Friends And Foes
San Francisco, California, January 20th 1861
San Francisco had never been a well-fortified city. The approaches to the Californian capital had been designed for beauty, and for ease of access, but not to arrest the approach of an army. Its defences now were nothing more than hastily-constructed wooden barricades dotted about the roads heading into the Bay, with soldiers whose faces betrayed the reality that was hidden within each: not a shot had been heard, and yet already they were beaten men.
Towards one such stockade, the solitary figure of a weary horseman slowly trotted at an exhausted stagger. The face of the rider was dirtied, haggard and grim- but it at least did not seem so devoid of hope as those it approached.
A shout, audibly lacking in conviction, rang out from the soldiers. “¡
Parada!” It echoed back from its target to the barricade, but the horse did not obey. It kept coming. “
Señor! You are advancing on the positions of the Fourth Army of the Republic of California! Declare yourself,
señor!” The horseman kept coming. “¿
Amigo o enemigo, señor?” They could see his face, his features clearly. He was staring at them blankly, almost disbelieving. “¡
Parada!”
Another voice overruled the first. “General?” At last the horseman responded, his head turning sharply in the direction of the call. The voice called again, its owner running out in front of the barricade, his face disbelieving. “General del Serrano?”
“Colonel Hamann?” Came the reply at last, the dishevelled rider finally breaking his silence. He turned in the saddle and slid down off the horse, offering the man who had addressed him a hand which the other took and shook warmly. “Colonel Christian Hamann!” Said Don Alejandro, smiling for the first time in weeks.
Hamann turned to his comrades, waving a hand for them to lower their rifles, still held apprehensively high in the direction of the newcomer. “Enough, boys!” He barked. “Don Alejandro del Serrano,” he indicated the aristocrat with his thumb, “commander of the First Army, Hero of the Republic and a heap of other nonsense like that.” His men, nervous, exchanged quick glances in the hope of reassurance. “Oh, cheer up!” Continued Hamann. “This
here’s what we call a real soldier!”
Don Alejandro laughed, but it didn’t last long as guilt at his moment of ease and memory of sorrow overwhelmed him. Moving to drown out his thoughts, he spoke. “So what in God’s name are you doing manning this…” he struggled for a word, considering the fortification with a wave of the hand, “this fence!”
Hamann laughed heartily. “Well, if only I knew…” He cast an eye warily back to his men, as though not sure whether they could cope with such damning testimony of their task. “The point of our mission,” he began again, putting on a show of confidence, “is to defend this road against the approach of the rebel army.”
“Rebel?” Inquired Alejandro with a frown.
“We’ve been led to believe, Your Excellency, that Don Tibalto Barja’s army will be prancing down towards us from thereabouts,” he pointed eastwards, inland, “any day now.”
“And this is going to stop them?” Don Alejandro cast an uncertain eye over the rickety wooden defences before him.
“This,” replied Hamann, with a sardonic grin that suggested he couldn’t quite believe what he himself was saying, “is just a precautionary measure. See, it is the view of the Emergency Government that the rebels are about to burn themselves out.” Alejandro gazed at him disbelievingly, but the colonel confirmed his fears. “Yes, altogether too much easy victory and lack of resistance- it can’t last, can it?”
“I don’t believe they think that.” Replied Alejandro darkly. “What
idiot could seriously believe something like that?”
***************
Juan Bautista Alvarado waved an imperious hand, commanding the other occupants of the room to silence. It was, quite consciously, the gesture of a great statesman at the peak of his powers. “Don Alejandro, I do not see quite where you have garnered the authority to speak like this- you just come galloping out of the mist and declare that we need to alter our plans.” There was a coldness in his voice when addressing Alejandro that the Don remembered from their last meetings. “There are reasons why we are acting as we are.”
“What reasons?” Demanded Alejandro. “What possible reasons?”
“Don Alejandro,” began Alvarado- his voice rising as though he knew that the moment for a great piece of oratory had come, “you have obviously failed to understand the nature of the threat we are facing. This is a very ferocious rebellion, one that manifests itself through energetic action and gestures of cruelty of which we have heard so much.” Here Alvarado’s gaze lingered on a thick-set soldier standing back from the table, before he continued. “However, it is also not a rebellion that can survive for long. The people’s inherent desire for liberty will shine through, and this rebellion will fail. Tyranny cannot be perpetuated, and it shall not be in this case. You accuse us of doing nothing, yet this is not the case. We are waiting, true, but this is not the same as idleness. Because what we are waiting for will be the decisive moment in the conclusion of this conflict: once the natural instinct of the people to struggle against tyranny is activated, once they learn that they have everything to lose in the event of a rebel victory, the situation for our enemies will become untenable. This is what we are waiting for: a simultaneous popular backlash against what it taking place in our country. A spontaneous manifestation of the will of the people.”
“Do you think that is likely?” Alejandro struggled to ask.
