• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

MadVlad

Sergeant
3 Badges
Sep 2, 2008
62
8
  • Europa Universalis III
  • Divine Wind
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
Hello.

And welcome. My first go at an AAR!

Recently, I just finished perhaps the most interesting and satisfying game of Victoria I have ever played. Satisfying because it marked the first time that I played as the Ottomans and truly felt like I pulled a complete turnaround and started kicking ass, as opposed to victory by survival. Interesting because in part because of this sudden power shift in Europe (or so I like to think) it led to a wholly ahistorical chain of events, moreso than any other game I've played... excluding the psuedo world conquest as Scandinavia, I suppose...

Anyway, I was trying to play as in-character as possible, changing my goals and motivations over time, trying to emulate an empire undergoing a rapid reformation and still holding together. So of course, as more and more stuff piled on that I hadn't anticipated, I began to justify it in my head, creating a back story as I went.

Finally, I decided to give writing an AAR a go. I am going for the 'textbook' approach, though I won't stick hard and fast to that, as I'm just starting out, I'll use whatever works, and whatever I feel comfortable with. Advice is appreciated.

I'll start in earnest Friday - Mexico and Venezuela are playing tomorrow, friend had tickets, got invited... I'm sure 99% of the world understands :D .

So for now a teaser. Just how bizarre was this Ottoman-dominated Europe?


EUROPE, 1920
1920Europe.jpg

Now the question is, how did we get there?

STAY TUNED!
 

germanpeon

Angel of Death
106 Badges
Feb 21, 2007
2.237
5
  • 500k Club
  • Europa Universalis IV: Res Publica
  • Victoria: Revolutions
  • Europa Universalis: Rome
  • Rome Gold
  • Semper Fi
  • Sengoku
  • Starvoid
  • Victoria 2
  • Victoria 2: A House Divided
  • Victoria 2: Heart of Darkness
  • Rome: Vae Victis
  • Warlock: Master of the Arcane
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Cities: Skylines
  • Europa Universalis IV: El Dorado
  • Europa Universalis IV: Pre-order
  • Pride of Nations
  • Mount & Blade: Warband
  • Crusader Kings II: Way of Life
  • Pillars of Eternity
  • Europa Universalis IV: Common Sense
  • Crusader Kings II: Horse Lords
  • Cities: Skylines - After Dark
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cossacks
  • Stellaris: Nemesis
  • Europa Universalis III
  • Arsenal of Democracy
  • Hearts of Iron II: Armageddon
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Crusader Kings II: Charlemagne
  • Crusader Kings II: Legacy of Rome
  • Crusader Kings II: The Old Gods
  • Crusader Kings II: Rajas of India
  • Crusader Kings II: The Republic
  • Crusader Kings II: Sons of Abraham
  • Crusader Kings II: Sword of Islam
  • Darkest Hour
  • Deus Vult
  • A Game of Dwarves
  • Divine Wind
  • Europa Universalis IV
  • Europa Universalis IV: Art of War
  • Europa Universalis IV: Conquest of Paradise
  • Europa Universalis IV: Wealth of Nations
  • For the Motherland
  • Hearts of Iron III
  • Hearts of Iron III: Their Finest Hour
  • Hearts of Iron III Collection
  • Heir to the Throne
Greece is, uh, still independant. Quite offensive to the Empire, both aesthetically and in terms of security.
 

MadVlad

Sergeant
3 Badges
Sep 2, 2008
62
8
  • Europa Universalis III
  • Divine Wind
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
Mmm... true.

However, Greece is the same murky brown color as Serbia, Georgia, Wallachia, and Moldavia... making it ever so slightly less offensive than if it were an eyesore shade of light blue.
 

