• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, what you know about madness?
From new scenario "Mitropa" (CP block won WWI)

26.png



25.png

28.png


27.png
 
  • 4Like
  • 1Love
  • 1
Reactions:
I think that event for Spain should be slept if the player chooses historical outcome option.

No. This decision can change only AI behavior. Then what the reason to play WWI scenarios if events will have railroad outcome?


Could also help with that. Just let me know what you're after.

Well, I'm have next situation - GER won WWI. Finland became pro-german kingdom (not a puppet) and thanks to German support integrated whole Karelia
Now question.
Could Finnish nationalists follow the principle that Russian Ivan will never take our territories because we're under protection of uncle Willy and then use Russian Civil War to strike Soviets and take Ingria and Arkhangelsk area?

Or is my idea too crazy?
 
  • 4Like
Reactions:
This literally looks like some events for Balkan countries from Thunder in the Sky and I love it. It will be satisfying.

Edit: will defeated Greece have a communist revolution? If so, will she be able to from - dare I say - communist Byzantium?
 
Last edited:
I'd give the Sudetenland directly to Germany, Pirot to Bulgaria and Erzurum to Armenia
 
This literally looks like some events for Balkan countries from Thunder in the Sky and I love it. It will be satisfying.

Edit: will defeated Greece have a communist revolution? If so, will she be able to from - dare I say - communist Byzantium?


They ARE from Thunder ;) Moreover, I'm integrated those flags from Thunder

Errrhhh I'm think yes. In next versions GRE will have commie path. Commie Byzantium? Sounds wild, but i's good food for brains and new ideas



I'd give the Sudetenland directly to Germany

I'm could understand your point if German Empire would have analogue of NSDAP, but victorious GE with soc-dem/ conservative government will never send ultimatums (Munich conference style) for it's strategic partners



Pirot to Bulgaria

Only if Serbia was defeated during Balkan war (1930s)


Erzurum to Armenia

Sounds good. I'll think about it
 
Last edited:
I have a few issues and questions with the current release:

1. When playing as USSR, you get events that force you to declare war on the Baltic states. Shouldn't these be decisions if you win the war? They make the RCW impossible for me as I don't have enough units to defend all fronts.
2. Can I change the country map colours to DH vanilla? I prefer them but don't know how to do it
3. 1914 Russia's unit flags are wrong. They are incorrect at first, then turn to Russian Empire flags when they become the Russian republic. Is this a bug?
 
Shouldn't these be decisions if you win the war?
No



2. Can I change the country map colours to DH vanilla? I prefer them but don't know how to do it

Why you asking me if you want to change it for yourself?

Darkest Hour A HOI Game/ Map/ colorscales.txt

Now copy colorscales.txt to PWV/ Map



3. 1914 Russia's unit flags are wrong.

No. They're correct.
If you talking about flag for counters - like i'm said before, counter maker for HOI does not work with my windows. I'm not going to reinstall my PC just to fix this issue
 
Can't you use the DH full for the counter flags, then?

What the reason to use it if all shields were re-worked and what the reason to use it when I'm added more than 30 of new countries (default counters without flags)
 
Well, Pirot and Nis were part of the Bulgarian Occupation zone in WW1. I assume in this scenario Serbia is an Hungarian puppet (or at least a defeated country), so it seems logical thas these two zones became officially Bulgarian, taking into account that Romanian and Greek provinces did.

About the Sudetenland, well, I was thinking about the Republic of German Austria, but for the moment I only saw some screens and don't know the context of Austria-Hungary dissolution and Austrian integration into Germany, so can't judge until i read the history/events.
 
and don't know the context

Austria-Hungary collapsed during "bread revolution" Hungary, Czech Rep, Croatia, Galicia, Moldova and Republic of Odessa are won war for independence against Vienna. New born Austrian Republic was integrated by German Empire

All young states became part of the German sphere
 
Last edited:
Well, what you know about madness?
From new scenario "Mitropa" (CP block won WWI)

View attachment 645096


View attachment 645097
View attachment 645098

View attachment 645099
Ideas are interesting, as always, but, question is, how plausible are they?
- For Germany and HRE, there are two problems,
smaller one: I don't think they would try to impose such idea without direct control over Rome (and thus whole northern Italy).
bigger problem: HRE is linked with Rome and thus Roman Catholicism, HRE emperors was Habsburgs and they were catholic. I don't see how protestant Hoenzollern's could fit in the narrative.
biggest problem: HRE was created on feudal principles of Middle Ages - you know, hierarchy of titles (emperor, kings, dukes...). While German Empire was united on principles of nationalism, where all regional titles and governments was put aside to create united and federal German Empire.

- For Greater Bulgaria, I fully agree, they indeed had a plans to claim the Constantinople and after that also the Byzantine imperial traditions. One thing I once found in hist.literature is that Bulgarian leadership was considering of implementation of new flag black-blue-white which would symbolize three seas (Black, Aegean and Ionian - Bulgarians had some plans for expansion to the Ionian coastline) - see to check that out, could it fit in game.

