Wow, funnily enough I was just coming into the thread to say, as an Irish person, thank you to the SWMH team for getting the county and duchy layout of Ireland so right and accurate to the actual Gaelic idea of Irish geography. Vanilla Irish layout is a painfully English-Norman version of Ireland that even I as a descendent of the Normans find hard to stomach. The fact the made Connacht into just one singular county is particularly annoying. So great job there guys.
As far as the High King title goes, I would probably have to agree that there should be a titular title of Ard Rí and a separate actual Kingdom title of Ireland because unless you're VERY fast to cut them off, Eire immediately blobs up, which is neither historically ccurate or fair if you're playing as Norse-Gaels or Viking invaders. It's extremely difficult for example playing as Lord of the Isles/The Kingdom of Mon and trying to hold off Ireland on your west and Alba on your east. Playing as av Ivars or the Crovans in most bookmarks is arguably too hard with a united Ireland forming so quicky.
So yeah, what might work better is, again, a separate titular title given and then an actual Kingdom title that the dukes can create after conquest, and perhaps to simulate that be generous by giving them a good few claims on each others land.
As far as the High King title goes, I would probably have to agree that there should be a titular title of Ard Rí and a separate actual Kingdom title of Ireland because unless you're VERY fast to cut them off, Eire immediately blobs up, which is neither historically ccurate or fair if you're playing as Norse-Gaels or Viking invaders. It's extremely difficult for example playing as Lord of the Isles/The Kingdom of Mon and trying to hold off Ireland on your west and Alba on your east. Playing as av Ivars or the Crovans in most bookmarks is arguably too hard with a united Ireland forming so quicky.
So yeah, what might work better is, again, a separate titular title given and then an actual Kingdom title that the dukes can create after conquest, and perhaps to simulate that be generous by giving them a good few claims on each others land.