MadVlad

Sergeant
3 Badges
Sep 2, 2008
62
8
  • Europa Universalis III
  • Divine Wind
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
Introduction
1836 – A New Beginning

When the first light of the new year shone upon Europe, all those that mattered saw the Ottoman Empire as a nation on decline. From London to St. Petersburg, bureaucrats and generals plotted against the Sublime Porte, all eager to stake their claim in the new order all were sure was inevitable. For the Ottoman's direct neighbors – and most hated enemies – the question was when (and how much) of the vacuum could be filled without causing international concern. For those nations further away, the primary concern was the maintenance of the Ottoman state, not out of concern for their fellow man, but as a pet buffer state against a drastic shift in the European balance of power.

MetternichandNicholas.jpg

Without a doubt, the two most wicked men in Europe.

AlternateHistory.jpg

The Long Road Down – An Alternate History Novel published in 1920, depicting a highly improbable carving up of the Ottoman Empire.


Though their motives differed, the end result was the same – Anatolia and the Near East were to submit to the will of Europe, and the only question that remained was whose will precisely?

Unfortunately, none of those concerned considered Mahmud II and his successors of the House of Osman to be among 'those that mattered'. History would show how wrong they were.

Mahmud II's reign had seen a mixed period of highs and lows. Coming to power after a period of unrest and rebellion within the upper echelons of Ottoman society, his rule had seen a slow and gradual series of reforms, including the abolition of the Janissary Corps in 1821. These reforms however did little to stop the disintegration of the Ottoman state – Greece was lost in all but name in 1827 (and even that by 1832). Ottoman Algeria was ceded to France in 1830. Most critically, Egypt and the rich lands of Syria had achieved de facto independence with European backing under Mehmet Ali.

In the face of such hardships, the court of Sultan Mahmud II looked for ways to stem the continued series of defeats. The final consensus was that European dominance would continue until a parity could be reached both in terms of the Army's organization and weaponry, and the strength of the national industry. Recognizing the strength of the latter tying directly into the former, Mahmud II began a fresh wave of reform, attempting to strengthen the army and the nation along European models, whilst maintaining an 'Ottoman' culture and pacifying the ultra-traditionalists who still held a strong position amongst the nobility – hardly an easy task.

And so the court arose into a flurry of activity. The best minds of Constantinople were sent abroad to the great trading centers of Europe, intent on devising an efficient, empire-wide economic system, as well as the creation of an internationally competitive industrial base. Simultaneously, diplomatic channels were opened up, ever so subtly determining what and how far European reactions would be to a reconquest of the breakaway Egyptian state. Domestically, an attempt was made to raise the dismally low literacy rate amongst the entire population. Finally, although new weaponry or a reformed officer corps were not available in the short term, the army continued to see reform in its organization. Within the year, the army would be completely reorganized along the following lines:

Army of the Balkans (3 Corps, Pristina, Silistra, and Larisa)
Army of Anatolia (2 Corps, Edirne and Kars)
Army of Arabia (2 Corps, Baghdad and Basrah)
Army of Africa (1 Corps, Tripoli)

Though grossly understrength compared to their European counterparts (many of these 'Corps' were hardly a full division's worth of men.) they placed upon each part of the army a definite set of responsibilities and expectations, and gave the court a clear picture of what each region of the nation could bring to bear, and which regions in particularly were inadequately defended. Over time, the Ottoman army would be an institution second-to-none, but for now, it was hardly a skeleton force capable of holding down the restless souls on the frontiers of the empire.

Needing a quick victory to unite the nobles and generals behind him, Mahmud II looked for an opportunity to heap praise over his 'new' military. Happily, such an opportunity presented itself.

Montenegro.jpg

Montenegro – arguably the only independent nation in Europe with a more ramshackle military. An impressive feat.

Seizing upon the political isolation and military weakness of tiny Montenegro, the Ottoman Empire declared war, the army quickly overrunning the tiny country more through brute force and overwhelming numbers than military cunning, but victory was victory, and the generals, relieved to be seen as doing something, prepared to fall into line behind the Sultan once more... at least for the time being.