- For Carpathia, I don't see any historical logic why would Hungarians, which named their middle ages kingdom Hungarian, would use geographic term Carpathia. Movement for independent Hungary during revolution of 1848. had their ideas based on nationalism (like most of state-building and independence movements of 19th century Europe) and called for state of Hungary. After all, Habsburgs give concessions to Hungarians in 1867. and dual monarchy was named Austro-Hungary, not "Austro-Carpathia".

Well, Pirot and Nis were part of the Bulgarian Occupation zone in WW1. I assume in this scenario Serbia is an Hungarian puppet (or at least a defeated country), so it seems logical thas these two zones became officially Bulgarian, taking into account that Romanian and Greek provinces did.
I support this claim by tioperete.
 
  • 4Like
Reactions:
Well, what you know about madness?
From new scenario "Mitropa" (CP block won WWI)

View attachment 645096


View attachment 645097
View attachment 645098

View attachment 645099
Graphic Pause. VOL III

Third Rech/ German Empire


View attachment 632468
View attachment 632470


USA

View attachment 632471
View attachment 632472


Red China. What are you doing ? Why you created skin for 3 province minor with creepy IC? Nobody will never play for them!

Well, what if I'm tell you that Red China will have opportunity to provoke coup in Lingnan Protectorate or proclaim itseslf if Wang Jingwei reforms failed?

View attachment 632478

View attachment 632480


For my next versions

Sibir. Like I'm said before, during RCW you will have opportunity to prevent Kolchak coup and play for independent Sibir against all for its own freedom

View attachment 632482
View attachment 632483


Mexico. Also commie Mexico will have it's own tag and events pack

View attachment 632484
View attachment 632485
I saw in some previous photos that you're working in some alternate mexico, I'm looking foward for a socialist mexican, I mean there's the example of the Kaiserreich, but I think this version will take more in deep the reforms of the demands of the Zapata and Villa factions from the Revolution in the 20's and nationalization of the industry much before.
 
you're working in some alternate mexico,

I'm did nothing for North & South Americas. First alternatives for American nations will be added in next version (next version after coming version. 2021)


example of the Kaiserreich

Last time I'm played KR in 2015. And judging by KR thread, current version is de-facto unplayble
 
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Well, I'm have next situation - GER won WWI. Finland became pro-german kingdom (not a puppet) and thanks to German support integrated whole Karelia
Now question.
Could Finnish nationalists follow the principle that Russian Ivan will never take our territories because we're under protection of uncle Willy and then use Russian Civil War to strike Soviets and take Ingria and Arkhangelsk area?

Or is my idea too crazy?

I think Ingria sounds doable (would this include St Petersburg as well?), but Arkhangelsk is a bit too far-flung, since it's way past the "three isthmus line" that some Finns saw as a natural line of defence.

It wouldn't really surprise me to see a very large Finland strong-arming Estonia into an alliance, or even a straight-out client state, by the way.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Ideas are interesting, as always, but, question is, how plausible are they?
- For Germany and HRE, there are two problems,
smaller one: I don't think they would try to impose such idea without direct control over Rome (and thus whole northern Italy).
bigger problem: HRE is linked with Rome and thus Roman Catholicism, HRE emperors was Habsburgs and they were catholic. I don't see how protestant Hoenzollern's could fit in the narrative.
biggest problem: HRE was created on feudal principles of Middle Ages - you know, hierarchy of titles (emperor, kings, dukes...). While German Empire was united on principles of nationalism, where all regional titles and governments was put aside to create united and federal German Empire.

- For Greater Bulgaria, I fully agree, they indeed had a plans to claim the Constantinople and after that also the Byzantine imperial traditions. One thing I once found in hist.literature is that Bulgarian leadership was considering of implementation of new flag black-blue-white which would symbolize three seas (Black, Aegean and Ionian - Bulgarians had some plans for expansion to the Ionian coastline) - see to check that out, could it fit in game.

- For Carpathia, I don't see any historical logic why would Hungarians, which named their middle ages kingdom Hungarian, would use geographic term Carpathia. Movement for independent Hungary during revolution of 1848. had their ideas based on nationalism (like most of state-building and independence movements of 19th century Europe) and called for state of Hungary. After all, Habsburgs give concessions to Hungarians in 1867. and dual monarchy was named Austro-Hungary, not "Austro-Carpathia".


I support this claim by tioperete.
This, let's leave the HRE as an Alternative for a victorious Austria and defeated Germany
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Two ministers for india and one for ukraine.
 

Attachments

  • india.ukr.rar
    187,5 KB · Views: 0
for india

Which one?
British Raj? Azad Hind? Classic Republic of India? Commie India? Different nations. Different tags


-Lysenko

I'm understand that Lysenko became local meme thanks to TNO mod for HOI IV. But in Soviet documentation, he was formally listed as a sick schizophrenic
And in general, this is true.

Thanks for your effort
 
Status
Not open for further replies.