“It is not
likely, Don Alejandro, it is a social and a moral certainty. It cannot be avoided.”
“But…” Alejandro stuttered. “But if we marched the Fourth Army out to fight a proper campaign, all military advantage would be on our side. We would prevent the enemy armies from uniting, so that we could destroy them individually, we would restore the confidence of parts of the army that have already lost faith, and we would eliminate the currently considerable risk of becoming trapped in San Francisco. We have everything to gain! And furthermore, I don’t see what we have to lose!”
“Then you are a fool!” Snapped Alvarado. “We cannot fight a war against these people- they are not a sovereign entity! This is a conflict that must be resolved by popular uprising: only then will it be the inclination of the people that has decided the outcome, and only then will they be galvanised in support of the Republic. We must not have a repeat of the last decade of our history- where the forces of tyranny have been allowed to gain ground so easily. We
must demonstrate to the people that the result of making deals with these odious characters is
always suffering and oppression, which is why it must be
popular action that brings about the defeat of these rebels.”
“I think it would be wise to
stop calling them ‘rebels’,” retorted Alejandro, “as they are already in possession of more of the country than the government holds.” He turned to the rest of the Emergency Cabinet, gathered around the table in the office that had once been, and was now again, Alvarado’s. “
Caballeros, I assure you, I was at Santa Maria and I have seen the Royalist army- they must be confronted with military action, and it must be now!”
“Well, how predictable.” Snarled Alvarado. “Don Alejandro del Serrano advocates the swashbuckling solution- didn’t de la Vega’s demise teach you anything? These disputes, if resolved by one elite fighting against another, will cause only more disputes: there must be a popular movement, or the same corruption of the state that occurred after 1850 will occur again.”
“So that is it?” Retorted Alejandro. “You only desire the Republic’s survival if it is a Republic that will always elect you?”
“How dare you!” Growled Alvarado, his eyes narrowing. “I am trying to do what is best for this country!” Again, he drew himself up- self-consciously the great orator. “It is not I but you and your ilk who have brought the Republic to this disaster, I have merely been called to save it. You may accuse me of cowardice or of self-interest, but of the two of us, I am not the one who has helped to instigate a civil war! Just because I do not favour your opinion does not mean I am engaged in some kind of conspiracy! Has it ever occurred to you, Don Alejandro, that you might just be wrong? There are other men here who have agreed with my course of action- soldiers, and men who have suffered at the hands of your friends and relatives! Perhaps you would care to speak to them? Perhaps you would care to ask General Morgan what he thinks?”
The thick-set man who Alvarado had considered earlier looked up as Alejandro turned to stare at him. “
General Morgan?” The Don repeated. “I beg your pardon, but when I heard that rumour you were only a colonel…”
“I was promoted.” Replied General Henry Morgan shortly, and without humour. His voice was low, his manner course and his expression aggressive. “And what President Alvarado says is right- I agreed with him. We can easily hold the capital from the south, and they cannot approach from the north and east because our guns can cover Oakland and Sausalito- they’ll never get close. Furthermore, I think there’s a grave risk involved in marching out to fight the rebels on open ground- particularly before our other forces have re-grouped. And, if I may say so, I don’t think having a Don encourage us to attack will sway the minds of many.”
“Excuse me, General?”
“I’ll say it in plain English, Don Alejandro: there’s no reason for us to trust you or anyone like you.”
“Excuse me?”
“You’re a Don. By rights you should be on their side, and God knows why you’re not. Perhaps you are, who knows?”
Alejandro’s expression darkened. “General Morgan,” he replied quietly, “I understand the misfortune that has befallen you, and so I hope I know the origin of that remark. But let me assure you that you have no idea what you are talking about- and cannot begin to understand the matter which you are attempting to discuss.” His tone was so bitter that for a moment it seemed as if he might elicit a reaction- an apology even- from Henry Morgan, but instead the man finally shrugged.
“I have faith in President Alvarado’s abilities, Don Alejandro.” He said simply.
“Then-” Alejandro started, but Alvarado cut him off.
“Don Alejandro! If you wish to aid the Republic, then you will do as you are asked. The First Division of cavalry is your command, as befits your rank- though given your actions and your origins it is more than you deserve. Will you accept the commission?”
Alejandro’s head dropped, his desire to argue his case seemingly exhausted at last. “
Si.”
“
Bueno. Then we shall have no more arguing our course of action. We will hold the capital, and await the spontaneous manifestation of the people’s desire for liberty. Holding the city will be the beacon around which they may rally.”
“One more question?” Asked Alejandro, his tone utterly defeated. Alvarado waved a magnanimous hand, inviting him to speak. “What will we do if there is no spontaneous manifestation?”
“Don Alejandro, if the people are unwilling to stand up and claim their liberty, then they do not deserve to have it.” There was a pause. Henry Morgan nodded grimly. Alvarado finally spoke again: “Meeting adjourned,
caballeros.”