Unfortunately, the war served to push Greece into the arms of Russia, preventing any ambitions of reacquiring those territories any time soon. This however was little concern in the short term. It was obvious that invading Greece, even without Russian promises of intervention, would be viewed unfavorably by the desperately courted western powers and draw attention and vital manpower away from the most pressing crisis – Egypt.



----------------------------------------------

Gameplay Notes:

Unfortunately, I lost the savefiles to this game, so I'm working off memory, a few notes, loads of anally retentive spreadsheets, and a glorious number of maps. Still, I will attempt to say a few things here in the Gameplay section after ever chapter for those who a) prefer gameplay aspects of AARs, b) those who have never played the Ottomans, and c) those who (like me those many moons ago) enjoy reading alternate history but don't actually have the game itself, but are curious about it nonetheless.

I am playing regular Victoria, might have used a few patches but I'm not sure (since playing have had to reinstall the game due to computer problems – also explains the lack of saves). I do mod the game slightly every now and then – mostly fixing up ugly borders, and fixing up Africa (more on this later). Often times I'll edit treaties (In this particular game for instance, Britain gained a fair number of North Italian provinces from Austria. For game play purposes, I turned these into a British satellite of Venetia.)

Gameplay wise, my first move was economic free trade, followed by taxing the population and imposing enough tariffs to drown my Customs offices. Military reforms can wait – not long, but they can. I've got no intention of going to war with Russia or Austria until I'm ready (and if I'm not, one army tech won't make any difference.) The goal is to have my southern flank completely under control before the Crimea War hits. Montenegro was the classic they-have-no-alliance-and-it-will-never-be-easier-than-now. I also liked it as a way to justify the changes I (err... the Sultan) implemented, changes made purely to make make keeping track of armies easier.

To those who have never played the Ottomans, they have a very interesting set of strengths and weaknesses. Their science and industry are laughably bad, and with a low literacy rate and lacking the Free Trade tech, this is unlikely to significantly improve anytime soon. The plus side is a fairly decent array of RGOs, with the potential bonus of Egyptian cotton. Also, they have two national cultures, and absolute MASSIVE room for growth, as a bunch of weak, uncivilized, national culture nations lie to the south and southwest. Libya, if you can grab all of it, is represented as a single 'state' and with its mass of national POPs + subpar RGO = INDUSTRIAL POWERHOUSE. Later... much later...

Other strengths include a military that while pathetic by European standards is strong enough to take on said southern neighbors, as well as an event-driven addition of eight divisions just before the Oriental Crisis kicks off, which brings us to advantage number four: Events.

Both of the Ottomans first two major wars are event driven, and so give the player the advantage of knowing well ahead of time what's coming up. Both also tend to favor the Ottomans in terms of international intervention.​

Once I get into the swing of things, I expect to write longer updates. This is me dipping my toe in the pool, so to speak. Making sure the water is wAARm before I jump all the way in ;)
 

unmerged(142857)

Corporal
May 30, 2009
35
0
looks good, As I'm also writing an ottoman AAR it will be interesting to see what you do differently. :D
 

Ksim3000

Imperator General
10 Badges
Jan 11, 2003
1.332
44
Visit site
  • Hearts of Iron II: Armageddon
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Europa Universalis III
  • Hearts of Iron III
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Victoria: Revolutions
  • 500k Club
  • Crusader Kings II: Horse Lords
  • Crusader Kings II: Reapers Due
When you say regular Victoria, you mean no Revolutions, right? Hmmm, should be interesting to see what happened. Seems the Europeans colonised Africa without much of a problem also, which is good.

Looking forward to more! :D
 

MadVlad

Sergeant
3 Badges
Sep 2, 2008
62
8
  • Europa Universalis III
  • Divine Wind
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
Should have the first 'real' update up tomorrow. Monday at latest.


Enwald: Indeed, it is not! Said book was more of a comedy than anything else.

General Green: And I shall be watching yours, sir! Though our roads diverge, no doubt we both shall arrive triumphant.

