i wasn't targeting you personally or anyone specifically. tbh i think i've myself been the most inactive person this game. i just thought the game as a whole was going rather slowly and thought i'd put a reminder.
-
We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
So, here are the certainties of the proposal: Aedan, Falc, Jacksonian.
Here are the people who rejected the successful proposal, so they're unlikely to be selected: npstr, jerman, tamius. npstr and jerman are also unlikely due to the card mess in the beginning of the game.
So I feel I should pick among Panzer and happycats for the 4th person.
npstr picked both panzer and happycats when he made his proposal without himself on; panzer approved that but cats didn't
tamius proposed happycats, with npstr approving that proposal, but that did have tamius on...
Sooooo...
PROPOSAL
FALC
AEDAN
JACKSONIAN
HAPPYCATS
APPROVE
Here are the people who rejected the successful proposal, so they're unlikely to be selected: npstr, jerman, tamius. npstr and jerman are also unlikely due to the card mess in the beginning of the game.
So I feel I should pick among Panzer and happycats for the 4th person.
npstr picked both panzer and happycats when he made his proposal without himself on; panzer approved that but cats didn't
tamius proposed happycats, with npstr approving that proposal, but that did have tamius on...
Sooooo...
PROPOSAL
FALC
AEDAN
JACKSONIAN
HAPPYCATS
APPROVE
hmm, unless we wanna be stuck with jerman's fifth proposal, we're gonna have to accept either this or jacksonian's(4th proposal), so i'd like to know if jack would put me on before voting.
Actually, it's in the interest of the spies to rush through the game, while the Resistance should think good about every move.
If the GM @Cliges approves, I'll post a link to a spreadsheet similar to the one last game.
Voting by PM again. My votes only irritate Resistance potatoes and give Jerman cheap excuses to cast votes that are good for him.
If the GM @Cliges approves, I'll post a link to a spreadsheet similar to the one last game.
Voting by PM again. My votes only irritate Resistance potatoes and give Jerman cheap excuses to cast votes that are good for him.
Adding to my first statement, the thinking: There is nothing obviously wrong with this team. We don't have much information, in your place I would have too chosen kitty over panzer cause I'm irritated by his remarks about going on with the game.
definitely agree there. i wasn't talking about thinking things through, but about those days we sit around doing nothing in the thread and just forget about the game.
I have no qualms with the proposed team. I like Happycats more on the team than you.
Approve
Approve
I like the team, Jacksonian will most likely propose the same, and I'd rather have Jacksonian get the cards than Jerman.
I like the team, Jacksonian will most likely propose the same, and I'd rather have Jacksonian get the cards than Jerman.
Yes. Your team was NCed by me to be sure it wouldn't be used to hurt the resistance, rather than any actual issue with the team. NC is pretty much never useful for the resistance, and has caused a number of spy victories, so SOP is to burn it ASAP.
I don't think it's too bad a proposal, but from my perspective, Falc's logic doesn't make the slightest bit of sense.
VOTING THROUGH PM
VOTING THROUGH PM
I get why my team was NCed (though thanks for explaining the plot card strategy, I'm still getting used to that). I'm just pleased to see it get proposed again as I think it's the best team to propose right now.
Team:
FALC
AEDAN
JACKSONIAN
HAPPYCATS
Approve: Falc, Jackson, Panzer, Aedan, Happycats, Npstr
Reject:Tamius, Jerman
Team passes 6-2. The mission failed. There was 1 sabotage. End of Round 2.
Round 3. Jackson is the next leader. His cards are:
Strong Leader – One time use - The player who receives this card may keep it and use it later to become Leader for the next Team proposal. If the next Team proposal is the first of a new Mission, they will also be allowed to distribute the cards for that Mission. Once this proposal is handled, the next Leader is the player in the list after the person who used Strong Leader. The use of this card must be declared in public before the next Leader does anything or before cards are revealed. This may be preloaded.
and
Overheard Conversation – Use immediately – The player to whom the Leader passes this card must publicly choose one player adjacent to him on the player list. This player's role will be revealed to him through PM by the GM.
Mission 3 requires a 4-person team. The leader can pass cards and propose a team when ready.
FALC
AEDAN
JACKSONIAN
HAPPYCATS
Approve: Falc, Jackson, Panzer, Aedan, Happycats, Npstr
Reject:Tamius, Jerman
Team passes 6-2. The mission failed. There was 1 sabotage. End of Round 2.
Round 3. Jackson is the next leader. His cards are:
Strong Leader – One time use - The player who receives this card may keep it and use it later to become Leader for the next Team proposal. If the next Team proposal is the first of a new Mission, they will also be allowed to distribute the cards for that Mission. Once this proposal is handled, the next Leader is the player in the list after the person who used Strong Leader. The use of this card must be declared in public before the next Leader does anything or before cards are revealed. This may be preloaded.
and
Overheard Conversation – Use immediately – The player to whom the Leader passes this card must publicly choose one player adjacent to him on the player list. This player's role will be revealed to him through PM by the GM.
Mission 3 requires a 4-person team. The leader can pass cards and propose a team when ready.
considering adding happycats to the team just caused a sabotage, i would love for him to defer to the resistance's best judgment in handing out cards instead of doing it on his own.
Using Overheard Conversation to check my/Jermans allegiance seems like the highest information option here.
@Panzer Commader: Jacksonian is giving out the cards, not happycats.
@Panzer Commader: Jacksonian is giving out the cards, not happycats.
I'd give aedan the Strong Leader. While we can't rule out anyone from the M1 team, as at least one Spy approved it (unless you think Jerman and me plus Tamius are the three spies, which can't be as noone of us was on the sabotaged M2; Jerman and me could only be both spies if Tamius is Resistance), aedan proposed a successful team while Falc proposed a failed one. The other possibilities are happycats who was on a failed team and Panzer and Tamius who are dark horses mission wise.
I don't see any way to make you give card to me at this point of the game so I won't go down that path, though I'd be the only Resistance member I know of so far.
I don't see any way to make you give card to me at this point of the game so I won't go down that path, though I'd be the only Resistance member I know of so far.
Last edited: