CHAPTER IV - THE KING'S JUSTICE
As Robert had requested, the Small Council convened in the chamber but an hour after Ser Balon Swann had been ordered to gather them. First to arrive was the King's brother, Stannis, never one to shirk his duties. Last to arrive was Septon Andren, the journey from the Great Sept taking longer than the other councilors' trips from within the Red Keep. By the hour's end, ten men had joined Robert in the Small Council chambers, where they would set out to determine what was to be done with the last remnants of the Targaryen loyalists. Robert wasn't a fool, contrary to what many pro-Targaryen lords would have whispered during the rebellion. He knew that half the room would be made up of those utterly loyal to him, and half of the room would be those who had fought against him. After all, that was why the traditional seven-member council was expanded to eleven, as to properly accommodate those on the losing side of the war, to consolidate his rule.
When the Master of the Faith had finally taken his seat at the table, business began. Robert stood to address his fellow council members.
"My lords," he spoke, "I have called you here to inform you of my brother's success in the Stormlands. Stannis has rooted out Lords Connington and Hasty, and is bringing them to the capital to face the King's justice. However, a king that acts without the advice of his advisers is a rash and reckless king, and so I have decided that it is within our best interest to leave this matter to the Small Council. What is to be done with these men, my lords? Give voice, let your opinions be heard so that we might best come to a conclusion."
Some of the men in the room with Robert had served on Aerys' Small Council, and so it must have come as a shock to them be offered the chance to voice their own opinions. They say that in the final days of his reign, the Mad King listened to no voice but the one inside his head. A Small Council with no room to give counsel. Robert would not repeat the same mistakes that brought about the end of the greatest dynasty the world had ever known, and certainly not within the first few months of his reign. No, he was smarter than that, enough time with Jon and Ned had seen to that. Though he had not shown it in his youth, Robert had always commended the ways of Jon and Ned, and perhaps now as king, he might hope to emulate such fine men.
"Take their heads, your grace." Came a voice to Robert's left. The Master of Coin had given voice to the words. "They have refused your offer of peace, and have taken up arms against their new king. That is outright treason, your grace. The Stark lords were put to death for less."
Lord Qarlton Chelsted spoke frankly and with anger in his voice. Perhaps he still bore the Targaryens ill-will for his resignation from Aerys' Small Council. Yet, Robert could not help but see the irony in the Master of Coin's words. As explained by the Master of Coin himself, he had left his position on the Small Council when Aerys Targaryen made known his intent to burn down King's Landing. Lord Chelsted could not condone such an act of ruthlessness then, and yet now he gave voice to another form of ruthlessness.
"I agree with Lord Chelsted." Spoke Grand Maester Agrivane. "Lords Connington and Hasty have committed treason. As I'm sure Prince Herbert will tell you, the law for treason is death. If we are to uphold the law, then we must abide by the law, and the law states death."
"Half the bloody realm fought against the king in the war, should we all die as well?" The words this time came from Baelor Hightower, or Brightsmile as some called him.
"A different matter entirely." Replied the Master of Coin. "You fought for your king, Lord Baelor, not against him. Regardless of your side, loyalty cannot be faulted."
"And yet you would fault the loyalty of these lords now? Lord Connington is one of Rhaegar Targaryen's greatest friends, his loyalty was never in question. You speak as if you stand on firm ground, my lord, and yet you lack the footing to do so." Baelor was getting noticeably angry at the suggestion of execution.
He has a point, Robert thought to himself. Lord Connington and Lord Hasty were both upholding their loyalty to the men they had sworn that loyalty too. Yes, those men were Aerys and Rhaegar Targaryen, but the whole damned war had started because of Jon's loyalty to Robert and Ned, and his refusal to hand them over to the Mad King. And yet, Robert knew that justice had to be served, otherwise, every man in the Seven Kingdoms could do as he pleased, fearing no consequences and seeing no repercussions. It was a difficult decision to make.
Prince Oberyn Martell spoke next, in support of Lord Baelor. "Breakwind is right," he said, etching even more anger on the face of the Hightower lord. "I would not see them die for their actions."
