Puppets and millitary alliance - inconsistent situation

[unmerged(53922)]

If you made your own millitary alliance all new puppets are automatically in. But some of old ones which don't like you so much (values in AI files) don't want. This is inconsistent in game situation.

What do you think about it ?


sorry for irregular English
Kristof
Poland

 

[unmerged(51700)]

I had something similar:
playing as Hungary I had Croatia as puppet. We both were members of the Axis. When I left the Axis, Croatia did too, but currently I'm not allied with Croatia (but it's still my puppet). The chance to ally them is 0%. Annoying

 

[unmerged(53922)]

I had something similar:
playing as Hungary I had Croatia as puppet. We both were members of the Axis. When I left the Axis, Croatia did too, but currently I'm not allied with Croatia (but it's still my puppet). The chance to ally them is 0%. Annoying

Of course you can fix it by adding manually in save file croatians to yours allies or by acceptall cheat in F12 command line. But I'm thinking that situation when puppet automatically stays your allies (if you are Allied with someone) is mistake. In real not all puppets want to fight at all. Their forces are standing in their own country and refuses to move somewhere.

I am not assuming military control to makes my games harder and I think it is a mistake that in 1.3 AI no longer sends units to human player. Historically some puppeted countries sends some their units under German army command or it was volunteers.