(Redux note: This should have taken place before Sean and Scallini's final interview.)
3 July 1440, Afternoon – Near Cerbaia
Antonio Scallini, minor Florentine noble and aide-de-camp to Gualtiero Alberti, was undergoing the most trying interrogation of his life since the age of 14 when his mother caught him in the rose bushes with one of the parlor maids. At the moment, he stood before the intimidating combination of the mercenary commander, known simply as Captain, and Bishop Bertilucci. Surrounding him were, he correctly assumed, the lieutenants of the vaunted Free Company. The Free Company which he embarrassed on the field of battle. Something told him he was not among friends. Conspicuous by his absence was Sean O'Glaigh.
Scallini still didn't know what to make of the appearance of de Celta. If he and the bishop needed an escort, why couldn't they get an escort from Lord Cosimo? But since they weren't the ones being questioned, there was no point debating that question now. So he tucked it away and turned to the more pressing question of how he was to survive this incident without ruining his position or reputation.
"Who ordered the attack?" Captain was going to handle this interrogation himself.
"I will not lie to you, gentlemen." He addressed each member of the congregation in turn. "My lord, Gualtiero Alberti, ordered the attack. However, I should add that he is not to blame."
The thought of selling out Alberti came to mind immediately and was thrown out just as quickly. When the Free Company leaves, he would again be at the mercy of Alberti's dictates. Perhaps he could claim ignorance and say he was simply following orders? Possibly, but they could still conceivably lay some of the responsibility at his feet for not questioning the order. No, the way out is to dodge all responsibility by saying they had been duped and lay the entire crime on someone else. Using a story they couldn't corroborate. It would only require twisting the facts, and he was quite confident in his abilities of being economical with the truth. After all, his wide was still none the wiser, and he had been carrying on for at least four years...
"You speak in riddles," commented his Holiness.
"What I mean, your grace, is that Alberti did, indeed, order the attack. He raised the peasant levy in preparation of the attack. He planned the ambush." Scallini noted with pleasure that, at the word "ambush," the faces of the Free Company officers became a notch more grim. Sooner you than me, Alberti. "He ordered the plan put into action when he heard you were about to pass Rocco Cerbaia."
"And you say Alberti is not to blame?"
Scallini answered with an ingratiating smile that completely failed to find a chink in the armor. "I was getting to that. Signore Alberti did all this for the most altruistic reasons." This explanation raised a few eyebrows among the Free Company offers who wondered how killing their men would benefit humankind. "You see, the countryside is in a uproar over the murder of Signora Catherine de Medici. She was a much beloved figure by our people. They wanted blood. We wanted blood." This raised a few more eyebrows.
"You see, this rider came through days ago, spreading news of the heinous crime and declaring that men responsible – the Free Company – were coming our way. The way he told his story, it sounded like a man or men from your company had been caught in the act. Since there was nothing to argue the contrary, we believed him. And so it was up to us to bring the fugitives to justice. This rider, who has long since left, is the one responsible for the attack. We are more sinned against than sinned. In fact, I believe our people have suffered ten times more casualties than yours."
"You could have simply asked us to halt rather than attack us."
"If you please, signore, put yourself in our position. We could only muster a fraction of your force, most of them conscripts at that. Would two thousand heavily armed fugitives stop simply because we asked them to stop? The idea is laughable."
"So you decided to attack us instead? It seems like the blood of your conscripts is more on your hands than ours."
Scallini shrugged. "Possibly. But who knows what they would have done if left to their own devices. Condittori do not have a good reputation around these parts. They might have organized themselves and be just as dead right now."
"We could easily ask a few farmers if you're lying or not."
"Oh, I'm sure you could easily make our peasantry say whatever you want. After all, they are but simple people. Being interviewed by a mercenary, especially after 300 of their husbands and sons have just been butchered, has a tendency to make you want to end the tête-à-tête any which way. Many of women were... taken advantage of the last time hostile mercenaries came through. They would not favor a long conversation, whatever your men's intentions."
Captain was getting tired of the way the Scallini spun his story, like an Arabian dancer, dropping each successive veil to ultimately reveal a truth, which Captain was fairly certain wasn't entirely genuine. "So, if I understand you, a rider that we will likely never catch incited the populace. We cannot confirm the people's mind because they are too scared of us. You say Alberti ordered the attack out of retribution rather than as a ploy to gain the favor Cosimo de Medici, which we also cannot verify. And, out of all this, you were only an innocent pawn?"
"Precisely." Scallini tried to disarm tensions with a smile and failed again.
"Which we also cannot confirm or deny?" The smile remained. In a flash, the cold edge of a dagger blade touched Scallini's neck and another pointed into his back. Scallini didn't dare turn to see who wielded the knives. "Describe this mysterious rider."
Fear came into Scallini's voice for the first time. "He-... he was riding a brown Andalusian steed. His clothing had no coat of arms or identification. He wore simple leather armor, a green tunic, and a cape of a darker green. He carried a sheathed sword."
"His appearance? His face?"
"Medium build, a little above average height. Dark hair, brown eyes, Roman nose, determined chin, no scars."
"You mean a perfectly ordinary man." It wasn't a question.
"Yes." Scallini answered anyway. The blade moved to a more tender spot and the Florentine's eye bulged. "He has a lisp! That's all I noticed, I swear!"
"Give him back to Sean."