broke out in the city that firefighters were unable to control. Its cause is unknown, but much of the city burned to the ground and many voters never got the the ballot boxes. In the end, 20,000 people were homeless and much of city's businesses had been burned.
The wall of smoke advances in New York
The 1936 election thus had the dubious honor of being America's most destructive, and also one of the lowest voter turnouts in American history, with only 35% of voters reaching the ballots. But never the less, the results were in, and the chaos was over. Or so Americans thought...
Harry S. Truman (Democrat)
Popular vote: 13,087,035 (29.2%)
Electoral Collage: 93 (17.5%)
Although Truman won an incredible 86% of the black vote, along with large numbers of other ethnic minorities, they still remained minorities, and he only carried five states, California, Oregon, Washington, Colorado, and his home state of Missouri. The Democrats had simply been too weak after the split to contest any others. The traditionally Democratic South had joined Long as well.
William Edgar Borah (Republican)
Popular vote: 15,776,151 (35.2%)
Electoral Collage: 219 (41.2%)
Borah's attempts to distance himself from Hoover had apparently worked. He carried virtually all of the Midwest and most of the North. His success showed that there was still plenty of moderation within the American people. Not everyone was willing to go radical for the sake of rapid economic improvement, and people still had faith in moderate government and capitalism.
Huey Long (New Democrat/Kingfish)
Popular vote: 15,955,426 (35.6%)
Electoral Collage: 219 (41.2%)
To say that Huey Long won by the skin of his teeth does not really do his victory justice. Technically he did not win at all. He had, as expected, swept the South, and got the better of the contested vote in New York. He was tied with Borah in terms of the electoral collage, and only got 0.4% more of the popular vote. This did not stop him from boldly announcing his victory over national radio however, stating that the Kingfish had triumphed.
Long's triumphant arrival at a "victory" party
In reality, it was now up to the House of Representatives, many of them brand new, to determine who would become President. They had until March 4th, 1937 to decide.