TotalWarKing: The map is Krogan's WM found at Vickywiki, with significant photoshop workings.

Ksim3000: Indeed, no Revolutions. As for Africa... oh boy, problems abounded. Save-game moddings were the order of the day. I don't really like the patch that causes the 'return to historical owner' event, as I feel that if a nation has freed itself from the shackles of historical fate, they don't deserve to have their colonies just given away. So I do a combination of horsetrading and what have you to 'force' ahistorical-but-still-neat-and-tidy-maps.
 

MadVlad

Sergeant
3 Badges
Sep 2, 2008
62
8
  • Europa Universalis III
  • Divine Wind
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
The First Great War of Unification (and Other Happy Euphemisms for Kicking Ass)

View_of_the_Seraglio_Point_from_Per.jpg

Constantinople, 1838. An artists' rendition of the Ottoman Navy in its entirety.

The period following the Spring Reforms and the half-hearted European reactions to the annexation of Montenegro is most often described as relatively serene. The major players of Europe had already come to a generally accepted conclusion on the crisis in the Netherlands, and were for the most part looking outwards, towards the unclaimed territories in Africa, Asia and the Pacific. The Great Game, as it was called, saw Russia and the United Kingdom continue their cat-and-mouse games over the vast and rugged lands of Central Asia, while Prussia and Austria both worked towards closer Germanic cooperation all while subtly undermining the other's position within the confederation.

The Second Oriental Crisis (also known as the First War of Unification) is considered by many to be the beginning of new era – a shift of power that would force the continental powers to once more pay close attention to any changes of fortune on the continent. At the time, the rivalry between the Ottoman Empire and the Egyptian state was seen as an opportunity for exploitation and influence, one in which both of those nations would play a minor role compared to their European puppet masters. Despite the fall of Montenegro, there was little to contradict this.

Such disregard could be seen throughout the capitals of Europe. Following the Spring Reforms, the Porte sent out diplomats across Europe with a renewed vigor, seeking to improve ties with those nations deemed to have an interest in Ottoman survival, and to hold off for the time being those who did not. Foreign reaction was unenthusiastic at best. While all professed a desire to 'improve ties', none were willing to make concrete promises regarding mutual defense, economic privileges, or even a promise of nonintervention. While these results were hardly surprising, they tempered the confidence of the Sultan and his closest advisers, many of whom had been confident military success would bring renewed interest in the Ottoman Empire abroad.

The sole ray of hope amongst such dreary affairs was Prussia. A nation eager to assert itself on the world stage, and sharing a number of common natural enemies, it was common sense that the nation with the most to gain from an Ottoman revival would be Prussia. Whilst unable to promise direct military intervention during war, and unwillingly to alienate its most important partner – Austria – Prussia nonetheless agreed to a limited proposal. In exchange for favored economic policies in Constantinople, the Prussians promised diplomatic support within the Ottoman realms (including Egypt) and most importantly, established a military mission at Edirne, with the goal of training 80,000 Turks to European standards by 1838.

By the time the Second Oriental Crisis came to a head, the reforms of the past few years were yielding significant results for the Empire. Literacy was on the rise, a positive, stable (if humble) budget had been established, and the process of industrialization had begun. The Porte had even gone so far as to establish a written constitution, which though changed little in terms of practical power, guaranteed to all subjects of the Empire basic rights. Though it would clearly favor those of Islamic faith, and would not diminish the segregated legal system of the Ottomans, it was clearly a huge step of unprecedented liberalization. The increase of both private and public funds as well as a sense of enfranchisement led to higher support for the government across the vast majority of society. While it would be foolish to claim that such changes were embraced by all (and as we will see later, clearly were not), the overwhelming tensions with Egypt required such disagreements to be set aside for now... For Egypt, time had run out.

