• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
  • 4Like
Reactions:
Twenty-five hours left, folks! :)
 
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions:
CK2:
  1. Avon Las Observes by @Midnite Duke
CK3:
  1. The Breton Chronicles by @Werther
  2. The Lions of Olomouc by @Revan86
  3. When Murder Solves Everything by @Tom D.
  4. The Grand Chronicle - Megacampaign by @Sunsteel
EU4:
  1. In the Shadow of the Ancients by @Tommy4ever
  2. The Thin Wedge of Europe by @Revan86
  3. New Era, Old Gods by @Bergil
  4. A Tale as Old as Time: Book II by @ibicko
Vic3:
  1. An Empire Where the Sun Always Rises by @hjarg
  2. Dreams of an Honest World by @Chilango2
  3. Brazilian Watched by @Nikolai
  4. The Cairo News by @witchveil
HoI4:
  1. Tomorrow Belongs To Me by @TheButterflyComposer
  2. The German Century by @Basileus2
  3. Poles Apart by @Bullfilter
  4. The Empire Strikes Back - Part 4 by @Idhrendur
Phew, finally got that in. Now if only I can find the time and headspace to write. The consistency of Revan's prose is awe-inspiring, while I'm fighting to write 400 words a week that I like.

A few miscellaneous thoughts:
  • @Werther - I love your format. I spent a good half-hour figuring out how in the world you center images. Those little black frames do a ton of work as well, I'm definitely stealing that idea.
  • @Midnite Duke, @Nikolai, @witchveil - I love the special perspectives these take on. There's something alive about the form.
  • I'm really looking forward to the "Other" category next quarter now that AoW4 is out.
  • I hope to vote in many more of these to come!
 
  • 3Like
  • 2Love
Reactions:
January 1st, 2023 and March 31st,, 2023

It turns out this specifically is bloody difficult. And I really need to get back into reading CK2 and CK3 stuff, because this past year has flown by and I feel like I've betrayed my roots by not boosting or really reading any crusader Kings stuff at all.

Oh well.

The ballot -

Ck3
Born to Breed - Peter ebsen's Bible of fifth makes the cut by the skin of its teeth. But it deserves it for fully embracing (amongst other actions) the ribalrdy of CK3 in a way not seen since Jabberjock's incest saga in CK2.

Pax Brittanica by Koweth - deserves some love for the absurdly ambitious mission statement of covering the british Isles from 400AD to the mid 20th century in a mega campaign surely doomed to...I mean, prove those cynical readers wrong. It's a very good history book AAR, and I'm always partial to a good England history book.

When Murder solves everything - is of course, excellent advice in general, and esepcially for CK3. Doesn't quite beat out the golden rule of Money Fixes Everything, but the tutorial itself spells that one out for you.

EUIV

The War of the Roses - not much to say about this one that I didn't recently say in the weekly awards. I pray for the health of the king, the death of the queen, and for the arrival of the one true Henry (the seventh).

Other/miscellaneous

The Butterfly Effect - under protest, as this AAR is clearly designed to be technically acceptable under the update limit for every Q vote for the past few years. This time was a double feature, which is good.

Talking Turkey - the best AAR of the past decade, as we all know.

Victoria 2

The Rise of Russia - want to see Russia continually crash and burn, only to briefly unite, crush everyone else in Europe, and fall apart again? Step this way!

HOI4

The Empire Strikes Back Part 4 - which involves all sorts of craziness as a good few years of reader contributions have led to a very strange Byzantine Empire, in one of its decline periods. And also the Orthodx Church, which continues being in its millenia long golden age.

Make Italy Roman Again by defensedefumer - basically Imperial Cheese played straight, which is horrifying if you think about it.

Poles Apart - Poland somehow becomes the most helpful ally in the world, Trotsky is am extremely out of character pacifist, and everyone else is determined to kill themselves burning China to the ground. For years. Now the amercians have attacked everyone, purely to be contrarian.
 