"And what would you have then, Prince Oberyn?" Robert asked.
"I would have you show an act of kindness, your grace, an act you had shown my sister and her children. Let them leave Westeros, let them live out their days in the pleasure houses of Lys, let them be free of this country, and you of them."
"Here here." Lord Lucerys Velaryon seconded Prince Oberyn's suggestion, an act of little surprise to any in the room.
"You fought for the Mad King, Prince Oberyn, it comes as little surprise that you would say such a thing." Kevan Lannister said, in opposition to the Red Viper's proposal.
"And you did not fight at all." Came Oberyn's reply. "Tell me, what kind of lion is it that refuses to fight?"
Rumblings of laughter escaped from a few of the men in the room, even Baelor Brightsmile showed how he came to possess the name. A clear division could be seen in the room, one side loyal to the Targaryens, wanting mercy, the other loyal to Robert, wanting death. With no mutual feelings between the two sides, the conversation was going nowhere, and so Robert stepped in to make his own feelings known.
"Half of you want me to kill the men, the other half of you want me to do nothing." Robert said with authority, putting his foot down. "Stop the bickering and start working towards a solution, we're getting nowhere. Lords Connington and Hasty will be punished for their treason, those of you who counselled otherwise can help me decide how, not if. Those of you wanting death, remember how the damned war started. The Mad King killed any man that disagreed with him, I won't follow down the same path. Another punishment will have to do."
Jon Arryn, Robert's closest adviser and Hand of the King, finally spoke, having listened carefully to the points the other council members had made. "The Wall is always in need of good men, Robert, and Lords Connington and Hasty are nothing if not good men." He said. "Lord Jon is a fine soldier and born leader, and Lord Barristan is of the thinking type, possessing a sharper tongue than blade. Both soldiers and thinkers are needed on the Wall, and it would serve as a suitable punishment for them both."
"It would be a slight against their houses!" Protested Lord Velaryon.
"A greater slight than taking their heads?" The Spider's retort shut down the dissent of the Master of Ships.
"The First Men view serving in the Night's Watch as a great honor, your grace." Spoke the Lord Commander, himself of First Men descent. "If the Conningtons and Hastys had any sense about them, they would view such a sentence as a gift from the Gods."
"The Lord Commander is right." Spoke Prince Herbert, "Send the men to the Wall, let them see out their days in service to the realm. The men themselves will be punished, and yet their families cannot say you did not treat them with some form of respect. Taking their heads would only serve to alienate them further. This is the right course of action."
Robert nodded to his kinsmen, before looking around at the other men in the room, one eyebrow raised as if to coax an opinion out of them. Kevan Lannister nodded in agreement, and Baelor Hightower followed suit.
"Well, it's better than nothing." Joked Prince Oberyn. "Tell us, what do the Gods have to say about all this?"
Everyone turned and looked to Septon Andren. The Master of Faith was a slothful man, and had been paying little attention. He was seemingly startled by the mention of the Gods, and knew he had to say at least something, to not appear utterly incompotent.
"The... the Gods would... would see it as a fitting punishment... for the uhhh... crimes... committed. The uhhh... Faith... stands behind your decision... your grace."
Robert nodded. "Very well, it's settled then. Grand Maester, draw up letters to be sent to House Connington and House Hasty at once. Inform them of our decision here. When my brother returns, I shall bring the men before me where I will personally deliver the verdict. They will depart for Castle Black when the sentencing is complete. Unless there is anything else, you are all dismissed."
The men said their pleasantries to the king and took their leave. Robert remained in his chair, wresting his forehead in his hand. His decision to build the Small Council that he had had created tension in the room, and would likely do so for some time. Yet, it was a necessity to unite the realm under him. He hoped that by punishing the men, he had appeased those who had remained loyal to him throughout, and yet by letting them live, he hoped to appease those who had fought against him in the war- and beside the men destined for the Wall. Just one of a lifetime of difficult decisions destined for a king, he thought. How fun.
- 1