Realistically, the Egyptians could never have hoped to mount an offensive against the Ottomans without heavy international support. In this sense, the Egyptians were doomed from the start – unable to win the war, it was only a question of by how little they would lose. Had they pushed the Ottomans to warearlier, it is likely that they could have forced a settlement in their (relative) favor. As it is, such are hypothetical guesses – in March, 1838, an army of over 100,000 Ottoman troops, led by a cadre of Turk and Prussian officers, crossed the borders into Syria.

In truth, the war was decided within days of the initial crossing. Diplomatically, the seeds of Ottoman labor bore fruit, as the major nations of Europe pledged neutrality in the conflict, clearly favoring the Ottomans. France, the lone hope for Egyptian ambitions, quickly adopted a sympathetic neutrality, unwilling to commit major forces in the face of European neutrality... particularly when much more lucrative opportunities existed beyond the seas. Outnumbered and poorly equipped, the Egyptians could hope for little more than to pacify the Ottomans with minor exchanges. Such was not to be, as all hopes died at the Battle of Bayrut.

Despite the obvious inferiority of his troops, Mehmet Ali insisted on the majority of his forces being placed in northern Syria, on the border of Anatolia. Believing that a thrust North would force most of the Ottoman army to place itself between his forces and the long road to Constantinople, he would be free to move westwards, into the rich lands of Mesopotamia. Furthermore, promised French forces would allow Libya to be overrun, ensuring Egyptian dominance of the Arab world.

Such was not to be. The newly enlarged Army of Arabia, consisting of the 2nd Constantinople Foot, 4th Constantinople Foot, 5th Constantinople Foot, 1st Benghazi Foot, 6th Baghdad Horse, 14th Baghdad Horse, and 4th Constantinople Horse moved into Syria from the west, overwhelming the border garrisons and pushing to Jerush. While a small garrison was left behind to pacify the region, the rest raced forward, capturing the scarce North-South tracks that would be vital for resupplying the enemy, aiming for the ports of Sidon and Nabulus, as well as the coveted treasure of Jerusalem.

Too late, the Egyptian forces realized they were caught in a trap. What began as an orderly retreat southwards – all pretense of invasion abandoned – soon became a rout as word spread of size and brutality of the Turks pushing from the south and east. With all semblance of order falling apart amongst the rank and file, second disaster struck. The Army of Anatolia.

Smaller than it's southern counterpart, the Corps of The Army of Anatolia tasked with assisting in the invasion consisted of the 1st Ankara Foot, 1st Edrine Foot, 2nd Constantinople Horse, and 3rd Constantinople Horse. Initially, their responsibility was to blunt any Egyptian thrust until the larger army could crush them from the south. However, as the Egyptians began to retreat southwest along the coast, abandoning their defensive works the Army of Anatolia took to the offensive, forcing the Egyptian army to attempt a fighting retreat. While The Army of Arabia would gain the greater share of the war's glory for annihilating a majority of the Egyptian force within weeks of the campaign, it is undisputed that the former's contribution was critical to buying the latter enough time to prevent any significant forces escaping.

Regardless of who claimed the most honors, the fact remained that by the end of June, Syria was under Ottoman occupation, the remnants of the Egyptian army making a stand behind the protective sands of the Sinai. Unfortunately, it proved just as ineffective as everything up to this point.

As the Egyptians scraped together a force to defend the vital Alexandria-Cairo line, a third Ottoman army entered the fray, The Army of Africa. Undermanned and consisting mostly of irregular forces, its purpose had been to simply been seen to be doing something in the vulnerable western provinces. As the war effort forced more and more Egyptian troops eastwards, orders passed down from Constantinople to open a new front. In mid June, roughly coordinating with the Ottoman advance across the Sinai, the 1st Tripoli Foot, 2nd Benghazi Foot, and 1st Tripoli Horse moved along the western coastline, overwhelming the severely depleted garrisons of the region.

It is likely that on the defensive, behind a massive geographic defensive line and with infinitely better (though still poor) logistics, the Egyptians should have been able to have kept the Ottomans out of Egypt proper indefinitely. However, general discontent, particularly within the army, as well as the collapse of morale and exaggerated claims of a massive Ottoman army moving out of Libya led to a full scale disintegration of Egyptian forces. Ottoman forces crossed into Egypt in July, and the 4th Constantinople Horse entered Alexandria without contest by the end of the month.

By September, most of the nation was occupied, and the European nations, once wavering but nonetheless supporting of the Ottomans, now began to voice concern about a sudden shift of power in the region. Outraged (never mind that not a few years ago, these lands were incontestability part of the Empire) , the Porte realized that they could not afford to win the war in Egypt, only to find Christendom united against them.


4thConstantinople.jpg


The 4th Constantinople Horse, Liberators of Alexandria, seen here in The Second War of Unification.
The unit would be one of the most decorated in the Ottoman army up until its near annihilation and subsequent disbandment in The Caucasus War.
They would be revived with much fanfare as a fully armored regiment in 1934.

The treaty of Constantinople was harsh – Syria, Crete, Cyprus, the Sinai Peninsula, and Alexandria were ceded to the Turks in perpetuity. Mehmet Ali himself was forced to take an oath of loyalty to the Sultan, effectively making him a hereditary governor, and Egypt into a vassal of the Ottomans. Neither side left the conference entirely satisfied. Unfortunately for Egypt, the Ottomans would later be in a situation to do something about it.

Oriental-Crisis.gif

Gameplay notes:

Right before the Second Oriental Crisis starts, the Liberal Constitution + Prussian Advisers kicks in, giving the Ottomans a Constitutional Monarchy, 10 research points, some prestige (I think), five infantry, and three cavalry. I tried to write these in as happening over time, hence the Prussian diplomatic talks. In reality, at this time I had no research points for which to be trading for techs, and no clout to be expecting anything other than blowing DP on 'improving relations'. A tough time. Mostly just saved them, but assume that in 'reality' the Ottomans abroad were doing something, no matter how fruitless.

I managed to scrape two (2!) machine parts aroundish this time and they will be put to great use in the next update. Not much went on prior to the crisis. Saving nonexistent research points, improving nonexistent literacy rates, supporting a nonexistent economy... good times, good times.

Clearly, the military reforms of the previous chapter were nothing more than creating an obviously non-Turkish naming system for my units. A cop out, but one I'd gladly make for the ease of know who is where. At this time, a vast majority of my units were in the war. I had a unit or two on the Russian and Austrian borders, and one or two that participated in the war as mop ups and thus didn't get any mention, as they technically weren't supposed to be there. The poor placement and subsequent pocketing of almost the entire Egyptian army was something new, and looking it up on vickywiki, it appears that declaring war right after the constitution prevents Egypt from getting reinforcements. First time I've done it that way, and I suppose technically that's a gamey move, and certainly explains the cakewalk... but let's pretend that it's due to the French weaseling out, eh ;)

Obviously, game play wise the Europeans didn't say boo after their scripted responses at the beginning of the war. However, I had no intention of total annexation at this time, and roleplay made me consider the port of Alexandria a much greater prize than the gold province in the southeast of Sudan. Probably should have gone for the latter, but ah well, them's the breaks.

Economy at this stage is crap, but for the most part improving. Basically running on hopes, dreams, and export of raw materials. And given the starting navy + current funding, the opening picture isn't as much of a joke as I wish it were.
 
Last edited:

MadVlad

Sergeant
3 Badges
Sep 2, 2008
62
8
  • Europa Universalis III
  • Divine Wind
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
Break over. Update within a day or two.

Truth is life: Indeed, would have been ideal. In fact, I probably should have kept going until I got that. Still, all in due time.

Viden: The maps are made with photoshop. Everything I know about making game maps comes from here. Make mine look rather dull in comparison, eh?

GregorytheBruce: Indeed. While I didn't quite manage it entirely this time, it's always one of my major goals when playing the Ottomans - both for its in-game usefulness as well as the interesting historical context.