  • 2Like
  • 2Love
Reactions:
hd002.jpg
hd003.jpg
hd004.jpg
hd005.jpg
hd006.jpg
hd007.jpg
"filcat's journey of Q1 ACAs of 2023. Tagline reads as Despite being late, there is no escape from the vote of filcat"

[-or actually Hulagu Khan and Doquz Khatun at their court, excerpt of miniature from Jami al-Tawarikh - Compendium of Chronicles by Rashid al-Din Hamadani (1247-1318)]




Crusader Kings II
- CK2AGOT - Breaker of Chains and Mother of Dragons by Thaiga
- The Dragons Realm, A House Targaryen AAR by @streaker77
- Suryavamsavali - An iAAR by KiratRawr
- Wings of Faith, Wings of Fury - A Slavic Pagan Revival AAR by @Superstorm


Crusader Kings III
- The Lions of Olomouc: a CKIII Ironman AAR (Duchy of Moravia, 867) by Revan86
- Jewish Alps - A Paradox Megacampaign AAR- Part1 by Bfc kfc
- Cradle of God, a Middle Eastern AAR by SongOfHorrors57
- Crowns of the Levant by Werther


Europa Universalis IV
- The Thin Wedge of Europe by Revan86
- The Wars of the Roses by coz1
- To Pierce the Heavens: Multiplayer Megacampaign by @King of Men
- A Tale as Old as Time: Book II: The Dual Monarchy - A Paradox Mega-Campaign AAR by ibicko


Victoria II
- The Rise of Russia by HistoryDude
- In the Shadow of the Ancients - An Assyrian AAR, Part Three by Tommy4ever
- Victoria II - Japan - AAR by Eurasia


Victoria III
- The Cairo News - An Egypt to Arabia V3 AAR by witchveil
- Dreams of an Honest World - a Mexico V3 AAR by Chilango2
- An Empire Where the Sun Always Rises- A Japan V3 AAR by hjarg


Hearts of Iron IV
- Poles Apart - an HOI4 Ahistory by Bullfilter
- The Empire Strikes Back - Part 4 by Idhrendur
- Tomorrow Belongs To Me - A ‘Democratic’ Germany AAR by TBC


Stellaris
- Wait. /// They're ... WHAT?! ... by @DanoShanter
- Shattered Glass: A Narrative Stellaris AAR by Von Acturus
- Rise and fall of the Imperium of Nova Terra, a story of war, triumph,... by Falhxer
- I Have A Dream - The Tale of the Sol Republic by Nikolai



Other - I:R and HoI3
- Once a Satrapy: A Parthian Dynasty by @alpherbethegamer
- Epirus Ascendant, Part 1 by HistoryDude
- Talking Turkey: Alternate History from 1936 by Bullfilter
 
  • 3Like
  • 3Love
Reactions:
  • 2Like
  • 1Love
Reactions:
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Slowly going through all votes. Quite few this time around, it seems to be less and less votes and voters each quarter. Which is good for my sanity on one side, with my health issues, but decidedly not good for this awAARd. :( And I can get through more votes, given time, so please encourage others to vote next time!

With that said, I want to get to this point:

[NB - I said a full ballot, but I just cannot see too many others here. Even Pip's is pushing it for this last quarter. I wanted to vote for some others that have been longstanding, but the work done in the last 3 months...not much if at all.]
We have a new game released by Paradox this Q2, which has already several AARs written for it. I can attest the one I have read there is top notch, and I am sure the others are too. I am talking about Age of Wonders 4, which has a dedicated AAR section, but which is not linked to AARland proper. Sigh, it's like Paradox wants to kill this part of the forums whatever it takes. :(

But I suggest we add Age of Wonders 4 in for the Q2 2023 ACAs. It released two weeks ago and has so far got four AARs. Perhaps we could add it to the Other category to begin with, and if it gets more traction, perhaps add it as a separate category. What do you guys think? :)
 
  • 3Like
Reactions:
  • 2Like
Reactions:
  • 2Like
Reactions:
@Midnite Duke, @Nikolai, @witchveil - I love the special perspectives these take on. There's something alive about the form.
As an author, that is highly sought praise, thank you kindly. I'm sitting smiling here. :)
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
Born to Breed - Peter ebsen's Bible of fifth makes the cut by the skin of its teeth. But it deserves it for fully embracing (amongst other actions) the ribalrdy of CK3 in a way not seen since Jabberjock's incest saga in CK2.
Update December 25th and then last weekend. Sorry, that makes it inelegible. :(
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
Pax Brittanica by Koweth - deserves some love for the absurdly ambitious mission statement of covering the british Isles from 400AD to the mid 20th century in a mega campaign surely doomed to...I mean, prove those cynical readers wrong. It's a very good history book AAR, and I'm always partial to a good England history book.
And this has had no update this year.
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
I would like to see a specific category for Age of Wonders 4, but like you said, it requires the game to get more traction first. Fingers crossed.
Yeah, same. :)
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
Finished counting the votes, but it's 01.30 in the morning and I need to go to bed. Will try to post the results tomorrow evening!
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
I would like to see a specific category for Age of Wonders 4, but like you said, it requires the game to get more traction first. Fingers crossed.
I concur.

