Republics
I was for the first time ever playing a republic yesterday, and it was actually a lot of fun and really seemed to fit into the mood of the setting as well! Loaded up as Gondor, revoked a duchy title from the count of Anfalas, revoked a city title and a county title also. Then renamed the city "Guild of Venturers" like the one from Numenor, gave the mayor a county so he became a Lord Mayor and then gave him the duchy of Annuland so he becomes a Patrician/Republic - and wow, really felt like a whole new dimension to the game, opening trade routes, making money and not fighting orc hordes, and trying to find new provinces in the Eriadorian coastline to settle with my rising mercantile empire.
It made me wish I had some competition, perhaps from Pelargir or the duchy below it, and definitely from Umbar and Bellakar - and also the elves of Lindon.
I know "Republics" don't fit into Middle-Earth, but with a little localisation, they can certainly represent sea-faring guilds! We name the Patrician "Great Captain" and we name the leaders of the other houses "Captains". We rename Republic to "Guild", and voila, we have something resembling the guild of venturers which some heir of Numenor used to colonize middle-earth and explore and trade, starting their colonisation efforts.
There are two ways we could go about it: 1, add some titular duchy titles, make a "guild characters" history file for the Great Captains and families, give them a province with a city as the main barony. 2, use the existing provinces - make Bellakar duchy a vassal trading-duchy of the King, and do the same for the two Umbarian ones that are NOT called Umbar. Make Harlond (or whatever the southern one is called) a trading duchy/guild also, and then the two southern duchies of Lebennin also.
What do you guys think?
For my next try, I think I'll have Elrond take over those independent duchy provinces in southern Lindon via claims, and then make Elrohir a merchant-captain/patrician, revitalising the Eldar in the 4th Age through trade and colonisation