Officers : national or not national culture ?

[unmerged(15046)]

Hi !

Could anyone provide me with a sound answer about this : if I convert som pop to officers, what happens ?

a) national-culture pop
b) foreigner culture pop

Seems to me, at 100% military fund, I always get the leadership increase, but once 'used', those points don't regenerate with a non-national officier pop...

Is it a buf or am I wrong ?

Thanks a lot in advance !

(Or maybe it's another Dreyfuss scandal !)

 

[unmerged(17395)]

> Seems to me, at 100% military fund, I always get the leadership increase, but once 'used', those points don't regenerate with a non-national officier pop...

That's exactly what I experienced yesterday; non-national officers didn't provide any Leadership gain.

Concerning Soldiers the nationality doesn't seem to matter.

 

[unmerged(12330)]

> Seems to me, at 100% military fund, I always get the leadership increase, but once 'used', those points don't regenerate with a non-national officier pop...

That's exactly what I experienced yesterday; non-national officers didn't provide any Leadership gain.

Concerning Soldiers the nationality doesn't seem to matter.

Interesting... That would explain why in my Austria game I could never get my leadership to have any gain per month, I was only using Ukranians and Hungarians as officers. I figured it was a bug and assumed it would be fixed.

I must be use to to playing simpler less realistic games, because having Ukrainians commanding Austrian troops wouldnt be very common, I dont know why I just didnt catch on to that from the start..

Does anyone find that if they convert a pop to officers, that the number of people steadily go down? For example, i convert 90,000 Ukrainians to officers, later on i look and there are only 70,000 left, then later 40,000, etc, until the pop disappears?

 

[Darkrenown]

If you have your rich taxes too high the pop can move away or devolve. That could be what's happening to your officers.

 

[unmerged(6766)]

If you're going for an egalitarian society, it's a good way to get rid of your Capitalists too. They're not dying, just turning into laborers.

 

[Darkrenown]

Seems to me, at 100% military fund, I always get the leadership increase, but once 'used', those points don't regenerate with a non-national officier pop...

When you say military, do you mean defence? It's defence spending that affects mapower and leadership growth, army main just affect numbers of men in a division.

 

[unmerged(10322)]

If you have your rich taxes too high the pop can move away or devolve. That could be what's happening to your officers.

Officers are middle class.

 

[Grosshaus]

Seems to me, at 100% military fund, I always get the leadership increase, but once 'used', those points don't regenerate with a non-national officier pop...

Is it a buf or am I wrong ?

The lack of increase of leadership from non-national culture officers is intended. That way for instance Dutch can't use their Indonesian colonies to boost their leadership. Actually I suppose you shouldn't get any from creating a non-state culture officer pop either. If you can confirm it, please report to bug forum. Provided it isn't there already, check the reported/fixed subforum as well.

 

[unmerged(760)]

Interesting... That would explain why in my Austria game I could never get my leadership to have any gain per month, I was only using Ukranians and Hungarians as officers.

hungarians are state culutured

 

[unmerged(12330)]

hungarians are state culutured

Seems that I have a problem then...

 

[unmerged(24890)]

Iwas playing as Dutch and I converted some african pops to officers and now i have a HUGE amount of leadership coming all the time. I don`t think that couple of thousand officers in Holland provide all this leadership.. :wacko:

 

[Darkrenown]

If you can confirm it, please report to bug forum. .

Just cheked, converting non-national pops to officers does give you a lump of leadership but does not increase your monthly gain.

 

[Darkrenown]

Seems that I have a problem then...

You won't get any if your defence spending is £0.