I 100% agree with @Nikolai’s proposal. (Full disclosure, I’m an AoW4 authAAR.) I would love for it to have its own category someday, but I’d appreciate it if the game could be considered under “Other” until then.

In the meantime, I’d love for everyone to come visit the AoW4 subforum and check out the great stories there.
 
  • 3Like
Reactions:
  • 2Like
  • 2
  • 1Love
Reactions:
Ladies and gentlemen! It is time! Time to celebrate the many great stories told in this little internet home we call AARland! :D

The results of the Q1 2023 ACAs are here!

First out is the venerable Europa Universalis IV, where eight works were nominated. It was quickly becoming a runaway win for @coz1 with eight points, followed by @Tommy4ever with five points on second place. Third place was shared between @Revan86 and @ibicko with four points each:

Europa Universalis IV
VotesNameAuthorLink
8The Wars of the Rosescoz1https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/the-wars-of-the-roses.1461656/
5In the Shadow of the Ancients - An Assyrian AAR, Part TwoTommy4everhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...he-ancients-an-assyrian-aar-part-two.1537567/
4The Thin Wedge of EuropeRevan86https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/the-thin-wedge-of-europe.1482961/
4A Tale as Old as Time: Book II: The Dual Monarchy - A Paradox Mega-Campaign AARibickohttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...monarchy-a-paradox-mega-campaign-aar.1478498/
3New Era, Old Gods- an EU4 Norse Sweden AARBergilhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/new-era-old-gods-an-eu4-norse-sweden-aar.1564048/
1The Absolute GAUL of Some People!firezatswill9https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/the-absolute-gaul-of-some-people.1559868/
1The Nation of the Tagalogs: A Tondo Megacampaign AARBlack Watchhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...he-tagalogs-a-tondo-megacampaign-aar.1506651/
1To Pierce the Heavens: Multiplayer MegacampaignKing of Menhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/to-pierce-the-heavens-multiplayer-megacampaign.1568362/


The old king Crusader Kings II got even more works voted in, but yet again a runaway hit presented itself early on. @Midnite Duke scored more than twice that of second places, shared between @KiratRawr , @Eurasia and @Thaiga . Third place were shared between @streaker77 and @Superstorm :


The new king Crusader Kings 3 also had a clear winner with @Revan86 on top, followed by @Werther on both second and third place. Third place also was awarded @Bfc kfc and @Tom D. :

Crusader Kings III
VotesNameAuthorLink
6The Lions of Olomouc: a CKIII Ironman AAR (Duchy of Moravia, 867)Revan86https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...iii-ironman-aar-duchy-of-moravia-867.1479193/
4The Breton ChroniclesWertherhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/the-breton-chronicles.1575073/
3Jewish Alps- A Paradox Megacampaign AAR- Part1 - Crusader Kings 3Bfc kfchttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...acampaign-aar-part1-crusader-kings-3.1533473/
3[Completed] Crowns of the LevantWertherhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/completed-crowns-of-the-levant.1513118/page-9
3When Murder Solves Everything - a CK3 Flanders AARTom D.https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...solves-everything-a-ck3-flanders-aar.1575383/
2Cradle of God, a Middle Eastern AARSongOfHorrors57https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/cradle-of-god-a-middle-eastern-aar.1571593/
1Song of the Karlings: Karloman's LegacyLPDK 356https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/song-of-the-karlings-karlomans-legacy.1446168/
1A Kingdom at the Crossroads - An Armenian AARDarumakahttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/a-kingdom-at-the-crossroads-an-armenian-aar.1570943/
1The Grand Chronicle- A (Hopefully) Humorous Megacampaign ARR Pt.1: It BeginsSunsteelhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...rous-megacampaign-arr-pt-1-it-begins.1567201/

The old lady Victoria II only got five works voted on this time, but that was because there were clear consensus. First place was shared between @HistoryDude and @Eurasia with five points each, followed closely by @Tommy4ever with four points and third place awarded one point each and shared between @zenphoenix and @Zeogludon :

Victoria II
VotesAuthorLink
5The Rise of RussiaHistoryDudehttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/the-rise-of-russia.1451901/
5Victoria II - Japan - AAREurasiahttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/victoria-ii-japan-aar.1533825/
4In the Shadow of the Ancients - An Assyrian AAR, Part ThreeTommy4everhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...-ancients-an-assyrian-aar-part-three.1574021/
1The Hohenzollern Empire 5: Holy Phoenix - An Empire of Jerusalem Megacampaign in New World Orderzenphoenixhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...alem-megacampaign-in-new-world-order.1022999/
1En la sombra de Morazán: A Central American AARZeogludonhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/en-la-sombra-de-morazan-a-central-american-aar.1494981/

The new lady on the block Victoria 3 also saw five works voted in, with a clear win to @Chilango2 , followed by shared second place to @hjarg and @witchveil and @Nikolai on third place:

Victoria 3
VotesAuthorLink
5Dreams of an Honest World - a Mexico V3 AARChilango2https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/dreams-of-an-honest-world-a-mexico-v3-aar.1554937/
3An Empire Where the Sun Always Rises- A Japan V3 AARhjarghttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...-the-sun-always-rises-a-japan-v3-aar.1553051/
3The Cairo News - An Egypt to Arabia V3 AARwitchveilhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/the-cairo-news-an-egypt-to-arabia-v3-aar.1562923/
2Brazilian Watched - A Watcher and Creature AARNikolaihttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/brazilian-watched-a-watcher-and-creature-aar.1564730/
1Plus Ultra - Gallispania in the Long Nineteenth Century (Sequel to an EU4 AAR)SibCDChttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...eteenth-century-sequel-to-an-eu4-aar.1560035/

The old war horse Hearts of Iron IV also got a consolidated following, with first place being a close run until the end, finally awarding @Bullfilter with first place, followed by shared second place to @TheButterflyComposer and @Idhrendur . Third place went to @Basileus2 :

Hearts of Iron IV
VotesNameAuthorLink
6Poles Apart – an HOI4 AhistoryBullfilterhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/poles-apart-an-hoi4-ahistory.1532542/
5Tomorrow Belongs To Me - A 'Democratic' Germany AARTheButterflyComposerhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...longs-to-me-a-democratic-germany-aar.1542366/
5The Empire Strikes Back - Part 4Idhrendurhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/the-empire-strikes-back-part-4.1565575/
3The German Century (Kaiserreich AAR)Basileus2https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/the-german-century-kaiserreich-aar.1559716/
1Make Italy Roman Again!defensedefumerhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/make-italy-roman-again.1423537/

Out in space Stellaris got a whopping ten works nominated, with @Von Acturus in a clear first and second place, the second place shared with @Macavity116 and @Nikolai . Third place went to @Falhxer :

Stellaris
VotesNameAuthorLink
6Shattered Glass: A Narrative Stellaris AARVon Acturushttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...arrative-stellaris-aar.1509298/#post-28057480
4Grand Theft StellarisMacavity116https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/grand-theft-stellaris.1571377/
4Thousands are SailingVon Acturushttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/thousands-are-sailing.1575927/
4I Have A Dream - The Tale of the Sol RepublicNikolaihttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/i-have-a-dream-the-tale-of-the-sol-republic.1568454/
3Rise and fall of the Imperium of Nova Terra, a story of war, triumph, decadence and collapse - a Stellaris AARFalhxerhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...cadence-and-collapse-a-stellaris-aar.1555118/
2Stellaris Wars: A Nemesis Ironman Saga II - Rebellion: The Imperium at WarArithmeticianhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/foru...aga-ii-rebellion-the-imperium-at-war.1523395/
2Life2.0 - a Broken Shackles Narrative (Started)CBR JGWRRhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/life2-0-a-broken-shackles-narrative-started.1568541/
1The Zenak Unity - Our awakeningdanivonhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/the-zenak-unity-our-awakening.1559829/
1The Stars are OursJohnnyMacintoshhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/the-stars-are-ours.938051/
1Wait. /// They're ... WHAT?! ...DanoShanterhttps://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/wait-theyre-what.1571810/

The Other category this time was less crowded than previously rounds, which might be changed in Q2 when Age of Wonders 4 is eligible. After close competition first place went to @Bullfilter closely followed by @HistoryDude on second place and @El Pip on third place:


And that sums it up, folks! Give a hearty applause to the winnAARs and nominees! :D
 
  • 6Like
  • 1Love
  • 1
Reactions:
@Nikolai: I hope everyone appreciates the considerable effort you put into compiling and counting all of the ACA votes. It is a significant undertaking and you handle it with aplomb. Well done, my friend.

Congratulations to all the winners!
 
  • 2Like
  • 2
Reactions: